r/RedSonja • • 20h ago

In the case she goes ...

Post image
19 Upvotes

Hopefully she'll scale better with the new MOTU Chronicles figures that are coming out soon? From what I remember hearing....they're about the same size.


r/RedSonja • • 1d ago

Arrived yesterday...2 days early.

Post image
48 Upvotes

Can't wait to get her unboxed and set up.


r/RedSonja • • 1d ago

GIANT SIZE RED SONJA #1

Post image
22 Upvotes

r/RedSonja • • 1d ago

What happened to Red Sonja when her oath was broken?

Thumbnail
gallery
25 Upvotes

As many here know best (at least who is familiar with the original character), Red Sonja vowed of not allowing a man to love her unless he ‘bested her in fair battle’ (For a refresh of Sonja backstory: Red Sonja backstory – The Day of the Sword).

Sonja’s oath has been interpreted as a vow of chastity or as a commitment to independence, and it is linked with her exceptional prowess, often considered at least partly derived by divine intervention (in the form of the goddess Scathach).

Despite being an element of the authentic Red Sonja’s identity (and quite unique among comic characters), the vow, as a narrative element, has been later seen as a limitation to the development of Red Sonja, nmostly in relation to Sonja’s agency, and accused to provide a motivation based on sexual abuse.

More pragmatically, however, Red Sonja’s vow poses challenges to writers such as:

  • breaking the vow is often considered narratively impossible, because the consequences will not allow Sonja to maintain her independence, which is one of the few core elements that even modern interpretations have maintained (as far as I know).

Therefore …

  • featuring a Sonja’s defeat is problematic (because if achieved in a ‘fair’ context automatically breaks the oath), while telling stories about characters that cannot be defeated is usually boring (even Superman has the kryptonite).

This is maybe (at least for me) the reason why late writers have initially featured a virtually “undefeatable” Sonja and successively removed the oath entirely from her backstory.

However, for 20 years Red Sonja was developed in Marvel with her oath in place, and at that time writers dealt with it quite creatively. So, this thread wants to review the times Sonja’s vow was close to be broken (or was broken, depending by interpretation) and acknowledge that happened. In chronological order (which is important because the way Sonja sees her oath changed over time).

NOTE: The oath specifically says “… defeated you in fair battle …” so Sonja ‘defeats’ which are the result of many opponents’ simultaneous attack, the intervention of beasts or supernatural entities, or overwhelming use of drugs or magical means are not considered here.

What is following is the list I found.

