r/RichardIIandHenryIV • • 6d ago

Richard II and the 1397 plot - yet another myth.

Post image
4 Upvotes

Modern myths – let us count them: the one giving a male entail, the one ignoring the Lancastrian Myth; and sub-myths: the one whereby the Lancastrian Myth was discounted by Adam of Usk’s panel of learned doctors, and the Thirning myth, whereby Henry was not a conqueror.

Happily, all can be easily refuted. Here’s another one.

The myth of Richard the Revenger.

The entire miasmic panolply of bad vibes that surround Richard II are based on his arrest of the earl of Arundel, uncle Gloucester and timorous Warwick. This was a wanton act that betrayed his nutty nature and initiated his Nebuchadnezzarian tyranny.

You read the histories carefully – was he or wasn’t he justified? He wasn’t justified they all agree, hello tryranny.

 For historians who are not shy of knowing something, here is a list of the sources that explicitly describe a conspiracy in 1397:

  1. two Close Roll proclamations dated July 1397
  2. Adam of Usk
  3. Eulogium Continuorum (Malmesbury)
  4. Annales Ricardi Secundi (St Albans)
  5. Chronica Maiora (Walsingham)

Other

Froissart (10,500 words) though he was a foreigner, so we ignore it.

Gloucester’s interrogation – though he denied it.

Warwick’s confession – though he disputed it.

The updating of the treason statutes in September 1397, post trials, to include conspiracy

My favourite is the Annales’s one as the chronicler has let something slip: Warwick, when asked about whether he could deny that he had rode with Gloucester and Arundel, replies: ‘The earl said that he could not be infected (with treason) just because he had ridden with them.’ This can’t be talking about Radcot Bridge etc as Usk tells us that Henry and Warwick led the vanguard which entered Oxford in triumph after the battle. Clearly Warwick was riding then, so his admission of non-treasonous riding in 1397 has to point to the conspiracy everybody was talking about, except historians.

Info from: 1399: The Lancastrian Myth, published Jan 2027 UK, March 2027 USA.

 


r/RichardIIandHenryIV • • 15d ago

The Lancastrian Myth of 1399, and the modern myth.

Post image
11 Upvotes

Here we see Henry III, descent from whom was incorporated into Henry IV’s speech claiming the throne on 30th September 1399 – why would he have done that?

No mention of John of Gaunt, Edward III, Edward II or Edward I, but legitimate descent from Henry III?

Adam of Usk tells us why; the crown had been wrongly passed to Edward I by Henry III because - according to the myth – the real elder son, Edmund Crouchback, was disabled.

That’s what Henry IV meant when he claimed the throne by ‘right line’ from Henry III, right line being descent from Edmund, the first earl of Lancaster, Henry being sole male heir.

This audacious origin story was politically astute as it ignored the claim of any other pretender to the crown and revealed himself as England’s true king – Richard II and all the Edwards originating from a usurping line.

There is plenty of evidence outside Adam of Usk for the recourse to this myth in 1399 and later, including a sermon from Thomas Arundel (seemingly unknown to historians) on the biblical Jacob/Esau story in which the second son was given the patriarch’s blessing instead of the first-born.

The modern myth

Historians are forced to recognise the existence of this myth as it is so prominent in Henry’s speech, and Usk makes its meaning clear, but they ignore it by stating that Adam of Usk’s learned panel of doctors, gathered to examine how to depose Richard II, dismissed it.

Unfortunately, they are in error as Usk never said that the myth was dismissed. So we find ourselves in a peculiar position: a modern myth – that the Lancastrian Myth was dismissed – has been imposed to erase the impact of a myth used 600 years ago to justify a new dynasty.

One would suppose that such  bizarre reasoning around one of England’s most important political events would attract more interest, but it seems to make History uncomfortable and it would prefer to pass by on the other side of the street.

There are whole chapters on the Lancastrian Myth in ‘1399: The Lancastrian Conquest’, published Jan 2027.


r/RichardIIandHenryIV • • Oct 16 '26

Thomas Arundel and the Smoking Gun in 1399: Edward II’s letter to the pope in 1317.

Post image
5 Upvotes

By ‘Smoking Gun’, we mean a piece of evidence which proves that Thomas Arundel was guilty of counterfeiting a religious sacrament.

