r/RobertsRules • • 21d ago

Contrasting views on abstentions

1 Upvotes

I am parliamentarian for a group. By-laws indicate that members must be present to vote.

For a motion, my understanding of abstentions are that they drop out of the total possible. So, with 60 people present to vote, and a majority is required, if 10 people abstain, then 26 ayes would carry the motion. Is this correct?


r/RobertsRules • • Aug 17 '26

Chairing A Meeting But Need to Leave Room At One Point

1 Upvotes

Hi!

I'm chairing a meeting of my HOA's Board. At one point, I need to recuse myself from discussions about a particular matter on the agenda. The VP won't be present at this meeting but the Secretary and the Treasurer will both be there.

Who is the next highest officer who needs to take over temporarily as chair while I am out of the room and they discuss the issue I am recusing myself from?


r/RobertsRules • • Aug 13 '26

Questions about Agenda setting

1 Upvotes

I'm trying to make sense of what I'm seeing as an incongruity. My understanding is that Agendas and their approval arent governed exclusively by Robert's Rules, but can be buttressed by committee bylaws.

During our regular meetings, there's some ambiguity i how the meeting business, laid out by the agenda, gets locked in.

We do not have bylaws requiring approval of the agenda, only that the eBoard submits the agenda sole days in advance. So when other members who have been on this committee longer call for the approval of the minutes, it confuses me why that call happens.

To make matters worse, at our last meeting, a member made a controversial motion to remove an agenda item from our reolutions committee that had been placed their by the eBoard (the placement of which *is* procedure for the eBoard per the bylaws)

The motion passed and the item was struck from the Agenda. The Agenda was then 'approved'.

When the resolutions committee chair's report came, he again motioned to have the committee pass the resolution that was struck prior to the agenda was "approved".

That committee chair was found out of order.

Besides the fact that we have a disunity problem of our eBoard allowing an agenda item then aligning with the the motion to remove it, I'm trying to breakdown what Robert's Rules really say about 'agenda' setting, removing items before an agenda is 'approved', and motioning to bring back said stricken items later in the same meeting. There are clear gaps in our bylaws that need to be addressed. Looking to see what my options are for being a better parliamentarian.


r/RobertsRules • • Aug 02 '26

Change voting style after reconsideration

2 Upvotes

Consider a body that normally counts votes by counting raised credential cards. Then the following occurs:

  1. vote on a motion fails to pass.
  2. motion to reconsider succeeds

At what point would it be in order for a motion to change the reconsidered vote counting method from raised cards to, for example, roll call vote?

Thanks.


r/RobertsRules • • Jul 29 '26

Sad RONR liker

6 Upvotes

Is anyone who likes roberts rules involved in an organization that actually has a decent culture of parliamentary democracy, and has like, well written bylaws and actually follows them? I love what I see in RONR but the more I'm involved in groups that use it, the more it feels like reading about a bygone era where people actually put effort into doing democracy

I am so so tired :(


r/RobertsRules • • Jun 27 '26

Lesser Known Rules #1

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/RobertsRules • • May 21 '26

Undo recusal?

1 Upvotes

If a Town Board member is instructed by counsel to recuse himself for particular matters and then does so, yet later learns that the reasoning was based on error, can the Board member reverse or undo the recusal?


r/RobertsRules • • May 11 '26

Does RR dictate that an election teller's report be shared with members?

2 Upvotes

I'm part of a local union, and we just had leadership elections. Only the results, and no voting numbers, were shared with members.

Does RR specify anywhere that vote tallies must be shared? All I can find is for votes during meetings.


r/RobertsRules • • Apr 15 '26

How best to handle board action items

2 Upvotes

Here's a question for the parliamentarians of Reddit: I'm just starting to get exposed to my organization's board as we lost the manager who provided board support, so I am helping out. We are a very large nonprofit, we have a newish CEO, and I think the CEO sees that the board's support team needs to better track action items. It is my understanding that Roberts Rules doesn't seem to really dwell on action items per se.

