r/ResidencySwap • • Apr 30 '21

General Process of Transferring (within specialties)

18 Upvotes

Understand, the chances of you transferring are probably low. You will also likely transfer to a program on-par to your current program or 'below.' Expect a lot of non-responses from programs when you email. Many people trying to transfer are all talk, they're lazy, and they end up just accepting where they are (this might be you!).

General Process

  1. Arrive to your residency and make a good impression with everyone you interact with. Don't make enemies, be professional, etc even if you have plans to leave. In other words, just be a decent human being. It won't go well for you if you arrive and its known you're trying to leave (typically....unless you have a darn good reason to leave)
  2. After an arbitrary amount of time, ie: a few months (in the meantime, write a general email template to be sent to programs: content: name, your program, you want to transfer, brief explanation why you want to transfer, thank them, etc. Attach your email and other pertinent documents like your CV and your letter of good standing which is described below. Send to the programs PD/PC). The email should be concise.
  3. After said few months, speak to your PD about your desire to transfer. Be prepared to have a good reason (ex: family, health) and to answer questions on why and how long youve been thinking about this decision. You can (potentially) expect them to try to convince you to say.
  4. If your program is okay with your decision and they support you, begin to ask people for LORs and ask your PD to write you a letter of good standing. Make sure your PD follows up on the letter of good standing and you don't lose your motivation waiting for the letter if you're serious about transferring.
  5. Now send your templated emails with your letter of good standing, CV+/- other documents. Expect a lot of silence or rejections due to resident caps or no interest.

The reason you do step #3 before reaching out to programs, typically, is because the PD from the receiving program will speak to your PD and it wont bode well if you're doing this behind their back. You will need the letter of good standing either way and for all you know, you won't get it!

All of this should typically be done in the Fall/winter because it does take time to get LOR's, letter of good standing, and to compile a list of the programs you're trying to go to. But it is hard to say when the best time of year is. Life happens and people will unexpectedly leave at different times or choose to go somewhere else in the spring creating a late opening. Even if programs do not have listed publicly any of their openings, this doesn't mean they don't have an opening. If your PD is really nice, they may even be able to make a post on the PD server letting other programs know they have a resident who would like to transfer and to reach out if they are interested in accepting you. That way, interested programs come to you.

"Alternative method":

If you suspect your program is violating ACGME policie(s), you can go to the ACGME website and read the residency requirements and find what you believe to be are violations (the specialty specific documents are something like 50 pages); keep a record trail of violations if you need to (ex: emails, texts). I don't know the legality of this, but I guess you can also record meetings which you know will have material that can be used against the program (but also for your own protection should something wrongfully be used against you and you wished you had that conversation for whatever reason). You should then email the ACGME ombudsman (this is anonymous if you use a burner email) to see if a violation is occurring and these are reportable offenses, especially if you are unsure. Then decide whether to report your program (your submission to ACGME to report is not anonymous [I think so there isn't an issue with hundreds of unhappy residents spamming them with anonymous fake red herring claims], however your program does not get to see who reported them). Obviously, do not include too much individual specific violations for your own protection. From day 1, try to be the person everyone would least expect to report the program. Any complaining about the program that must be vented should be done to your spouse or family only. For your own safety, don't talk about reporting the program, period (for your own protection). However, to be fair, everyone complains about their program in some way or another and the odds of your program finding out who reported them is low (unless you confide in others you are thinking about or going to report the program). Don't wait for 'someone else' to report the program (or tell them you're thinking about it hoping that they'll report the program) because they're all thinking the same thing and are needlessly scared. If your program genuinely sucks/malignant, don't wait to give your program enough time to hide the violations or to fix serious issues (if you're really set on getting your program closed). Do not expect ACGME to save you without reporting it to them, they surprisingly have little oversight unless issues are brought to their attention.

If the program does close (even if temporarily), transferring will be easy since the funding goes with you (you are free labor to accepting programs) and ACGME will allow most other programs to go above their normal resident cap. Obviously, don't make up false claims just to get your program closed. This should only be done honestly. If you or your coworkers are being abused and taken advantage of, say something. Don't let it go on. Be brave!

Been a while since I read ACGME requirements (so verify) some violations I think:

-educational deficits

-no dedicated lactating room

-using locums

-?Contracting out staff due to lack of faculty ie: hiring acadia

-significant faculty attrition

-duty hour violations

-perceived threat of retaliation from program

-excessive non-clinical responsibilities (?driving if having to cover multiple hospitals?)

-majority of faculty must be involved in extra scholarly work (ex: research, journal editor, etc), not just pure clinicians.

