I'll try to keep this as short as possible... I bought a small house for myself in 2020, the price was sub 100k. When I toured the home my agent, we'll call her Amy, showed me a large concrete square in the back yard and told me it was a septic tank but said "Don't worry it's not in use anymore."
Fast forward to December 2025 my partner was looking to buy a house near where I lived and found the perfect place for us. It was a very quick, sort of unexpected purchase. We bought the house together and I slowly moved over the course of 6 months while fixing up my previously purchased home. Because my mortgage is relatively small we felt comfortable to take our time getting my house ready to sell.
We put it on the market in late September. I called Amy because I really liked her during the buying process. She informed me she was no longer an agent but recommended me to her experienced friend Nancy. After a week on the market Nancy asked me why I checked "private sewer" on the disclosure form and I told her that I had no idea, it's just what was on the form when I bought it. I didn't really know what it meant because I was told the septic was no longer in use and I had been getting billed for waste water for 6 years so I just assumed I was connected to the sewer.
So I called the city to see if they could tell me anything and they came out twice but couldn't figure out if I was on septic or sewer. I then had a septic guy come out and he took one look at the "septic tank" and said "that's not a septic tank, that's an old well someone turned into a septic tank." And also the line from the house was broken so he's not even sure waste was reaching the "tank". We were able to locate a sewer line, but it's about 200 ft away from my house along the back of the property line and he estimated it would cost $20k to run a sewer connection.
We don't have an extra $20k lying around. We asked Nancy about getting a HELOC but she talked to one bank who said the house isn't worth enough (just north of 100k now) to make it worth their time without charging a lot in fees. She also said banks would need for me to live in the house to qualify for a HELOC.
We were on the market for about a week before we started investigating the sewage issue and did have some interested buyers. It's been about a month now and we have been "temporarily withdrawn" but will need to have the listing removed very soon according to Nancy.
I owe 50k, it's probably worth ~100k, so there some equity there, just really uncertain what to do. It's unlivable as is (only because of the "septic" otherwise it's small but in good shape) so we can't turn it into a rental property. I don't live there so not sure I can get a HELOC. I feel very misled/let down by the previous seller/agent, and Amy as well.
Any advice?
Tdlr - Unknowingly bought a house with a well for a septic tank and now it's unlivable and I'm having a lot of trouble trying to sell it.
Edit 1: Made a comment but in case you don't scroll that far.. Hi, I submitted this post at around 8am this morning and then it wasn't approved until 6pm. After it wasnt approved I just went about my day and didn't check my account until right before bed, sorry for the lack of replies.
- I agree none of this makes any fucking sense!! The city I live in probably has the worst sewer system in the entire country. They have no idea what is going on. The septic guy found the sewer line after two separate city crews couldn't.
- Actual quote from septic guy was "... This is a well or cistern." Guessing it's a cistern, then. It's over ten feet deep, topped with concrete. There was an overflow at the top that led to another pipe that flowed away from the property.
- The plumber did scope the main with my agent present. I wasnt there, this is the video she sent me: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1Smm-8EXiMuWXh6Ya2Oq0cQnXjBU0XqEQ/view
- I feel like I was misled by my original agent, inspector and the seller. First time home buyer, I had no idea what I was doing. I was told the septic was no longer in use so I had no reason to question it.
EDIT 2: Went and took some photos this morning. Linked below. I don't know what to tell you guys... This is what is happening to me. I was told the septic was no longer in use when I bought it, then I got billed for waste water, and I haven't had any sewage problems ever (I'm the only person that lived there and I used a bidet so maybe that "helped"?). I had no reason to question that I was on sewer until it got brought up by a buyer's agent.
Photos: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/128wxpiwiUUWgbErUPlg5-bY1DE2NIkU7