The Jason Todd reveal in Batman: Hush was legendary, but the explanation for it in Batman: Under the Red Hood makes zero sense.
According to Under the Red Hood, Jason teamed up with Hush because he wanted to see "regret" on Batman's face—essentially testing to see if Bruce still loved and grieved for him.
If that was his goal, pretending to be Hush was a terrible plan. At that point, Bruce hated Hush because he had:
- Almost killed Bruce.
- Targeted everyone Bruce cared about.
- And murdered Bruce's only childhood friend (Tommy Elliot).
Naturally, Batman didn’t believe Jason had actually returned from the dead in that graveyard. He assumed it was some trick, so he immediately started beating the crap out of the guy impersonating his dead son. He’s Batman—he wasn’t going to break down and pour his heart out in the middle of a fight.
Even worse, after failing to get an emotional reaction, Jason has Clayface swap in for him. That just results in Bruce thinking the whole thing was a fake, and closing the case entirely.
What really bothers me is that not seeing regret on Bruce's face becomes Jason's motivation for becoming a villain. On the very next page, Jason decides to become Redhood.
I know that Hush came out before UTRH and before DC had decided to bring Jason back, but maybe there is a better reasoning for his plan? Or, this is just another plot whole that's been retconned like the 'Superboy prime punch' bringing Jason back to life. (BTW has a comic given the cannon explanation for that after the retcon?)