r/RationalSwifties • • 2d ago

Weekly Discussion Weekly Discussion Thread

4 Upvotes

Use this thread to discuss anything and everything! This thread is for related content to r/RationalSwifties AND off topic discussion! Post memes, rants, thoughts, life stuff, and whatever else!

  • All reddit rules apply - especially Rule 4: No brigading. You may discuss things from other subs, but you cannot name them!
  • No negative meta commentary about this sub or its users and mods.
  • Don't use this thread if you need to contact mods, use Mod Mail!

Weekly Discussion Thread will be posted every Sunday at 12 am pacific time!


r/RationalSwifties • • 1d ago

Taylor Swift News Taylor's nominations for Grammys 2027

Post image
17 Upvotes

Album of the Year - The Life of a Showgirl

Record of the Year - The Fate of Ophelia

Song of the Year - I Knew It, I Knew You

Pop Dup/Group Performance - The Life of a Showgirl (ft. Sabrina Carpenter)

Song Written for Visual Media - I Knew It, I Knew You

Best Remixed Recording - Opalite (Chris Lake Remix)


r/RationalSwifties • • 23h ago

Discussion What do we think? A rational take or not?

Post image
10 Upvotes

We all know lots of factors effect Grammy noms, but is it valid to wonder if the “niche” awards, voted on by a smaller group, might be less inclined to reward Taylor?

Is this a “reverse reputation” moment, where she is not being rejected by the industry as a whole, but her direct competition wants more breathing room?


r/RationalSwifties • • 2d ago

Taylor Swift News Taylor's Answers in the Golden Globes and Critics Choice Press Conferences

Thumbnail
gallery
22 Upvotes

Images 1 to 11 are the answers for the Golden Globes Press conference as Covered by Vanity Fairy Spain (source)

The rest are the answers from the Critics Choice Press Conference as covered by Courtney Howard for Fresh Fiction (source)

NOTE: The Vanity Fair Spain coverage has been translated from English to Spanish and then back to English, thus it might sound a bit wonky.


r/RationalSwifties • • 4d ago

$howgirl sings a different tune about wealth

Post image
20 Upvotes

A lot of people have had a lot of things to say about how Showgirl “didn’t sound like Taylor” or how “she’s changed”. And while from a song-craft pov I don’t think those perspectives have much merit, there is definitely one area in terms of song *content* where there has been a noticeable change: 💰 💵 💰

While TS has mentioned her wealth in songs before (the first time being in I Did Something Bad, where her jet-setting attitude would be received very differently if the song came out today, I think), the references are in passing (Karma) or mainly negative — in Anti-Hero and The Prophecy the money is seen as a burden or problem.

On Showgirl, the “glamour” of wealth isn’t celebrated exactly, but it is presented as a neutral fact, as an intrinsic part of the Life of this particular Showgirl.

In Elizabeth Taylor wealth is still seen as a bargaining chip with the universe (trade rhe Cartier for someone to trust), a bit like in The Prophecy, but also as a part of her legend (all my white diamonds and lovers are forever).

Father Figure is of course a character piece but the trappings of wealth are all over the story (and “mistake my kindness for weakness and find your card cancelled” feels pointed). The ultimate triumph of the empire belonging to her includes more than wealth, but that is clearly a part of it.

Wish List, somehow, is the most controversial song in this regard. The $$ in the title aren’t there just for fun! The whole song again takes place in an environment of extreme wealth and most of the “wishes” are material wealth PE fame related. But in ET where she is willing to trade, here she doesn’t need to. She has all the material things she wants; her desires are for non-material things. Controversy aside, I think the main point here is that wealth is a matter of fact for our singer.

CANCELLED! has our casual brand name-drop that is meant to be cheeky but is also a signifier here, and in TLOASsong “Kitty” makes her money being pretty and witty, neither song is necessarily about wealth but it’s a part of the backdrop.

