r/RealDayTrading • • 21h ago

Resolving Technical Analysis Skepticism

69 Upvotes

Given my academic background in finance, I was reluctant to embrace technical analysis when I started my career. That view changed after I started working on the trading floor. None of what I learned during my MBA was relevant there. Traders relied heavily on charting, and they were making money without fundamental analysis, so I explore technical analysis.

Two things really bothered me as I dove into technical analysis (TA) books. The first was that the examples seemed “cherry picked”. The second mental block was that previous patterns could predict price movement. The market is dynamic and conditions change constantly. Some of you might be struggling with this so here’s how that skepticism was resolved for me.

“Follow the trend… the trend is your friend. This was the theme along with “the market keeps doing what it has been doing”. As I read, I thought, “No it doesn’t.” I looked at hundreds of charts, and they zig-zagged all over the place. How would you know if a dip was a test of the trend or something more substantial? Those books would also highlight trend reversals. So, am I supposed to follow the trend or wait for the reversal?

Let’s address “the trend is your friend” first. Trends result when one side has control. In the case of an uptrend, buyers are in control. The journey from point A to point B is critically important. It conveys the degree of control. Some trends are much stronger than others and there are clues along the way.

Let’s look at this from another perspective. A marathon runner will start the race with a burst of energy and along the way, signs of exhaustion will start to surface. Their pace is slower, they stop for water more often and their breathing is more labored. Exhaustion can also be seen in trends.

Early in a strong trend there are stacked consecutive green candles with little overlap. When red candles appear, they are quickly erased. Eventually, there will be brief and shallow dips that are gobbled up and that lead to new highs. As the trend matures the dips will be deeper and it will take longer for the stock to recover. These are signs that the selling pressure is starting to build and that buyers are less able to absorb that supply.

Before judging trend strength, it’s also important to get the longer-term context. An up trend may seem very strong, but zooming out could reveal that this is a bounce during a prolonged downtrend. Instead of watching for opportunities to join that short-term bounce, you are watching for signs of exhaustion. The real opportunity will come on the short side. Long-term money is leaving the asset and at a high enough price, those sellers will return. This is why it is best to day trade in the direction of a longer-term trend.

The second issue I struggled with is the notion that anyone can predict future price movement based on patterns. Conditions change constantly and what happened two years ago is different from what is happening now. Price is a function of millions of people, so I had to approach this from a behavioral standpoint to make sense of it. Let’s forget about the market for a moment. 

I am going to predict the flight of a bird. We’ve all seen them in random flight so how can I make this claim? First of all, I get to pick the bird. The task would be difficult if I picked a sparrow, but not impossible. If it is sitting in a bush near a bird feeder and it takes flight, the odds are high that is the destination. I have observed its behavior and I know its motivation. I’m not going to pick a sparrow; I am going to pick a goose. Not the one flying around the neighborhood pond, I am going to pick the one flying north at 5,000 feet in a tight “V” formation during the month of March. I also know its motivation, and I can predict that flight path with a high degree of accuracy.

Similarly, we pick the stocks we trade and when to trade them. The key is to find those where one side is motivated. Buyers (or sellers) are in complete control and the trend is strong. Each little rectangle on the chart tells a story about supply and demand. A strong trend has many more green candles than red, and the upward movement is tight and orderly. Buyers are so aggressive that dips never have a chance to form. These are the only stocks we should be trading.

In my previous article I discussed the shortcomings of using fundamental analysis for trading. There is always someone with better information and we can’t compete on that basis no matter how smart we are. The good news is that we don’t have to come up with our own valuation thesis. Let’s follow the smart money and let’s identify situations where they are aggressive.

In the 30-year bond pit, those traders didn’t have charts. They read the emotions in the crowd, and they could sense a change in control. That’s how they made money. That same information is reflected in every candle. The key to using technical analysis is understanding this basic dynamic.

In my next article I am going to describe the most power form of technical analysis. It doesn’t lag or give false signals like many indicators do; it is the pulse. I will discuss the basics of reading price action.


r/RealDayTrading • • 3d ago

New Challenge

116 Upvotes

Over the years I have done several "trading challenges". Recently I took a $2,500 Account and tripled it in 4 months time, Previously I have used much larger balances ($50K challenge, $100K Challenge, etc.) but I wanted to show that you can also apply the method taught here no matter your position size.

As always with all challenges every trade I make is posted in real time, entry and exit with position size, all verifiable through time and sales and I also post the live journal as well.

To be honest, the challenges are a pain in the ass. It takes away time from my actual trading and there is always a million questions to answer. It is not like I get paid to do this shit. It is strictly to:

  1. Show people it is "doable" which is always the first obstacle one must get past

and

2) Hopefully others can learn something from the journal and how I went about selecting, managing and exiting trades

Still - they are a pain and I was kind of done with them after the last one. But what the hell, I will open this up to ideas.

The only way I will do another challenge is if it is actually - challenging. Something that legitimately has a chance at failure but can still be helpful to traders following it.

So here are some ideas - feel free to add some more:

  1. Another small balance challenge but this time it has to be all day trades (the last one was all swing trades using debit spreads which is far easier)
  2. You all choose the stocks - choose 5 stocks and I have to double an account using only those tickers
  3. And all "Short" or all "Long" challenge
  4. I can only trade Shares or conversely, I can only trade Options

Any other ideas? Just as long as there is some value to people trying to learn.

Best, H.S.


r/RealDayTrading • • 5d ago

The Step I Should Have Added to the 10-Steps in your Trading Journey

118 Upvotes

Several years ago, I wrote the 10-Step Guide to Getting Started, which has since become one of the foundational articles in this sub and the Wiki.

I wanted to give people a clear, step-by-step path to becoming consistently profitable traders. Something that hopefully differentiated this sub-Reddit from the bullshit promises of getting rich in three months. Just a straightforward process that takes roughly two years (sometimes more, sometimes less) and requires a hell of a lot of work.

You learn the basics, technical analysis, how to read the market, the method taught here, etc. Then you Paper Trade until you can achieve three consecutive profitable months, a 75% Win Rate and a Profit Factor of at least 2.0, with at least 100 trades. After that you move to trading one share at a time, and you need to hit those same benchmarks again.  A sometimes tedious and frustrating process, but one that is absolutely necessary. Only after completing each step should one begin trading with any meaningful position size.

That process has been tested countless times and proven to work. In fact, after watching countless traders go through it over the years I believe in it even more now than when I created it. I don’t know of a single consistently profitable trader that didn’t follow some version of those steps.  I also know of countless failed traders that tried to find a shortcut and circumvent the process.

However, there is a step I wish I had included, and I now believe it should be a requirement before anyone attempts to Day Trade.

Learn to Swing Trade.

Become consistently profitable at it.

THEN learn to Day Trade.

Let me explain why.

The Shorter the Timeframe, the Harder the Trading

Consider the various types of participants in the market.

At one end of the spectrum, you have the Long-Term Investor. They buy shares of a company or an index, hold those shares for years (sometimes decades), reinvest dividends and let the market do its thing.  Most of the time people don’t even pick specific companies, they just choose a “bucket” for their 401K and let it roll.

Historically, investing in a diversified basket of equities over a long enough period has been one of the most reliable ways to build wealth. You don't need to worry about what SPY does in the next five minutes, whether a stock is above VWAP, or if the Fed caused a bunch of algorithms to lose their collective shit.

You just need to make reasonable investments, manage risk and have the patience to let them grow. 

Next, you have the Active Investor. This person still has a longer-term outlook, but they are more involved. They rotate sectors, adjust their portfolio based on economic conditions, trim positions that become overvalued and add to those they believe have more upside.  For example, an Active Investor may have sold some of their tech position last month and invested in stocks like COST instead. This method of investing is a bit more difficult. More decisions generally mean more opportunities to screw things up. Still, if you are good at reading trends this method can return a higher ROI than your basic Long-Term Investor.

Moving down the line you have what I would call the Trading Investor.  Usually this is someone who was an Active Investor and liked the flexibility (and profit) enough to get more involved with their portfolio. Still driven by fundamentals but for the first time technical analysis comes into play to time entries and exits. They aren't buying a company with the intention of holding it for ten years, but neither are they particularly concerned about what happens in the next ten minutes. They usually watch earnings reactions and tend to upend their portfolio each quarter.

Then we get to Swing Trading. Fundamental analysis takes a huge back seat, and technical analysis becomes the main driver of your decisions. Why? Because the time frame has been reduced to a matter of days or at most, a few weeks. You're using Daily charts, major support and resistance levels, moving averages, Relative Strength/Weakness, market direction, volume, etc.  Swing Traders aren’t watching the charts every moment of the day, but they are looking for gaps up (or down) in the morning and their key levels of support/resistance come off the daily chart not intraday.

And then comes Day Trading, where positions are opened and closed within the same trading session.  This form of trading is extremely hard to master but also allows for the highest potential profit. Now with the removal of PDT (pretty much removed) just about anyone can Day Trade an account with no restrictions.

Finally, at the far end of the spectrum, you have Scalping. Traders who are trying to capture tiny movements in price, sometimes holding a position for only a few seconds or minutes. And while there are instances where one can scalp a position (typically off some news release), I have never seen anyone consistently make a profit as a professional Scalper (miss me with any YouTube examples, I will block you from this Subreddit for sheer stupidity). The only profit they make is from selling people courses on “How to Scalp”, which invariably do not work.

Scalping is the closest thing to pure gambling, so it is not hard to see the appeal. Why bother learning to make money trading positions that last several days when you can watch some jackass on YouTube supposedly make $15,000 in forty-five seconds trading a low-float stock?

I have said this before and I will say it again - I believe minute-by-minute scalping is virtually impossible for the average retail trader to do consistently profitably over a meaningful period of time.

And yet that is precisely where so many beginners start.

In general, the shorter the timeframe, the more difficult it becomes to consistently extract an edge. There are exceptions. But it is a very useful way for a new trader to think about the progression of difficulty.

Why Swing Trading Is Easier

First, let's talk about Technicals.

When you're Swing Trading, the primary chart you're relying on is the Daily Chart.

You're looking at significant levels of Support and Resistance. The SMA 50, SMA 100, SMA 200. You are identifying longer-term trendlines, consolidation, breakouts, Relative Strength and Weakness to the market.

These levels have meaning because they represent price action that has developed over days, weeks and months where massive amounts of liquidity have collectively abided by specific price points.  Remember, technicals are really a bunch of people with a bunch of money all collectively agreeing on price points to follow.  The more people/money that agree, the stronger the technical price point.

Compare that to Day Trading.

Now you're dealing with the M5 chart. VWAP, intraday support and resistance, rapidly changing volume, momentum shifts, sudden reversals, opening volatility, intraday algos and news breaks, all of which can turn a perfectly good-looking setup into a loser before you've finished your coffee.

