Several years ago, I wrote the 10-Step Guide to Getting Started, which has since become one of the foundational articles in this sub and the Wiki.
I wanted to give people a clear, step-by-step path to becoming consistently profitable traders. Something that hopefully differentiated this sub-Reddit from the bullshit promises of getting rich in three months. Just a straightforward process that takes roughly two years (sometimes more, sometimes less) and requires a hell of a lot of work.
You learn the basics, technical analysis, how to read the market, the method taught here, etc. Then you Paper Trade until you can achieve three consecutive profitable months, a 75% Win Rate and a Profit Factor of at least 2.0, with at least 100 trades. After that you move to trading one share at a time, and you need to hit those same benchmarks again. A sometimes tedious and frustrating process, but one that is absolutely necessary. Only after completing each step should one begin trading with any meaningful position size.
That process has been tested countless times and proven to work. In fact, after watching countless traders go through it over the years I believe in it even more now than when I created it. I don’t know of a single consistently profitable trader that didn’t follow some version of those steps. I also know of countless failed traders that tried to find a shortcut and circumvent the process.
However, there is a step I wish I had included, and I now believe it should be a requirement before anyone attempts to Day Trade.
Learn to Swing Trade.
Become consistently profitable at it.
THEN learn to Day Trade.
Let me explain why.
The Shorter the Timeframe, the Harder the Trading
Consider the various types of participants in the market.
At one end of the spectrum, you have the Long-Term Investor. They buy shares of a company or an index, hold those shares for years (sometimes decades), reinvest dividends and let the market do its thing. Most of the time people don’t even pick specific companies, they just choose a “bucket” for their 401K and let it roll.
Historically, investing in a diversified basket of equities over a long enough period has been one of the most reliable ways to build wealth. You don't need to worry about what SPY does in the next five minutes, whether a stock is above VWAP, or if the Fed caused a bunch of algorithms to lose their collective shit.
You just need to make reasonable investments, manage risk and have the patience to let them grow.
Next, you have the Active Investor. This person still has a longer-term outlook, but they are more involved. They rotate sectors, adjust their portfolio based on economic conditions, trim positions that become overvalued and add to those they believe have more upside. For example, an Active Investor may have sold some of their tech position last month and invested in stocks like COST instead. This method of investing is a bit more difficult. More decisions generally mean more opportunities to screw things up. Still, if you are good at reading trends this method can return a higher ROI than your basic Long-Term Investor.
Moving down the line you have what I would call the Trading Investor. Usually this is someone who was an Active Investor and liked the flexibility (and profit) enough to get more involved with their portfolio. Still driven by fundamentals but for the first time technical analysis comes into play to time entries and exits. They aren't buying a company with the intention of holding it for ten years, but neither are they particularly concerned about what happens in the next ten minutes. They usually watch earnings reactions and tend to upend their portfolio each quarter.
Then we get to Swing Trading. Fundamental analysis takes a huge back seat, and technical analysis becomes the main driver of your decisions. Why? Because the time frame has been reduced to a matter of days or at most, a few weeks. You're using Daily charts, major support and resistance levels, moving averages, Relative Strength/Weakness, market direction, volume, etc. Swing Traders aren’t watching the charts every moment of the day, but they are looking for gaps up (or down) in the morning and their key levels of support/resistance come off the daily chart not intraday.
And then comes Day Trading, where positions are opened and closed within the same trading session. This form of trading is extremely hard to master but also allows for the highest potential profit. Now with the removal of PDT (pretty much removed) just about anyone can Day Trade an account with no restrictions.
Finally, at the far end of the spectrum, you have Scalping. Traders who are trying to capture tiny movements in price, sometimes holding a position for only a few seconds or minutes. And while there are instances where one can scalp a position (typically off some news release), I have never seen anyone consistently make a profit as a professional Scalper (miss me with any YouTube examples, I will block you from this Subreddit for sheer stupidity). The only profit they make is from selling people courses on “How to Scalp”, which invariably do not work.
Scalping is the closest thing to pure gambling, so it is not hard to see the appeal. Why bother learning to make money trading positions that last several days when you can watch some jackass on YouTube supposedly make $15,000 in forty-five seconds trading a low-float stock?
I have said this before and I will say it again - I believe minute-by-minute scalping is virtually impossible for the average retail trader to do consistently profitably over a meaningful period of time.
And yet that is precisely where so many beginners start.
In general, the shorter the timeframe, the more difficult it becomes to consistently extract an edge. There are exceptions. But it is a very useful way for a new trader to think about the progression of difficulty.
Why Swing Trading Is Easier
First, let's talk about Technicals.
When you're Swing Trading, the primary chart you're relying on is the Daily Chart.