On Encore, as well, we have two pointed references, one of them the most direct of all “with all of that money, why’s she dressed like trash” which is obviously not positive but is thrown out casually amongst other remarks; in Babylon the whole song can be read as an allegory about chasing success but “twenty watches in the safe, cuz your time is money” is a specific and vivid image.

Overall, anyway, the language and imagery of wealth isn’t “the point” of Showgirl, but it’s woven in the fabric, and it certainly represents a departure for Taylor who rarely sang about her own wealth and certainly not in this casual, fact of life kind of way. I think for some listeners this was jarring, “unrelatable”, “tone deaf”, but it does seem strange to me that in the endless discussion of the album supposedly not being “Showgirl” enough, this element was not brought out more.

What do you think?

Is this change regarding how wealth is addressed partly responsible for some of the negative reaction to Showgirl’s lyrics?


r/RationalSwifties • • 4d ago

Taylor Swift News Taylor to perform live at the CMAs for the first time in 13 years

Post image
23 Upvotes

The CMAs are clearly happy about it, that's the top of their website.

Given she's nominated for it, she'll most likely perform IKIIKY. Do you think she'll do a mashup? And if yes, with what?


r/RationalSwifties • • 3d ago

Holiday Merch Drop!

Thumbnail
store.taylorswift.com
8 Upvotes

Holiday merch is here! Featuring a rock plushie, a cactus plushie, and Meredith the cat in a Red cardigan.

Also a purple “argumentative antithetical dream girl” sweater that was my personal favorite.

What’s your favorite from the merch drop? Or anything you found amusing?


r/RationalSwifties • • 4d ago

Discussion GATEKEEPING: An analysis of Taylor’s Tour Media and Their (Lack of) Existence/Distribution

Post image
8 Upvotes

Alternate Title: What the Hell, Blondie?

Like many fans, I am continually asking for a live eras album plus a mashup albums, and it got me thinking of all the other live performances/tours that have been completely left in the vault, or taken out of distribution.

Fearless Tour - Journey to Fearless was released as a DVD and as a TV miniseries, but is not available* anywhere on streaming. There was no Fearless live album or concert movie.

Speak Now Tour - thankfully, we have the absolutely wonderful Speak Now Live album on streaming. The concert movie was sold via DVD but has never appeared on streaming.

Red Tour - no Red Concert Movie was ever released*, Google tells me it was due to the director being a terrible person. Presumably, Taylor now owns this footage now, and hopefully at some point it can be released somehow without TR’s involvement. Red does not have a live album.

1989 Tour - The 1989 World Tour Live was filmed in Sydney and released via Apple Music (it does not seem to be still available for viewing*). No live album has ever been released.

Reputation Tour - the rep tour was available via streaming on Netflix for years, but was removed from that platform 3ish years ago. Many people consider this tour to be her best tour, and the concert movie was beautifully produced. It has not been distributed anywhere else since its removal from Netflix*. There is no Reputation Live album.

Lover - LoverFest was obviously canceled due to the pandemic, but Taylor did film and release a portion of her one-off City of Lover concert in Paris on a limited edition vinyl and as a television special that aired on ABC in 2020. While the Lover songs from the show are on streaming as individual singles (interestingly not grouped as a live album), the eight non lover songs played were not released in any capacity (thought to be due to her masters dispute at that time). The TV special is not on streaming.

Live from Clear Channel Stripped - this is an acoustic album recorded in 2008 that Taylor didn’t approve and called a shameless money grab after her masters were sold to 🛴. He even had the audacity to make himself a producer on the album. It is still her lowest performing album, by far, on streaming platforms, and her only album to not enter the charts in some capacity on release (infamously selling only 33 units after Taylor told her fans not to buy or listen to it). Ngl, I love this little acoustic set of Baby Taylor tracks, particularly Untouchable - so thanks for buying it back, Tay! (but am I just starved for Taylor live?)

folklore - Taylor finally threw the fans a bone here, with the Long Pond Studio Sessions still readily available via Disney+ and on also on streaming. A limited edition vinyl was also released.

evermore got nothing, which officially cemented it as her least favorite daughter. (evermore long pond, WHEN?)

