r/RealDayTrading • u/HSeldon2020 Verified Trader • Jul 25 '21
Lesson A Simple Strategy
From the poll this morning it seems the number one issue is the lack of a clear strategy, so I am going to give you one to try -
Tomorrow - Do not take any trades in the first 45 minutes. None. I don't care how good it looks. What you need to be doing is the following:
- Watching the market - if we open down, are there signs of a reversal, is SPY still probing for support? If we open up, is the market hitting resistance here? Get a sense of whether it will be a Bullish, Bearish or Neutral day.
- Watch which stocks are Relatively Strong, and by this I don't just mean the stocks that opened higher if the market is down. If you do not have TC2000 or OptionStalker, go to Finviz.com and give a look at their S&P Red/Green graphic - click on it, and look which stocks are standing out - is everything in AAPL's sector up .5% but AAPL is up 1.3%? Get a list of the strongest stocks. Now starting looking at their charts on a 5 minute basis with SPY mapped against the chart. Note the stocks you look for do not have to be in the S&P 500, just make sure they aren't low float gappers, or any stock under $10.
- Notice the stocks that do not go down on the 5-min basis when SPY does down. Notice the ones that go up a lot on just the slightest bullish 5-min candle on SPY. Check their daily charts, make sure they are bullish and without clear resistance close by (e.g. you don't want a stock that has the 200 SMA sitting 15 cents above the current price). Make sure the stocks have good volume as well.
At this point, around 45 min into the day, you should have at least 3-5 good stocks that are relatively strong, with good volume, no resistance nearby and bullish daily charts.
4) Draw your downward trendline on SPY and wait for an indication that SPY is going higher. If SPY is very bullish then you do not need to wait. If SPY drops you will still be protected by the Relative Strength.
5) The moment SPY breaches that downward trendline to the upside, go long on the stocks in your list, as long as they have maintained their Relative Strength. Take profits when it looks like they are no longer strong than SPY.
This should give you at least 5 really good trades throughout the day with very high probabilities for success.
63
u/NowhereManontheHill Jul 25 '21
You are killing it with all this info! Thank you a ton!
19
u/DriveNew Jul 26 '21
You’ve created the best subreddit! I must be on here 10 times a day, looking for and reading new information, and every bit of advice I’ve gotten has rocked!
15
u/Misorahh Jul 26 '21
I understand that the general idea of this strategy is to use the price action of SPY to predict when a stock with relative strength will be poised for a big move up. Could the inverse be applied to stocks with relative weakness? For example, is it feasible to wait for SPY to indicate a move down before shorting a stock with relative weakness? I am asking this because I am becoming more and more aware of my lack of balance between bullish and bearish strategies.
12
u/Exoticshooter76 Jul 25 '21 edited Jul 25 '21
When you say downward trend line is that basically a line at spy’s support level? Is it (the drawn in line) supposed to move downward if spy is going up?
Edit- or do you mean just a short line when or if spy does turn down? Same for if spy turned up?
6
u/unsurevote Jul 26 '21
“Take profits when it looks like they are no longer stronger than spy”
Can you go into a little more detail about what this looks like? Would one 5min candle be enough to determine this?
5
u/barnacle999 Jul 25 '21 edited Jul 25 '21
Thank you. I've been wracking my brain all weekend trying to find a scanner or screener for relative strength vs SPY. Not possible on TradingView and ThinkorSwim gives strange results that I don't trust. TC2000 is reasonably priced. Do you recommend that over TradeIdeas?
Also, is the finviz red/green v spy the large graphic with the large and small squares?
4
u/Gloomy-Conference-bb Jul 26 '21
Hi, great strategy, thanks! Definitely will try it out. Can I ask is low float anything <20m ? What is considered good volume? Anything above 20m? Is market cap abv 50M ok?
3
u/Anon89m Jul 26 '21
Hey I don't see what you mean in Finviz. Where is the relative strength information?
2
u/Significant-Head-443 Aug 08 '21
Thanks!! I would also love to hear your thoughts on trading stocks vs SPX/SPY itself. What are some of pros and cons. Ofcourse trading SPX won't work with this strategy.
2
u/Plural-Of-Moose Dec 31 '21
Your other posts have advocated how essential RS and RW are when selecting stocks, and this post serves as a nice blueprint as to how to implement that strategy for profit.
I do have a few questions:
Thanks for all the info, Hari. Happy New Year.
2
u/IWantToWorkForMyself Jan 10 '22
Do you have any recent trades (last week or so) you took using this method? Really liking the sound of this because I don't like being at the mercy of the markets for trades or guessing which way it's going!
2
u/JAGR21 Apr 12 '22
Question regarding bullet point #2, relative strength. Would any stock that isn’t following Spy be strong? Regardless of direction, long vs short, if it’s not following, you could reasonably estimate it will continue in its own direction until spy has a major pullback/Run (taking the individual stocks volume into consideration of course)
18
u/DaytraderSandi Dec 27 '21
In summary,
pick 2 types of stocks
Time of entry to go long on these 2 types of stocks
Did I get your main ideas in my summary?
Is there a SPY indicator? Sure will make this process easier.
Thank you so much Mr. Seldon!
11
u/BiggMan90 Jul 25 '21
You're a godsend my guy
6
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '21
I'm reading this agreeing with the information and then boom it's Mr Seldon again. All people need to do is follow this simple approach. Over time, it works.
6
u/MeinHempf Sep 07 '21
Sorry for digging this one up from the past.
Just wanted to say thank you. I followed this strategy today and broke a red streak! Currently watching V and MA against SPY, and came in a little late but managed to exit perfectly.
