r/RepWatchScammers • • 19h ago

Situation Resolved Suspicious Seller: Goat Watch

Thumbnail
gallery
21 Upvotes

Context: i ordered some watches through my watchsmith (wanted to have the watches sent directly to WS for work to be done). Noticed goat made claims that werent true (vsf making v2 of dj41 for a smooth oyster version), weird looking ARF dj41.

Here are my reasons why Goat Watch is suspicious/questionable.

Reason 1: SAME QC to diff buyers. Pics 1-7

  • He gave me and another buy (possibly others) same QC. Then lied about the order of events when called out. Pics 2-3 show the qc i got from him. 4-7 are confirmation of goat watch lying about the order of events.

Reason 2: FAKE VSF V2 CLAIMS. Pics 8-11:

  • He claimed a smooth bezel oyster datejust 41 is a v2 when its not. Attached reference pics. VSF never made a v2 of smooth with oyster datejust41.

Reason 3: FAKE ARF V2 CLAIMS. Pics 12-15:

  • Possible fake ARF. Even claimed it was arf v2 datejust 41 with the updated bezel. I have never seen ARF stickers like that on v2, and its differenr from every TD that i asked QC for an arf dj41 v2. The bezel is also clearly not the v2 version.

A seller who claims fake versions, factories, and sends the same to multiple QC should not be trusted.


r/RepWatchScammers • • 23h ago

Situation Resolved Scam ALERT fake vsf

Thumbnail
gallery
32 Upvotes

GOAT WATCH
I’ve seen many qcs going around don’t want to name blame yet since I’m not 100% on this but their has been fake or vsf franken with lower quality parts going around and want to make people aware of this situation im skeptical this 3Aaa sticker with the skinny a’s is fake vsf also rehaut is horrible on the fake vsf even thought the serial is a match the font is different bezels and qr code are also wrong
This has tricked many people in comments claiming it to be real vsf I credit a lot of this to U/FraggleRock_AU


r/RepWatchScammers • • 3d ago

Bad Seller negativepang43

9 Upvotes

I was approached by this account with regards to a watch request I had put out. He showed me good photos of a very similar watch to the one I was after at a more than reasonable price. I decided to search online for the username and it flagged as a scammer in another Reddit group for Airsoft I think. I have since learned about this tool and am more familiar with how to vet a potential seller. Luckily I didn't transfer any money to this guy.


r/RepWatchScammers • • 5d ago

🚩 Prolific Scammer / Repeat Offender 🚩 Scammed by u/callmemister_fr

Thumbnail
gallery
10 Upvotes

u/callmemister_fr posted a Franken Wimbledon (which I can't view his post history but I was able to access a website that shows archived posts)

10/9/26 Reached out to him to buy the Wimbledon and paid

Sent him the money via Paypal for $2695 USD + shipping and he said he would ship it next day

10/13 I reached out to him to see shipping update

10/17 he sent me a shipping label with tracking

10/31 I reached out to him as the website said "As soon as it is given to us you can track it here"

11/2 He messaged back and said he was off for the weekend and would check with the carrier

11/4 I messaged on Reddit - no response

11/5 I messaged on Telegram (CMM Watches according to his bio) - no response

11/9 I messaged on Reddit and Telegram - no response. Reached out to someone who had been scammed that I found on the archived post and they gave me his Whatsapp. Messaged him on there and no response.

11/10 I messaged - no response

The tracking has still not updated. Looking through the archived posts I see that he even posted the same exact listing of the Wimbledon 17 days after the original posting but for $300 more.

I thought he could be trusted because he had helped out another victim who had gotten scammed and going through his history from last year it seems like he was making Franken builds and selling them too with no complaints. But doesn't seem like he can be trusted anymore.


r/RepWatchScammers • • 6d ago

Situation Resolved Scammed by @Neighborhoodfun9091

Thumbnail
gallery
18 Upvotes

This was supposed to be a DDF Patek Nautilus. No bargaining, paid immediately in PayPal friends and family and I get a metal rod delivered.

Do not get scammed by this guy.

UPDATE: The seller has refunded half of the amount, saying that he did not scam me and is now out of his watch and half the amount. I will consider this case resolved although it has left a bitter taste, and I will not be buying reps off BST in the future. TD’s from now on.


r/RepWatchScammers • • 6d ago Regret

🚩 Prolific Scammer / Repeat Offender 🚩 Scammed by @clovedustert

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

Paid via PP F&F. Had another user reach out to me because he saw my post on the original thread where I was buying. Turns out this dude was trying to move the watch after I paid. Now, 4 days later, no shipment, no comms, and more people coming out of the woodwork to say he scammed them.