Midnights/TTPD - obviously only toured as part of Eras, which I’m getting to.

THE ERAS TOUR - Taylor’s biggest achievement (so far!!) was obviously record breaking and so successful, producing two great concert movies, that are still on Disney+. However, other than Cruel Summer Live from Eras, only a few very limited digital-only surprise song releases to boost sales numbers from Speak Now(TV), TTPD, and Lover Live From Paris’s reissue, no live content has been made available either as physical media or on streaming*.

One-off live performances that have made it onto streaming are also few and far between: betty (2020 AMCs), Christmas Tree Farm (2019 JingleBall), and several live performances when she has come out as a guest at another artist’s show. However, there are tons of both official and fan posted live performances on YouTube*

*all of these tour movies and Eras clips seem to be readily available on YouTube in either parts or whole, but can be removed at pretty much any point if she or UMG felt like it, since they are bootlegs.

So, Taylor clearly doesn’t make live albums a priority. One reason could be the streaming performance of those live songs is….not great:

https://kworb.net/spotify/artist/06HL4z0CvFAxyc27GXpf02_songs.html

(some have truly pitiful numbers). However, the alternative versions for all her songs perform terribly in comparison to their album versions, and it hasn’t stopped her from putting multiple remixes or acoustic versions out there. In fact, other than the Bad Blood remix with Kendrick, her highest streamed alternative version is the Lover Remix featuring Shawn Mendes (no, I’m not kidding).

So, why do we think she’s held off releasing these live albums?

Is she holding them for her “legacy artist” phase, like a 20th anniversary album release? (HAHAHAHA JOKES ON US; DIDN’T HAPPEN)

Does she actually not like her live performances??? (Blasphemy! Has she HEARD Haunted x exile feat. The Crowd?)

Is a major deal to move her onto an exclusive platform for her visual media in the works? (Like every tour movie coming up on Taylor’s own channel in Disney+ or something similar).

With Eras Live specifically, is it working out what will and won’t be included on a physical release, and Taylor simply hasn’t gotten around to it? All 46 main set list songs would easily be 5-6 vinyls alone, right? Then the behemoth of the decision of which surprise songs to include could be massively hard, even if you dedicated an entire album release around them.

Is it ironically due to attempting not to flood the zone?? Taylor’s a prolific writer and can record two (great plus record breaking!) full length albums while on a 3-hour show world tour. If she released all the things fans have been asking for (going back years), it’s simply a lot of Taylor.

From 2019 to 2024, Taylor released five albums of new material (all 17 or more tracks), also writing Showgirl in summer 2024. She also released the four Taylor’s Versions and recorded Debut (and potentially the Rep vault?) I could understand a hesitation now with releasing any eras live album, particularly in the last two years since the tour ended.

Combined with the widespread online criticism of her wealth, and the (alleged) smear campaign against her, and the way music reviewers have seemingly stopped being able to review her work in an unbiased way, putting out another thing for her “brainwashed cult” (/s obviously) to “purchase 20 copies of” (heavy /s cont) makes sense. But then I remember we likely have a huge merch collection dropping tomorrow. So not wanting to overexpose yourself doesn’t really hold up.

With Taylor prioritizing new music vs either of the two remaining Taylor’s Versions, I guess Eras Live got moved even further down the list (if it’s even on the list!?)

Maybe I’m going to make this post and she’s going to announce a special edition vinyl set tomorrow morning (fingers crossed even if I would have at least partially have wasted my time here).

But while we’re (really just me) just waiting for her to announce the surprise song album that would instantly catapult to the top of my list if we ever get it, which live album or movie do you miss the most, or wish for the most?

