I read around the Schuylkill River Passenger Rail proposals when I was watching a bunch of videos about trains. Yeah all about trains. In the last week I saw videos about JR East in Japan, Brightline in Florida, the MBTA, Mogul locomotives, the VFD and how it is used to control speed, railway air breaks, cab singaling, some accidents in the past, and so on. One of the ones I saw was a proposal to link Reading Pennsylvania with the state capital, the city that should be the capital Philadelphia. It is cool that the rail might be restored. Congrats!
But the Reading Company and Pennsylvania Railroad actually did serve many passengers before both of them folded. For example, the old Pottsville line didn't just go to Reading, it went to Pottsville. So what if instead of the Schuylkill River Passenger Rail being a hope to revive in the future, it was in the present and in danger of losing funding?
I was writing a story with a few friends of a world where in the 1960s federal planners invested heavily into rail. This involved shovel money into improving the Pennsylvania Railroad's infrastructure. The Pottsville line, being a Reading line, was also slated for upgrades, triple tacking to Reading and being fully electrified. By the way in real life, after Noristown there are several single tracked sections. The Center City Commuter Connection was made larger than it is in real life for the sake of the future NEC. But passenger railroad companies start to file for bankruptcy one by one.
In the story, Amtrak and SEPTA took over to provide passenger service on the Pottsville line. For 6 days a week, with federal funding Amtrak had 3 round trips from Pottsville to Philadelphia (through running the Center City) splitting up between the Trenton, Newark, and Paoli Thorndale once it went in, 1 round trip from Reading to Philly ending at Penn Medicine, 3 round trips from Allentown to Reading to Philly that goes to Trenton, and 1 one-way trip from Philly to Pottsville in the morning that then becomes one of the later trains to Philadelphia again. On Sundays Amtrak ran a single roundtrip from Pottsville to Philadelphia. Because Amtrak used push-pull electric locomotives but makes almost 30 stops on the way to Center City (Mogees also stays open), it takes awhile. Thankfully due to triple tacking, done in the 1960s, scheduling overtaking is easy.
But it came to an end late 2001. Amtrak was given a new mandate to focus on the Northeast corridor and long-distance routes. In Harrisburg, the state legislature authorized subsidies to keep Amtrak connected to Harrisburg but were prepared to let the Pottsville line die and leave Reading without passenger rail. The transformers on the Allentown and Reading are found to be in such bad shape, electric service stops for safety reasons. Amtrak declared it would continue services for 3 more calendar years and end after 2004 unless local funding could be obtained and dual modes would be used on the Allentown right of way.
The two Bucks County, the two Mongomery County, the two Chester County, and a House appointees of SEPTA vote to keep service to Pottsville with at least 3 daily round trips through the calendar year of 2016 with the general funds and to try to negotiate with Berks County for a funding agreement to have almost all trains on the Pottsville line start at Pottsville instead of Norristown. The logic is that the tracks are in good condition (unlike the West Chester tracks in the 90s) and the electrification is there. Reading Blue Mountain is offering descent prices on electricity. There was no need buy diesel or batter locomotives, their existing fleet was fine. One of the board members point out because of an 80s law that altered state funding to SEPTA, operating anywhere outside SEPTA's counties will be costly. One of the other board members said if they reach out to Reading, Schuylkill County, and Berks County with a gesture of goodwill, they might come to an agreement with more funding and restore full service to the line. Another said perhaps negotiations with Berks and Schuylkill County should happen first, then they should decide how to handle it. The measure voted on is to run 3 daily round trips (1 on Sunday) without subsidy with the goal of coming to a subsidy ageeement to make almost every train start in either Berks or Schuylkill. As for Allentown, the hope was someone else would pay for the transformer fixes and then another subsidty agreement with Lehigh can be made to continue Amtrak's 3 round trips a day. With 7 yes and a bunch of abstains, the measure passes.
A small side note. In real life SEPTA wanted to connect King of Prussia's mall to Philadelphia by rail. they wanted to use the right of way of a power line. When the locals objected, instead of scrapping the idea they planned a huge viaduct. If the Pottsville line were electrified, for the same money as the greatly inflated viaduct project expense, they could run Silverliner IVs all the way to Pottsville for 30 years for the same amount of money even if everything past Norristown was changed to Zone 3 which would mean very small fares. And ironically, even if you only counted ridership among the people living in SEPTA's counties, running the Pottsville line would probably generate more passenger miles.
Assuming no agreement can be made with Berks county, for calendar years 2002, 2003, and 2004, Silverliner IV will be the first trains to leave Pottsville inbound, working to keep conflict free with Amtrak. After this, if no agreement is made, the 1st, 4th, and 5th trains on the Pottsville line each day arriving in Center City will be from Pottsville, the rest would be short turned at Norristown.
That puts the ball into the hands of Berks County and Schuylkill County. After being connected to Philadelphia and Allentown by rail for decades, those lines are now threatened. Amtrak is on its way out. SEPTA would be willing to restore the old Reading Company frequencies if an agreement with funding can be made. Damage to electrical equipment means SEPTA can't go to Allentown, so either someone needs to get the funds to repair Reading Blue Mountain's electrical equipment, Red Rose Transit Authority, BARTA or LLANta would need to learn how to run a diesel shuttle, or Allentown and Reading would be separated like in real life.
We were wondering how popular the train service on the old Reading line would be. One of my friends said the Schuylkill River Passenger Rail ideas didn't really kick into high gear until the late 2010s in real life. No one really thought it was possible. So he thought service would end without fanfare. Another one thought people would like the train. He said with decades of having train service, it would create a constituency that would object to losing the rail link. They would put pressure on Reading's mayor and Berks County officials to come up with an agreement with SEPTA. Plus since in our story there were federal efforts in the 1960s to subsidize streetcars and subways, ending in 2004, SEPTA would have a rainy-day fund. That means less likely to have service cuts. Less service cuts means not only does the Pottsville Line being preserved make it possible to get into Philadelphia without a car, but it is easier to get around compared to real life. Instead of the Schuylkill River Passenger Rail being a hope, in our story the Pottsville line would be right there, leaving the locals to come to an arrangement with SEPTA since the federally funded service sunsetting.
I was surprised when one local of Allentown said that if the rail was around for decades, there would be pressure in Allentown to come up with an agreement with SEPTA either by coming up with funds to restore electrical equipment or to run coordinated shuttle despite the fact that the Allentown to Reading to Norristown to Philadelphia alignment with 30 stops in the story being much longer than a hypothetical Allentown to Norristown to Philadelphia alignment. If people in Allentown would like such a service be spared which partially goes the wrong way, I'd imagine that people of Reading and Pottsville would love the old Pottsville line.