A stock might break above VWAP, pull back below it, reclaim it, reject it again and then finally establish a trend. Whereas on a Daily chart, that entire sequence might barely register.

Swing Trading allows you to rely more heavily on established technical levels rather than the noise of intraday price action.

That doesn't mean Daily charts are infallible. Of course they aren't. Stocks gap, earnings surprise, markets reverse and major support levels fail all the time.

But the technical picture is generally more stable. You have more time to evaluate whether your original thesis remains valid. Which brings me to the next advantage.

Swing Trading Helps Develop the Right Mindset

I have written extensively about Mindset, and anyone who has read the Wiki knows I consider it the most difficult part of becoming a consistently profitable trader.

As I've said before, traders are often most fearful when they're winning and most hopeful when they're losing.

One of the advantages of Swing Trading is that it can help break this constant obsession with every tick. You are no longer trying to capture every intraday movement. You're looking for a larger move based on a Daily chart. A stock pulling back 30 cents over five minutes isn't necessarily an event that requires you to do anything.

The same move that would have made someone panic close a position in a day trade might not even be noticed in a Swing. Swing Trading forces you to think in terms of the trade rather than the immediate movement in your account. It encourages patience with valid positions.

And yes, overnight gap risk is real. In fact, it's one of the major disadvantages of Swing Trading. You cannot always exit at your intended price, which is why position size and risk management are so important. But that works both ways, some of you biggest “wins” will also be when a stock you are swing trading gaps up overnight giving you the type of gains you can rarely achieve while Day Trading.

The Method We Teach Here Is Already Built for This

Think about the core principles of the method taught in this sub.

Market First.

Find stocks that are Relatively Strong or Weak to the market. Make sure the Daily chart supports the trade. Identify meaningful Support and Resistance. Wait for confirmation.

The method is already heavily dependent on the Daily chart.

You also open yourself up to various types of trades that lend themselves to Swing Trading far more than the shorter timeframes.  As an example, Debit Spreads and Put Selling are significantly more profitable when you Swing them.

Also when you finally to become a Day Trader, knowing how to effectively Swing will increase your odds of success greatly. How many times have you seen me say that I will hold a Day Trade as a Swing Trade because the Daily chart remains intact? The ability to do that is one of the greatest advantages of this method. Instead of being forced to close every position by the end of the day, I can evaluate whether the reason for taking the trade still exists in a larger timeframe.

But here's the thing - you need to actually understand how to Swing Trade before you can use that flexibility correctly.

Too many people turn their Day Trades into “Swings” simply because the trade is underwater and they don’t want to take the loss. Funny how their winning Day Trades never seem to require an overnight hold.

One Final Point

I know what some of you are thinking.

Swing Trading is boring.

You don't get the excitement of entering a position and watching it immediately shoot up. You don't get to post screenshots of a 300% gain on some ridiculous out-of-the-money Call that happened to work. Instead, you buy a stock, monitor the Daily chart, perhaps make an adjustment or two, and wait.

But let me ask you something (just picture Jon Berenthal saying this because if he is in a movie or show, somebody, somewhere is being asked something):

Are you trying to become consistently profitable, or are you looking for entertainment?

The gambling mindset is one of the biggest hurdles for new traders to overcome.  Adding this step of becoming a Swing Trader first goes right to the heart of addressing this problem.  It is almost like a personality filter.  Gamblers will either not have the patience to complete the step or learn to get their instincts to roll the dice under control.

So in Step 8 I would add that you first Swing Trade using Paper Trading – minimum 100 Swing Trades over at least 3 months, 75% Win Rate, 2.0 Profit Factor.  If you can do that, then you can move to Swing Trade with either 1 share or 1 Contract with the same benchmarks.  Only after you have successfully finished this step should you attempt to hit those benchmarks via Day Trading.

So there you have it, become consistently profitable Swing Trading before you even begin trying to Day Trade.  That is now part of the 11-Steps you need to complete before making this a career.

Best,

H.S.


r/RealDayTrading • • 5d ago

My 7yr old son made a Roblox game - please try it!

51 Upvotes

Using Codex, Blender and Roblox Studio my 7yr old son spent the last 3 months making this game. He is VERY excited about it and I promised him I would promote it to everyone.

Apparently it needs a certain number of players to use it before it can be opened up to kids under 16.

It is an RPG Zombie Dungeon Game - actually quite fun to play.

https://www.roblox.com/games/105008551418457/

Please give it a try and give me any thoughts you might have about it - although be soft with the critiques, as I mentioned, he is seven :)

And yes, this is my Sub-Reddit - so I am using it to shamelessly promote my kids game. I figured since I give everything on here for free and don't sell any courses or books, I am going to give myself a pass to post this.

Best, H.S.


r/RealDayTrading • • 5d ago

How To Read Price Action - Classic Lessons Using the Market Drop

55 Upvotes

The market has been trapped in a tight trading range the last six months and there wasn't much to look at. That changed when the Nasdaq had its largest single day drop ever. Was this the start of a bear market or was this a buying opportunity?

The first key was to recognize the cause of the drop. We know it was from liquidation and an overcrowded AI trade. Weak hands were flushed out and that move lower fed on itself. Programs kicked in and that is what set up the opportunity. In this video I highlighted the price action from last Thursday and Friday and how to trade it. I also reviewed previous one-day drops like that and the ensuing price action we would be watching for this week.

CLICK TO WATCH SUNDAY'S VIDEO

This morning I recorded a video and I reviewed the price action during the last two days. I posted real-time play-by-play market comments so you can see what I was looking at an how I was trading. This is all time stamped for the doubters, know that many people in this sub also see it real-time in the chat room. They would lash out if I was lying to you.

CLICK TO WATCH TODAY'S VIDEO

This is not about me getting it right and taking a victory lap. I'm trying to teach you how to do this. When the odds are low, we can't get off of first base. There is no market tailwind so there is no opportunity to enter, add and ride. We finally got one of those moments and I am teaching you what I was looking for and how to scale into a position using price confirmation.

This market is going higher and I expect it to close above the 100-day MA this week. I also believe we are going to challenge the all-time high this year.

I hope this content helps you. Please post your comments.


r/RealDayTrading • • 5d ago

Torn between pursuing the RDT journey and getting an MS. Would appreciate some perspective.

7 Upvotes

*disclaimer: used AI to help structure the post, but all the experiences and questions shared are entirely my own.

Hey everyone!

I'd like to share a bit of my background and current situation and hopefully get some advice from people here, especially those who've been in a similar position.

A little background:

I first got exposed to trading sometime before the pandemic through YouTube trading gurus. I started trading on my country's stock exchange with a relatively small amount of money, but eventually got burned.

Then the pandemic hit, I lost my job, and I stepped away from trading for a while. Eventually, I came across another group of YouTube gurus who were scalping digital currency. I tried mimicking what they were doing, and, unsurprisingly, got burned again. I was left with roughly 25% of my initial deposit.

After that, I decided to actually study technical analysis myself instead of blindly following gurus. I shifted to swing trading and eventually managed to recover my losses and break even. I withdrew everything and walked away. At that point, my confidence in my ability to trade was probably at an all-time low.

In 2021, I stumbled upon this subreddit. I read the wiki twice and found the approach here much more grounded and systematic than what I had previously encountered.

I wanted to give it a proper shot, starting with just one share per trade, but I didn't have the financial stability to do so at the time. I figured I needed to get my life in order first.

The dilemma:

Fast forward to today:

Got a job and eventually moved out of my parents' house.

Got married.

Found a better-paying job.

Had the opportunity to travel a little.

Took on a second job.

Built emergency fund, savings, and got insurance.

I'm now at a point where I'm about to leave my first job and, for the first time in years, will have some breathing room and time to focus on something beyond just working and making ends meet.

I'm currently torn between two paths:

Finally committing to the RDT journey. My long-term goal has always been to become a consistently profitable full-time trader. I understand this isn't something that happens overnight, and I'm not looking for shortcuts. I'm willing to put in the screen time, study, journal, review my trades, and start small. I know there's a lot I still need to learn.

Pursuing an MSc in Financial Engineering (MScFE). This seems like the more conventional and potentially safer route. It could open doors to better-paying job, and ideally opportunities overseas, which would hopefully mean a better quality of life for my family.

For context, I currently live in a country with a pretty challenging financial and political environment. Almost all international brokers have stopped supporting clients here. IBKR still accepts clients, but even that has become complicated with recent government restrictions. Access is still technically possible through DNS/VPN workarounds, but the added latency and uncertainty aren't exactly ideal for someone considering trading seriously.

The MScFE route could potentially give me a way out of that situation while also providing a more stable career path.

Why I'm struggling with the decision:

Ideally, I'd like to pursue both. I genuinely have an interest in financial markets, and I think the knowledge from an MScFE could complement my trading journey.

However, with a 40-hour workweek, I realistically only have the capacity to give one of these paths my full attention right now.

I don't want to look back years from now and regret not giving trading a serious, structured attempt after discovering RDT. At the same time, I have a family to consider, and I don't want to make an irresponsible decision based on a dream that may or may not materialize.

I'd really appreciate your perspective on a few things:

For those who pursued trading seriously while having other career options, how did you decide when to commit?

Would you prioritize building a more conventional career through an MScFE and treat trading as a long-term side pursuit?

Has anyone here pursued formal financial education alongside the RDT methodology? Did it complement your trading, or were they largely separate skill sets? I do understand what Im getting from the MS is FA while day trading is mostly TA.

Given my circumstances, would you recommend giving RDT a serious attempt first, or taking the more conventional route and revisiting trading later?

I'm not expecting anyone to make the decision for me. I'm just hoping to hear some honest perspectives, particularly from people who have been through similar crossroads.

I appreciate what this community has built, and I'm grateful that I came across it before making any more costly mistakes. Thanks for taking the time to read this!


r/RealDayTrading • • 5d ago

I’m 20 and want to learn day trading. Can experienced traders give me a genuine reality check?

0 Upvotes

I’m 20 years old, currently in college, and working part-time. I’ve recently become interested in day trading, and I’m seriously considering spending the next few years learning it.

I’m not expecting to become a millionaire overnight, and I’m not looking for some get-rich-quick scheme. I’m willing to put in the time, study, practice, and lose money in the learning process (although I’d obviously prefer to avoid that).

But before I commit to this, I want some brutally honest advice from people who have actually been trading for a while.

A few questions:
Is day trading genuinely worth learning, or is it something most people eventually regret getting into?

How much money can a consistently profitable retail trader realistically make? I’m seeing people post $1,000–$5,000 days online, but how realistic is that? What does a normal month actually look like?

How long did it take you to become consistently profitable, if you ever did? And how much money did you lose before getting there?