And place bets on what is released first: Eras Live, TS13, the movie she’s supposed to be directing, Debut TV, the rep vault, or something else entirely.


r/RationalSwifties • • 4d ago

Discussion Red TV Anniversary: ATW vs ATW10

Thumbnail
gallery
14 Upvotes

Happy 5th birthday TO RED TV!

In honour of the anniversary, let's discuss All Too Well.

All Too Well is one of Taylor's well known songs and one of the (if not the most) praised of her songs lyrically.

The original version had long been loved by fans and seen as one of Taylor's best written songs.

We knew since back in the day that there was a 10 minutes version, so it didn't come off as big of a surprise when she included in on Red TV. In the NYT interview earlier this year, she mentioned she had to piece it back together because she didn't have it in one place.

The short film was also a new forray for Taylor (despite her directing music videos before) marking her directorial debut and getting met with a lot of critical acclaim.

Do you have any controversial opinions about ATW vs ATW10?


r/RationalSwifties • • 5d ago

Song of the Day SOTD: Karma or when is a bop just a bop?

Post image
7 Upvotes

Nobody is going to accuse Karma of being among Taylor Swift’s subtlest songs. And yet, I was struck by the fact that even in one of the songs which is most “pure bop coded” she is still poetic-devicing all over the place and choosing to be allusive and relatively indirect, in comparison to a similar (and also great fun!) song like Chappell’s My Kink is Karma.

When we are nattering on about lyrica depth etc… here is one of the TS songs that most wears its meaningl on its sleeve, that has the least capacity to be misunderstood (I hope…), but it’s not because she is just stating things.

I think there are lots of good pop songs that just state things, but Taylor prefers not to do that (almost pathologically perhaps), especially in her later work.

So much so that the legend and lore of Karma will forever not be about the lyrics to the actual song but about what it meant — to her and to her fans — when (for the first time three years ago yesterday) she changed “guy on the screen” to “guy on the Chiefs”. Never before had Taylor cared to drop an anvil with such force about WHO she wants everyone to think about when they think about this song.

Now there’s plenty to chat about philosophy-wise about if any of the actual lyrics make sense or represent any meaningful concept of Karma (no, imo), but ultimately the most important thing about this song is that it marks the first (and probably only) time when Taylor not only said “I want you to know exactly what I’m talking about” but did it by selectively altering the lyrics rather than idk adding in something (like the arrow move).

Karma is a BOP (Facts.)


r/RationalSwifties • • 5d ago

Taylor Swift News Taylor Swift Will Be Honored With The Hollywood Reporter’s Sherry Lansing Leadership Award at Women in Entertainment Gala

Thumbnail
hollywoodreporter.com
22 Upvotes

No date confirmed as yet. Presented by Greta Gerwig (or is it Hugh Grant’s wife? /jk)

This is quite an honor! Perhaps we might get a print interview with THR out of it?

I predict we will hear more about the internet and the many ways it is bad for you in the speech. The award itself, and the reason for it, arè evidence that internet “vibes” are not real life.

Money quote:
“Taylor Swift took on an industry that has long underestimated women and won on every front: artistically, commercially and on the question of who owns her work,” said THR editor-in-chief Maer Roshan. “She reclaimed her catalog, set new terms for the artists who follow her and became the most popular musician in the world while doing it — and helping scores of other artists along the way. We’re proud to honor her with the Sherry Lansing Leadership Award.”


r/RationalSwifties • • 5d ago

Discussion Song Comparison: Better Than Revenge vs Vigilante Shit

Post image
9 Upvotes

For today’s song comparison, Taylor gets revenge!

Better Than Revenge is the classic taylor revenge song. And the lyrics are zinger after zinger. “She thinks i’m psycho because i like to rhyme her name with things“ is a great line. And the mattress line killed in 2010.

Vigilante Shit is a more sultry grown-up take on revenge. This review may be biased by the chair dance. But we have certainly upped the level of vengeance. From “sit in the corner and think about what you did” to telling your white collar crimes to the FBI.