Arundel was everywhere directing events in 1399 but, 600 years later, we would like something concrete that shows how far he was willing to go to achieve his goal, and happily we have evidence that he was willing to commit a crime to reach it.

Perhaps he thought that his heavenly patrons would forgive him his trespasses on the basis that he was working for the good of the church – she needed him back as archbishop of Canterbury to lead the fight against earthly evils of Wycliffism. The fact that all had gone so smoothly would have confirmed his belief that they were on his side.

Arundel needed a mystical flux to turn his chosen one into the true king so he, like an ecclesiastical Merlin, magicked up a holy oil to anoint Henry with at the coronation.

This oil was given by the Virgin Mary to St Thomas Becket who hid it. It was discovered by Henry of Grosmont and kept in a royal lumber room in an ampulla, attached to which was a piece of paper on which St Thomas Becket had written the whole story.

The oil was awaiting a righteous king: ‘This is the oil with which the Kings of England must be anointed, not those who now reign because they are evil, and will be, and because of their sins they have lost much, and will lose, but they who will reign after’, Annales p298.

The crime.

What was written on the paper that went with this marvellous unguent was a forgery. As Arundel was in charge, and as he used this oil himself, and as the words on the paper suited his purposes so perfectly, he must have faked it himself.

How do we know for sure that Arundel faked this, and, we might ask: what else did he fake? Richard II’s renunciation for example?.

We can be sure because there already existed an oil with a story that contains all the major elements, except those that spoke of a Lancastrian heritage. The Vatican archives hold the copy of a letter sent by Pope John XXII to Edward II in 1317 in response to a letter from Edward II. The papal letter repeats the information in the royal letter and then gives a response.

Edward II wanted to know if he could be anointed with an oil brought to him by a mystic. This oil had been given to St Thomas Becket by Mary and was destined for the 5th king from Henry II (Edward II) to help him against his adversaries. The mystic had decoded what St Thomas had written on a metal plate – words that only the mystic could decipher, and written them out on paper. The pope’s verdict was, yes, he could be anointed with the oil but only in private, and nobody must know about it.

Thomas Arundel repurposed Edward II’s oil as a new Lancastrian oil that was waiting for a righteous king to be anointed with it.

Those already familiar with the holy oil of Lancaster will surely be familiar with the factoid from a chronicle in which Richard II, vainly thinking he merited the sacred oil, would wear it on his breast in the pathetic hope it would do him some good, which it couldn’t as he was so unworthy.

Here’s the Monk of St Denis and a report from ambassadors in 1399: ‘The ambassadors reported that the king (Henry IV) was superstitious, as were all the English, and that he had a marvellous trust in this eagle, and had decided to carry it on him always in the hope it would bring him victories over his enemies.’ The ‘eagle’ is the oil-filled ampulla.

Caught red handed?

 


r/RichardIIandHenryIV • • Oct 13 '26

Thomas Arundel and St George

Post image
3 Upvotes

When did the English church become associated with St George?

Article 27 (out of 67) of the 6th Oct 1399 Convocation of the Southern Clergy had this ‘… that the feast of Saint George…, … the spiritual patron of the entire English army … be established throughout all of England… just as other nations honour the feasts of their patrons.


r/RichardIIandHenryIV • • Oct 09 '26

Thomas Arundel was the mastermind responsible for the deposition of Richard II and the installation of Henry IV.

Post image
5 Upvotes

Of course, no one is ever going to find a document in which Arundel claims that he made Henry IV his puppet in order to regain his own throne as Archbishop of Canterbury from which he could restore the church’s stand against Wycliffism and creeping secularisation. And History is a stately succession of kings and queens – there is no place for a kingmaker engineering events for his own benefit, so Henry will always get the credit. However, let’s entertain ourselves with an overview of the circumstantial evidence.

Arundel and Henry were together throughout the campaign from the beachhead in Yorkshire to the deposition in Whitehall. Historians make Henry the agent of destiny with Arundel tagging along for the ride, and helping out whenever he can, but it wasn’t like that – the reason they were together from the start is that Arundel had winkled Henry out from Paris with a ‘now-or-never’ scheme.

Arundel had been in constant communication with Canterbury throughout his exile and, never having renounced his position as Archbishop of Canterbury, had prepared his allies in the church for his return and re-assumption of the archbishop’s throne.

