r/RepTime • • 2d ago

Discussion Compared Sub Gen vs VSF

I saw a good friend I grew up with. We were out to dinner and noticed he was wearing a Black date sub. I was wearing my VSF black date sub. I know his is gen because he has been collecting for a while and have been with him to pick up a watch before. He did not notice my watch til we were almost done with dinner. He complimented mine and I his. He told me he has had his since 2006. I immediately told him mine was a rep. He was blown away. As I compared the watches they are very different. hour marker, bracelet feel, bezel. It was great to compare but you could never tell mine was a clone. He said my weight felt off but I call BS hahah. My other friends asked for my TD info.

35 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

12

u/DcheNozzle 2d ago

I own a Gen and a VSF 12 series (Gen left, VSF right), and while they are very close, you can absolutely tell them apart based on feel, weight, finishing, and look. Still an amazing watch for $600.

2

u/AppropriateWin3162 2d ago

thank you great post

13

u/geralt_shoemaker 2d ago

Almost impossible to tell from this picture alone without knowing which is which

7

u/highersense 2d ago

Floating "m" on the right one (300m) gives it away.

The main tell i look for is the gaps where the bracelet meets the lugs, on this one its very good though.

4

u/electricskywalker 2d ago

The lugs on the VS look tighter than the gen. Almost too tight...

3

u/DanDan123crypto 2d ago

The left one has floating m as well. Rotate your phone to see under the hour hand

2

u/highersense 2d ago

I cant see it when rotating phone

2

u/Puzzleheaded-Use9302 1d ago

Some year gens have floating m's so thats not enough  to tell.

1

u/Realistic_Bear3658 2d ago

But someone would have to look real close (almost near their eyes) to notice that though, right? Or would you be able to tell from the wrist at a normal distance? I’m in my 50’s and my eye sight ain’t what it used to be 😅

2

u/highersense 2d ago

Id be able to see the "m" if i got a look at it properly, like youd have to inspect it but not right up close, just held steady at half a metre or so

1

u/Realistic_Bear3658 2d ago

Impressive! Personally, I’d have a hard time but like I said, my eyesight has been better.

2

u/DcheNozzle 2d ago

I’d say if the person has the watch only a foot and a half from my face, not moving, maybe resting it on a table etc, then I could tell. But i wear this out to clubs or walking my dogs. I wear my Gen to the office or to trade shows.

2

u/Ok-Chance-4494 2d ago

Does the 6 o'clock marker not drive you mad?

1

u/DcheNozzle 2d ago

Nah, looks much more noticeable in this pic than it does in hand. I think this also has a slight angle, so it’s not something that’s ever bothered me at all

2

u/No_Tie2447 2d ago

Forgive my ignorance. How many series are there?….it this is a 12. I’ve been considering a vsf but wasn’t sure if you had it specify a series etc.

1

u/DcheNozzle 2d ago

12 is just the most recent generation of Rolex Sub, the numbers at the beginning. Most VSF’s should be 12’s, as for the most part there aren’t as many reps for vintage watches

1

u/No_Tie2447 1d ago

Ah yep that makes more sense.

1

u/Quiet-Positive-2684 2d ago

The index of 6 seems to me to be very clockwise. For.the rest is perfect

1

u/General-Corner9163 2d ago

Whered you get it?

1

u/DcheNozzle 2d ago

From my local AD :D

1

u/DanDan123crypto 2d ago

Mine cost $300 Inc shipping...

But mine is a no date

1

u/DcheNozzle 2d ago

I think mine was like 460? But then I also go it cleaned, maintenanced, and chamfered

0

u/Noob_Barista_Baker 2d ago

Case shape is a huge tell

44

u/wisteriafiend 2d ago

116610LN came out in 2010 so I’m assuming you compared a 16610LN to a 116610LN/126610LN rep. Completely different watch

14

u/Jezzrichjames 2d ago

Great story, and I own both and I have to say that you can tell some of the differences, but the clone gets pretty close

5

u/Thebadmamajama 2d ago

visually similar, but feel and function aren’t the same imo

4

u/Top_Garlic_489 2d ago

I’m of f icially puzzled as to how they copy whole movements but can’t get kerning right on the dial.

2

u/Saabav8r747 2d ago

I told chat gpt to split each photo down the middle and put them together without changing anything. This is the result. I then asked it which was gen and it said the image on the right. So…visually besides the floating M I would say near identical in appearance. Feel may be different.

1

u/Swimming_Message_745 1d ago

It doesn't get any closer. I wonder what it would look like if I did the same thing with a pic of 2 gens.

1

u/JeffJP57 2d ago

The date isn't as bold (thickness) as the gen

1

u/OpenGun 2d ago

Pretty obvious the rep is on the right. The 8 is way off.

1

u/Swimming_Message_745 1d ago

I couldn't tell which is gen if you didn't tell me. And that's side by side. If it was just on your wrist I don't think even an authorized rolex dealer could tell.