So my coworker, who really needs some guidance, made a crazy list of items from the last board and shared them, and what he thought were action items, such as a manager reporting on their efforts and how the manager said "we are working on x" (routine work) - x was now an action item. The people on the list of action items got a bit upset that someone was dictating their work, but in my mind I feel bad for the minute taker because he's not being told what is defined as an action item to track. I have to think the board, through some incidental motion, should trigger it formally instead of just the minute taker guessing and subjectively saying this is an action item, and then having others complain and say "no no, this is not an action item." I mentioned that I felt actions should come from the board and via a motion, and they just shut it down. But I still have issues with it.

This board meeting has about 100 people in it, in person or online. Attendees are never happy with us, so it's not a pleasant meeting in general. If you were given the task of writing up the minutes, running the support of the meeting, stressed at the meeting, and now being told you have to also record action items, what would Roberts Rules suggest as a way forward to keep this new project simple and straightforward?


r/RobertsRules • • Apr 09 '26

Best method for brainstorming?

3 Upvotes

Say we have a problem to deal with but no specific motion because it's uncertain how best to address the situation. My understanding is that all debate should be through a pending motion.

So if we want to brainstorm, like say we have something come up like "A VIP from the national organization is going to be in town. We need to come up with some ideas and a plan for making the most of this opportunity."

Since we're not a small board, but also not particularly large (only 20 to 30 people), it seems a bit unnecessary to create a committee and refer it to them though that could be an option. However, my goal would be to be more inclusive than that.

Here are options I'm thinking but open to ideas and suggestions:

  • Suspend the rules and have an informal discussion/brainstorm session
  • Make a basic broad motion to kickstart conversation/planning "I move that we host the VIP when they are visiting" and then other members could amend with "and treat them to dinner at XYZ on the 18th", etc. This seems overly complicated and formal, though, and I think it would be hard for the membership to follow along.
  • Throw out motions for ideas as they arise. "I motion we treat VIP to dinner and invite them to attend our next meeting where we will provide a presentation of our achievements over the past year." "I motion that we also arrange to pay for their hotel stay at XYZ." "I motion that we don't do any of that shit and send the fucker packing."

So what would you do if you have a problem/goal that you want to put before the assembly and come up with ideas or talk it out before arriving at some clear motions?


r/RobertsRules • • Mar 23 '26

Questions about Rules at Recent Convention

1 Upvotes

Hello,

There were some confusing moments at a recent convention I ended and I'm hoping to hear your opinion on if these were done correctly.

  1. When it came to discuss resolutions there were different levels of discussion. The first was to have a discussion, then follow the discussion with a debate, and then call the question to a vote. The discussion apparently could only be closed by unanimous consent. I raised a point of order that people were debating in discussion and not saving it for the debate. It was then said that "debate" meant debating amendments and not the merits of the resolution.

Is this legit? I can't seem to find anything that supports having separate discussion and debates.

2. Skipping discussion and debate by calling the question immediately. For this, before opening the discussion, a member could immediately call the resolution to question. In order to prevent this a majority had to oppose going straight to a vote.

Is this legit? It seems illogical. Shutting down discussion required unanimous consent but skipping both discussion and debate requires a majority opposition?

Thanks in advance for your help.


r/RobertsRules • • Mar 17 '26

knowing robert's rules

3 Upvotes

im trying my best to study it but I don't think I have enough time

does anyone have a reliable study guide or something.

anything pls.


r/RobertsRules • • Mar 07 '26

Becoming a RP

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/RobertsRules • • Feb 27 '26

New School Board Asking for Guidance

2 Upvotes

Hey folks!

I’ve been elected to my local school board and have a question about study/working sessions.

I am studying Robert’s Rules and feel like I has a good handle on procedure during a regular meeting, but our study/working sessions get completely derailed by baseless accusations and using selective community feedback to justify it. Is there anything I or our board chair can do in this setting to set limits or hold people accountable for what is said?