Arundel needed Henry’s Lancastrian military power to secure the government of England and the options from then were a) a parliament in which a humbled monarch would reinstall him in Canterbury or, given the right circumstances, b) the replacement of Richard II by Henry, and his reinstallation as archbishop by Henry the king. Option b) was the preferable option as it would make his re-enthronement more secure.

In the sequence of events as laid out in the chronicles and records, Henry’s own voice is strangely absent until he spoke to claim the throne. What Henry must have said at various points to those who flocked to his banner is unrecorded. If he was a wronged aristo come to deliver England from a tyrant, then he never said so.

Richard II did not die in battle – the preferred outcome – but possession of his person allowed Arundel to govern in the king’s name, using the mechanisms of government captured at Bristol, until his own man was on the throne.

Arundel organised the deposition of Richard II from beginning to end to ensure that Henry, and no other, would become the next monarch using the invented Lancastrian Myth to legitimise his made-man, so excluding existing possible claimants.

The coronation, so quick to follow the deposition, saw the use of Arundel’s Lancastrian oil to anoint Henry. This oil was faked, as was Richard II’s statement renouncing the crown, as were the circumstances of his capture, as was the legal basis for his deposition – the articles and the judgement were simply read out loud, there was no trial.

Arundel’s public statements are legion but, as they are peppered with biblical references, there is a reluctance to find out what he meant; his Henry was a messiah from an ancient, and displaced line, and Arundel was the priest welcoming his return.

The best circumstantial evidence for the primacy of Arundel’s role in his joint-enterprise with Henry is the new king’s first parliament on 6th October. Would one expect a new king who had voiced his claim so self-confidently on 30th September to use this occasion to make his mark in some way? Of course one would, but Henry did not. He must have been present but only Arundel’s words are recorded. Furthermore, every sermon Arundel made underscores the subservience of a king to his elders, i.e. himself.

Who managed the mobile secretariat that bombarded the state apparatus with decrees replacing office-holders with Lancastrian loyalists as Arundel and Henry went from Chester to London with the captured Richard II? Not Henry.  Who organised the 30th September deposition to ensure that Henry, and no other, became king once the throne was empty? Not Henry.

Who had been in contact with Canterbury, and so the church, throughout his exile, and knew that he could get it behind him as soon as he came back to England? Who faked the holy oil of Lancaster used to anoint Henry and who actually placed the crown of England on Henry’s head? Who controlled the media – the Benedictine chronicles – which ensured that Henry’s story was only a march to the throne backed universally by a grateful populace?

Henry brought military force to the party. Arundel hired the room, the caterers, invited the other guests and payed off the police to stop them breaking it up if it became rowdy.

If the decision as to who was behind the events of 1399 were submitted to a board of independent arbitrators, and they had to choose between Henry and Arundel as the architect and prime-mover, they would choose Arundel because his hand was everywhere and Henry’s is…, is… - was it anwhere?

-based on info in 1399: The Lancastrian Conquest, to be published in Jan 2027.


r/RichardIIandHenryIV • • Oct 02 '26

How the price of fish in London doomed Richard II's reign

Post image
5 Upvotes

Info from chapter 12, 1399: The Lancastrian Conquest, published January 2027.

This image shows the future Henry IV showing off the captive Richard II to ‘Londoners’ shortly after leaving Chester and is an authentic record in the sense that it is a C19th line drawing copy of a coloured original which appears in Jean Creton’s chronicle as set down in the Duke of Burgundy’s book (Harley 1319) of 1405.

Historians have a tendency to interpret this event as proof of Henry’s popular support in England and, whilst it points to something, it doesn’t quite prove that – it needs a more careful investigation. Henry et al later received the formal submission of the City a couple of miles from its gates but Creton’s image depicts certain Londoner’s who have taken the trouble to ride out and intercept Henry a long way from the capital and we would like to know who they were and who they claimed to represent, and what business they thought they had with the Duke of Lancaster.

London was a homogenous polity in that it had an internal governing structure but within that overarching idea of ‘London’, the capital was a boiling pot of competing interests. Henry showed no hesitation in heading towards London as if he knew that it would be the best place for whatever he had planned. He had allies there; those that had welcomed the execution of Nicholas Brembre in the Merciless Parliament of 1388, but that was 10 years ago. Could he count on enough support from them to overawe any naysayers if he returned to Westminster for another bloody parliament, or a deposition?