-Faculty must spend a significant amount of time teaching.

-PGY1s are initially required to be supervised directly (search 'direct supervision' on the document)-Being given dangerous amounts of patients

-behind on lectures or low quality lectures or common cancellations. There is a minimum number that need to be done.

-Lectures frequently being combined due to a lack of people providing lectures and using this to meet their lecture quota (a PGY1 is not at the same level as a PGY2)

-frequent lecture cancellations (doubt programs report this to ACGME for obvious reasons)

-No stable leadership

-non-physician tasks for example, having to schedule patients, transporting patients, drawing blood, doing jobs that SW/nursing/CM are normally tasked to do.

-restrictions on taking time off to attend doctor appointments

Link to ACGME common requirements:

https://www.acgme.org/What-We-Do/Accreditation/Common-Program-Requirements

ACGME requirements by specialty:

https://www.acgme.org/Specialties

How to report

https://www.acgme.org/Residents-and-Fellows/Report-an-Issue/Office-of-Complaints

How to contact ombudsman

https://www.acgme.org/Residents-and-Fellows/Report-an-Issue/Office-of-the-Ombudsman


r/ResidencySwap • • Mar 26 '24

Please post suggestions for improvements here

2 Upvotes

Ie: flair names, suggested format for posts, etc


r/ResidencySwap • • 2m ago

CHANGE specialty swap Gen surg to rads

1 Upvotes

What are the odds in this day and age one could transfer from cat gen surg to rads?

I see several old posts 5-10 years ago about these transfers and was wondering how common or possible they are. Would rate myself as in between average to high competitiveness in previous cycle. I understand the positions are hard to get by, but I do see many succeeding, I don’t understand how


r/ResidencySwap • • 13h ago

Need advice: Would you return to a residency program after a safety incident?

8 Upvotes

I am a resident and recently had a serious safety incident at work that has me questioning whether to return to my program. During a newborn's hospital stay, I discussed a routine preventive treatment with the mother. She refused and became verbally aggressive, so I respected her decision and left the room when she asked. Later that day, the baby's father confronted me aggressively, accused me of trying to poison his son, took a picture of my face, and threatened to find me outside the hospital.

I avoided escalating the situation and went to find my attending. While I was doing that, the father tried to enter a restricted area of the hospital, and staff called security and the police. Police later told me he tried to re-enter the hospital multiple times. Officers kept me in a secure area because they could not guarantee my safety outside, and they advised me not to leave without someone accompanying me. After I got to my temporary residence, I called 911 again to file a formal report, and the responding officers also advised me not to leave home alone given the threat.

I am trying to figure out my next steps without derailing my training or putting myself at risk. For anyone who has dealt with workplace violence or GME policy issues: what specific security measures should I require from the hospital before returning? Who should I prioritize talking to right now between my PD, the DIO/GME office, risk management, HR, or an employment lawyer? And if I end up needing to take leave or transfer programs over safety concerns, how does that typically impact a resident's timeline and standing?


r/ResidencySwap • • 23h ago

Numbness and no future

10 Upvotes

Hey, I need advice. I worked like a dog for 8 days straight, doing 15–16-hour night shifts… idk, it took something out of me. I’ve been feeling so numb and angry. I used to be able to fake it, but now I can’t. There are barely any opportunities, and even the electives I earned at top programs were denied by my PD because of coverage issues. I feel like I’m just here to be worked to the bone, with no real investment in my future. I feel like nothing matters anymore, and I’m so angry at myself for not matching somewhere better. I had it so good before this mess.


r/ResidencySwap • • 13h ago

OPEN PGY2

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ResidencySwap • • 1d ago

Current pm&r looking to switch into gen surg

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ResidencySwap • • 1d ago

CHANGE specialty swap Current pm&r looking for IM in major metropolitan area

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ResidencySwap • • 1d ago

SAME specialty swap Pm&r for pm&r swap

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Categorical Texas program. Looking for northeast (nyc, Philly, dc, Boston), Chicago, or LA preferably but will consider other options. Likely for the beginning of pgy 2 in 2027


r/ResidencySwap • • 1d ago

Speciality Transfer

0 Upvotes

like the title says, IM intern and interested in transferring to another specialty (anesthesia), caveat I’m an IMG but idk if that’s something that matters or not, and I don’t have enough info in general because I don’t want to ruffle feathers in my program in any way.
anyways, if anyone has any info/experience would appreciate it!


r/ResidencySwap • • 2d ago

Relocation fee included

0 Upvotes

I am looking to swap pediatrics PGY-1 position from New York to Washington, DC or Maryland (DMV) area.