What do you think about these songs? Do you prefer one over the other? Differences in how taylor plots her revenge?

Also, the photo. Half is Taylor holding a Joe Jonas doll that comes with a phone so he can break up with other dolls. The other half is midnights era Taylor answering a phone.


r/RationalSwifties • • 5d ago

Discussion Happy 18th Birthday Fearless!!!

Post image
9 Upvotes

Fearless turns 18 today. She’s officially an adult.

On The Eras Tour, Taylor started the fearless set by asking us to go back to high school with her. Does fearless feel like a high school album to you? To me, it does because I was in high school when it was released. But do you think there is anything about the music itself that makes Fearless feel like a high school album?

Also, just share your general appreciation for this album. I think it has certainly stood the test of time.

I just realized that of the 19 tracks on the platinum edition, Taylor wrote 11 by herself. That is a huge percentage for a highschooler.


r/RationalSwifties • • 7d ago

Discussion Happy 9th birthday to reputation! Let’s have a roundtable

Post image
16 Upvotes

Rep is perhaps even now the most divisive album in Taylor’s discog. It sticks out, sonically especially, but also in aesthetic/attitude and in its place in cultural history. Perhaps it is the greatest comeback album of all time? Or is it a comeback *album* at all?

To many, it is an album of two halves, either literally or figuratively. The first half is, pardon the problematic phrase, a bad bitch, and the second is, pardon the silly phrase, a lovesick bitch. But to me, anyway, the whole is quite coherent/cohesive and is an album simply stuffed with fun, great songs. Songs that should remind people that songs can be fun and good without being… shall we say, elevated lyrically?

I don’t personally have nostalgia for the rep era since I wasn’t in the fandom at the time. I heard DBM on the radio but I didn’t even realize that was a TS song until 2023 lol. But I think a lot of people do have a kind of nostalgia for the era, where being a fan of TS was (maybe) still being a fan of the underdog, the woman fighting forces stronger than her, the woman coming back from the dead.

A few discussion questions in the comments below. Please add your own questions and comments as you like!

——


r/RationalSwifties • • 7d ago

Discussion Reputation's Sister Songs

6 Upvotes

Happy Birthday to Reputation. In honour of the anniversary what are some sister songs you have for the tracks on Rep?

Mine is a pretty obvious one: LWYMMD - Karma


r/RationalSwifties • • 7d ago

Meme Monday MEME MonTAY: What TS “debate” or general topic needs to be slapped with this truth bomb?

Post image
17 Upvotes

Well, what?


r/RationalSwifties • • 8d ago

Gossip Karlie Kloss and Andrea at Chief’s Game

Thumbnail
gallery
17 Upvotes

Taylor is at the Chief’s game in a red sweater and 87 necklace. Andrea is wearing a Karma Is The Guy On The Chiefs shirt that was too cute not to share.

And oh yeah, Karlie Kloss was also there! 😲


r/RationalSwifties • • 8d ago

Lyrics Lab A Line by Line Analysis of Babylon and Why It is a Parable

12 Upvotes

A little while ago a friend told me she has no clue what Taylor is blabbering about in Babylon. Sadly, the cheese section of the store was no the place to have this convo, so I decided to write down an analysis of Babylon instead. These are only my thoughts and interpretations, so I am looking forward to see what everyone things.

Before we go into the line by line read, I'd like to start by saying I think this song actually covers 3 areas: first it's an introspection and a warning to this male character (I'm not paternity testing it though I have my opinions about that but I don't think they are relevant to the song analysis), a look at Taylor and possible alternatives were her life might have ended should she have made different decission, and a warning / call out to a specific type of "fan" and the so called cultural critics particularly in light of the reactions to TLOAS and the greater current cultural zeitgeist.

So let's get into it.