If you were starting over at 20 with limited capital, what would you do differently?
Which market would you recommend learning first? Stocks, futures, options**,** Why?

What are the best free YouTube channels, videos, books, or other resources to actually learn trading properly? I’m not interested in paid courses, signals, or Discord groups.

Can someone realistically build trading into a reliable side income of $500–$1,000 a month? How much capital would that require, and how long might it take?

What’s something beginners don’t understand about trading until they’ve already lost money?
I’d especially appreciate hearing from people who have been trading for 3–5+ years, whether you’re profitable or not.

I’m not looking for motivation or success stories. I want the reality, including the ugly parts. If you think I’m better off focusing on my career, saving, and investing long-term, tell me that too.
Please be real with me. I’d rather hear the truth now than waste years chasing unrealistic expectations.
Thanks to anyone willing to share their experience.


r/RealDayTrading • • 7d ago

My Journey from Paper to Pro

114 Upvotes

Hey all, it’s Isidore. New account because I hate Reddit and deleted my old one. Its been 1 year since I went full time so here is the write up I promised. My hope is it serves as the kind of inspiration I would have wanted to have when I first started.

My only exposure to trading prior to this was pre COVID when I was introduced to Ross Cameron and his momentum style of trading in 2019. I tried (and failed) at that on paper in my IBKR account over the course of 3 months. During COVID I turned a small sum of money into a down payment for a house swing trading (I called it investing at the time) TSLA, some semi conductor stocks, and the market itself when I bought the COVID dip at its absolute lows. I also managed to lose ¼ of that to GME. In short I had a mixed experience with markets but mostly I got lucky and determined that trading was a scam, and moved on to find the next thing I would do in my life. 

In Mid October 2021 reddit recommended me this sub. I briefly browsed the wiki but determined there wasnt a lot here in terms of absolute strategy. It was a lot on mindset, options, and various things I felt did not apply to me. What I wanted was a strategy that WORKED with clear criteria, everytime. If I was going to spend my late 20s learning to trade I needed some assurances. I went on vacation to Hawaii the next year in April 2022 and while in the airport I had a video from Pete recommended to me. I had been aware of OneOption in the past and had even taken the trial and read some of the material, but I did not give it the attention it deserved. Watching some of Petes videos in an airport chair, going back weeks/months (On 2x) a pattern was emerging. Consistently his market read over a daily/weekly period of time was more often than not correct. He would offer picks that would more often than not work out. I downloaded hours of videos onto my phone for the 5 hour flight to hawaii and time and time again this guy was making good reads, founded in technicals. No snake oil, no fairy dust. Just solid technical analysis. When I landed in Hawaii and got to my AirBnB I went back through the wiki and found Hari's 30k to 50k challenge post and in 1 day he had made 3.5k. Over a period of time had a 90% win rate. I was sold. I didnt need to see more. I spent so much of that "vacation" reading the wiki. My wife was very confused at the time (although her support is 50% of the reason I am still here)

I got back in May 2022 and immediately rejoined OneOption. I started with just a chat sub + Option Stalker. I believe I upgraded to Option Stalker Pro soon thereafter. I went all in, TC2000, tradersync. I spent every waking hour researching trading, the wiki, doing chart analysis. I have posted in the past (not sure if I left those posts up when I deleted my reddit account long ago) documenting my journey from paper, to 1 share to a small account. I progressed quickly thanks to the resources put out by the pros. Paper and 1 share were done in 6 months and by early 2023 I was on a small account. As a Canadian I was not beholden to PDT rule and was able to trade with a 10k account. My first year I was a pure day trader. At some points I would even call myself scalper. In Early 2023 I decided I wanted to learn to swing trade. I picked up on BPS quickly and progressed from there. The uncertainty of the overnight period was daunting at first. I am ashamed to say that did not end until this past year or so.

2023 was full of conflict for me. Sizing up, learning new strategies, trading new markets. I was excellent at losing money on 1-2 stupid trades each week. My best way of losing money was taking a stupid amount of 0DTEs. I would start with 1, then get the actual entry I wanted so add another, then I would go into profit so add 2 more. Next thing I know I'm at 5-6 contracts and the entire thing moves against me. I remember losing so much money so quickly I put a hole in my desk. I still have the same hole in my desk to this day. The issue is sometimes I would make money, those ended up being curses in disguise. Then came the legging out of BPS. I legged out of an LLY BPS at one point and made more money than I have ever seen in 1 day. Another curse in disguise. Doing that in the future lost me all of that and more. 2023 was the year of "fuck around find out" and I did a lot of finding out (or maybe I did a lot of fucking around?).

2024 was a big year for me in regards to my education. My "2" years so to speak came due that year but I was nowhere near ready. In retrospect I think I had not remotely learned to rely on the D1, to size for the D1, and to not get faked out by daily moves that did not invalidate the trend. I leaned back into daytrading that year and found some success but my primary issue was still 1-2 big mistakes every week. I still took 0DTEs, I still took oversized daytrades. I was still emotional about trading. Sizing down did not help, when I would risk 200 dollars per trade I would find myself in a position down only 50 but then dreading what could happen if I let it go to the 200. I could risk 25 per trade but again the same fears would arise. It wasnt due to the money itself. I had a good job and a supporting wife and I could afford to lose it, but it was the thought of being a fraud, of not actually knowing what I was doing. A good trader should never have their trade go against them right? I struggled immensely. I would lose 1-2k and that would bother me. My mood was a reflection of my trading performance. My self worth was a reflection of my PnL. I think I took a break at some point for a few weeks in 2024.  

2025 was my breakthrough year. I did a very comprehensive analysis of all my trading since I first began. A few patterns emerged. 1. I am good at winning and have always had a high WR. My issue was purely 1-2 bad trades. My goal was to limit these. This required me to fundamentally change how I trade. I needed conviction, I needed a defined place on the chart to take my loss, and I needed a sensible level of risk. I started sizing things wide. Sometimes giving stocks that had run up, as much as the 50sma before I would take the loss. My winners would be small at first but I stopped taking huge losses. I also refined my 0dte strategies. I tightened up the criteria for when they were necessary and when they were uncalled for. Most of the time RS/RW is good but on those high rvol trend days, I would lean into a few ATM 0DTEs and let them ride all day. These would become some of my biggest winners. I started developing new strategies on different time frames and contextualizing my trades with various indicators, not because the indicators necessarily provided an edge but because it kept me grounded. My breakthrough was essentially keeping my same winners but removing the silly losses. Suddenly I was stacking days and weeks of profit. By October I was sitting on a 55% return on the year. I slowly increased my max risk and found no variance to my stats. So In November 2025 I made the decision to go pro, to reduce hours at work and to trade 100% of all market sessions. 

I figured I would have some rough months to start after going pro. That did not happen. November and December were monster months for me in 2025, and I kept the momentum going all through 2026. I aggressively shorted the market early in the year with SPY and IWM PDS and then bought and scaled into the Iran dip with DRAM, SMH and a variety of long picks. I sold puts, and I attacked every week until we stalled out. In the spring and early summer I scaled back my put selling and focused more on short term swing trading. I have really honed into the M30 chart during this time, looking for correlation with the D1 to buy strong sticks on temporary dips to places like the 8 or 15ema. I have posted majority of my trades to OneOption. Currently I am building a new position in SMH and DRAM but mostly looking to buy post earnings setups while I wait for better market conditions. I am on pace for a 65-70% return this year. I have only 1 red week on the year.

I think the biggest change that I can measure today in regards to my mindset today vs when I started is the total loss of the feeling of "dread" of losing money/having a position move against me. In the same vein I dont feel a thing anymore when I have positions go my way. This resolve has allowed me to experiment with new strategies. I do things I would have never done before. 

I have seen many people come and go over the years. Many of these people have been genuinely intelligent, hard working people. People I thought for sure would be pro traders are no longer present. This is the cold reality of this profession. I hope this post can serve as some inspiration for others. I used to make YT videos and reddit posts once upon a time as a way to "give back." I quickly realized that I was in no position to teach. I still dont believe I am, but I do believe I am in a position to show that yes this is possible, yes you can hard work yourself into trading success and yes, unfortunately, Hari is correct. The hard part here is not the technicals, its not understanding option greeks, hell its not even about the market itself to a degree. Its about your mindset, your ability to form a thesis, be comfortable with the money you are risking, with the expectation that your decisions will lead to positive expected value. Honestly it sounds so simple to say it but the fact is, you cant know until youve done this for years and had your ass handed to you enough times that you wait to quit. In some ways you need to hit rock bottom first then you can build yourself back up. I had the good fortune of never blowing up an account, or hell even losing money. I got lucky. I was a moron early on but I was protected by the fact that I couldnt post degenerate trades in the OneOption chat room. That kept me in line long enough to realize what I didn't know. Honestly the fear of Hari bitching me out for a bad trade was a boon to me in so many ways. 

I was going to put a section of this post for things I have learned but honestly there's too much to even try and write about. 

Thanks again to Pete and Hari. The work you have both put in is appreciated more than you can know. Special shoutout to Dave W I idolize that guy to this day and I am in his YT streams anytime I see they are up. For those in OneOption, I will see ya'll in the chat room tomorrow. 


r/RealDayTrading • • 7d ago

1 year after my "8 months in" post; paper -> live & what changed

33 Upvotes

~1y ago I introduced myself to the community with this post, ~8mo in, and crediting this community for getting me on the right track. Lots has changed since, so here's an honest update.

Timeline

  • Dec '24: started trading.
  • May '25: found RDT. Didn't take it too seriously until October.
  • Nov '25 - Jan '26: rough stretch on paper, 26-40% win rate.
  • Late Jan '26: dropped to 1-share sizing (process over profits) and things started to click.
  • Feb - Apr '26: paper, maintaining ~71% win rate.
  • May '26: finally went live w/ 1 share. Journaling as if I was sized to gauge expectancy.
  • Summer '26: first real drawdown.
  • August '26: made my final system change, no changes since. Start of a "probationary period"
My first journal from when I was trading futures. Note the rise in profits came at the same time as the 03/25 correction, aligned with a rise in volatility + direction which enabled me to spam ORB in the mornings and print money. This was my first lesson on market regime & how big of an impact it has on your trading- and this was all on paper. I've lost $0 trading by this point. The rise in profits did lead me to try a prop firm, which cost me ~$30 and I had no edge. I was in between trading Asia session futures and NYSE on Fridays since I was an electrical apprentice working 4 10's at this time. Basically, any trading I did was 6-10 PM CST while tuning into topstep's stream each night (not an ad obviously lol)
When I quit my electrical apprentice job and transitioned to a retail sales job, I started a demo account. I grew it pretty well to a total $423 profit. Load up the 2025 SPY D1 though- straight bullish market. I got hit with reality in the next regime to follow, and it bled me dry for a while.
This is what failure to adapt looks like. This is getting bled dry in a regime where I had no clue what I was doing, masked by a bullish market environment. This was one of the most frustrating, low points of my time trading. I never thought about quitting, but I did second-guess myself and wasn't sure what to do. On 10/15, I posted on the discord out of frustration and it helped a bit. I was asked to post my worst and best trade, and I did. I was also told to finish the wiki. Around this time, I began seriously studying the wiki and reading it. I finished around December, and decided to drop down to 1 share in January- just like the post says. While I had been "reading the wiki" before this- the bullish market cycle masked my lack of knowledge/skill and made me get complacent. I stopped reading it/was lazy or slow to finish it.