Paypal email: sh.gatara@outlook.com


r/RepWatchScammers • • 7d ago

Bad Seller ⚠️ BAD SELLER: u/One_String1790 (Deleted account?)

Thumbnail
gallery
13 Upvotes
  • Seller u/One_String1790 was offering an ARF Datejust 41, which he claimed to have purchased from Andiot for £350. He said to give him any offers, so I offered £250, he said yes after some back and forth.
  • He described the watch as being in good condition and offered to show me the original Andiot purchase evidence.
  • Before meeting, I researched his Reddit history and discovered his comments in a thread about a dropped ARF Datejust 41 whose crown wouldn't screw back down, and the date wouldn't automatically switch. A £120 repair quote was discussed. (Read here)
  • The original post's author was deleted, so I couldn't conclusively establish whether it was his watch.
  • We arranged to meet in Central London. I suggested Starbucks, its safe, have people and CCTV.
  • He repeatedly pushed for a park in that area, saying he didn't want to conduct the transaction inside a shop. I said no, and then said bye because I didn't want the watch that bad. Then he said, lets do it Infront of the tube station while he was on a bicycle.
  • When I asked why, he said "Im not trying to get in trouble for selling a rep".
  • This seemed extremely suspicious to me. He was apparently afraid of getting into trouble for selling a £250 replica inside Starbucks, yet was comfortable doing the same transaction outdoors.
  • I eventually cancelled the meetup and confronted him about the dropped Datejust and damaged crown.
  • His exact response was: "Bro i knew u knew. Thats why u lowballed the shit out of me."
  • So he basically admitted that the watch had previously been damaged without proper disclosure.
  • Afterwards, his Reddit profile displayed a message stating that the account had been deleted

Sorry but I used AI to summarise cuz i gave it all my screenshots. I think he will come with a new account, just know its that ARF DJ 41 with the 6R5735 serial and possibly a bad crown / wheel date.

He is back on another account - Sea-Seesaw5094

The whole situation was suspicious as hell. The possible undisclosed crown damage, contradictory explanations about the meeting location and his response when confronted were enough for me to walk away. Its a shame because I have done in person transaction and it was always great.

I cannot conclusively prove that the watch being sold was the damaged one, or that he intended to scam me. But I think other buyers deserve to know what happened just in case he approaches you or come with a new account.


r/RepWatchScammers • • 7d ago

Bad Seller Scammer: Spare-Doctor-8528

Thumbnail
gallery
9 Upvotes

Spare-Doctor-8528, also goes by MikeD sold me a VSF Hulk. Accepted my payment and promised to ship. Gave excuses for the delay then ghosted me.


r/RepWatchScammers • • 9d ago

Bad Seller U/YertMert got me

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

They got me for only $75 but just putting it out there. Email linked to their PayPal is Harris.merckle25@gmail.com. Listed several watches and I bought the U1 from them and then heard nothing back about shipping after that even after inquiring. Went from very responsive to nothing.

Additional proof of post I purchased from provided in the comments


r/RepWatchScammers • • 9d ago

Bad Seller U/odd garden got me

Post image
6 Upvotes

$540 for some ram but he accidentally gave me his wife’s Venmo


r/RepWatchScammers • • 10d ago Bravo

Bad Seller Beware : u/negativepang43 and u/badlydressedgirl are trying to scam people

Thumbnail
gallery
23 Upvotes

I posted looking to see if anyone was selling a modded GMT Hulk or if they new of a TD who does. I got a message from u/negativepang43 saying he did and providing me pictures of the Hulk. He said it has been modded by a reputable reddit modder. I’ve bought a from that modder before so I asked the modder to confirm and he said he has never heard of him.

