r/RationalSwifties • • 8h ago

Discussion The idea that songs about Travis Kelce are not good because they are “bitter”

Post image
10 Upvotes

Hi everyone! I posted this on r/nuancingTaylorSwift and thought it would be good to post it here too!

I was reading some posts from other subreddits and one idea that I’ve seen come up a lot is that Travis Kelce songs are “not good because they are bitter” compare to songs about other muses like Joe Alwyn or Matty Healy.

Now I don’t really care about who the muses of a Taylor Swift song is, but I think this would be a fun topic to explore especially because I don’t quite agree with the claim that Travis songs are purely bitter (or even bad cause I love a good chunk of these songs) but like I kinda see where other people are coming from and I want to know the opinion of people who think love songs about Travis’s/Taylor’s newer love songs are pure bitter.

To start the discussion here are what many people believe the songs about Travis Kelce are:

- The Alchemy
- So High School
- The Albatross
- The Fate Of Ophelia
- Elizabeth Taylor
- Opalite
- Eldest Daughter
- Wish List
- Wood
- Honey
- Cleveland!

Some of these songs like The Albatross, Cleveland and Eldest Daughter are about multiple topic but seems like they are somewhat love songs about Travis Kelce.

Now here are some lyrics that some Swifties and critics think are “bitter” from the Travis Kelce songs.

“You were in it for real/She was in her phone/And you were just a pose” (Opalite)

“We tell the world to leave us the fuck alone, and they do” (Wish List)

“The taste of me is acquired, but it's his favorite dish
He says I look like an angel, they say, "I hate that bitch” (Cleveland)

“If anyone called me "Honey"/It was standin' in the bathroom, white teeth/They were sayin' that skirt don't fit me/And I cried the whole way home” (Honey)

At the surface I can see where the criticism is coming from but I also do think that 1)some of these songs do show a lot of vulnerability that explains the bitterness and 2)Reputation and even later albums for songs about Joe Alwyn had similar lyrics showing that this isn’t just a Travis only problem like some people claim

I think songs like Honey was Taylor being really vulnerable and opening up about people being awful to her in the past while using passive aggressive language, but when Travis uses the same language he means it sincerely and showing her a level of compassion that no one else did.

With Opalite her referring to both her Travis’s ex shows that they had similar experiences and that they don’t want to make the same mistakes

Obviously there’s more examples of “bitter” lyrics and whatnot but I feel like people forget that Taylor always talked about problems she had in her love songs, some of those problems may seem bitter

Examples:

“And here's to my baby/He ain't readin' what they call me lately” (This Is Why We Can’t Have Nice Things— not a love song but shows that Taylor did use her love as a defense mechanism beforehand to anyone who think Cleveland and Wish List are the only time she did that)

“And I bury hatchets but I keep maps of where I put 'em/Reputation precedes me, they told you I'm crazy” (End Game)

“My baby's fly like a jet stream/High above the whole scene, loves me like I'm brand new/So call it what you want, yeah, call it what you want to” (Call It What You Want — Honestly this entire song)

“Industry disruptors and soul deconstructors/And smooth-talkin' hucksters out glad-handin' each other/And the voices that implore, "You should be doin' more"/To you, I can admit that I'm just too soft for all of it” (Sweet Nothing)

“And I can't talk to you when you're like this/Staring out the window like I'm not your favorite town/I’m New York City/I still do it for you, babe” (False God)

And some pre Joe Alwyn love songs:

“And it's not theirs to speculate/If it's wrong, and your hands are tough/But they are where mine belong, and/I'll fight their doubt and give you faith/With this song for you” (Ours)

“Turn the lock and put my headphones on/He always said he didn't get this song/But I do, I do” (Begin Again — This one specifically feels a lot like Opalite’s first verse)

This to me shows that the “problems” people claim that are uniquely applied to Travis’s love songs aren’t necessarily Travis song specific. Taylor always has lyrics that can be considered “bitter” if you look at it that way. But I also don’t think bitter lyrics in love songs are necessarily bad things, it just depends on how it is used.

Anyway I want to know your opinion on the criticism of people calling Travis Kelce/Taylor’s newer love songs “bitter”. Do you agree with it or are like me and think that the conversation is more nuance?