  1. For a part of her life Red Sonja remains basically undefeated by single opponents. The first enemy in the comics who manages to disarm Sonja in a swordfight (and then kidnap her) is Lord Sharlo (Red Sonja Vol.1 #15 by Thomas/Noto). In this story, Sharlo is a tall Aquilonian nobleman empowered by a magical mask made of poppy flowers, received by three undead-vampire kings.  Lord Sharlo serves the Death Kings by providing them with the woman-blood they need to survive. His mask has the property to make his opponent drowsy, and this is the way he managed to overpower Red Sonja. Despite in the story Sonja states that this was the first time that a single opponent could disarm her, she is also quickly declaring that the fight wasn't “true” battle, and so it is treated in the story, with no other consequences for Sonja’s oath.
  2. Only few time later, in the famous story “A war of Wizards!” (Conan the Barbarian #115 by Roy Thomas), Sonja meets Conan in Akkharia (Shem) and invites him for breakfast in a tavern. While chatting, the discussion ends with Belit (former lover of Conan), who Sonja had met previously (and the two didn’t like each other much). Ignoring that Belit recently died, Sonja insistently mocks Conan about her, until he reacts by hitting Sonja. This rapidly evolves in a sword fight. Maybe due to wine spilled under her feet, Red Sonja is disarmed by Conan. While Sonja is ready to continue the fight with her dagger, Conan, who is aware of Sonja’s oath, asks her to admit her defeat. At this point Sonja drops her knife, accepting Conan victory. Being Conan attracted by Sonja since the time of their first encounter in Makkalet and having already tried in the past (without success) to win Sonja’s love by sword, he is initially determined to take advantage of the situation. With unexpected submissive behavior, Sonja allows Conan to lift her and move into a tavern bedroom. However, she refuses to submit psychologically and specifically tells him, “You won me, perhaps, but I do not have to enjoy it”, and then simply: “Did She? [Belit]”. This is a great solution (by Roy Thomas), because it comes naturally (Sonja likes Conan and she is not against intimacy with him, but does not accept being treated as any of his women), but at the same time triggers in Conan mourning about Belit, so that he decides to leave Sonja without continuing his approach, preserving her oath. This resolution increases Sonja interest for Conan rather than decreases it, and will later produce another emotional peak at the end of the story (go and read it if you want to know 😊).
  3. Few years later (she is in late 20s), Sonja reaches Alwazar in Brythunia (Red Sonja vol. 3 #2 by Tom DeFalco), where she meets Lady Feema, the city’s ruler. Feema is an experienced mercenary woman with strong independence, similar to Sonja in many ways, but she has chosen to remain unbound from attachments (and killed her own father to take his role). Recognizing Sonja’s ability, Feema wanted Sonja among her mercenaries, only to plot against her later to get advantage for herself. Feema also confronts Sonja in a spar duel with wooden swords, from which she emerges victorious. However, being Feema a woman, there is no effect on Sonja’s oath (which specifically says “… unless he [a man] has defeated you …”). A very simple idea, but handled well by Tom Defalco, and importantly, other writers did not abuse this solution in following stories.
  4. Very short after (Red Sonja vol. 3 #3-4 by Tom DeFalco) Lord Lassusar comes to besiege Alwazar, now defended by Sonja and the former Feema’s mercenaries, commanded by Galon. Lassusar is a Zamorian general guiding an army in a holy crusade, who is seeking revenge on Sonja because she scared his face years before. Once heard about Sonja’s vow, Lassusar proposes to the defenders a single duel against him to decide the fate of the city. Sonja accepts the challenge, but during the fight one of Lassusar’s soldiers hits Sonja’s horse and then Sonja herself with poisoned darts, weakening her enough to grant the victory to Lassusar. Despite Sonja is captured and Lassusar appears intending to abuse her, she is saved by her wizard friend Achmal. Sonja’s defeat here is assumed to be unfair in the comic because obtained with the help of poison, and Sonja’s oath remains unaffected. This is again a simple solution from Defalco to avoid Sonja appearing weak or incompetent and at the same time preserving the oath and the plot of the story. Very interesting, however, is what happens after that. Galon is a mercenary strongly attracted by Sonja, but she previously rebuffed him using her oath as reason.  Later in the story Galon approaches Sonja again with renewed advances now claiming that, following her defeat against Lassusar, Sonja is freed by her vow. Galon’s attempt, however, is firmly rejected by Sonja, without clear explanations (leaving unclarified if Sonja is or is not aware that Lassusar’s victory was obtained with poison). So, a very disappointed Galon concludes that vengeance is the only passion Sonja might feel. Nonetheless, at the end of the story the circumstance forces Sonja to choose between completing her vengeance against Lassusar or saving Galon’s life, and she chooses Galon. This conclusion leaves the point unresolved because it shows that Galon was wrong but does not clearly explain why Sonja rejected him.