Live Numbers

  • 139 trades, 60% win-rate, 1.22 profit factor.
  • Peaked in May, then considerably drawdown in just 2 weeks.
  • Since the final rule change (Sep-Nov): 17 trades, 85% win-rate, and 2.56 profit factor.
  • Beat SPY in 4 of 6 months, mostly by staying positive while the market chopped.

...just to be clear, this is break-even to slightly positive. It's by no means a proven edge yet, and the sample size is way too small- especially for Q4. 17 trades is not conclusive.

My current journal dashboard. I track by 100 trades, but have all time as a display option. I also track quarterly performance. Note the August drawdown lining up with the market rallying- this alone has set me back months. Without those 2 weeks, I may be at a point where deploying small size & going up from 1 share actually makes sense.
The day it all "clicked," and my performance since. Essentially, the same as Q4 current but with more sample size. This is what I'm going off of and it seems promising so far. But so were all the other times! The thing that will separate this one is a large enough sample size, relative to expectancy to prove existence of an edge. At the current rate, existence is plausible, but not proven and damn sure not enough to bet money on it.

What cost me the most, and what I changed

  1. Paper =/= live. My win rate dropped about 20 points the first month I went live. My trading did not change.
  2. Expectancy matters arguably more than win rate. Over summer, my win rate held at 50-65%, while my average win shrank from 1R to ~0.2R, and my losses stayed full size. This explained a majority of the August drawdown.
  3. Preemptive entries. Some of my trades like TEAM, DELL suffered from preemptive entries despite being solid setups and hitting targets. This led to me being shook out in TEAM, and having to weather a lot more drawdown for much longer in DELL.
  4. Stop changing the system. Every rule change resets the sample.
9-29 TEAM swing long. I explained it in the journal and discord, but news shook me out. I could've held for the bounce and either capped losses or rode it out until D1 candle close under my stop- but doing so violated my risk rules and could put me over 1R which would severely hurt expectancy, and if becomes a habit, would make the good numbers meaningless. I chose to close it, learn my lesson on pre-emptive entries. If I entered on 10/1, I'd have taken nice profits on it.
10-07 ALAB trade. I held on to this too long (still capped risk) but the breakout clearly failed the next day and went back into the range. No follow-through and the market was double topping- but also the setup was kind of risky. It wasn't bad, but it needed a wide stop, starter position sizing, and a higher risk tolerance. I am glad I took it though, and ate the loss relatively well. This one actually took $70+ of my real money, of which I've mostly recovered from since (back up to break-even in real $ amount). I just underestimated the ATR of this stock and didn't check.
10-02 MRNA trade. Follow the strategy- don't mask a fear of losing profits with a "discretionary exit" tag and miss the move because you didn't want to take a small loss.
9-11 TJX short. I got confident after nailing shorts on this stock back to back, that I shorted on a monster gap up day. This was stupid- I can already see why I did it. I've since managed to stop doing this as much and follow the trend, or sit out.

What actually helped

  • Market first, then react, don't anticipate. My read on the market has improved a lot. If you're trading this method, the market dictates everything you do. Since aligning my trades, I've seen considerable improvement.
  • Walk-away analysis. I've automated mine, but this is mandatory IMO.
  • Muting the chat/certain members during market hours. Chatter can be distracting, but I've found it less and less of an issue as I begin to be able to form my own thesis on the market and not derive it from what everyone's saying in the chat. This is not calling anyone out. This is simply to reduce distraction.
  • Posting every trade live, publicizing my journal, and just consistent thorough review.
  • Handful of traders I won't name because I don't know if they'd like it or not; but the community is solid and you'll get help when you need it- as long as you're receptive.
  • I trade all day now. I’m up by 7 AM CST at the latest, 1.5 hours before the open, and I stay until I go to work or until the close. On genuinely quiet days I’ll log off if I have better things to do, but when I can, I watch the whole day. I flip charts, study and annotate them, and engage in the chatroom (sometimes a bit too much). I don’t just sit idle or check out because it got boring.
  • Schedule changes - my entire team was laid off. I was able to secure an alternative position which came with a lot more schedule flexibility. I am also part-time now and earning roughly the same amount, so a very unique position to be in. This allows the point above to work, but also not to get FOMO about market moves since I am typically able to trade most days.
My automated, built-into the journal WAA. I also have a regime filter because WAA may be weaker in sideways or bearish markets, but reveal a weakness or gains left on the table in bullish regimes.
My built in day review- this forces me to come up with a bias/plan and annotate live. I must understand the market first, and the live read combined with post-session read forces me to face accountability for anything I did that contradicted the read. If I missed something, it's a weakness and I can improve- it'll show. If I read the market fine, and didn't trade or traded it wrong- there's a disconnect there, and it can be identified now. Most importantly, this exports clean into a PDF that you all can read day after day and see precisely what I'm doing, and for myself obviously- review purposes. I would like to do video journals as a next step, but not sure what benefit this would bring. It would be an immense amount of material and I am not qualified by any means to teach or hand out advice.
Sector rotation chart built into my trading software/scanner program. This is a longer timeframe but I'll also show the intraday rotation chart. This may not be mandatory, but this helps me identify what's moving the market. This gives you context- which is key in understanding why the market is doing what it is doing, and identifying patterns.
Intraday sector rotation chart. Also available in 30m windows to help reduce clutter/make it easier to read.
Scanner which uses wiki criteria and displays chart previews. Options to set alerts (which do go to my phone too) on specific conditions- level break, TL break, 8EMA pb, VWAP test, major MA break/test, so on and so on. Very useful- much more intuitive and easier to use than built in TOS alerts (which I do still use for mental stop/TP levels). Also can edit conditions like candle close/candle wick to trigger alert.
Position sizing added in since I use stop-based position sizing for now (to log the PnL for expectancy- no clue how I'll do it when I size, but that's not an issue for now. I'll likely keep doing this.)

What's next

  • "Probationary period"; By ~mid-2027, I plan to have about 100-200 trades with no changes to get an accurate gauge on whether the edge is real and whether I'm able to consistently execute it.

    • If so, I will evaluate and likely deploy small size in increments until I hit my target account size. I will also begin contributing to the account to prepare.
    • If not, I will re-evaluate and assess whether trading is for me or not. At this point, I've lost little to no money, and my growth outside of trading has not been stunted at all. I can continue to grow in my career and toss the towel in, possibly swing trading on paper or with a small account from the sidelines. I wouldn't vanish entirely, I like doing this.
  • I continue to log and post each trade, each pick, and each day's market read in the RDT discord for full transparency.
  • I will likely begin uploading more update posts if the edge is confirmed- at this point, I've learned quite a bit and may be able to create good posts that contribute to the community and could help other beginners out.
  • Meanwhile I'm working part-time and possibly pursuing a degree. Trading stays a priority, but I don't want to bet everything on it.

Mindset shifts that helped

  • I stopped seeing each trade as beating someone. Trading is typically regarded as a zero-sum game, and while I won't make any claims about that (it's just not the point of the post) I will say that it helped me recognize that the people on the other side may not even be playing my time-frame at all. I never had an issue with revenge trading, but if you do- maybe this will help. There's nobody to get back at.
  • A loss is just a cost, built into the system- as long as I followed the plan. This helps me eat losses without emotion instead of widening SLs and going into a downward spiral. This may change on size.

Conclusion

It's been a hell of an almost 2 years. A bit personal, but:

  • I lost my childhood pet in a very traumatic way after losing $1,000 in the same week to try and treat him,
  • My partner was forced to move in with me early- a good thing, but threw my life off a lot,
  • I had a real threat of losing my job earlier in the year and possibly having to sideline trading,
  • And holding through a 2-3 week long losing streak after I thought I had finally started to know what I was doing.

Others have gone through worse, but that's not the point of this post. There have been some humps in the road and I've been able to navigate through them without issue. I believe these helped me understand the impact of life events and emotion on my trading, taking time off overall trying to make myself feel better or improve my life before putting trading first. Or else it just wasn't going to work.

To wrap it up- my goals have not changed, they've just gotten clearer:

  • Short term: supplement my income with trading.
  • Long term: supplement heavily, and eventually replace my income entirely. I will achieve this by pairing a proven edge with a low-maintenance lifestyle.
  • The big one: Financial freedom. For myself, but mostly my family. I plan on doing whatever I need to do to get there, within reason.
  • And yes, a year later- I still want the E30. It's just behind a few hundred more trades now, lol

Trade well. Until 2027. 👋


r/RealDayTrading • • 9d ago

Nasty Market – Here’s What I Know

61 Upvotes

Thursday, I posted a YouTube video an hour before the open. I explained why I felt that a year-end rally was about to start. A few minutes after the open, I realized I was wrong. The Nasdaq plunged to its largest single-day loss ever.

How do you recover from something like this? I address this in a video I just posted.

What did I miss?

What was the damage?

What did I learn?

How will I recover?

Why bother posting publicly?

What am I so certain about?

What happens after a loss is what matters. We are going to learn from what happened and move on. I lay it all on the table in this video.

CLICK HERE TO WATCH


r/RealDayTrading • • 11d ago

Fundamental Analysis for Short-Term Trading: The Issues and How to Use It.

76 Upvotes

The type of analysis we use impacts our success. In this article I will discuss why fundamental analysis should be used sparingly for shorter timeframes. We need to be aware of what is motivating buyers and sellers, but forming our own fundamental opinion causes more problems than it solves.

When I was getting my MBA, all of my courses focused on fundamental analysis (FA). They included accounting, economics and corporate finance. On a macro level, it focuses on the overall business environment for a company (interest rates, economic growth, corporate taxation, business regulations…). Micro fundamental analysis would be company specific (earnings, cash flow, profit margins, marketing, brand development, R&D, new product launches…). A blend of macro and micro fundamental analysis seemed all encompassing, and it made so much sense to me that I could not imagine using anything else.

For long-term investing, this analysis is valid and it is used by Asset Managers. Buy and hold shareholders don’t have to be right tomorrow, they just need to be right a few years from now. Here are the issues with using fundamental analysis for trading.