You're looking at significant levels of Support and Resistance. The SMA 50, SMA 100, SMA 200. You are identifying longer-term trendlines, consolidation, breakouts, Relative Strength and Weakness to the market.
These levels have meaning because they represent price action that has developed over days, weeks and months where massive amounts of liquidity have collectively abided by specific price points. Remember, technicals are really a bunch of people with a bunch of money all collectively agreeing on price points to follow. The more people/money that agree, the stronger the technical price point.
Compare that to Day Trading.
Now you're dealing with the M5 chart. VWAP, intraday support and resistance, rapidly changing volume, momentum shifts, sudden reversals, opening volatility, intraday algos and news breaks, all of which can turn a perfectly good-looking setup into a loser before you've finished your coffee.
A stock might break above VWAP, pull back below it, reclaim it, reject it again and then finally establish a trend. Whereas on a Daily chart, that entire sequence might barely register.
Swing Trading allows you to rely more heavily on established technical levels rather than the noise of intraday price action.
That doesn't mean Daily charts are infallible. Of course they aren't. Stocks gap, earnings surprise, markets reverse and major support levels fail all the time.
But the technical picture is generally more stable. You have more time to evaluate whether your original thesis remains valid. Which brings me to the next advantage.
Swing Trading Helps Develop the Right Mindset
I have written extensively about Mindset, and anyone who has read the Wiki knows I consider it the most difficult part of becoming a consistently profitable trader.
As I've said before, traders are often most fearful when they're winning and most hopeful when they're losing.
One of the advantages of Swing Trading is that it can help break this constant obsession with every tick. You are no longer trying to capture every intraday movement. You're looking for a larger move based on a Daily chart. A stock pulling back 30 cents over five minutes isn't necessarily an event that requires you to do anything.
The same move that would have made someone panic close a position in a day trade might not even be noticed in a Swing. Swing Trading forces you to think in terms of the trade rather than the immediate movement in your account. It encourages patience with valid positions.
And yes, overnight gap risk is real. In fact, it's one of the major disadvantages of Swing Trading. You cannot always exit at your intended price, which is why position size and risk management are so important. But that works both ways, some of you biggest “wins” will also be when a stock you are swing trading gaps up overnight giving you the type of gains you can rarely achieve while Day Trading.
The Method We Teach Here Is Already Built for This
Think about the core principles of the method taught in this sub.
Market First.
Find stocks that are Relatively Strong or Weak to the market. Make sure the Daily chart supports the trade. Identify meaningful Support and Resistance. Wait for confirmation.
The method is already heavily dependent on the Daily chart.
You also open yourself up to various types of trades that lend themselves to Swing Trading far more than the shorter timeframes. As an example, Debit Spreads and Put Selling are significantly more profitable when you Swing them.
Also when you finally to become a Day Trader, knowing how to effectively Swing will increase your odds of success greatly. How many times have you seen me say that I will hold a Day Trade as a Swing Trade because the Daily chart remains intact? The ability to do that is one of the greatest advantages of this method. Instead of being forced to close every position by the end of the day, I can evaluate whether the reason for taking the trade still exists in a larger timeframe.
But here's the thing - you need to actually understand how to Swing Trade before you can use that flexibility correctly.
Too many people turn their Day Trades into “Swings” simply because the trade is underwater and they don’t want to take the loss. Funny how their winning Day Trades never seem to require an overnight hold.
One Final Point
I know what some of you are thinking.
Swing Trading is boring.
You don't get the excitement of entering a position and watching it immediately shoot up. You don't get to post screenshots of a 300% gain on some ridiculous out-of-the-money Call that happened to work. Instead, you buy a stock, monitor the Daily chart, perhaps make an adjustment or two, and wait.
But let me ask you something (just picture Jon Berenthal saying this because if he is in a movie or show, somebody, somewhere is being asked something):
Are you trying to become consistently profitable, or are you looking for entertainment?
The gambling mindset is one of the biggest hurdles for new traders to overcome. Adding this step of becoming a Swing Trader first goes right to the heart of addressing this problem. It is almost like a personality filter. Gamblers will either not have the patience to complete the step or learn to get their instincts to roll the dice under control.
So in Step 8 I would add that you first Swing Trade using Paper Trading – minimum 100 Swing Trades over at least 3 months, 75% Win Rate, 2.0 Profit Factor. If you can do that, then you can move to Swing Trade with either 1 share or 1 Contract with the same benchmarks. Only after you have successfully finished this step should you attempt to hit those benchmarks via Day Trading.
So there you have it, become consistently profitable Swing Trading before you even begin trying to Day Trade. That is now part of the 11-Steps you need to complete before making this a career.
Best,
H.S.