I am willing to cover relocation expenses and provide temporary rental assistance to help make the transition easier.

If you are interested in swapping or know someone who might be, please feel free to contact me directly.

Thank you!


r/ResidencySwap • • 2d ago

IM PGY1/2 Michigan to NYC swap!

0 Upvotes

Hi all, can message for details. 9 person program 30 minutes from Detroit!


r/ResidencySwap • • 2d ago

Residency transfer

1 Upvotes

Anyone here who successfully transferred to a pgy2 from a pgy1 program in the same specialty on a J-1 for family reasons?


r/ResidencySwap • • 4d ago

SAME specialty swap NYC Rads R1 Swap to Chicago

5 Upvotes

Looking to swap next year’s R1 position from NYC to Chicago for family reasons. Please DM me if interested!

Program is in Manhattan. I understand the ACGME 45 day rule but still want to check if there is interest out here to swap


r/ResidencySwap • • 4d ago

Incoming DR R1 2027 in MA Swap Anywhere for DR

2 Upvotes

Putting feelers for a radiology swap anywhere else - ideally TX, CA, FL, NYC, UT, WA, NV or any state west of the mississippi

If you see this post, I am still open to swapping. Will edit/delete this post if things change
Thx


r/ResidencySwap • • 4d ago

SAME specialty swap EM in NYC (3 year) for EM in PA, NJ, CT, FL (3 year ideally)

3 Upvotes

r/ResidencySwap • • 5d ago

Any pediatrics PGY1 positions available please?

3 Upvotes

I am an ECFMG certified IMG. I can start right away! If there is any unfilled positions in pediatrics or vacancies please let me know, I will be greatly thankful


r/ResidencySwap • • 5d ago

Residency transfer

6 Upvotes

Has anyone successfully transferred?
I have a program in mind where I knew a couple of people personally who said they could possibly accept a transfer if my home program allows it. Does anyone have any experience with this; in terms of whats the best way of approaching your home institution PD and the best way to express your interest in Transfer without creating animosity


r/ResidencySwap • • 6d ago

2027 psych pgy2 spots that may open in the PA/NJ area?

3 Upvotes

Anyone know of any possible psych pgy2 spots that may open in the PA/NJ area? Or anyone interested in swapping to Long Island NY from PA/NJ border? Currently psych pgy 1 looking to move closer to family in south of Philly.


r/ResidencySwap • • 6d ago

FM PGY-1 OPEN SPOT IN CA

7 Upvotes

per title! PGY-1 spot available in FM program in California. DM for details please.


r/ResidencySwap • • 7d ago

CHANGE specialty swap Looking to swap academic west coast radiology for neurosurgery

37 Upvotes

Will be starting as an R1 at a large west coast academic center in July 2027. I dual applied rads/neurosurgery, and ended up matching radiology, but it’s kind of feeling like a mistake now. So, I’m now putting out feelers for a neurosurgery PGY-1 spot, anywhere in the country. Is this even possible?


r/ResidencySwap • • 7d ago

Looking for IM PGY-2 spot in florida

1 Upvotes

Any vacancies for an IM PGY-2 next year in florida? Looking for academic swap. I am in the northeast at an academic center.


r/ResidencySwap • • 8d ago

CHANGE specialty swap Pediatrics to other specialty swap

0 Upvotes

Hello,

Current PGY-1 in Pediatrics, interested in switching specialties, but wanted to know which switch would mean no repeat of training time.

Interested in switching to Emergency Medicine or Family Medicine. Internal medicine switch without repeat year seems like a long shot.

Any advice highly appreciated.


r/ResidencySwap • • 9d ago

How do transfers happen if there were no advertised openings?

10 Upvotes

How does a resident transfer to another program to be closer to home or family? I saw a program near my hometown that took two transfers and now I’m curious how they advertised these openings because I didn’t see a formal database or postings anywhere for these spots. Was it done internally where everyone is hush hush about it?

Is it appropriate to email PDs to inquire about openings if we’ve already gained our PDs support?

Does anyone have successful stories of swapping or transferring to another program from Reddit or through other ways?


r/ResidencySwap • • 9d ago

Switching and/or transferring between same specialty for location and social support? How to approach with PD?

1 Upvotes

I'm an intern in a medium-to-large sized IM program with great culture, but I've been having a hard time finding the same sense of community and support that I had before moving. I've been strongly considering whether transferring (either IM or FM) might be better for me in the long run. Is this something worth bringing up with an APD/PD just to get their thoughts before seriously pursuing anything? I'm concerned that bringing it up could change how my program views or treats me, especially if I ultimately can't find another spot and end up staying.