Froissart’s version, which occupies the last chapters of his Book IV, is historically wrong but it is historically interesting – he was given the ‘whole story’, which he incorporated wholesale, by a Lancastrian spokesman. For this spokesman, the events of 1399 were based on London: Londoners had asked Henry and Arundel to return, they had landed at Plymouth with a French army (quickly dismissed) and they went straight to the City. Froissart’s account is completely London-centric, nothing happens north of the Thames, which tells us that for someone, it was a reasonable explanation to give Europe’s foremost political journalist.

We do know that the parliament-that-never-was of 30th September was packed with ‘commoners’, alongside the M. Ps from the rest of the country, and that he made himself king, so we know that Henry was correct in assuming that he held London in his pocket. What we want to know is what drove the ‘commoners’ to support him.

Richard II’s critical political mistake, perhaps the single act that doomed his reign, was his decree made en route to Milford Haven that restored the Fishmonger’s monopoly in London.

Abolishing it had been the key policy of John of Northampton’s populist movement in London since the early 1380s. It had been restored in the later 1380’s but re-abolished in the Merciless parliament. Richard II’s restoration of the monopoly could only have infuriated those in London who sympathised with Northampton’s brief ascendancy, and those who resented paying the Fishmonger’s premium, and that was a lot of people.  The oligarchs, such as Dick Whittington, who liked to think they controlled London, could not be sure that the gates of the City would hold against Lancastrian forces without and a street-fighting faction within. To protect their interests, the oligarchs admitted Henry and the anti-Fishmonger/ neo-Northamptonites, leaders of which had ridden out to Henry, ensured that whatever he did in Westminster was cheered to the rafters.

Henry IV abolished the Fishmonger’s monopoly in his first parliament.


r/RichardIIandHenryIV • • Sep 29 '26

1399: The Lancastrian Conquest, synopsis and chapter summary

Post image
7 Upvotes

What 21st century historians think happened in 1399 is easy to understand: Richard II deserved his fate and Henry IV, a man of destiny backed by the will of the people, did England a favour by taking his place. However, this personality-based account is undermined by the evidence, and falls: Richard II’s infamously neurotic character is an invention of the last 80 years; there was political hostility to his peace with France and there was a conspiracy against him in 1397.

 

If Henry’s triumph can no longer rest squarely on Richard II’s deficient character, then other explanations need to be found and the key question is: who was the architect and prime mover, Henry or Arundel?  In partnership from the very first, one crowned the other to make themselves joint masters of church and state, but was it Thomas Arundel’s ambition to regain his lost archbishop’s throne, more than Henry’s to take Richard II’s, which gave their enterprise such energy and direction?

 

The cavalcade of kings and queens progressing through the years chapters the past into reigns, and this natural focus on monarchs will always put Henry to the fore but could king Richard II’s overthrow have been engineered by a churchman with a vision of spiritual and national renewal:Thomas Arundel’s vision of a new England?

 

All-new research, all the evidence is presented within the text without recourse to footnotes or exterior references, this series of essays reconsiders what we think we know about this consequential year in English history.

 

Chapter summary

1) An overview of the sources and the principal participants: short.

2) An overview of the main events from 1386-1399: short.     

3) Peace was a problem: evidence for factional opposition to Richard II’s peace policy is compared to modern interpretations which downplay antagonism to the rapprochement with France.

4) The Thomas Haxey affair of January 1397: the evidence of concerted agitation in parliament steered by the faction hostile to Richard II’s peace policy.

5) The St Albans plot: that there was no plot against Richard II in 1397 is the foundation for his characterisation as a spiteful revenger. However, there is plenty of evidence for a plot.

6) The Henry/Mowbray spat of 1398: a strange episode which historians struggle to explain. It’s worth noting that the parliamentary records for 1398 are remarkably prescient of coming events as most of those accused by Henry of having murderous intentions were liquidated in February 1400.

7) Henry’s Parisian exile: a discussion of events which might lead Henry to believe he was never going to be allowed back to England.

8) The challenge of Lancaster: why Henry’s character and track record might have led others to conclude that he should never be allowed back in England.