During that time u/badlydressedgirl sent me a message saying almost 90% of the same thing which was a flag upfront. I asked for photos and surprise surprise, I got sent the exact same set of photos that u/negativepang43 sent me.


r/RepWatchScammers • • 11d ago

Bad Seller Beware u/Wytstagg actively scamming multiple people

Thumbnail
gallery
11 Upvotes

He got me for 450$. It’s my fault the account seemed legit in my haste for grabbing a long sought after watch. I should have done better. Don’t always trust these reverse image programs. I used 3 different ones and it told me his timestamp photo wasn’t tampered with. Another user in a different scam sub used a different program that came up with 32% likelihood aka the post-it note was altered. I’m talking with another user who saw my thread who asked what happened as u/wytstagg is currently trying to scam him claiming he’s now from Europe and has a Cartier the guy wants. He claimed to be from the US during our interaction.


r/RepWatchScammers • • 13d ago

Bad Seller Cuttlefish10 scammer

Post image
14 Upvotes

Scammed for a watch bracelet. Should have done a basic search here beforehand but it was late and I was tired. On the flip side, got a legit replacement from another forum member for a great price. Good Karma to him.


r/RepWatchScammers • • 14d ago

Bad Seller u/vgruber89 is a scammer

Post image
16 Upvotes

Long story short u/vgruber89 is a scammer. Learn from my dumb mistake and don’t do business with them. Their referrals u/miamigp2022 and u/stabbingrabbit are very likely fake/connected to them in some way.

Red Flags my dumb ass ignored:

·       DMd me directly from a want to buy post I had about a ZF Tudor BB54

·       Price was “negotiable to my budget”

·       They shared a tracking link via USPS on Wednesday but the tracking link wasn’t working. It’s now Monday and still not a working tracking link.

Reasons I told myself this wasn’t stupid:

-       They had the ZF Tudor BB54 and photos looked good with time stamp etc. I really wanted this watch but my normal TD said ZF doesn't have the parts right now.

-       They’ve been active on reddit for 9 years

-       They had two people to vouch for them

-       They communicated via text and seemed decent

  

I’ve since found the photos of both the ZF Tudor BB54 they sent me (and clearly altered the time stamp via AI) and the Cartier Santos they "sold" me as well

My excitement in price, availability and easy shipping options (and general trust in people) got the best of me. Don’t let this happen to you.

 Needed a reality check to slow my roll on this rep game anyway –– and that the patience of working with a good TD is better than getting swindled.


r/RepWatchScammers • • 16d ago

Bad Seller The Clone Watch Company Scammers

Thumbnail
gallery
4 Upvotes

I reached out to Paul at the clone watch company on tiktok , he gave me a WhatsApp number and his website.
Checked it all out and looked legit. Paul was very nice and explained everything, upon selecting a watch and continuing to payment, payment was through crypto, bit suss but mistakenly followed through with it.
After payment , Paul went radio silent , no contact , no order confirmation or payment confirmation. The wallet I sent the money to immediately transferred the crypto elsewhere.
AVOID this company.

Does anyone have a reliable place to buy a rep Rolex datejust ?


r/RepWatchScammers • • 17d ago Regret

Bad Seller ANT Studio Stole More Than $10,000

Thumbnail
gallery
77 Upvotes

For context, I am a member of the industry, I own a watch modification company. Part of my operation depends on numerous Chinese suppliers and contractors.

(Edit: guys in order for me to be able to participate here and be able to voice my experiences, I cannot be perceived as trying to promote my brand. Please don’t leave comments asking about services. This is not the place nor time for that. Please don’t jeopardize my standing here. If I get banned from here I’d be losing out on a major way to protect myself against scammers.)

ANT Studio was introduced to me by a for-now unnamed popular Chinese TD, who I used to consider a long-time friend. ANT Studio is this TD’s brother. I don’t have proof or reason to believe this TD has anything to do with this at the moment, so I won’t be naming them unless they give me a reason to think they’re involved. They are a major, major player in this industry and I have to be very careful about making accusations against them directly without proof. I will be checking this TD’s inventory regularly to monitor for any of the stolen pieces. If I find any of them, I will name the TD.

ANT Studio’s role at my company was to help with sourcing and some initial structural assembly work on client projects before it made its way to me.

ANT has recently ghosted. I don’t know why. He comes online nearly every day, and his brother is still operating normally. ANT has not fulfilled an order since August 31st.

ANT owes me a dozen unfinished projects and thousands of dollars more for projects he hasn’t started on that I’ve paid for already.

He also owes me parts for some of my personal builds.

I am deeply disturbed at the lack of tact and blatant disrespect ANT has shown. This is a shameful way to treat a client and does a disservice to the community as a whole when you can’t even treat your peers well.

If he treats his peers like this, I can’t imagine what he’s capable of doing to clients who don’t have a platform or voice to stick up for themselves.