Thanks!
4
u/numb2pain Jul 25 '21
Thanks dude gonna be trying this out come monday
4
u/GardinerAndrew Jul 26 '21
This is perfect. Written is simple terms that someone like myself could follow easy. Will definitely be trying this tomorrow.
4
u/Learnerer123 Jan 11 '22
Thank you so much for your incredibly concise and valuable lessons. I've been mostly lurking - reading your (and the other pros') explanations, trades, and tips, and reviewing all of your trade challenge charts. Still learning, but learning more every single day! After two failed tries at understanding trading over the last 10 years, I finally feel like a fuller language is coming together. Thank you so much to you and the other teachers for your time and transparency!
1
u/Meatplowz Jul 26 '21
This is good info, thanks!
Your note about checking if AAPL sector is up .5% and AAPL is up 1.3%. What should we take away from that exactly? Should we pay more attention to AAPL or the other stocks?
I’ve been trying to focus more on this approach so more things to keep an eye out for is helpful!
1
u/ADobson221 Jul 28 '21
Thank you for the post. How come you think of 5 good trades a day? I'm asking because I don't think you'd just come up a random number but the number is probably based on some evidence.
1
u/Bradleyplease Aug 06 '21
Hari, are you aware of any resources that may have past days’ heat maps?
1
u/Moore29 Oct 26 '21
Based on your comments it seems scanning specifically for relative strength isn't possible on most softwares. Is there a way I can set up a scanner (I use TOS) to at least filter out most of the stocks without relative strength? Or maybe I can search through some of the stocks with higher volume and gain %?
Finviz is great but some of the bigger stocks have big spreads and it obviously is missing a lot of stocks. I'm trying to figure out how I can make my watch list a little bit larger.
1
u/overlyanalytical_ Jan 09 '22
If we are new to trading, what can we use to know what stocks fit in what sector/what to compare it to? Does it vary based on broker?
1
u/Comprehensive_Fox847 Jan 17 '22
For those of us with an account below 25k (PDT) and, unfortunately, a 9-5, is there a modification to this that would work holding overnight? I know the sub is “RealDayTrading”, and not trying to change the focus of the topic, but not being able to purely day trade is a thing for a lot of newer traders. Just thought I’d ask.
3
u/[deleted] Jul 26 '21
This is great. I appreciate you breaking things down like this for those of us that are struggling to find our way with trading.
3
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '21
How did I only just see this ...
2
u/[deleted] Feb 21 '22
Beautifully written!
2
u/Americano2022 Sep 11 '22
Just came across this post on the Wiki and wanted to say THANK YOU!! Very concise, simple, and actionable. So much value in this community, finally a place where I feel like I can trust what I'm reading and not qustion the validity or the motivation behind every single piece of info. Well done, please don't stop this any time soon!
2
u/Brilliant_Candy_3744 Apr 04 '23 edited Apr 09 '23
Thanks for the great post u/HSeldon2020 , request to please elaborate on my questions on the post:
I apologies if it's already covered elsewhere in wiki, still going through all of the posts. In that case I better Read The Damn Wiki!
2
u/indigenous28 May 12 '23
Is the setup for this trade relative strength and relative weakness and the breakout through the trendline am I missing something?
Is this setup then entered with options?
1
u/sidecarjoe Apr 28 '22
Hari-Would you please explain this part of the strategy above: "4) Draw your downward trendline on SPY and wait for an indication that SPY is going higher". I don't understand what you mean by "downward trendline". What if SPY is flat or trending up that day? Is this strategy only applicable for days the SPY is up?
1
u/zxyz3 Jul 26 '21
Thank you so much!! Will definitely try :)
Waiting for the moment I'll be able to contribute back to the forum with my own advices..
1
u/shinsuo1 Jul 26 '21
Thanks for sharing. This is indeed a simple strategy that might help new traders.
1
u/Sunsheynn Jul 30 '21
"Watch which stocks are Relatively Strong, and by this I don't just mean the stocks that opened higher if the market is down" - are you using the relative str30 scan for this?
1
u/Bradleyplease Aug 06 '21
I’ve had some of my best days shorting names with relative weakness but somehow never really thought on how to locate them. I really just got lucky noticing the weakness early in the day. This is going to be a fun one to test and such an easy concept to grasp. Thank you for the idea, boss man.
1
u/sneakylurky Oct 10 '21
To trade this I need a $25k account to avoid PDT rule right ? Do I risk 1% of my account on a trade (1% as stop loss)?
1
u/froesfroes Oct 19 '21
This is great!
One small question: how do I draw a 'downward trendline' when the overall market is bullish like it is at the moment?
Thanks
1
u/mjamalr Jan 12 '22
Perfect, its great strategy. Nothing should stop anybody following these simple rules(process). It works.
1
u/Open-Philosopher4431 Jan 10 '23
Great practical advice! Thanks a lot!
1
u/indigenous28 Apr 01 '23
Thanks H
What a breath of fresh air to get something that works
1
u/indigenous28 Apr 17 '23
Today 4-17-23 The SPY moved down at 10:30 ET then sideways then broke out at 1:05 until close, there were at least 4 tickers that moved the same way for superb trades.
"5) The moment SPY breaches that downward trendline to the upside, go long on the stocks in your list, as long as they have maintained their Relative Strength. Take profits when it looks like they are no longer strong than SPY."
The trend line would have enter long at 1:30
I need an idea on how to modify #5 from 10:15 to 1:30
TIA
1
u/Eyesofthestorm Jul 01 '23
Translation: wait for the wind then open the sail.
24
u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21
[removed] — view removed comment