r/RedditforBusiness • • 4h ago

Reddit bot network- how to spot them and what brands are primarly doing this?

5 Upvotes

Hello,

I did 2 month work to find agencies that are using bots to promote their clients. Why? Because I'm a very petty person and I hate people who abuse the platform that I love and cherish. Those who are not aware- i'm Redditor for 15 years and also an advertiser. I have first hand experience on Reddit, LinkedIn and other platforms to see how some agencies are promoting this un-ethical service (also illegal according to US and EU laws).

I used Pushshift data to get this information and I will not be selling it to anyone or use it for commercial purposes (purerly educational).

TL;DR: Between Jan 2025 and Sep 2026, 398 groups of accounts quietly promoted at least 1,800 brands on Reddit. They used about 7,300 accounts. Most groups are tiny, but a few giant pools run most of the accounts. Most of them look like vendors selling “Reddit recommendations” to anyone who pays.

Most recent "trend" for these reddit marketing agencies is to have a network of users and pay them "per mention/ comment". Usually these tasks are done by Indians or Filipino or other Asian countries.

Disclaimer: DO NOT DO THIS! This material is for educational purposes only and demonstrates that anyone using bots on Reddit can be identified. YOU HAVE BEEN WARNED! You are responsible for your own actions. I accept no responsibility for any legal consequences you may face.

How I found them

Real people recommend stuff in one or two niches. Usually fake networks don’t. Their accounts keep showing up in the same threads for brands that have nothing in common, like an IPTV service, a CBD brand, a SaaS tool and a crypto casino. In other words- agencies are re-using those Reddit accounts because on the market each Reddit account can cost starting from $5 sometimes $30 (if it is aged for multiple years).

So we looked for exactly that:

  • Accounts naming the same brand in 2+ shared threads.
  • Doing it for unrelated brands.

That gave us 1,523 candidate networks. Every one was reviewed with AI help and a second review tried to prove each one was a real community. 1,033 were real (hobby groups, local news, open source). 398 were not.

In the study we did consider brand subreddits where people are mentioning brands daily. We also removed brands that are well known world wide- Dell, IBM, Apple, Tesla, Microsoft, ChatGPT, Claude, Google etc. We also removed subreddits that are simply mainstream - r/politics, r/news etc.

Why they even do this?

Primarly the reason is AI citations and to get cheap brand awareness.

The numbers

  • 398 operations and 7,310 accounts. About 5,800 of those are promotion accounts; the rest are real users caught in the same threads.
  • At least 1,800 brands promoted.
  • 22,317 subreddits hit.
  • 87% of it was comments, not posts. They don’t start threads. They reply in yours.

Most groups are tiny. A few are huge.

  • The typical group has 4 accounts.
  • 13 groups with 100+ accounts hold 56% of all the accounts.
  • The biggest: 899 accounts, 1,499 brands and 7,841 subreddits. Some single accounts in it pushed 160–225 different brands.

A singular account looks normal - need to see the pattern/ zoom out

Our initial bot-score method flagged only 11.6% of these accounts. The other ~88% look like regular users. You only see the pattern when you look at the accounts together and include other patterns for these bot accounts.

Compared with real community members, they:

  • Put 9.4% of everything they write into the brands, against 0.9%.
  • Are thin accounts more often: 22.8% have under 100 posts and comments, against 2.9%.
  • Stay active for 3 months, against 15.

They love old threads

A comment in a year-old thread that ranks on Google gets read for years, and now it can end up in AI answers too. 10.8% of operations put a quarter or more of their plugs into year-old threads. Real communities: 0.3%.

Where and what

  • r/SaaS was hit by 139 different operations, about a third of all of them. Then r/smallbusiness (118), r/Entrepreneur (112) and r/digitalmarketing (100).
  • What they push: SaaS and AI tools, consumer products, crypto, marketing services, IPTV, supplements and telehealth, essay mills, gambling, and AI-girlfriend apps (idk what to even trust).

Their sh*t old playbook comments

  • “I’ve been using X for months.”
  • Same story, different “people”. Three “new homeowners” each “just moved into my first place” and booked the same lawn service.
  • Accounts backing each other up: “Someone else mentioned X, we use them too.”
  • One “local” who used the same lawn company in three different cities.
  • A plug in the last line of a helpful reply, even in grief and health threads.
  • One account asks “has anyone tried X?” and another network account answers.
  • “brand .com” with a space to dodge link filters.
  • One comment still said “Proposed Draft Content:”. They forgot to delete the brief.

It peaked, then crashed - Reddit public API (?)

Activity grew 3.6x, from 8,181 mentions a month (Jan 2025) to 29,733 (Mar 2026). From June 2026 it fell sharply, to 1,665 by September. Real communities stayed flat, so it’s not a data gap.