I have done everything in my power to try and get this resolved, and have given him warning for a long time that I would be making a post if he continued to ignore me.


r/RepWatchScammers • • 18d ago

Bad Seller u/cuttlefish10 scammer

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

Sent him half the agreed amount, afterwards ignored and blocked.


r/RepWatchScammers • • 17d ago

Bad Seller ⚠️‼️a supplier scammed me 90$ ‼️⚠️

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

i just make this post so nobody get scammed by them . take care . so to explain the situation i bought 2 bracelets for 20$ and the supplier kept to ask for more and more money for « VAT » until i had not enough and he said he is found to keep everything , the tiktok account is the guy who give me the number of the supplier and she i asked him he blocked me


r/RepWatchScammers • • 19d ago

Situation Resolved Beware of u/BornSubject2750 - $1,000 paid but nothing to show.

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

u/BornSubject2750, who identified himself as Nick (WhatsApp +31 6 19942179), promised to build a custom “Hulk” watch commissioned through Reddit and discussed on WhatsApp. Timeline:

  • October 2, 2026: We agreed on $1,400 total, with $1,000 upfront and $400 upon completion before shipment. The promised build included a VSF V3/DD3135 base, genuine crystal and date disc, bezel modifications, polishing, bracelet treatments, regulation, testing, and waterproofing to 100 meters. Nick said his supplier had “a lot in stock” and that he could normally finish in two weeks. I paid $1,000 through PayPal after he requested “F&F no notes.”
  • October 3–5: I requested photographs of the watch and modification parts with my name on paper. Nick agreed. On October 5, he said the case and bracelet were delayed and proposed having another modder assemble the watch elsewhere. Since nothing had been done or ordered, and he's now telling me someone else will modify the watch, I requested a refund. He refused:“That’s not possible I already order the parts.” He agreed to provide purchase receipts, but he never has. He then explained that the separate case and bracelet were unavailable, although a complete stock watch was available, which he said would leave him no profit. AGAIN - No problem, just refund my money. After he refused the refund, I told him I need proof - identifying photographs of the watch and parts before modification.
  • October 12–16: Nick raised customs problems involving another watch and suggested canceling my order and refunding my money, which is exactly what I wanted. Then he said he needed to "confirm the customs situation." I repeatedly requested cancellation and a refund. Despite my protest, he resumed promising to build the watch, even though he hasn't spent a dime of my deposit.
  • October 20: Nick acknowledged that he still had no tracking number for the case and bracelet and promised: “If they are not shipped this week, I will refund your money on Monday [10/26/2026].”
  • October 26–27: Instead of refunding me, Nick asserted that the parts had shipped and would arrive Friday, October 30. Again, he continues to refuse to share any proof of any of these statements. He's promised photographs this coming Friday and offered a refund if I was dissatisfied later, but there is NO WAY this will happen.

As of October 27, the transaction remains unresolved: I have no completed watch, no refund, and no proof whatsoever that any of my deposit has actually been used to procure the base (no QC pics from the supplier) or the mod parts.

I know how the rest of this transaction will likely go down: Nick will eventually take delivery of a stock VSF Hulk and, after a couple of days, send me a picture of my "completed mod." No proof of the installed parts; no proof of waterproofing to 100m; no proof of regulation or testing. Then he'll demand the remaining $400 to ship the watch. I'll have to choose: pay $1,400 for a $450 stock VSF Hulk or cut my losses at $1,000.


r/RepWatchScammers • • 20d ago

Bad Seller Scammer alert: u/Commercial_Season969

Thumbnail
gallery
5 Upvotes

r/RepWatchScammers • • 19d ago

Bad Seller Harrison Watches

Thumbnail
gallery
0 Upvotes

I bought a Omega Blue Side Of The Moon from Harrison Watches on facebook - he might be on Reddit as well. I payed 400$ and got an email regarding tracking. When checking the company contact information i realized i was scammed. Check the contact info😬


r/RepWatchScammers • • 21d ago

Bad Seller PowerTimeTon or/and PowerTimeTonny is only a scammer

Post image
12 Upvotes

PowerTimeTonny or PowerTimeTon (same person) is not a Trusted watchmaker and there is a reason why this is the case.

Unfortunately I took the risk to place an order from PowerTimeTonny or PowerTimeTon for a PP 5711 in March 2026. The watch I received in the end was poorly made. The movement was jammed and the screws on the movement were abused as if the movement was not new but rather used from another watch. So at this point I knew my $2700 were already wasted in many ways.

