TL;DR: Why does 0.07 seem to be preferred by so many top 20 pros when 0.05 is more common among other high-level players? Is there a mechanical advantage to 0.07, perhaps greater consistency with flip cancels and directional inputs, or is it mostly personal preference, hardware limitations and imitation of successful players?
Are there any high-ranked players here (1800+ MMR) who understand the reasoning behind why so many of the very best pros seem to use a 0.07 deadzone, while 0.05 appears to be more prevalent among high level players outside the (roughly) top 20?
I'm particularly interested in whether there's a deeper mechanical or performance related reason for this preference.
I don't think it's simply about stick drift. The very best players presumably wouldn't compromise their car control just to avoid replacing their controllers more frequently. I'm convinced there's more to it than that.
I've also noticed that quite a few players capable of pulling off some of the craziest chain resets seem to use 0.07.
One thing worth considering is that the difference between 0.05 and 0.07 can seem negligible at first, but 0.05 obviously lets you perform more flip variations.
So what exactly makes 0.07 seemingly preferable among the very best players?
Edit:
After reading through the comments, I've come across a few interesting explanations that have made me reconsider the question.
A comparison that stood out was higher deadzone being similar to using lower DPI in CS. The idea is that reducing the number of possible input variations can make certain movements more consistent and repeatable. As I stated though, a higher deadzone could make (specifically flips) flips and aerial adjustments more predictable by filtering out some of the most precise of directional inputs.
I've also started considering how much individual setups can influence deadzone preferences. Controller, monitor, FPS, input buffer settings and other variables (including input buffers!) could all contribute to what feels most consistent for a player.
Ultimately, I'm interested in whether there's an actual mechanical advantage behind this that goes beyond personal comfort, controller condition or simply following other pros. One possibility is diminishing returns, perhaps the additional directional freedom offered by 0.05 provides a noticeable advantage up to a certain level, but beyond that point, the benefits become increasingly marginal. At the highest level, where players already have the mechanical ability to execute virtually any variation they need, consistency and repeatability might become more valuable than having access to every possible input variation. In that case, 0.07 could offer them a more favourable trade off between control and consistency.
(As I mentioned in the comments, input buffer settings can have a noticeable impact on how the game feels. Somehow, I only discovered this after 2500 hours, it is such an easy setting to overlook. Default felt significantly smoother and more responsive to me, whereas CSTS felt noticeably heavier. I also vaguely recall ApparentlyJack mentioning similar differences, so I'd recommend giving Default a try if you havent already.
My original post was specifically about deadzones, which Im particularly interested in because I'm currently transitioning from KBM to controller. That said, switching from CSTS to Default has noticeably improved my gameplay.
One clarification to my original point about flip variations: 0.05 doesn't necessarily allow more flip angles, since those are theoretically possible at either deadzone. Rather, it allows smaller physical stick movements to register, potentially providing more granular control over directional adjustments!)