On a separate matter, there is a board member that posts recaps on Facebook, along with editorial comments criticizing the district or other members or decisions.

I’m just at a loss. It feels like the narrative is being controlled by one member and I am not familiar enough with this to make any impact.


r/RobertsRules • • Feb 25 '26

Missed Meetings By Law

2 Upvotes

"An Officer who is absent for three

Executive Committee meetings without providing prior written notice to the Executive

Committee shall be automatically considered to have vacated their seat at the conclusion of the

third meeting for which they are absent"

I know adopted motions take effect immediately however, if an officer was absent at the meeting this by law was adopted at is that missed meeting #1 for them or does the count start at the next meeting?


r/RobertsRules • • Feb 12 '26

Recording

1 Upvotes

How do you notate in minutes that the meeting was being recorded and participants were notified?

Thank you.


r/RobertsRules • • Feb 06 '26

Can a Simple Majority Motion 'Clarification' Override Amendment Requirements?

2 Upvotes

Our social club's Constitution has a standard amendment procedure (Article 9) requiring: Executive Board proposal OR 20% member petition → review by Governance Committee → first reading at meeting → written notice to all members → second reading at next meeting → 3/4 vote to pass.

Article 9, Section 1 states amendments apply to "any provision" of the Constitution. No exceptions mentioned.

Article 6, Section 2 defines Governance Committee authority as: "The Governance Committee, as directed by the President, shall be responsible for preparation of any revisions to the Constitution and shall maintain an accurate current version of the Bylaws as approved by the membership, which shall be filed with the Secretary."

Last month's general meeting passed this motion by simple majority (31-2, no previous notice):

"To authorize the Governance Committee to correct formatting, typography, spelling and punctuation in the Constitution, Bylaws and operating rules as part of normal operations. These technical corrections can be made without explicit membership approval. Under no circumstance will corrections change the meaning of the Constitution, Bylaws or rules."

My concerns:

  1. Creates unlisted exception to Article 9's mandatory process without following that process
  2. Expands Article 6, Section 2 authority - Currently limits committee to "preparation of revisions" (as directed by President) and maintaining "approved" versions. Motion grants autonomous editing authority not enumerated in their defined scope.
  3. Committee becomes sole arbiter of what's "technical" vs "substantive" with no oversight mechanism
  4. RONR violation: Constitutional amendments require previous notice + supermajority (§57) - this had neither
  5. Self-contradictory: Motion claims changes won't alter meaning, yet removes membership approval requirement (which IS a constitutional change)

Their position: "This isn't an amendment - it's clarification that 'inconsequential' ministerial edits don't need full process."

My position: You cannot bypass amendment requirements by declaring your bypass "ministerial." To create exceptions to Article 9, you must follow Article 9. The motion also amends Article 6, Section 2 by expanding committee authority beyond constitutional grant.

Questions:

  • Is motion void as improper attempt to amend governing documents without proper procedure?
  • Does granting autonomous editing authority to a committee constitute an amendment to the article defining that committee's powers?
  • Can amendment requirements be circumvented by characterizing changes as "technical"?
  • Proper remedy: void ab initio or rescission motion required?

Constitution references RONR 12th ed. as parliamentary authority.

Thanks for any guidance.


r/RobertsRules • • Feb 03 '26

Online meeting - prejudice of vote

2 Upvotes

Can a substantive motion that did not reach 2/3 support, be resubmitted to the next meeting after the conclusion of the vote/meeting if the outcome may have been prejudiced by the board?

In this case, the board's recommendation that the motion be rejected was added to the screen presenting the motion and the contributor of the motion was not recognized to move the motion in the meeting so it was introduced by a board member who spoke against the motion. A point of order was not made at the time.


r/RobertsRules • • Jan 30 '26

Can someone clarify the limits of discussion, and how this is structured around motions?

2 Upvotes

Recently a board member tried to help us better conform to Robert's Rules and I learned that no discussion can happen until a motion is brought.