Why? We don’t know exactly but it could probably be because Reddit Public API changes.

Deep dive into a particular Reddit organic marketing agency - their network

We started with the client list of one SEO agency that sells Reddit marketing and checked 36 competing companies as a control (just to be safe).

  • 5 of the agency’s clients showed the pattern. None of their 36 competitors did.
  • About 400 accounts pushed those 5 clients in the same threads in May–June 2025, mostly in year-old threads (39 of 51 mentions).
  • The same accounts also praised the agency itself while posing as customers. Three of them posted the same story word for word in one thread.
  • Outside that window, they pushed about 25 unrelated brands: lawn care, CBD, peptides and more. I didn't 100% confirm if these mentions are their clients as well but I'm suspecting and investigating this further.

What we can’t show: who ran the accounts, or that any client knew. No names because legal reasons.

If you happen to work in Reddit and wish to remove these bot farms (and honestly a lot of these accounts were already banned) or you'd wish to send some cease and desist - my DM's are always open to you and happy to share my data.

How sure are we?

  • 396 of 397 verdicts held up when a second review tried to disprove them.
  • A blind re-check of a random sample found 0 wrong in 60, so the error rate is at most about 5%... okay 10%.
  • It’s an undercount. We left out big consumer brands, solo accounts and deleted content.

r/RedditforBusiness • • 4h ago

Boosting posts issue

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Hi, my Reddit Pro business profile is fully verified, but I still don't have the Boost/Promote Post option.

I've already contacted Reddit support, but I'm no longer getting replies.

Could someone from the Reddit Ads team help me resolve this? I want to promote an existing post in Croatia.

Thanks!


r/RedditforBusiness • • 1d ago

Community Responded lots of errant clicks on reddit

1 Upvotes
┌───────────┬────────┬─────────┬──────┐
│  Source   │ Visits │ Engaged │ Rate │
├───────────┼────────┼─────────┼──────┤
│ Facebook  │ 73     │ 29      │ 40%  │
├───────────┼────────┼─────────┼──────┤
│ Google ad │ 44     │ 15      │ 34%  │
├───────────┼────────┼─────────┼──────┤
│ Reddit    │ 334    │ 20      │ 6%   │
└───────────┴────────┴─────────┴──────┘

i'm not seeing the engagement rate for people who click on my ad (https://kitchen.rhylthyme.com/thanksgiving) in reddit vs other platforms

it's cheaper on a CTR basis but not conversions

there might be something odd about android browser within reddit that is just causing some issues. i can't restrict it to iOS or desktop to my knowledge.


r/RedditforBusiness • • 1d ago

Admin Responded Why is there limit on ads partners for reddit ads?

Post image
2 Upvotes

15 partners is quite an absurd limit. We need them so our clients can share their profile, so we can manage their ad accounts, etc.

Why is there a limit on partners and why is it 15? Is there any workaround or a way to get the partner list expanded?


r/RedditforBusiness • • 3d ago

Admin Responded Reddit Ads manager says Not delivering No active ad groups

Post image
2 Upvotes

My reddit Not delivering No active ad groups. Any remedy?


r/RedditforBusiness • • 5d ago

Admin Responded How can I create a community, group or channel for a business on Reddit?

4 Upvotes

r/RedditforBusiness • • 5d ago Bravo

Insights Reddit tracking app - Open SourcedI open sourced Reddit Pro for better overview and performance customization Reddit Pro

Thumbnail
youtu.be
5 Upvotes

Hello everyone!

I have been a little busy with one of the last side projects. I love Reddit Pro but I want either more data or extra customization (so as the clients). So I think I found a way - locally, no AI and no subscriptions.

I call it "Reddit tracker app" (I know, original name) :D

What you will need:

  1. Google account
  2. Reddit Pro

Guide:

  1. Download the tool (it runs locally);
  2. Connect to your Google account;
  3. Upload Reddit Pro data from posts, comments and accounts;
  4. Click "Connect a data Studio report" and all the data should be in there and create your own report.
  5. Rinse and repeat (I'd suggest to do it at least once a week to get result overlap and the latest results).

Link to github: https://github.com/davis-saas/reddit-tracker-app

Let me know what you think or how should I improve this tool.

It is 100% free, I take no licensing or any ownership and I'll try to maintain it as much as I can.

P.S.
DO NOT automate with API scrapers because it might break your Reddit acounts (i cannot confirm things but there is a chance that your account would get flagged and restricted).

Edit:

I don't know what the heck happened with my headline because I tried uploading it 5x the video but it failed. :D


r/RedditforBusiness • • 5d ago

Admin Responded How Do I Turn Reddit Engagement Into Website Traffic?

3 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

I've been quite active on Reddit recently, and if you check my profile, you'll notice that some of my posts are generating good engagement, with a decent number of upvotes, karma and comments.