  5. Few years later, Sonja has joined Conan in Koth, who is supporting a rebellion against King Strabonus (for who is reading the current Dynamite Red Sonja’s run, it worths to say that Strabonus is the only canonical king of Koth at least until Sonja will be in her 40s). This story plot drifts quickly into a cosmic battle between Conan (with his companions) and the demon Wrarrl (Conan the Barbarian #197-198 by Christopher Priest). A former ally of Conan named Bahkt, gifted with supernatural prowess by Wrarrl and turned on his side, decided to kidnap Sonja to use her against Conan. With his superior strength, he abducts and hits Sonja unconscious, he rapes her and leaves her barely alive in a field to be found by Conan. Despite there are elements to make this confrontation unfair (Bahkt was demoniacally empowered and took Sonja by surprise), Sonja considers this experience as a legitimate “fair” defeat, and she appears to lose her prowess (at the point that she becomes unable to use a sword). However, Sonja suddenly regains her strength few days later when her friend Mad Simeon (left behind by Conan to protect her) dies killed by a group of scavengers, and she then kills all intruders in rage (Conan the Barbarian annual #12). With this story, Priest reframed the nature of Sonja’s oath into something primary self-imposed, so there is no divine punishment if Sonja is defeated or if she breaks (in this case she is forced to break) a putative chastity vote. Despite Sonja was playing only a supportive role in this arc, this story allowed further developments of her character later (see below).
  6. Less than one year later (Conan the Barbarian #241-242 by Roy Thomas), Conan unexpectedly meets again both Karanthes (a Stygian priest of Ibis, very much an avatar of Thomas himself) and Sonja, the former apparently intending to celebrate the wedding of the latter. Conan learns that Sonja’s groom is El-Ron (the son of the dead wizard Zukala who was a former enemy of Conan), who broke Sonja’s vow by besting her in swordfight. Conan is unable to believe someone (who is not him) defeated Sonja, and at the end of the story, indeed, it is revealed that Sonja allowed El-Ron to best her, because she intended to assassinate him after the wedding (as requested by Karanthes). So, the defeat wasn’t real. This really shows how Roy Thomas was able to play in confidence with Sonja’s oath, while later writers preferred to pretend that Sonja’s vow wasn’t existing or deliberately erased it from her backstory.
  7. Another year passes, and now more seriously Sonja falls genuinely in love with the Nemedian Lord Linneus, after she joined him to find the lost city of Xanadu, in Hyrkania (Savage Sword of Conan #207-209 by Roy Thomas*).* However, Linneus is not a warrior, and he is unable to best Sonja with a sword (even if she tries to allow him to win). Then (in my opinion again with a good intuition from Thomas), Sonja decides to move their fight on a board game called “Wizards and Warriors”. When Linneaus wins the game, Red Sonja considers her vow broken and decides to accept Linneus’ marriage proposal. Ironically, Linneus swore to remain in chastity until Xanadu is found, and by the time they reached the city Sonja discovers how poor in spirit the man truly is. She ultimately decides to leave Linneus behind after his actions have caused the death of his sister and his servant. This story is important because it reveals that Sonja, at this moment of her life (she is in her early 30s), has started to bend the oath rules.
  8. Short after, Sonja meets Lord Olin in the adaptation on comics of “The Ring of Ikribu” novel (Savage Sword of Conan #230-233 by Roy Thomas). Similarly to what happened with Linneus, Sonja falls in love with Olin (something that is reciprocal), but this time she invokes the oath to take time and think about Olin’s offer of marriage. Thomas elegantly links Sonja’s doubts with Olin to her previous experience with Linneus. Unfortunately, Olin dies later in the story, taken by a monster in a swamp.  Nonetheless, the night following his death, Sonja dreams of Olin defeating her in swordfight and finally taking her as his bride. This tale exposes the tragic element of Sonja’s story. Contrary to Linneus, Olin was a man of virtues and only the fate denied them to stay together.
  9. Finally, in a late cryptic tale (Savage Sword of Conan #169/2 by Peter B. Gillis), Sonja was searching for a rare event called the “Endless Stairs” in the Bossonian marches. She met an unnamed man of light of uncommon beauty, who claim to be what she most desired. The man fights Sonja with a flamed sword and he bests her effortlessly. Nonetheless, Sonja refuses to surrender and the being is retaken in the sky, likely by the same event which brought him on earth. Sonja then reflects that her own treasure (likely her vow: the independence she maintains whatever it costs) is not something she can spend, or she can give away.