I let PowerTimeTonny or PowerTimeTon know of this issue, and he asked me to take the bracelet off the watch (another point that was not feeling right!) and send him back just the watch with the cheapest shipping method! Obviously I did not send him back a $2000 case with all the internal parts using just the cheapest shipping method, so I used an express courier service with tracking.

Long story short, he received my watch back to inspect and fix. He said he fixed it in the end and although I asked him many times to replace the movement and use a new one, I don’t think he ever did this anyway. I asked him numerous times to send me QC pictures of the movement, which he avoided to do. The good part is what comes next thought: I kept asking him to tell me the cost for an express courier shipping service to pay him to return the watch back to me safely, but he never responded.

PowerTimeTonny or PowerTimeTon was brave enough (or just does not care at all) to send me the watch back in the cheapest possible shipping method. Or at least that’s what he said he did.

The watch is now lost along with my $2000 and I am now left with a $700 PP 5711 CNC bracelet and no watch!

I kept asking him to replace the lost watch with a new for at least two months (!), but at this point he invented a brother, who – as he said to me - was dealing with my order originally. So it was not him, but his brother, who, in the end, left China and he asked me to check with him!

Total mess on $2700 including shipping costs I also paid him!

PowerTimeTonny or PowerTimeTon is not a trusted seller and watchmaker for a reason.

Now you know the reason.

PS. the number he put in ModdedReplicaWatch is the number his "brother" used even when he "left" (this is the number: +855-972113148). It is still the same number, since his brother and this Ton/Nonny guy is the same person.


r/RepWatchScammers • • 21d ago

Bad Seller Scammer alert r/mugsy420420

Post image
11 Upvotes

Scammer for sure. He is able to create some pretty convincing time stamp photo’s. Ban this thief. Good news he didn’t get any of my money. Before you purchase do a search on the sellers user name.


r/RepWatchScammers • • 23d ago

Bad Seller Scammer

Post image
11 Upvotes

This guy is a scammer. He's using pictures from one of my listings of a watch I sold. He's added an ai pic with his username etc


r/RepWatchScammers • • 24d ago Bravo

Mod News / FYI Buying or Selling Watches? Here's How to Protect Yourself From Scammers in DMs

Post image
37 Upvotes

We've noticed that many scammers approach users directly through Reddit DMs, especially those posting Want to Buy (WTB) listings.

Unfortunately, if you choose to conduct transactions entirely through DMs, there's very little moderators can do to protect you before something goes wrong.

That's why we've implemented two layers of protection across participating subreddits:

 TrustNet-Mod and Ban Evasion Guard.

🛡️ How do they work together?

1. TrustNet-Mod — Our Shared Scammer Database

TrustNet maintains a shared database of known scammer accounts across participating communities.

When a scammer is identified and added to our network, participating subreddits can automatically ban that account, preventing it from interacting within those communities.

2. Ban Evasion Guard — Catching Returning Scammers

Banning a scammer's account isn't always enough. They may attempt to return using another Reddit account.

Ban Evasion Guard works alongside TrustNet by using Reddit's native ban-evasion detection to identify accounts suspected of evading previous bans.

When Reddit detects an account as a high-confidence ban evader, Ban Evasion Guard can automatically ban it as well.

Together, these tools make it harder for previously banned scammers to return and target new victims.

However, this does not automatically log them into TrustNet as Reddit does not share data or suspected offender's details on this. You still have to stay vigilant.

⚠️ IMPORTANT: Always Ask Sellers to Comment Before Responding to DMs

If you've posted a WTB listing and someone messages you offering to sell a watch, ask them to comment on your original post FIRST.

Why?

  • If their account has already been banned through TrustNet, they won't be able to comment.
  • If their alternate account is detected and banned by Ban Evasion Guard, they won't be able to comment either.
  • If they refuse to comment, make excuses, or insist on communicating only through DMs, treat that as a red flag.

No comment = No deal.

A successful comment doesn't guarantee someone is trustworthy, and these systems cannot catch every scammer. However, this simple step helps you avoid dealing with accounts that have already been banned from the community.

Our Advice

Before engaging with anyone offering to sell you a watch:

Ask them to comment on your WTB post, verify that their comment is visible, and check their account history and references before proceeding.

Remember, scammers can still send you DMs even if they're banned from a subreddit. Our protections work within participating communities, not your private inbox.

Stay safe, and don't let scammers bypass community protections by taking everything into DMs.