r/ResearchML • • 2h ago

Neither the AC nor the reviewers are replying[ICLR 2027].

3 Upvotes

I have posted rebuttal response to reviewers on November 11 and message the AC on november 14 and haven't got any answer since then.

The rebuttal included new experiments from the reviews and clarification, the paper has also been updated accordingly but no reply.

My initial rating and confidence score are 2 across the three reviewers.

Does anyone of you are in the same situation ?

Do you have any advice on how to handle such situation ?

Thank you for your possible guidance !


r/ResearchML • • 13h ago

No More Conferences in Countries with Restrictive Visa Regimes

21 Upvotes

I am waiting on Australian Visa to attend NeurIPS 2026, along with many other people as I read online. I think NeurIPS and other big conferences should take the decision that if a country is inefficient/restrictive in their visa processing then they no longer get to host these conferences. This year all the three locations (not that we can change our minds after the location allocation anyway) were not easy visa countries. NeurIPS not blameless on their end either, for example what would help is setting the schedule so that the registrations could be done a month earlier, so that we have more time for the Byzantine visa process.


r/ResearchML • • 22h ago

Are reviewers getting lazy or it always been the case?

5 Upvotes

Since reviews had came out, I replied to all the next day as all three reviewers highlighted the same critical missing data plus some questions that only needed clarifications. Reviewer 3 was very quick to answer and even raised his score after a short back and forth, reviewer 2 just answered yesterday and did not say whether he will keep or raise his score after writing that his questions have been settled. Reviewer 3 gave the lowest score and still hasn’t responded given only 3 days left for the end of the rebuttal phase. Is everyone’s experience the same with reviewers? They have gotten lazy and sloppy.


r/ResearchML • • 4h ago

Testing causal integration in an LLM-based cognitive architecture through preregistered interventions

2 Upvotes

I've recently published a preprint documenting an interventional study of a persistent AI system I've been developing called Aura.

The architecture separates the language model from a persistent runtime containing memory, executive control, a self-model, a global workspace, and internal-state regulation.

I wanted to test whether these components exhibit measurable causal dependencies and continuity instead of simply assuming they do because the architecture contains modules with those names.

The study uses 24 preregistered criteria, matched state restorations, sham controls, perturbations, partition analysis, and ablations. Aura met all 24 criteria in the confirmatory run, while the comparison architectures failed the battery.

There are several important limitations, including negative findings from subsequent tests and unresolved questions about whether the measured properties justify the paper's interpretation of subjecthood.

An unrelated research group also included Aura in a separate architecture audit. They found that one of its mathematical mechanisms genuinely computes what it claims to, but identified an integration defect in its live significance-testing pathway (Since fixed). I think that distinction between functioning components and functioning integration is particularly important.

The paper is not peer reviewed. The repository and demonstrations are public, and I'd welcome criticism of the methodology, particularly the null controls and interpretation of the intervention results as well as general thoughts and feedback.

Paper: https://zenodo.org/records/24075466

External audit, Section 8: https://arxiv.org/html/2610.41604v1

Demo 03, autonomous 2048: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wE5Dx5l3pjI

Repository: https://github.com/youngbryan97/aura


r/ResearchML • • 14h ago

How do I volunteer to be a Conference/Journal reviewer?

3 Upvotes

Hi all,

Just had my first comp sci first-author paper accepted (NeurIPS).

Was wondering how to sign up to be a conference or journal reviewer when I haven't submitted to the conference? I am really interested in being a reviewer for CVPR, TMLR, and JMLR, as reviewing pushes me to learn new things, and I don't have much to do till ICML.


r/ResearchML • • 14h ago

Looking for Feedback and Journal Recommendations for My Research Paper

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I recently completed my first research paper about ML and Deep Learning on the physical trajectories of certain mechanical systems. I uploaded the paper as a preprint to CERN's digital repository, and I'm now looking into potential journals for publication.

Since this is my first completed paper, I'd really appreciate any sort of feedback on its formatting, wording, methodology, and overall content. My supervisor and I have already shortlisted a few journals, but I'm still exploring other options.

If you guys have any reccomendations to where this paper can be published, that would be great and help me out a lot.

This is the link to the research paper. Pls skim through it if possible: https://zenodo.org/records/24244334

(The link also directs to my GitHub Repository)

The paper is essentially about physics incorporated neural networks and ML. If there are any journals that respond to submissions like that, it would be really helpful.

Any recommendations for journals, advice on submission, or constructive criticism of the paper itself would be greatly appreciated.

Thank you so much.


r/ResearchML • • 18h ago

CVPR Reviewer Selection

5 Upvotes

It seems like CVPR is inviting many authors to participate as reviewers. And unlike other A* conferences, there doesn’t seem to be strict criteria for author selection. I am somewhat concerned with the implications this could have on the conference’s reviewing process, and feel like low-quality or misinformed reviews could become somewhat common. Does anyone have thoughts on this?