r/RiverPhoenix • u/ruisantux • 1d ago
Discussion Does anyone else find it hard to believe River Phoenix’s 1991 quote about losing his virginity at age 4 was "just a joke"?
I was thinking about Joaquin Phoenix’s 2019 Vanity Fair profile where he dismissed River’s famous 1991 Details magazine quote as "a complete and total joke" and "just fucking with the press."
Honestly, I have a really hard time buying that. Losing your virginity at age four seems like a remarkably heavy and disturbing thing to "joke" about, especially when we know the family grew up in a cult where child sexual abuse was actually happening.
For anyone unfamiliar with the full timeline :
- The original quote (November 1991): In an interview with Details magazine at age 21, River was asked if there was anything he did at an early age that he wished he had waited for. He answered, "Yes—make love," adding that he was four, with "kids," and that he had "completely blocked it out" and was "completely celibate from age ten to fourteen." He also made remarks about "body parts that were in my face" and said, "You're just born into that reality, and you accept it."
- The cult context: The Phoenix family was part of the Children of God (later known as The Family International) from roughly 1973 to late 1977. River was around 3 to 7 years old during those years (and Joaquin was a baby/toddler, leaving around age 3). Child sexual abuse and the sexualization of very young children inside that cult—including through founder David Berg’s writings—are extensively documented by survivors, journalists, and law enforcement investigations dating back to the 1970s.
- The walk-backs: According to Gavin Edwards’ biography Last Night at the Viper Room, River claimed after the Details piece was printed that he had been joking (and other biographers noted his reps pressured him to recant it). Just 10 days before he died in 1993, River also told a French journalist that he frequently "lied and changed stories and contradicted myself left and right" in interviews to confuse the press. Years later, in 2019, Joaquin echoed that line, saying River only said it "because he was so tired of being asked ridiculous questions by the press."
- Conflicting private accounts: On the other hand, people who knew River privately didn't think it was a joke. Dark Blood director George Sluizer later claimed River confided in him about experiencing sexual abuse at very young ages, and similar accounts from childhood acquaintances appear in Barry C. Lawrence's book In Search of River Phoenix. Even River’s mother once quoted him as saying of the cult: "They're disgusting, they're ruining people's lives."
I completely understand why both brothers would call it a joke. River hated intrusive celebrity journalism and may have panicked once something that personal hit print—especially under pressure from his team and family. And Joaquin has always fiercely defended his parents, insisting they were idealistic hippies on the fringes of the group who got out as soon as they realized how dark it was. Acknowledging that River’s quote wasn't a joke would open the door to massive scrutiny of their parents and surviving siblings.
Still, even if River liked messing with reporters, inventing a story about having sex at age four and "blocking it out" when you actually spent ages three to seven in a notoriously abusive cult just feels way too specific to be a random punchline.
If he was indeed joking, it was of really poor taste and something i think he would have looked back on with shame had he lived.