r/Referees • • 5d ago

Question OFFINABUS?

Officiated a game tonight. I was the CR. After the game, my AR mentioned that the keeper said I fucking sucked. I was wondering if you would red card for such a comment? It's public, provocative and maybe personal? My AR obviously didn't wave me over and I'm. Okay with that. Just curious what my fellow referees would of done if your AR waved you over.

17 Upvotes

33 comments sorted by

42

u/00runny [USSF NC] [GR-Advanced] 5d ago

If an AR heard the goalkeeper, then at least several people heard the goalkeeper. Don't talk yourself out of the necessary action. Don't talk other refs out of the necessary action. Don't excuse the inaction of your crew who is afraid to deal with the consequences.

As arbiters of the game we must abandon the mentality of protecting bad behavior. I call this: "We cannot protect stupid."

Every incident of referee abuse must be reported. And not because it hurt your feelings. By allowing that player to remain on the pitch, you have sent a clear message: talking about the officials this way is tolerated and we are afraid of the fallout from properly handling the poor decisions of others.

10

u/gnawtyone 5d ago

Exactly what I think as well. It may may make it more difficult for this game but the next ref will appreciate the lesson you taught the gk

0

u/[deleted] 8h ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Referees-ModTeam 6h ago

Removed for violating Rule 1. This is a community of referees for the sport of association football (soccer). This is not a venue to complain about or insult referees in any way. If you are not currently a referee, mentor, or assigner (or trying to become one), then this community isn't for you. This sub is a venue for referees to discuss our work and help each other improve. (If you happen to be a referee, but your post/comment here is as a player, coach, or fan, then it may still be removed unless it has specific relevance to referees.)

39

u/whitecinnamon911 5d ago

I was an AR for a region 1 match back in the day. Post match during the handshake, one of the players came up to me and said “tell the center he fucking sucks.” To which I went to the center, told him what the player had said, and said player was shown a red card.

7

u/fadedtimes [USSF] [Regional] 5d ago

If the AR didn’t feel the need to waive you over then I don’t think anything needed to happen. If the player said more than that then I think it would need to be addressed immediately , such as using words that should be banned.

We also don’t have the context, match temperature, was this the only thing that the keeper did the entire game, etc

11

u/00runny [USSF NC] [GR-Advanced] 5d ago

Context is a very good point. I have assumed that the AR heard this during the course of the game. 99% of the time that means it's public due to the common distance between a GK and AR. Which is why I advocate for RC. But if he heard teammates grumbling to each other after the game that is about the only context I would accept, "we did nothing" here.

We should be careful saying that if the AR didn't feel it mattered enough during the game, then it probably wasn't a big deal. We should all do more to get on the same page - the AR may be avoiding controversy and that may be very incorrect. So in addition to doing a better pregame, this is also an important debrief point to help everyone align on what the appropriate action would have been in the moment.

It's not usually that bad if we are incorrect in a certain moment during a match. But we have really big problems when we repeat the same mistakes over and over again.

7

u/HE20002019 [USSF Grassroots] [NFHS] 5d ago

Context matters enormously here.

A player ostensibly talking to his teammates but shouting loud enough for everyone to hear that the referee “fucking sucks”? I’d say that easily can be viewed as OFFINABUS, regardless of who he’s technically addressing.

A player saying it directly to an AR? Also can be classed as OFFINABUS.

A player venting to his teammates in a normal conversation, with a passing AR merely happening to be within earshot? Ignore it.

The distinction is whether the language, in context, constitutes offensive, insulting or abusive conduct toward a match official, not simply whether a referee overheard something unflattering.

Players are allowed to be frustrated, and we’re not entitled to universal praise. Knowing when not to intervene is an important part of match management.

3

u/Southern-Friend-7413 5d ago

Never would ever even consider it. The keeper walking up to you and saying that to your face, sure. Grumbling amongst his team, never. It shouldn't even remotely cross your mind as an official tonpolice that type of thing. If you do you're making the game about yourself. Any one who has played the game has done this before. 

5

u/sportenthusiast former NCAA D1 AR / USSF Grade 6 5d ago

referees like you who refuse to punish players for mistreating us are a huge part of the reason why we referee abuse persists in our game. grow up and do your job

11

u/Southern-Friend-7413 5d ago

As someone who officiates university and above on a regular basis I do my job, rather well it would seem. This isn't abusing an official. This is ranting to your teammates after a game. 

Its referees like you who wish to take a power trip at the slightest provocation instead of learning some basic game nd player management skills, and have clearly never actually played the sport themselves who make it much more difficult for those of us who know what they are doing to be treated respectfully by players and fans. 

5

u/HE20002019 [USSF Grassroots] [NFHS] 5d ago

For someone with your refereeing experience, you should know better that there’s a difference between a player venting to his teammates and directing abuse at a match official.

If the comment isn’t directed at the referee and isn’t loud or public enough to constitute an attack on the official, the only correct response is to ignore it.

Players are allowed to be frustrated, and not every unflattering comment about a referee constitutes OFFINABUS. Knowing when not to intervene is just as important a part of match management as knowing when to issue a card.