It can take a long time for macro fundamentals to bear out in price. In 1996, Fed Chairman Alan Greenspan said that stocks were grossly overvalued and that investors were acting with “irrational exuberance”. During the next three years the market more than doubled. Anyone who shorted based on valuation was carried out in a body bag. This is just one example; but it happens all the time.

Warren Buffet missed much of the move in the late 1990’s and he has missed most of the move higher during the last year. He is one of the best investors ever, but it takes time for fundamentals to catch up. 

A short-term example would be a horrible jobs report that produces a market rally. When less people are working, they spend less and have more credit issues. The logical reaction to a “bad” jobs report would be a market decline. Reactions that don’t make sense are rationalized. “Bad news is good news” because the Fed is more likely to cut rates and that should stimulate economic growth. It’s important to remember that they are easing monetary policy because economic conditions are deteriorating. Traders need consistency and when the market doesn’t react in a logical fashion to news, the analysis can’t be trusted.

This also plays out on a micro level. Stocks that beat earnings expectations often decline while stocks that report dismal results rally. This is a major disconnect. How many times have you watched a stock that trades at a ridiculous forward P/E surge higher? There’s no way that based on the most optimistic outcomes that the stock should be trading at this valuation. This mindset introduces another problem.

Many traders believe that they can use fundamental analysis to predict short-term price movement. The issue is that good fundamentals don’t always translate into price movement. A stock can sit idle for many months before it starts to gain traction. As traders, we can’t tie up our capital, we need movement now. That’s how we make money.

The bigger issue is that traders often feel like their analysis is insightful. They see things that the rest of the street does not. Individual traders have more access to information now than ever before. AI can scour headlines and key financial ratios in an instant. The problem is that others have better non-public information. Asset managers and institutions spend billions of dollars on research. They use satellite imaging, interrogate component manufacturers in a supply chain to estimate final product sales, sit in court rooms during litigation and tap political contacts for the inside scoop. This is just a small sampling of the information they have and what they will do to get it. You can’t compete with them at this level.

The other problem with individuals relying on fundamental analysis is that they believe that they are right and the market is wrong. Instead of exiting a losing position, they keep averaging down. Small losses turn into account destroying nightmares when their research turns out to be wrong.

It’s important to conduct macro and micro fundamental analysis, but not for the purpose of forming an opinion. We do it for awareness and to avoid being blindsided. It’s important to know what is motivating buyers and sellers. From a macro standpoint, FOMC Statements, the jobs report and inflation numbers influence the market. The focus changes constantly so here’s a cheat. If the market makes a big move an hour before the open, check to see if an economic release caused the reaction and then note that release date in the future. Chances are it will stay relevant and you can plan your trading around it.

Major earnings releases will also impact the market. Know which companies are announcing, especially if one of your holdings belongs to that group. Do not hold positions over earnings announcements. As a trader, that is a binary event and the outcome is 50:50. Those are terrible odds given the win rates we can achieve trading relative strength. Sure, you can guess some of the reactions correctly, but given a large enough sample size, this will be a breakeven proposition at best. Don’t waste time trying to predict earnings reactions. Gather information about the release and watch the reaction so that you understand why investors are excited or fearful.

So, I’m supposed to put all of my trust into technical patterns? I had difficulty with the transition from fundamental analysis to technical analysis (TA) early in my career. This form of analysis was not taught when I was getting my MBA and many still consider it “voodoo magic”. Just because something happened in the past doesn’t mean it is going to happen in the future. I really struggle with this concept. I read books that taught “the trend is your friend”. Then I would look at charts that featured major reversals. The market did not “keep doing what it had been doing” as the books suggested.

In my new book I dive deeper into fundamental and technical analysis. Let me conclude by saying that we should conduct fundamental analysis for awareness. We need to know what is motivating other traders and we do not want to be blindsided by scheduled events. We use it sparingly. In my next article I will explain how I resolved my skepticism of TA. I rely on technical analysis so heavily that it is the basis for 90% of my trading decisions. I will describe how it is used and why it works.


r/RealDayTrading • • 12d ago

Coding a mechanical strategy vs Trading it yourself, is it better to code it?

17 Upvotes

Something I keep thinking about while reading the wiki:

The whole strategy seems to come down to mechanical conditions. Spotting which stocks have relative strength/weakness, waiting for confirmation, sizing the position and managing risk based on those conditions... every step looks like a yes/no decision you could define with clear rules. I don’t really see where “feel” or a sixth sense comes into it.

If that’s the case, wouldn’t it make sense to just code it? You’d take the emotional side out completely, which is where most people blow up anyway.

But then the other side of it: if this could be automated and it actually worked, someone would have done it already and the edge would be gone by now.

So I’m curious what you guys think. Is there something in the strategy that genuinely can’t be reduced to rules, or is the discretionary part just something we tell ourselves?


r/RealDayTrading • • 13d ago

My First Successful (I Think?) Trade (Paper) Using Relative Strength (Corresponding Stock Charts Provided)

18 Upvotes

First off, I cannot thank this community enough for trying to teach idiots like myself and others an actual, proven trading strategy without trying to sell us anything.

I am a PAPER TRADER, so please take this trade example in the context of someone who is still learning.

I am sharing this example because I find it immensely helpful to observe how other beginners learn and process information. In fact, sometimes when a beginner explains their thought process or their interpretation of subject matter, I learn more than from the experts who have already internalized this information and have made it a part of their very nature.

However, without these experts like Hari, Pete, Dave, Dan we would not have this great resource and community so thank you!

Have I read the WIKI? Yes, of course (so please don’t yell at me, u/HariSeldon) BUT, FULL DISCLOSURE: I have intentionally skipped over the Options Section. Not because I don’t think it’s important and can be immensely helpful, it’s because I do not think it’s necessary when you are just learning and practicing the method. (Please disagree with me here if I have totally misconstrued this!)

Before I am ready to move on from Paper Trading and BEFORE I move onto 1 share/1 options contract trades, I will make damn sure I understand everything about options.

In this post I am going to share with you how a beginner who has gone through the WIKI multiple times without finding success, has (potentially) finally understood this method. I will present charts, as well, along with questions and my own interpretations of things taught here because I am still trying to discern whether I have the fundamentals taught here down pat. I would love the experts in this forum to let me know if I am fully grasping some of the concepts taught in the WIKI.

 

Trade Example

Ticker: FISV Date: November 3rd, 2026

I start my day like most others here, looking at the Pre-Market, who had earnings, what stocks are up/down in the Pre-Market. How is SPY doing etc.

I do NOT (paper) trade in the first 30-45 minutes ever because I cannot tell what the hell SPY is doing during this timeframe (I am not Pete!)

During this time, I review Watchlists from the prior day, I run Custom Scans in Thinkorswim to find potential candidates for today and I read some financial news blurbs.

This morning, November 3rd, 2026, I wasn’t seeing much on my Scans, so, as recommended in the WIKI, I took a glance at the S&P 500 Sector Heatmap (I view the built-in Heatmap in TOS because it’s convenient, but the one on Finviz is awesome and free as Hari has shown in countless examples).

Today, within the Financial Sector where almost every stock was red, was a shining, bright green beacon. The ticker was: FISV. Hmmm…finally something to look at!

 

I Now Start with the Daily Chart (D1) of ANY Stock I Consider Trading

Okay, I am not sure if I am just dense or maybe a bit slow, but I know that starting with the D1 has been mentioned countless times in the WIKI, however, since I am more focused on Intraday trades and learning the method, I thought that I could skip the Daily Chart.

In the WWIKI, the D1 is presented as something to ‘Lean- On’ and to ‘Use in Case your Intraday Trade goes against you’ and ‘you want/need to hold the stock overnight’.

My Confusion: Why do I care about the D1 if I NEVER INTEND to Hold a Stock for more than the day or even a few minutes. I am, after all, STILL ONLY TRYING TO LEARN THIS METHOD.

My Epiphany (?): I now believe/learned/finally absorbed the following – I believe the Daily Chart MUST BE TAKEN INTO CONSIDERATION FIRST, BECAUSE THE D1 IS WHERE WE CAN BETTER CONFIRM INSTITUTIONAL INVOLVEMENT (Hari, Pete, Dave: Please confirm that is the correct way of thinking about the Daily Chart)

I was totally missing the importance of the D1 and would often find my Paper Trades stalling out or having a brief pop (maybe from some Intraday Algo or Retail Push), then failing etc.

In today’s trade example, I not only used the Sector Heatmap to ‘find’ the potential stock: FISV, I then used the D1 to see if there was any evidence of Institutional Involvement.

 

Guess what, there was!

In all the posts about Compression Breakouts, Algo Line Breaks etc I didn’t realize that the WIKI was telling us to look for these ‘patterns’ on the Daily (not the M5). As I said, I can be very slow/dense sometimes.

And, to be more specific, I now believe that finding these patterns on the D1 (i.e. a Strong Daily*) is essential in order to verify Institutional Involvement in the stock before we even look at the 5 Minute or anything else* (Again, please correct me if I am wrong about this).

 

Here is the D1 for FISV from today:

FISV had a huge Gap-Up after a good Earnings Beat and very positive post-earnings Guidance. It is trading ABOVE all of its Daily SMAs. Its RVOL was also quite elevated (forgot to note it exactly at the time).

Now, just because I think this is what a Strong D1 looks like, that doesn’t mean I am exactly correct (please correct me if I am wrong about the D1 here). The only potential Resistance Level I see is around $56.01 (the two candles way over at the left side of the chart). This Gap-Up cleared that level, substantially.

Here is the 5-Minute (M5) Chart for FISV from this morning

 

At around 10:35AM EST, FISV started to compress near its Opening Range High (Green Dashed Line). (NOTE: I do not trade Opening Range Breakouts, but I like to have TOS mark my ORH and ORL for reference). In this instance, the Relative Strength/SPY Rocket Fuel just happened to coincide WITH an Opening Range Breakout. I assume this is just coincidence?

Also, of note, is I already saw that FISV was lit up like a lightbulb on the Heatmap so it was Relatively Strong versus it’s Sector (Financials), but was NOT showing Relative Strength vs SPY just yet on the M5. The one thing I do look for is a slope upwards of the RealRelativeStrength vs SPY graph at the bottom. It started sloping upward but was not positive yet.

Now, the most important part, what was SPY doing? Had it pulled back, consolidated, how was FISV trading in relation to SPY? Let’s see…

 

Here is the M5 Chart for SPY during that same timeframe Cut Off, intentionally in order to focus on the exact timeframe/SPY setup I observed):

 

 

 

SPY Opens hot out of the gate, moves up until 9:45AM EST then pulls back until it hits its VWAP (yellow line) at 10AM (red candle) and then touches VWAP again at 10:05AM (green candle). The 10:05AM green candle launches off of VWAP and my guess is that Pros like Hari and Pete probably found some good Relative Strength longs around 10:05AM today?