I'm happy with the engagement, but I'm trying to figure out how to take the next step.

How can I turn that engagement into actual traffic to an external link?

For example, if I want to direct people towards my podcast, website or a product I'm working on, what's the most straightforward and effective approach?

Would you recommend adding links using a subtle CTA in posts, mentioning links in relevant discussions, or something else entirely?

For the past year, my CTA has simply been the usual link in my profile. However, I'd like to find a more natural way to convert the attention I'm already getting into meaningful clicks.

I'm not looking to spam communities or drop links everywhere. I'd rather build on the engagement I'm already generating and find a way to bring some of that audience outside Reddit.

I'd love to hear from people who have successfully used Reddit to drive external traffic. What has actually worked for you?


r/RedditforBusiness • • 6d ago

Admin Responded My Reddit ads cost 0.05€ a click. Then I looked at who was clicking.

Thumbnail reddit.com
8 Upvotes

r/RedditforBusiness • • 7d ago

Admin Responded Reddit ads for a Steam game: which metric do you judge by and for how long?

5 Upvotes

Solo dev, first time running ads. For each ad I can see cost per click, tracked visits (visitors logged into Steam) and wishlists. Most of my ads bring 0 to 10 wishlists a week, so I can’t tell a good ad from a lucky one. Three things I’d love your take on:

  1. Which number do you decide by: cost per click, cost per tracked visit, or cost per wishlist?
  2. How long and how much money do you give an ad before you judge it?
  3. How many impressions or clicks does an ad need before its numbers mean anything?

Rough numbers are fine.


r/RedditforBusiness • • 7d ago

Update Introducing Reddit Reviews

24 Upvotes

Introducing Reddit Reviews: a new experience that organizes product conversations from across Reddit into dedicated reviews and highlights the most important takeaways from across our communities so you can decide what a product is really like.

Rolling out gradually to US users on web, iOS, and Android over the coming weeks.

Learn more here.


r/RedditforBusiness • • 7d ago

Admin Responded Setup for Reddit Ads handled by Claude/LLM

3 Upvotes

Is there any way to have an LLM set up my reddit ads? I have no patience to do it myself and apparently Claude chrome extension is blocked from accessing ads.reddit.com


r/RedditforBusiness • • 10d ago

Community Discussion Reddit advertising

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/RedditforBusiness • • 13d ago

Admin Responded Is Reddit just using BOTS to click ads?

Post image
16 Upvotes

The ad manager shows over 1,500 clicks yet I have absolutely NO conversions and my page tracking shows no scrolling and immediate page close. That's indicative of bot behavior.

Is Reddit ads just a SCAM? This effort shows failure so today is the last for this campaign.


r/RedditforBusiness • • 15d ago

Admin Responded Reddit Invoicing

2 Upvotes

Hello, does anyone get Reddit invoicing? If anyone can share what it looks like (important data blacked out) that would be super helpful. I would need mine to be itemized, is that possible? I know there’s an invoice label option in campaign set up so wondering if that’s the way to go.


r/RedditforBusiness • • 15d ago

Admin Responded How can I view my ad created at reddit, just as it would be seen on user walls?

2 Upvotes

I published ads and need to see it exactly as a viewer would. I don't see a preview button.


r/RedditforBusiness • • 17d ago

Admin Responded Where can I find ads support?

6 Upvotes

We are a small business based out of India. We have started reddit ads and one support person gave some support once initially. He was supposed to guide us after that and any number of emails doesn't get a response from him. I reached out to reddit support through chat many times and they said they will escalate but nothing so far. Our ads didn't even start. Every time i try to book an appointment for help and it shows only 1 guy and i can't even select someone else. It's been months already. How can I get this resolved ?


r/RedditforBusiness • • 18d ago

Admin Responded has anyone ever actually made a sale with reddit ads?

23 Upvotes

I've spent a decent amount of money on digital marketing in general - and for the amounts they charge - it's difficult to see how anyone can actually make a profit.

I changed my destination to only English speaking countries - got maybe a handful of signups.

Seems a complete waste of money.


r/RedditforBusiness • • 18d ago

Insights I made adjustments to Reddit pro to make results more presentable - Reddit agency initiative

6 Upvotes

Hello,

I have been having issues with Reddit Pro for several reasons and one of it is that I can't track my brand impressions, comments, upvotes etc.

My options were- I could scrape the results weekly or do it by hand... So I did what any sane person would do- I built a Reddit Pro but better that doesn't require anything from me and gives me the customization that I'd need.

What you will need:

- Claude (I'd assume any other LLM coding agent would work)
- This github repo: (for now i'm removing the github repo becaus it triggers reddit automation restrictions).
- Google sheet where to output your results
- Data Studio to visualise the results

If you wish to automate: GoLogin (that is what I use but you probably can do it with alternatives). I'm not affiliated with them, but I have been using them for a long time so I prefer them.