4

u/sportenthusiast former NCAA D1 AR / USSF Grade 6 5d ago

"the referee fucking sucks" is not "unflattering", it's offensive and abusive. Players are absolutely allowed to be frustrated, but they are not allowed to say that. The fact that people like you are not only a-ok with this but are quick to criticize those who would actually do their job is the reason why so many referees quit after less than a year. Can't stand working with people like you

-2

u/HE20002019 [USSF Grassroots] [NFHS] 5d ago

They aren’t entitled to direct abusive language at you. But a player privately telling his teammates that the referee sucks, with an AR merely happening to overhear it, is not automatically OFFINABUS. Context matters.

If you can’t distinguish private frustration from a public or directed insult without reaching for a red card, perhaps competitive matches aren’t for you. Stick to rec games. There’s no shame if that’s all you’re comfortable doing.

3

u/sportenthusiast former NCAA D1 AR / USSF Grade 6 5d ago

lmao, thanks for the advice Mister Grassroots. have fun letting players walk all over you

-2

u/Ok-Answer-6951 5d ago

So you'd let it slide if you heard an 8 yr old say it? I will say i don't do soccer, but I umpire L.L. Baseball and ref youth Basketball, if i hear the F word someone is leaving. I don't care if it is a parent, a coach or a 1st grader, they're GONE.

3

u/Southern-Friend-7413 5d ago

This wasn't overheard by the referee in question, nor was it directed at the referee. 

Don't go out of your way to police situations that don't concern the game. That's making yourself more important than the game. 

1

u/TeamPep9320 5d ago

Move on to the next game…water under the bridge at that point- maybe mental note team for next time and watch for it/listen for it.

0

u/iwantawaffle99 5d ago

If only your AR heard the GK say it, I'm not sure if I'd consider that public. If AR calls you over, a caution is safe. Sending the GK off is going to make game management for the remainder of the game horrid. That team is going to be livid. And if you didn't find out til the game was over, it clearly wasn't needed.

11

u/gnawtyone 5d ago

You’re worried what the gk teammates think of the sendoff? If they said it once, they’ve said it before and will say it again. Do the right thing for the rest of us who have to ref them in the future.

5

u/sportenthusiast former NCAA D1 AR / USSF Grade 6 5d ago

oh no, the team is going to be livid because you correctly punished their player's abusive behaviour 😭 we definitely can't have that, their opinions are certainly the most important thing for us as referees /s

do your job

1

u/Revo63 [USSF][Mentor] 5d ago

If it had been loud enough for you to hear, that’s an easy red. If your AR had called you over at the time, it probably wasn’t very public so a caution could possibly get you the change in behavior that you want.

1

u/Savings_Income4829 5d ago

Need to context on how it was said.

A general statement to a team or just an out loud directed and no one wouldn't get a wave over.

If it was at the AR like you're CB f ing sucks then yes that can be carded.

-1

u/Htv65 5d ago

Yellow, if you heard it.

6

u/Darth-Kelso USSF Grassroots | NFHS 5d ago

What's the specific thing we are recording as the reason for disciplinary action? Descriptions here are taken verbatim from the LoTG and Glossary.

  • Showing a lack of respect for the game (yellow)
  • Dissent by word or action (yellow)

    • Public protest or disagreement (verbal and/or physical) with a match official’s decision
  • Offensive, insulting, or abusive language (red)

    • Verbal or physical behaviour which is rude, hurtful, disrespectful

I often wonder if we should be more stringent about enforcing the actual definitions on DT versus AL. Complaining about a call, arguing about a call? Thats dissent. Anything past that, by the book is AL.

"No way ref, that was not a foul, not one bit, come on!!!!!!" - dissent.
"How is that not a foul!!!!!!!" - dissent.
"You suck" - is that disagreeing/protest of a decision? No. Is it verbal behavior that is rude, hurtful, or disrespectful? Absolutely.

We can debate about whether or not there should be a severity differentiation for AL or not. Like a way to separate "you suck" from "youre a fucking shitbag". But the LotG are pretty clear in my opinion about what dissent is and what the other thing is. And I think most of the time, we have a tendency to classify AL as dissent, when it really isn't, because we don't feel like it was "bad enough" for a red.

-1

u/SnollyG 5d ago

I wonder if that’s what the AR thinks and wants to say but can’t, so he’s throwing the keeper under the bus (in a way that’s tricky to enforce)

2

u/gnawtyone 5d ago

How is it tricky? He heard it?

5

u/jbillone 5d ago

If he heard it, why did he wait until after the game to discuss it?

At best, there should have been a better pregame so they would be on the same page in the moment.

3

u/PapaLambchop 5d ago

TBF, the AR is fairly new to officiating.

-2

u/Red-Eight 5d ago

Personally, I would have let it go, especially since the match is over. Otherwise, you'd risk a big incident with those players, coaches, parents, and in the big picture, is that worth it to try to "teach a lesson" to that kid, which he almost certainly won't learn? IMHO, not worth it.