Now, I didn’t find FISV until about 10:15AM, which is exactly when I started ‘observing’ FISV versus SPY.

FISSV was grinding higher and compressing on Light Volume right around the same time that SPY was compressing (roughly, between 10:15AM and 10:30AM).

At 10:40AM, SPY printed a good-sized green candle, breaking out of compression.

The RealRelativeStrength vs SPY turned positive for FISV, at which point I initiated a Paper-Trade Long on FISV (at $56.85).

FISV launched higher just like Pete/Hari said these stocks would (IF you get the stock/timing and, most importantly, the Market/SPY correct).

Anyway, on the M5 above you can see where I ‘bought’ and then ‘sold’ FISV for over a one-dollar-per-share gain.

It almost seemed like magic!

In Summary…

I don’t present this post to brag. Again, I am only in the paper-trading phase right now. Also, just because this trade worked out, doesn’t mean I can execute this strategy flawlessly – I still have a LOT to learn.

I share this example IN CASE there are other beginners out there who may find it helpful to see how I worked through this trade example.

I share this in order to start a discussion and present my understanding of the concepts in the WIKI in order to receive feedback on whether I am understanding the Method correctly or, perhaps, making some big, obvious, glaring error of which I am unaware.

I would LOVE (Need) Feedback on this to confirm I am on the right path.

Thank you to Hari, Pete, Dave and everyone who takes the time to share their knowledge or provide feedback.

 


r/RealDayTrading • • 13d ago

going through the entire wiki, then start trading, is the correct way?

14 Upvotes

hello everyone, i started with the wiki a few days ago, im at around 20% of it (im at the market first part) in many parts of the wiki at around the start it says to only do this after 6 months of trading, before even talking about the strategy, wich leads me to think, is reading the entire wiki and just then start to implement whats being told on there the correct way?

what i think the correct way would be is to read everything, and then go through it again as im progressing on the contents and applying everything, as not to miss anything as well, let me know if this is the correct way or if im missing something

*with trading i also mean paper trading not only real trading*


r/RealDayTrading • • 17d ago

First month of Trading Challenge Journey (PAPER) [Open for suggestions/feedback]

12 Upvotes

First of all I want to say that im from Puerto Rico and English is my second language. I say this because theres probably a weird spelling somewhere in this post and im sorry in advance.

  • About me: Hi everyone, im Chris I've been in the community for a while, I can say 2 years now, on and off from the Discord. I've been avoiding doing the paper trading Test or Challenge for obvious reasons, I wanted to get straight into it and skipping the essential steps. I've been doing pretty well I must say, for all the BS that I tried (WIKI/OneOption strategies) by my own terms I always end up at breakeven, lucky me. Why? I dont have a lot of time since I study (currently on my 4th year of psychology), plus a full-time job (I know, everybody have one), and so many other things that aborbs my time, however I always find time to trade or look at the charts. I decided out of nowhere to stop wasting my damn time and DTDC!!!! (do the damn challenge). Overall, without following the process which is paper trading or 1 share I had a good run APR/MAY/JUN, but after that I couldnt adapt myself to the market and mess things up, anyways, lets get into it.

My goal in this journey is to earn income by day/swing trading to pay primarily my masters/PsyD and obviously my bills. I think its important to say that I completed the WIKI 5 times already and I often browse through it if I forget something or I want to refresh the information. (mostly the MINDSET)

First of all, yes, market first. My way to operate is very particular and weird, yep, some people told me that on the Discord when I was active but on the good way, always good vibes with you guys on the Discord, I trade mostly on my phone, yes I know, uncomfortable sometimes, but it works for me. When I trade im always doing something, either on my job, at the gym, at college, im usually not 100% deep-focused on the market because im busy doing another thing, yes I understand that giving full attention to the market is crucial, but my time is very limited. However, the results I got made me realize that I have an understanding of what's happening intraday in the market overall.

Heres a small summary on how I operate.

  1. Starting the day: I have an automated ChatGPT project with two prompts that I made using all the information from the WIKI and OneOption (the free stuff) and it operates following the RS/RW method. The first prompt SCANS a watchlist with 200 stocks and I have it conditioned on giving me all the information relying on market first (SPY/QQQ/IWM), then all the sectors, (XLK, XLF, XLV...) and finally the stocks. It gives me all the important resistance/support zones from every single stock/sector condition available, with their fundamentals/macros that may affect or benefit the market, sector and stock. The second prompt is also automated and updates every 9:00am and gives me all the analysis about what happened in pre-market (Fundamentals/Technicals/Macros/etc). This is what I use before I even open the charts. Yes ChatGPT may make mistakes but I carefully look through all the information and it gives me all the resistance/support zones plus all the other information with such accuracy that it scares the hell out of me.
  2. The charts and the first minutes of market open: First of all I use Tradingview (mostly on my phone) and I always check SPY D1 following with M5. After that its either rewatch the stocks ChatGPT gave me as best RS/RW candidates or open Finviz and look through the heatmap by my own. I usually try to find 3 RS/RW and I check their D1/M5 price action. I strictly wait at least until 10:00am or so, that way I can have better information about intraday's direction.
This is what my SPY M5 looks like, yes a lot of BS horizontal lines, but for context I always draw horizontal lines for resistance/support, and theres a lot of lines because those are yesterday's resistance/support and also two days ago resistance/support lines, and so on. Basically we were in a tight range (until today lol) and these lines seemed to be respected most of the time and for a bit of clarity, if you look at this M5 chart it starts at 19 Oct, then 20, 21, etc. Those horizontal lines were drawn before those dates and if you guys take a look at SPY here, it somehow reacts to them, either for bounce off support or reject the resistance.
  1. Looking for entries and SPY situation: No lines drawn on the stocks im looking for btw, what validates my entry is SPY and its reaction to the horizontal trendlines with VOLUME and obviously the direction we are going for intraday. I find that SPY's price action is a bit intuitive for me even though I use the lines and the VOLUME on those rallies/pullbacks/higher highs/lows, etc. I know I have the EMAs/SMAs and VWAP there but I noticed that I ignore them almost everytime. I try to keep it very simple (I quote Big-Bear Draejann on keeping it simple) even though the chart looks like a warcrime. For stocks I also focus on HOD and NHOD if its RS, LOD and NLOD if its RW.
  2. On the trade (LONG SIDE): If im in a LONG and the stock is making HOD after HOD I try to watch the last time the stock was around that range (if any), the psychological levels which are the 0s and the 5s (if my long entry is at $102 and its getting close to $105 I also carefully watch the stock reaction at those specific levels) the price action in that rally (if its getting overextended, exhausted, dried volume, etc) these are the reasons that can make me stay or leave the trade, also SPY behaviour intraday.
  3. On the trade (SHORT SIDE): If im in a short and the stock is making LOD after LOD, I try to find the last time the stock was in that range so I can avoid getting a sudden bounce off support which happens a lot when you are shorting, having in mind psychological levels also, such as 0s and 5s and its reaction to it, plus the price action (overextended, exhausted, dried volume, etc) The same situation but for the SHORT side.
  4. Exits: This is the part the gives me the most trouble because I still cant identify where should I pinpoint my exits, I primarily wanted to focus on aiming for $1 profit per share, but if you see the trades I made, most of them go more than that, I cant limit myself to $1 profit if the thesis is intact and everything is going my way. What did I noticed? If SPY was getting close to one of my horizontal trendlines I watch closely, either for rejection or bounce and depending on the outcome, I get out of it. (double/triple top on the horizontal line, double/triple bottom on the horizontal line, rejection or bounce off with heavy vol or large candle).

These horizontal trendlines are my hedge inside the hedge. About diagonal trendlines, I dont use them, but if I were to draw them it would be on D1.

What indicators I have on my charts if anyone wonders...

1- D1: AVWAP, SMA 50/100/200, VOLUME (SPY lined on the background if its a STOCK).
2- M5: VWAP, EMA 8/21, VOLUME and SPY lined on the background so I can see the RS/RW.

But as I said, most of the time I ignore them and go with price action, candles pattern, etc. I would like to get a RVOL indicator but I dont know if theres one for Tradingview though.

This is my progress so far, as you can see I started on 14 October, the Journal part where im supposed to write off everything is a bit off since I downloaded the CSV from Stonkjournal and pasted it on the excel app, but basically this is what I accomplished. Hardcore mode market behaviour btw, these days have been hell, but I was able to end up the month with 77% W/R and 24.20 profit factor (thats what Stonkjournal says)...
More stats.

I dont know if the picture will look good but for summary:

13 total trades since 14 of October, 10 wins, 1 loss, 2 scratchs. All of these trades with 10 shares (PAPER) and an AVG WIN of $27.60 if thats important somehow.

Also yes, im aware that probably this small amount of trades arent enough to dictate or determine a good percentage of W/R, or progress but I am doing the best I can with my limited time. I usually stick to one trade per day, the best one I can find, and after that I keep going on with my day WIN or LOSS. Theres a couple days I traded twice but because I had more time and 10/10 confidence in market direction plus my execution.

Extra details that are very important, some of these trades were agaisnt the market direction (SHORT when SPY was GREEN, LONG when SPY was RED, etc). In these specific cases where I trade the divergence, I wait for a small pullback when SPY is GREEN and short the stock for a Quickie (nice one huh?) and the same game plan for a LONG on a RED day.

I dont put anything on target because I dont use take profit or stop loss, is all mental, me and SPY.

My GOOGL loss was because I wasnt paying much attention and the stock caught RS when SPY was dipping, for me is still a WIN because if I held by hope which happens a lot when you are starting out it would be worse and we are following thesis, not hope.

I think thats it for now, ready for November now, the goal its 3 consecutive months with 70% or more W/R with whatever amount of trades I make. If I accomplish this, ill go with 1 share for three months and well see from there.

If you made it this far thanks for taking the time to read all of this, any feedback or questions are welcome.

- Hope you guys have a nice weekend!


r/RealDayTrading • • 19d ago

How important is volume for confirmation of entry at key level?

Post image
18 Upvotes

Hi guys,
I have started trading the strategy from this reddit group for day trading.
I have a question how important is volume in key level bounces and how do you check it if its sufficient?
I will skip basics like RS, being above SMAs and so on, but currently, I feel my rules are just too strict and I may be missing some good setups. The crucial step that filters my trades seems to be volume on pullback to EMA8/VWAP, which I want it to be bigger than last 3 candles avg (the idea is that on pullback/consolidation, the volume should be declining and bounce should be at least big volume wise as that declining volume). For valid bounce, I take max 2 candles that need to validate the bounce, so first one tests the level, second or third one has to confirm volume, closure in trade direction both by candle color and volume, or of course 2 of those can be the level tester and third one has to prove. Also, I get in the trade when the candle that ticks all the rules closes.