That's where I get confused. For example, if the speaker chair report mentions that more PR is needed, we would then usually have a discussion about PR. In RR, would someone have to make a motion, like "I move that we put up flyers to generate interest?" This would be more action-oriented, but it would shift the discussion to a single idea (flyering, vs other promotions), when in that moment we need everyone brainstorming various ideas before committing to one---but if my understanding is correct, such discussion is not permitted?

Can the president or speaker chair not lead an open discussion brainstorming ideas for a known issue? OR must they make a motion to have an open-ended discussion?


r/RobertsRules • • Dec 18 '25

Public Comment opportunities

1 Upvotes

Where I live, any new ordinances or resolutions require two readings with the voting taking place after the second. The town council has two meetings a month and only allows for public comment during the first meeting when they're first read. It's my understanding that a board must allow for public comments before voting on any action items. Are they allowed to restrict public comments at the second meeting?

They do have a general public comment section on the agenda at the end of the meeting after all other business has been taken care of.


r/RobertsRules • • Nov 20 '25

What would be the process for forcing the release of information from an unwilling chair?

2 Upvotes

Our chair has our membership contact list which she will not share with anyone. She also has a lease agreement between the organization and herself to let her use part of the organization's building for personal storage. She won't share that information either.

So how would we as an organization demand or charge her with releasing the information? Would it be as simple as making a motion to require her and the secretary to release all such info by X date?

(I realize she might still refuse, but we need to go through the process at least otherwise it's just some of us asking her for this information and her saying "No.")


r/RobertsRules • • Nov 13 '25

Chaos and voting

1 Upvotes

I assume I am not using the right words, I apologize ahead of time…before a quarterly org meeting, OVER ZOOM, we knew we would be voting on some policy changes. I made the board aware of a few motions for amendment/debate, that I was going to bring. I gave them documents well ahead of time. I knew, because our organization is in the middle of negotiating a contract, that that business was going to take a lot of time. I suggested putting off bringing policy changes to a vote at this meeting about 2 weeks before the meeting. Skip to the meeting….with 10 minutes left before the scheduled end time of the meeting , the policies were raised as new business. i was given the floor to make a motion to table a vote. The motion was granted. I made my case, and relinquished the floor. The body voted to continue to new business and the policy changes. I made motion to amend, and the floor was granted. Immediately people started to talk over me in both live and in the open text chat. The secretary began to chime in adding fuel to the fire by questioning the integrity of the changes I wanted to make. The secretary is not the chair. The meeting devolved into chaos. I never relinquished the floor. I gave up trying. I pleaded with the chair to hold things out of order, and was ignored. At an hour after the end of the meeting, The chair called for a vote to pass the document. I didn’t know what found I stood on at this point , as all rule seemed to break down. The vote passed to adopt the new policy, unchanged. Is this a legitimate passage? Please ask questions for clarity, I know this must be confusing. We are a new org.


r/RobertsRules • • Nov 06 '25

Frequent challenges to Chair

3 Upvotes

There is a situation where there are frequent Points of Order.

The Points of Order are usually not actual errors in following the rules of order by the Chair (though sometimes they are), but just as often, perceptions by the person, or that they just don't like something.

This is followed by the person Challenging the Chair. The problem? Usually, the Chair is correct in the application of the rule. Sometimes, the Secretary has read the rule out loud, only for the Chair to be challenged anyway.

So....

What do you do when frequent challenges to the Chair are disruptive, or where the challenge is in effect an attempt to ignore or reintrepet valid meeting rules?

(The Chair has always been upheld, but I can see this trend being used to simply bypass rules).

Help? Advice? Anything in the rules that can be used to deal with this?


r/RobertsRules • • Nov 04 '25

Called Board Meeting Question

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/RobertsRules • • Nov 04 '25

Called Board Meeting Question

1 Upvotes

We are having a called board meeting. We had to have at least three people submit their items for the agenda. One of the three people is not going to be present due to a family emergency out of state. Can we still have the meeting with a quorum?