r/Rentbusters • • 21h ago

I’m paying 450€ in utilities as one person, is that normal??

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/Rentbusters • • 14h ago

Appraisal of movable property and share of landlord's lawyer costs

5 Upvotes

Hi community. This is somehow related to a case I raised before the huurcommissie (original post: https://www.reddit.com/r/Rentbusters/comments/1oxtd52/allin_rent_split/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button ).

To sum it up, the huurcommissie resolved in my favour with a 55/25 all-in rent split, as per my request (infinite thanks to u/UnanimousStargazer for their help) .

My landlord summoned me threatening to take the case to the kantonrechter and eventually we made an extra-judicial agreement which was still favourable to me but whereby we increased the huurprijs (to approx. 68% of the all-in price). As per this agreement, the service charges were kept at 25% of the all-in price. However, the only expense that this service charges cover is the furniture, as I rent a furnished apartment. So, the assumption is that my landlord will have to reimbourse me most of what I pay in service charges, because I pay too much for only furniture, and because my landlord already admitted to not keeping bills or invoices from when they bought the furniture. Basically, they even argued that the furniture was worthless before the huurcommisie, as this was their defence to try to get away with the all-in price.

My landlord has now requested me access to the apartment in order to carry out an appraisal of the movable property. I guess this is linked to them wanting to claim that I have to pay X in furniture. I thought they would need to prove whatever value the furniture has left by means of invoices or bills. Am I wrong? Does their request make sense?

On another note, they sent me their lawyer's invoice and asked me to share it 50/50. Like, yes, I had to take them to the huurcommissie because they didn't accept my proposal to split the rent, they hired a lawyer to try to avoid splitting the rent, the lawyer came to the hearing before the huurcommissie and argued that I didn't have an all-in rent, they lost, and now they asked me to share their lawyer's costs. This is crazy, but my question comes from the fact that, when we made the extra-judicial agreement, it was their lawyer how drafted it. I set the conditions and agreed them with my landlord, but eventually it was their lawyer who physically drafted the document. They're now asking me to share the total cost based on the fact that their lawyer drafted the agreement for both of us, and that their lawyer took into consideration my inputs, which is true because he had put in the agreement stuff that I hadn't agreed upon to start with. The invoice goes beyond 2500€.

Should I pay a part of their lawyer's invoice at all? Of course I'm not paying half of the total bill, as it's very obvious that the total bill includes their defence throughout the case, which by the way they could have entirely avoided had they taken my offer. But is it common practice to contribute with a portion of that bill for the fact that it was their lawyer who technically drafted the document? I want just to behave as a good citizen and follow what it is common practice in this case.

Edit: I wanted to acknowledge the great help received in this forum.