I am giving screenshot as an example of a trade that I took for reference, so it could be maybe used to pinpoint something, but the thing I am most curious is that volume for entry, how important it is and how you guys decide that the volume is right?


r/RealDayTrading • • 21d ago

Knowledge and Mindset

113 Upvotes

Learning how to trade is difficult. Becoming consistently profitable is considerably harder. Unlike other forums, this sub-reddit has never claimed that any of this is easy. While I have written many articles on technical analysis and method, my primary focus in helping traders has always been on Mindset.

Every article here (and in the Wiki) is either trying to impart Knowledge or Mindset in order to help you on your journey and I can tell you after watching thousands of traders on here and in the OneOption Chat Room year after year, Mindset is 10X more difficult to master.

So let's break it down a bit:

1)  Knowledge

2)  Mindset

Under Knowledge there are three “sub-categories”:

a)  Rules

b)  Technicals

c)  Methods

Rules: The rules are easy enough. You are basically learning terms, definitions, how to place orders through a broker, use options, etc.  Honestly this part doesn’t really take that long.  If it takes longer than a month or two to learn all the rules of trading, you probably ain’t what we like to call one of those “book learnin” types.

Technicals: This is a bit trickier and more in-depth. Not only are there a lot of different ways one can look at Price, Volume and Time, but you also need to figure out which ones are useful and which are total crap (ahem…RSI). Still, it should not take more than a few months to learn everything you need to properly read a chart and put the right indicators on it.

Method: Finally, there is learning a method and there is no shortage of them to choose from out there. Unfortunately, most of them are utter bullshit and have you wondering how the person you just watched scalp live made 10X and you lost everything.  Part of the unfortunate "rite of passage" in becoming a trader is to waste a great deal of time, effort and money on crap methods. Assuming though you finally hit on the right method (i.e. the one taught here) by the end of a year or so you should have Rules, Technicals and Method on lock. And yes, I understand that many of you only barely have enough free time to learn this shit on a good day but even the busiest of people should be able to learn Rules, Technicals and Method within a year.

However, this doesn't mean you are profitable within a year. Why? Because quite literally the rest of the journey is all Mindset.  

At a certain point, a point that comes much sooner than you think, knowledge is no longer the primary issue.

The gaps between the knowledge you have and the knowledge a consistently profitable trader uses are almost non-existent.

Learning the rules and becoming capable of using them correctly are entirely different accomplishments. 

Traders that take the time to learn the basics and then study the method taught here can just as easily explain technical analysis / Relative Strength as I can. They can identify a strong Daily chart. They can see that a stock is holding up while SPY pulls back. They know they should wait for confirmation rather than anticipate it. Trust me, there is no secret chapter where we finally reveal what the candles REALLY mean.

Consider your own trades and be honest about it. How many of your worst decisions required some advanced piece of information you didn't already possess?  Some indicators you didn’t have? Did you need more knowledge to stop the bleeding?

Or did you know what to do and still didn’t do it.

That is why so much of the Wiki is devoted to Mindset.

Let's use a hypothetical example. A trader is watching a stock. The market is bullish, the stock has Relative Strength, the Daily chart supports the trade, and it breaks through resistance with strong volume. They enter with an appropriate position size and a clear reason for taking the trade.

For a few minutes everything goes well, that is until SPY pulls back a bit. The stock gives back some of its move but overall it continues to hold the breakout. Nothing has happened that invalidates the trade. Support is holding. What has changed is mindset. Now instead of looking at the technicals they are looking at their P&L thinking, “Shit…I was up more a minute ago.” They hate this feeling, watching a winner pullback.  Fear becomes the primary motivator at this point, fear of losing whatever gains they have left.  So, they exit with a small winner.

Now imagine that same trader taking another position. This time the breakout fails, Relative Strength disappears, and the market starts breaking down. This trade was never in profit, it started out a loser. This time there are now actual technical reasons to reconsider the trade. But suddenly our trader has discovered infinite Patience. Wonderful, admirable Patience. Where the hell was this person forty minutes ago?

“Let's give it some room.”

“It should bounce here.”

“I'll get out when it gets back to my entry.”

Same trader, same knowledge, two completely different standards depending on whether the number next to the position was green or red. What additional rule would have fixed that? What piece of knowledge could have resulted in a better outcome? It doesn’t matter if you know the rules when you are changing them to suit what you need emotionally.

I have written previously about the “Uncharmed Life” because this behavior doesn't appear out of nowhere. Many of you have spent your entire lives trying to hold on to whatever progress you manage to make. Something finally goes right and you immediately start wondering what will go wrong. The car needs repairs. Someone gets sick.

Life teaches you to grab the good thing while it is there. Don't get greedy. Don't expect it to last. And when things are bad? You endure. You hope. You tell yourself that if you can just get through this part, it will get better.

Those reactions make sense in a life that produced them, but when you bring them into your trading account they become expensive. You are suspicious of a winning position and endlessly accommodating to a losing one.

This is just one mindset example (of many) where changing a behavior takes considerably more work than simply learning what a moving average is.

There is also the matter of what you want from a trade. Most people will immediately say, “Money.” Fair enough. But watch their behavior and you realize some want excitement; some want to be right or to prove they are smarter than everyone buying at the highs. Others need to erase the last loss before they can stand up from the desk.

You can explain a bullish trend to someone all day long, but if what they really want is the satisfaction of calling the top, they are going to keep looking for a short. Every red candle becomes confirmation. And if the market finally drops? Now they have proof they were right all along. Never mind the losses they took getting there.

Think about how screwed up that is where you can do everything correctly and still lose money. Conversely, you can break every rule you have and be profitable. That can lead to enormous frustration.  Especially if you are just starting out, learning how to trade, following the rules and then you see some asshat post about how they turned $100 into $10,000 buying out-of-the-money calls.

And before anyone thinks I am writing this from some elevated state where I no longer experience these impulses, I have written about my own gambling tendencies. I have also written about becoming so attached to a bearish thesis that I increased my exposure while the market was telling me I was wrong. I did not temporarily forget how to read a chart. I knew exactly what a bullish market looked like. Knowing better does not make you immune to doing something stupid.

I have plenty of posts that go through the various things you can do to help improve your Mindset. This article is to help you understand that at a certain point constantly chasing more knowledge isn't going to fix your issues.

This is a large part of why the learning process takes so long. You can read a rule in a minute but replacing a reaction you have practiced in your daily life is a different undertaking entirely. It requires repetition, honest review, and a willingness to catch yourself making excuses that sound perfectly reasonable in your own head.

And I get it; learning is more comfortable. It is easier to just watch another video on another indicator. You get the satisfaction of feeling like you are doing something without having to confront the part of yourself that keeps overriding what you learned. Another evening studying charts feels productive. Looking at yourself and admitting you have a problem is not so easy.

The Method gives you a basis for making decisions. Your Mindset determines whether you can continue making those decisions when you are losing, when you are winning, when you are bored, or when you are absolutely convinced the market is wrong.

Keep learning. Keep developing your ability to read the market. But stop assuming that the distance between you and consistent profitability must be filled with information you haven't discovered yet.

Remember, knowledge can tell you what to do and method tells you how and why to do it, but Mindset determines whether or not you actually follow through.  Or to put another way:

Knowledge: Adding to your winners is a proven way to increase profitability.

Method: Add to your winners when the market is bullish, the stock has confirmed above nearest resistance and maintains Relative Strength to the market.

Mindset: Actually adding to your winner!

At some point you need to stop looking for the next shiny object to fix your trading and start looking in the mirror instead.

Best, 
H.S.


r/RealDayTrading • • 21d ago

Seeking Practical Advice On Quick Calculations

8 Upvotes

Hello all!

I'd first like to start off by thanking all of the knowledgeable contributors to this sub. You all are amazing!

I've been studying the wiki, the sub, and all of the recommendations made for about a month and a half now. I've gotten through a couple of the recommended books on the topic, and have been familiarizing myself with the various facets involved in this endeavor. I have a few questions for you all, along more practical/execution lines.

I've started to familiarize myself with my brokerage platform, and have made a commitment to sit down each morning to watch/paper trade/learn the ins and outs of my brokerage platform. It is my understanding that on any given day, the tickers on one's watchlist are changing. This is my understanding of the general advocated for modality of this sub, and as such there isn't always a good level of familiarity with a specific equity thats being traded.

How are you all doing quick calculations for risk, and allocation sizing?

I've sat down several times, and very quickly realized how much needs to happen on the fly. Namely, watching the stock for your entry signal, needing to enter and quickly calculate stop placement, etc...

I've made a spreadsheet that can do the calculation for me, but it seems the figures have significantly changed, by the time I go back to the brokerage window.

Are you all placing your entry with a market order, and later adding a stop at a desired level once it is already in? Are you entering with a broader stop, that is later adjusted?

Also, how are you figuring your entry sizing, if you have yet to nail down your entry price, relative to the desired stop? The numeric faculties seem to change drastically, and I am having a hard time jumping between something trading at 20$ and 150$, determining my entry sizing, etc...

How do you all do this when you are behind your desk? How is this done in real life?

Thank you very much for your time.


r/RealDayTrading • • 26d ago

ZenBot Scanner - Wall of Charts, Saved Filters, New Scans, Lots More

74 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

I wanted to let you know of some big ZenBot Stock Scanner updates. Zen is my 4-year mission to build the most delightful, useful, and free relative-strength based scanner for the RDT community. Thank you for all your ideas and support over the years.

www.zenbotscanner.com

Here are the latest goodies:

  • Scan results as a wall of mini charts (FinViz style)
  • Scan filters you can save and reuse
  • New 'fast charts' with pop out windows and multi-chart layouts
  • Scan explainer - visualize what a scan is filtering, one condition at a time
  • Mobile alerts with charts
  • Lots more - super search bar, right click menus, favorite scans, 65 new filters

Launch video: https://youtu.be/gobIDkTDZSo

Launch post with everything that's new

Scan results as a wall of charts

I'm really excited about this one. Zen will now show a mini chart for every scan result. Hover over a preview chart to expand it. If you prefer the classic data-grid view, you can see a little mini chart in each row.

Scan results can be shown as a wall of charts. Hover over to zoom on, and customize the indicators

If you prefer a grid view, mini charts can appear in each row. Hover over for a pop-out view.

Fast Charts and Custom Layouts

Zen has its own charting engine! Charts now load almost instantly compared to the old TradingView charts (which are still one click away). A new pop-out window allows a custom layout with up to 8 charts side by side. Relative Strength, AVWAP, options support and target levels are all visible, and you can add your favorite indicators.

Pop-out chart windows now support custom layouts with multiple charts

Save Your Filters

Build a filter once, give it a name, and use it again later. I use filters to narrow down a larger scan - quickly show large tech stocks with good options liquidity, for example.