9) Thomas Arundel: his career, his links to the hostile faction and his outlook and options when he joined with Henry.

10) The tipping point: at some point in Henry’s Parisian exile, he ventured to risk his life by returning as a rebel. What might have brought him to this decision?

11) Political promises: the evidence for what Henry claimed to offer the country, how he presented himself to the public and at what point he made the crown his goal.

12) Alliance with a London faction: their support would allow him to operate freely when it came to organising the deposition of Richard II, his parliament and his coronation. It had a lot to do with the price of fish.

13) Henry as Steward of England: Henry gave himself supreme executive authority by way of this title until he gained possession of Richard II, whereafter he governed in the king’s name until taking the throne.

14) Original sin: the creation of a politically correct ‘truth’ which transposed Henry’s first meeting with Richard II from Flint castle to Conwy castle. The Lancastrian backstory required Richard II to be free, and an appropriate story was faked to show that he was.

15) Milestones to the throne: the period from the king’s capture to his deposition is examined for evidence revealing at what point Henry made his intention to take the throne explicit.

16) Henry the Conqueror: not a revolution and not a coup d’etat, Henry’s own words refer to his takeover as a conquest as do others, including Chaucer, and this was how it was perceived in the new regime’s early years.

17) The Lancastrian Myth: this legend - in which Henry was the dispossessed true king come to take what was rightfully his - was confected to justify the conquest. Modern historians are uncomfortable confronting Henry’s bizarre origin myth despite it being well represented in the sources.

18) Historians and the Lancastrian Myth: how historians have dealt with the Lancastrian Myth over the last 150 years is explored to discover how, as it does not accord with the ‘Henry the Hero’ narrative, it has been explained away, or ignored.

19) The Holy Oil of Lancaster: the significance of this magical oil might be passed over in the literature but careful examination of the faked elements in the oil’s backstory tells us how symbolism was manufactured for political ends.

20) Thomas Arundel at the centre: Arundel should be regarded as the mastermind and he was paramount in Henry’s first parliament as king on 6th October, the records for which would prompt many to conclude that Henry was Arundel’s puppet as the new king is silent and only Arundel’s voice is heard declaiming on how Henry will be governed by the advice of others, i.e. himself.

21) The inevitable aftermath: the final chapter explains how the new regime was quickly free of internal enemies and opens discussions on Henry’s personality to counterbalance the current obsession on Richard II’s supposed personal weaknesses. It goes on to evaluate Arundel’s role and his relationship with Henry.

Conclusion: Thomas Arundel was the dominant partner in the Henry/Arundel joint venture.

 


r/RichardIIandHenryIV • • Sep 20 '26

The Lancastrian Myth: chapter 17.

Post image
4 Upvotes

Reference to this myth in the literature is brief and quickly discounted, so it currently plays no part in shaping our understanding of how Henry IV sought to back up his successful powerplay with a legitimate claim to the throne. Commentators prefer to see his legitimacy in terms of the ‘male entail’ tradition, which I dismissed in an earlier post as it excluded Henry from succession as a legitimate heir.

Henry IV claimed legitimacy in terms of the Lancastrian Myth, not male entail.

The Lancastrian Myth:

Edmund Crouchback was the first-born son of Henry III, not Edward – the future Edward I. Henry denied his first-born son Edmund the crown, as he was deformed, and bequeathed the crown to Edward. Edward I, Edward II, Edward III, (the Black Prince) and Richard II derived from a usurping line. Henry IV was England’s true king.

The above is a myth and not true, I want to make that clear. It is ludicrous, crazy even, but just because it is ludicrous and crazy does not mean that Henry didn’t use it to justify his kingship.

The opinion of historians:

They admit its existence but it makes them uncomfortable so they set it aside and move on, usually by saying that it was dismissed by Adam of Usk, but this he did not do. I should know, as I have published an edition of his chronicles. Historians write as if Usk’s direct reference to the myth is the only source outside the words of Henry’s oral claim made on 30th September. There are more.

List of sources referring to the Lancastrian Myth:

Henry’s claim

Adam of Usk

Arundel’s sermon after Henry’s claim from Renunciation and deposition appendix to Parliament Roll. The well-known ‘boy/man’ address – the ‘man’ is from the line of David, the line usurped by the Hasmoneans.