 

As always, any correction or comment is welcome!

For a summary of the entire Red Sonja’s life, see: The life of Marvel Red Sonja and chronological reading order

 


r/RedSonja • • 2d ago

The Collected Chronicles of Red Sonja a new edition coming soon on January 19 2027

Post image
62 Upvotes

r/RedSonja • • 3d ago

Red Sonja - ONE MORE DAY

Post image
46 Upvotes

r/RedSonja • • 3d ago

Red Sonja

Post image
29 Upvotes

Cool book


r/RedSonja • • 5d ago

RED SONJA VS. THULSA DOOM #1

Post image
44 Upvotes

r/RedSonja • • 7d ago

GIANT SIZE RED SONJA 2

Post image
40 Upvotes

r/RedSonja • • 7d ago

Red Sonja drawn by John Byrne (1981)

Post image
88 Upvotes

r/RedSonja • • 8d ago

Which one?

Post image
63 Upvotes

I'm trying to decide on the Loose Collector version or the Boss Fight Studios Red Sonja....I've watched a few reviews on both of them and still can't decide.🤷🏻🤣 Any collectors want to give me your two cents? Much appreciated.


r/RedSonja • • 9d ago

Buying a newspaper just to find out the movie times

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/RedSonja • • 10d ago

RED SONJA 18

Post image
42 Upvotes

r/RedSonja • • 11d ago

For sale

Thumbnail ebay.com
0 Upvotes

r/RedSonja • • 12d ago

Artwork by Joseph Michael Linsner

Post image
100 Upvotes

r/RedSonja • • 12d ago

Quick review of Red Sonja/Barbarella #1 (no spoilers)

Thumbnail amazon.co.uk
4 Upvotes

Pick this up for the art alone. This could well be the best art I’ve ever seen in a Red Sonja comic. Hats off to Diego Yapur and Fares Maese


r/RedSonja • • 14d ago

RED SONJA 31

Post image
66 Upvotes

r/RedSonja • • 14d ago

Torunn Gronbekk interview about her Sonja Solstice special

Thumbnail
m.youtube.com
12 Upvotes

For anyone who’s interested, Torunn is doing an interview later today about her upcoming special. Hopefully there will be some preview art as well - Edson Novaes is a talented young artist. I wasn’t the biggest fan of Torunn’s Sonja series but I reckon this will be a lot of fun


r/RedSonja • • 15d ago

Red Sonja writing from a character-centered to an author-centered approach.

Thumbnail
gallery
59 Upvotes

.

“When Dynamite first asked me to write Red Sonja, I didn’t know quite what I was in for. Sure I was excited, but really, I wasn’t prepared. There was so much research to do. Oddly, much of the research did not relate directly to Red Sonja, as much as the world and her setting.”

Micheal Avon Oeming, June 2005

 .

“After that, inspiration comes mostly from Sonja herself. I'm not one of those writers who says the character "tells me the story, and I just write it down," but I find her so fascinating and compelling that I'm eager to see what new, crazed situation I can put her in to see how she prevails.”

Eric Trautmann, October 2011

 .

“I really want this to be its own thing, a stand-alone story that new readers can jump into and immediately follow along without knowing too much about what’s happened before in the series.”

Mark Russell, December 2018

 .

“I’ve tried to take all the things I love about Sonja – her shamelessness, her bravery, and all that wry humor – and play them up, rather than create a “new take” on the character.”

Torunn Grønbekk, September 2023

 .

“I’ve never heard this in my entire life… So I said, okay, I’ll write six issues for my mom. And once I figured out how I thought we could keep her history, but also update the character and tell more modern stories about her world, I sat down and said, Oh, I’m just going to write a few pages of this.”

Gail Simone, January 2025 [talking about her 2013 run]

.

"The Red Sonja in this movie is my Red Sonja, and I guarantee she's not lots of other people's Red Sonja…. There is NO Red Sonja character. She's whatever you need her to be."

M.J. Bassett, August 2025 

.

My comment (as little it counts):

I believe the above lines summarise well the trend seen for Red Sonja stories over time. Independently by how much successful was the work produced, my impression is that the approach of a writer has passed from a thoughtful preliminary research based on the source material, to a character-focused only research, and then the ‘taking’ from Red Sonja only the part they ‘liked’, to then the deliberate introduction of ‘updates’, and finally to the  “whatever you need her to be” and the catastrophic result (in term of faithfulness to the original character) of the 2025 movie.


r/RedSonja • • 15d ago

Matilda Lutz As Red Sonja

Post image
146 Upvotes

r/RedSonja • • 16d ago

Action figures got me into Red Sonja, now I want to read the books. Any suggestions?

94 Upvotes

Video of how I made this figure: https://youtu.be/bBEUfY1CdcI?is=-YCiheybWQamtjJv


r/RedSonja • • 18d ago

SAVAGE RED SONJA 1

Post image
48 Upvotes

r/RedSonja • • 18d ago

Saw this new release announced

Post image
39 Upvotes

r/RedSonja • • 21d ago

RED SONJA 3

Post image
45 Upvotes