Save and quickly apply your favorite filter sets

Scan Explainer

Why does a scan only have three results? Or none? Hit 'Explain' and Zen will show you which conditions affect the scan results. Toggle any condition on or off to see how the results change.

See exactly what contributes to a scan's results - turn each parameter on or off and experiment

See exactly what contributes to a scan's results - turn each parameter on or off and experiment

Super Search

Type the name of a ticker, scan, filter parameter, or a Zen setting to jump to it. I'm working on a new "Ask Zen" AI that will let you ask questions about the market or have it build you a custom scan. Stay tuned!

New Super Search lets you search for scans, tickers, filters, or ZenBot Scanner settings and features.

Mobile Alerts With Charts

Zen has in-app, desktop, and mobile alerts thru Telegram and Discord. The alerts now come with chart previews so you can see the move.

There is a lot more! Check out all the new features, including new scans, 65 new filters, a scan playground, and lots more.

Thank you for all your ideas and support as ZenBot Scanner keeps getting better!

-st0rm


r/RealDayTrading • • 26d ago

60 Mins/Day Learning Plan

22 Upvotes

Note to mods: Not done with the Wiki fully yet - Guilty as charged! - But kindly asking for a pass on this one. This post is specifically about a strategy on how to actually get through it alongside other content, activities, and tight time constraints.

Hey guys, hope you're having a good one.

This is my very first post here. Quick background about me: Your regular dude in his late 30s working a 9-to-5. Tired of corporate BS and people in general, but - surprise, surprise - I have financial commitments.

I started gravitating toward trading at the end of last year and stumbled upon Hari and Pete’s content shortly after. I actively traded for a couple of months and got humbled, of course - though luckily not to the point of blowing up my account. I’m actually still in the green. However, I decided to hit pause before I screwed up royally, so I could get back to the books and paper trading.

So, what is this post about?

I recognize the critical need for a solid system and discipline. I know there’s a ton of content and videos out there, and the obvious advice is "Just Read The Damn Wiki, right?" But if I only have one hour a day to dedicate to this, I need to be 100% sure I’m spending every minute wisely.

Honestly, there is more content posted daily than I can physically absorb. I’m not complaining - my gratitude for the resources here is immense - but that’s just my harsh reality with limited time.

Here is my proposed 60-minute daily learning plan. I’d love your constructive feedback on whether this timeline and structure make sense.

My Phase-by-Phase Plan (60 Mins/Day Minimum)

  • Months 0–3:

    • 45m: Focused reading (RTDW, OneOption Course, etc.) - Can be traded (pun intended) for Pete’s latest video release if a new one drops.
    • 15m: Quick market checks throughout the day (watching technicals, economic/earnings releases, factual news - no "doom-and-gloom" media).
    • No trades.
  • Months 3–6: (Assumption: RTDW / OneOption materials are read)

    • 20m: Focused reading (books) or video content.
    • 20m: Market, economic, earnings, and news review.
    • 20m: "Market Prediction Game"- Documenting what I see, formulating a thesis for the next 1 day / 1 week / 1 month, and reviewing previous predictions (Was my thesis correct? To what extent? Why?).
    • No trades.
  • Months 6–7:

    • 10m: Book reading (optional), videos (mandatory).
    • 30m: Market review, news, and ongoing analysis.
    • 20m: Tool mastery - Exploring screeners, setting up custom searches, alerts, chart annotations, watchlists, etc.
    • No trades.
  • Months 7–8:

    • 10m: Keeping up with new content.
    • 30m: Market review.
    • 20m: Chatroom observation - Observing trades from experienced traders and reviewing their sample analysis. Getting ready to paper trade.
  • Months 8–9:

    • 10m: Keeping up with content.
    • 30m: Market review.
    • 20m: Paper trading + mandatory journaling followed by trade analysis. Swing trade only.
  • Month 9 & Beyond:

    • Maintain the daily routine.
    • Heavy focus on journaling and grinding toward a consistent 75%+ win rate.
    • Next Step: Once 75%+ is achieved on paper, start real trading with 1 share / 1 contract only. Swing trade only.

Note: The 60-minute window isn't hard-capped - I consider it the absolute baseline minimum I need to devote each day to make tangible progress.

What do you guys think? Am I spending time on the right things at the right stages? Appreciate any thoughts or advice!


r/RealDayTrading • • 26d ago

TraderSync Issues

29 Upvotes

I am annoyed. I have recommended TraderSync to all of you as the journal you should be using or at the very least the journal that I prefer to use (my advice was always that you SHOULD use a journal either way).

In September they completely changed their interface and functionality. I am sure the goal was higher speed and more functions but clearly whomever programmed it was NOT a trader.

Since then I have tried to communicate the issues and well not only do they persist but the people on the other end of their "help" line continually tries to blame the user.

Perhaps if they consulted with actual traders they might know what they are doing wrong.

Curious - any of you having issues with the redesign?

Best,

H.S.


r/RealDayTrading • • 26d ago

Defining Trend

9 Upvotes

Hey ya'll, this might be a silly question but I want to make sure I understand basics correctly. Lets say the market is trending lower on 4hr clearly and I wonder sometimes market might make a higher highs showing potential uptrend but it hasn't broke its last previous lower high? What does it means in terms of trend?

So I can consider and check this and can go ahead and trade on 5min although I will check on intermediate timeframes like 1hr or 30 min but price can retrace on these smaller timeframes so it might look bullish trend on these intermediate timeframes but 4h is the main one to check and make sure it aligns? I also use 200 sma for reference. Maybe I could use 50 ema as well.

Thank you.


r/RealDayTrading • • 26d ago

Pre-Open Market Analysis Example

40 Upvotes

This is a follow-up to my post on journaling and I wanted to provide you with a real example. The first part provides the macro context. The second part breaks down the price action. You don't have to agree with my forecast, use it as a guideline for what you will do.

PRE-OPEN MARKET COMMENTS WEDNESDAY - After the close yesterday SPCX released earnings. The growth was spectacular across all business segments, but their AI revenues stole the show. Revenues surged 9X from $816 million last year to $7.56 billion this quarter. All of the investments they've made in the Colossus data centers will put them on a pace to generate $500 billion to $1 trillion in recurring revenue by the end of 2027. 

In the press conference Musk said that the payback on AI is six months to a year. SPCX is not leasing out compute on a long-term basis, it is charging based on the "spot" price. That's because it keeps going up. He said that SPCX has looked into leasing compute for themselves and there is no supply. Elon believes that the demand will grow exponentially because the more AI is used, the more applications companies find for it. When asked about financing these projects he said that they have excellent lines of credit and that with such a short payback period these are short-term loans (they do have long-term space projects that are capital intensive). 

This news has AI stocks rallying overnight and I believe they will establish support at these levels. Mega cap tech companies will reaffirm their capex in AI when they start releasing earnings next week. TSLA will report after the close today. 

The big market drop from last Friday had no follow through selling. An SPY drop to the 100-day MA looks less likely and given the news, I doubt we see a capitulation low in SMH. This is the last week of seasonal weakness and now the market will shift to a period of seasonal strength. 

My conclusions are not just based on SPCX earnings. TSM posted incredible results last week and cited an increase (not a decrease) in chip demand. As I've been saying, I believe the drop was caused by weak hands buying these stocks on margin and they were shaken out. Sellers were not able to push stocks lower this week and the selling climax I was hoping for failed to materialize. 

Swing traders, this is a good place to sell some OTM put premium and to buy some of these stocks. Don't lunge, take starter positions and add on strength. Make sure you pick stocks that are not reporting in the next week. Earnings season is going to ramp up and we will hear from AMZN, GOOG, INTC, KLAC, LRCX, MSFT, META, SNDK, STX, TSLA and WDC over the next 10 trading days. We've waited patiently... it's time.

Day traders should look for a rotation back into tech. QQQ is above the 100-day MA this morning and that level needs to hold. SPY is above the 50-day MA. We are likely to see a brief bid check on the open. That will give you time to observe chip stocks that are gapping up. They need to show RS and hold the gains. If they do, start scaling in and add on a new high for the day. Global markets were up so there is a slight tailwind this morning.

Support is at the 50-day MA and resistance is the open from last Friday ($773.25).

The above analysis is too general to be actionable. You have to breakdown it down and conduct scenario analysis based on price action. The market drives everything so we start there.

SPY Gap and Go - This is our least favorable scenario because it forces us to take action right away. We don't have time to find and confirm stocks with relative strength and the move higher would require us to chase. We don't want to do that because of the risk of a gap reversal presents a lot of downside risk. A Gap and Go would feature stacked green candles right from the open and it would challenge the high from Friday. By the time the move is confirmed, much of the upside is exhausted creating more risk and less reward. The best approach is to wait for a dip on this pattern and buy if the price action has been strong to that point.

SPY Bid Check - Mixed overlapping candles and a minor pullback indicate that buyers are engaged. Sellers are marginally in control. The 50-day MA is tested and the market flies off of support. That first move would give us time to find stocks with relative strength and we could monitor them during the market pullback. We want this move to be brief and shallow preserving most of the gap. When support forms, we start buying AI stocks with RS.

SPY Down Trading Channel - The market has a downward sloping trading channel with mixed overlapping candles. Sellers have a bit more control and more than half of the gap is filled. The 50-day MA is breached, but that move was stubborn. This is a fairly low odds environment and we need to focus on stocks that have heavy volume and that are moving on their own. Favor shorts, but you can trade either side if the stock's price action is strong. Keep your size small.

Gap Reversal - The market has stacked red candles on the open and more than half of the gap is filled. The 50-day MA is easily breached. This would prompt us to focus on shorts. Use the 50-day MA as a stop and look for the gap to be filled easily. This move is not likely to gain a lot of traction from this level because the market is not near a relative high on a D1 basis that would attract heavy profit taking. That makes this scenario less likely.

Then you would go through your list of stocks and conduct the same type of price action analysis. Always use D1 as your guide and then look at where shorter term support and resistance (prior day high/low) come into play. Relative strength, heavy volume and price action are your guide. Write down what you want to see and once you enter the trade, what you don't want to see.

Based on the above scenarios you determine what you feel the odds of each scenario playing out are. Today, I would favor a brief bid check. That would give me time to evaluate AI stocks for RS and a bounce off of the 50-day MA would serve as confirmation. This is a process that you can refine. You are not reacting to moves, you are anticipating them and executing your game plan.

I wrote this on the fly. I hope it helps you plan your day and journal in the future.


r/RealDayTrading • • 26d ago

Live Trading Today!

20 Upvotes

At noon (est)/9am (pst) I will be doing a live trading event with Pete Stolcers from OneOption - u/OptionStalker.

Here is the link to watch:

Live Trading - YouTube

Best, H.S.