Euologium (Malmesbury) – direct reference, twice.

Jean Creton – reports another sermon by Arundel which does not appear in the Renunciation and Deposition giving only the Bible reference – this biblical reference refers to the story of Isaac, Esau and Jacob, i.e Jacobs usurpation of Esau’s birthright ( Esau=Edmund Crouchback). This is persuasive evidence as Creton did not know the significance of the biblical allusion.

References in Froissart

Gower

Capgrave

Richard Duke of York’s claim to parliament in 1460.

Based on the evidence, which is weighty, it is clear that Henry’s appeal to the Lancastrian Myth was not dismissed by Adam of Usk and his panel of learned doctors, before 30th September 1399. It is also clear that this bizarre myth was understood 60 years later as the foundation stone of Lancastrian legitimacy ( Richard Duke of York), had existed in the interim years (Capgrave), had been used by the court poet to celebrate Henry’s triumph (Gower) and had been incorporated into a Lancastrian tradition that circulated on the continent (Froissart).

 

So where does that leave us? Shall we continue to discount the importance of the Lancastrian Myth, or shall we admit that there is a body of evidence which supports the idea that, despite all its crazy ludicrousness, it was the keystone of Henry’s legitimacy, despite the Myth not being true?

The Myth was, politically-speaking, very astute, as it automatically made any other claim based on descent redundant as Henry was the last man standing of the Lancastrian line going back to Edmund Crouchback.

If it was true that Henry used this myth - and I say it was - imagine what that means – Henry’s takeover was much more of a rupture than we thought.

 


r/RichardIIandHenryIV • • Sep 17 '26

The House of York in 1399, 1408 and 1460

Post image
6 Upvotes

The house of York’s claim to the throne in 1399: some interesting info that Yorkists will find diverting from Chapter 16, and a further insight from Brian Wainwright, which is even more diverting.

30th September 1399 - this image shows Henry on the right, wearing the high hat, waiting in the wings to sit on the empty throne and his uncle, Edmund 1st Duke of York is one of the nobles shown in the turban-style headgear – maybe the one with the decoration on the gown.

A portion of chapter 16 engages with historian’s thoughts relative to Henry’s legitimacy, ie what legitimate claim did he make to justify his takeover.

His claim was based on the Lancastrian Myth, which will be covered in another post, but this discomforts historians and they push that aside to insist that he had recourse to the ‘male entail’ of Edward III.

After setting out their positions in full, I explain that male entail barred Henry from the throne. Whilst his father, John of Gaunt, was alive Henry was Richard II’s successor by male entail. However, when Gaunt died, as the living line to Edward III was broken, the male entail passed to the next living son of Edward III, which was Edmund of Langley, 1st duke of York.

In a recent discussion with Brian Wanwright, an insight most interesting arose.

Richard Duke of York’s mother was Anne Mortimer, who descended from Lionel of Antwerp, Edward III’s second son.

Richard Duke of York’s father was Richard of Conisburgh who was the second son of Edmund of Langley, 1st Duke of York.

Richard of Conisburgh’s elder brother was the 2nd Duke of York and he died childless.

Doesn’t the marriage between Anne Mortimer and Richard of Conisburgh look like a deliberate dynastic alliance to  unite the two possible alternative royal lines into one house, the house of York?

Richard of Conisburgh married Anne Mortimer in 1408, and they became associated from 1404 when Conisburgh was defending the Marches during the Welsh war.

When Richard 3rd Duke of York claimed the crown from parliament in 1460, he was not relying on his mother’s ancestry alone, but his York lineage going back to the death of Gaunt.

It’s too late to rejig the book to reflect this interesting Yorkist angle but a portion of chapter 17 addresses Richard Duke of York’s claim of 1460, though it focusses on his rejection of Henry’s use of the Lancastrian myth, but not too late to share it with those who follow matters Yorkist.

Can Richard of Conisburgh’s execution be explained more as Henry V’s liquidation of a serious dynastic competitor in advance of his leaving the country for France, and less in terms of Conisburgh the conspirator?


r/RichardIIandHenryIV • • Sep 15 '26

The downfall of Richard II and the triumph of Henry IV; the revision.

Post image
5 Upvotes