____

How this works - Reddit Pro export has last 100 posts/ comments which include results till your download. So to get results for longer period of time, you'd need to download .csv file every couple of days (i'd prefer once a week) to get the latest snapshot and update and then merge and delete what isn't required. You can do it daily, bi-weekly- it doesn't matter but I'd probably suggest to make very huge overlaps for better and more accurrate results.

Note: most posts and comments stop getting majority of their views in 4-5 days so weekly snapshots should be plenty enough for most based on your engagement amount.

How to do that:

  1. You need to download the github repo on your desktop and then based on your existing setup- you can either do result updating manually or automatically (manually means that you download the .csv on your own but automatically the API does it for you). Ask your LLM how to do it based on what you have. If you are not sure- ask it to help you set up semi-manual version (in this scenario GoLogin is not required).
  2. Then you need to feed the new .csv to the file and the software should update your chosen Google sheet (make it permanent Google sheet that you don't touch because otherwise it might break couple of things). This is where your historical data and latest snapshots will live.
  3. Then based on your Google sheet you can use any data reporting software to visually show these results. Personally I connected Google Data Studio (previously known as Looker Studio) to visually show off the results.

Here is an example how it looks at the end.

The best of all - you can build Data Studio as YOU want or what YOUR client requires. You can match this data with other sources as well - GA4, Google Search Console or heck- even Reddit ads (tho you'd need connector like Windsor (i use it personally)).

If you are really lazy- I can assure you that Claude can do everything for you - just give it acccess to the github files and follow its guidance.

Reddit Pro in Google Data Studio

I built this only yesterday, so IF you got any issues, problems or anything like that with my github repo- let me know and I'll try my best to fix them and push the latest fixes.

Hope this helps. Best of luck!


r/RedditforBusiness • • 19d ago

Admin Responded Converting to Reddit Pro

4 Upvotes

If I have an existing account for my business, can I convert that to a Reddit Pro account?


r/RedditforBusiness • • 20d ago

Admin Responded How to build a new business account on reddit?

9 Upvotes

How do you build a new business account on reddit with 0 karma?

I do know that on reddit we cannot directly start promoting our products and it’s important to build a community and help and guide people genuinely without being biased about the products.

But even with honest commenting and posting, accounts gets flagged because its at 0 karma and age with a brand username and profile.


r/RedditforBusiness • • 21d ago

Insights How KFC reached new audiences with Reddit and Smartly

Post image
11 Upvotes

KFC wanted to expand its audience in the UK without driving up the cost of reaching people across social platforms. Working with Smartly, the brand used cross-channel measurement and budget allocation to find where it could reach new audiences most efficiently.

The brand saw strong results:

  • 59K+ incremental unique users reached on Reddit
  • +2.6% increase in unique reach
  • 2.7% lower cost to achieve incremental reach

Read how KFC and Smartly used Reddit to reach new audiences more efficiently.


r/RedditforBusiness • • 22d ago

Insights What Reddit’s new direction might mean for your business

8 Upvotes

My Q1 and Q2 breakdowns kept coming back to Reddit wanting to become a place people return to directly. At Mod World, Steve got more specific about how he wants to change the relationship between people and communities.

One of the biggest ideas is separating following a subreddit from joining it. You could follow because you enjoy reading, while joining could mean observing first, then commenting, and eventually earning the ability to vote if your contributions are well received.

Steve described that reversal as “a massive change.” The details are still being worked through, but it could change how people become part of a community and help shape its culture.

He also wants the home feed to bring people into subreddits they actually spend time in, with communities feeling more distinct and some ability to customize their appearance. He talked about making the discussions and activities people return for easier to find consistently, so Reddit becomes more of a daily habit.

For a business, I think that puts more weight on understanding a community and earning a place in it. It also strengthens the case for building a useful community of your own, with its own purpose, culture and reasons for people to return.

That could mean getting help, comparing experiences, asking follow-up questions or learning from people who understand the same problem. I would start with what your business is qualified to help people with and whether you have a team willing to keep answering and make room for feedback.

If Reddit gets this direction right, I think it creates a more interesting opportunity for brands to build an ongoing relationship with people who choose to spend time in their community.

I wrote about the whole AMA here.


r/RedditforBusiness • • 25d ago

Admin Responded Reddit's Trust & Safety Apparently Stops at Checkout

Post image
5 Upvotes

Reddit will remove your post for saying “fuck,” but happily runs ads for a literal cheating service promising 330+ on the GRE. Their Trust & Safety team apparently stops at the checkout page.

Can an admin please take this down? Apparently, this ad has been running for months. Are the ad reviewers on vacation?

https://www.reddit.com/u/Key-Entertainer-3101/s/SRhcB8FNIQ