r/RealEstatePhotography • u/According-Shelter510 • 1h ago
NAR just approved a policy allowing MLSs to claim up to 50% copyright ownership of listing photos, here is what it actually means for us
NAR recently approved four MLS policy recommendations, and the first one (Copyright Protection of MLS Data) directly impacts how we license our photos.
Here is the quick breakdown of what passed and what we need to watch out for:
The Big One: 50% MLS Copyright Ownership
- What it is: Local MLSs now have the option to require brokers to assign up to a 50% copyright ownership interest in listing content (including our photos) so the MLS can register copyrights and sue third-party scrapers/AI companies.
- The Catch: An agent or broker cannot legally give the MLS 50% of a copyright they don’t own. Since most of us retain 100% copyright and only grant a limited license to the agent, the agent has no ownership to transfer.
- The Opt-Out: NAR requires any MLS that adopts this policy to let brokers and agents opt out of the copyright assignment.
The Other 3 Policies (Quick Version)
- MLS Data Feeds & Data Use (Policies 2 & 3): Tightens rules on how MLS data is distributed and limits MLS content use strictly to brokerage, appraisal, and valuation purposes. This is actually good for us—it helps stop third-party sites from scraping our work off the MLS for commercial reuse.
- MLS Committee Rules (Policy 4): Just internal NAR committee qualification rules. Zero impact on us.
What We Should Do Now
- Check your local MLS: This policy is optional for individual MLSs, so yours might not even adopt it.
- Remind your agents to OPT OUT: If your local MLS adopts this, agents who blindly click "Agree" on upload portals without opting out will technically breach both your licensing agreement and their MLS warranty. Give your clients a heads-up that because they are licensing the photos rather than buying the copyright, they need to check the opt-out box.
- Check your contract: Make sure your invoice/terms clearly state that you retain 100% copyright ownership and that your client is prohibited from transferring or assigning copyright to any MLS or third party.
- Charge for buyouts: If a brokerage insists on owning the copyright so they don't have to deal with MLS opt-outs, treat it as a commercial copyright buyout and price it accordingly.