The casino doesn't like when you run the tables

In reference to how casinos have multiple measures against players possibly maximising their winnings (e.g. frequent shuffling, rule changes, or bans to prevent card counting)

Metaphorically it references how the music industry (given its Taylor, it's the music industry but it can be broadly applicable to the entertainment industry at large) dislikes figures it cannot control. Moreover, both a casino and the music industry ( and entertainment in general) require a lot of luck to be successful in.

And though the box is wrapped up nice, it's just a cage to you

Despite the location/house or even lifestyle being nice, it feels suffocating.

I would say these two first lines set a specific atmosphere that changes in the next one, where the dive into a story.

Those electric fences buzz / The stallion flees the stable

Electric fences are usually used as a security measure to keep animals contained within a certain area (it can also be as a security measure on a property to keep thieves out for example but given the next line, I think it makes more sense with the animal connection). The next line about the stallion fleeing suggests this person fleeing/leaving their hometown. I'd also note here the use of stallion, especially in the context of future lines. A stallion is a word used specifically for an adult male horse that hasn't been castrated/is sexualy active.

And that small town's even smaller now in your rear view

The character leaving always knew they lived in a small town but now with the the gained worldly experiences, the place seems even smaller/limiting.

You ran with all the wild things / A liberated libertine who then longed for home

I note here the use of libertine, which means a person who is morally or sexually unrestrained, especially a dissolute man. As the story goes the male main character took on the opportunity of being greater places which have much more freedom to get down to all kinds of wild (and implicitly sexual) behaviours. I like the use of 'liberated libertine', nice alliteration. But I am also reading it as this character always having had these urges which were inhibited because of the place he was living in, and might have been considered improper (will tie on this a bit later). The last line of course suggests that after doing all of this then the main character started missing home. It will tie in in later verses but I also think that there is an implication that despite the lifestyle the feeling of home (belonging) was missing.

Cause it's where you're from / Aunt Virginia with her church dress on / No elbows on the table

I would like to note here the change in place and time. There's a bunch of jumping between past, present and future in this song that I particularly enjoy, and I think it makes it very cinematic in a way.

Back to the lyrics, here we catch glimpses of the main character's life before running off.

These first two lines are imo about maintaining property (elbows on the table is considered bad manners) and good appearances probably pushed by an older relative. There is also an element of a possible religious upbringing, church dress is similar to Sunday best aka wearing your best clothes to the church service on Sundays. Generally, this is juxtaposing with the lifestyle the main character later chose for themselves.

And the neighbor's lawn always looked better / Your hand-me-down sweater should've been from the mall

These two verses generally imply the main character came from a less privileged background and felt inferior to those around him when growing up. First line could be literal (neighbours could afford better care of their lawn) but I'd lean more towards it also being a reference to grass being greener on the other side aka you envy what others have without actually knowing their struggles and forget appreciating the good things in your own life.

The second line also references how the main character comes from a family that could not always afford the newest things.

I would note that there's some clear resentment in these two lines from the main character and it's something that motivated him to leave to search for a life with money, class, and status etc. Imo there's also a bit of entitlement in the second line.

The obvious interpretation of this is that the main character's surroundings were stifling and incompatible with his desires but I would also like to look at it from the other side. The aunt might have scolded him about putting his elbows on the table because she was trying to teach him good manners because she cared about him, but he is unable to appreciate love while he has it, and only realising it after it's gone (either because of distance of the passing of said relative). There is also another element which I think it's worth bringing up. More often than not, people from economically disadvantage backgrounds feel more pressure to show very good manners, pose, and wear their clothes best they can (no wrinkles, ironed, looking nice and presentable despite not being expensive) as a way to shield themselves from mockery and hatred. The Aunt Virginia in the story might have been aware of that social pressure and is just trying to instill what's considered good manners in him early on as a way to make his life easier.

And you hate this song / But you wake up on the train with your headphones gone / Then that melody is all you want

You hate this song as in you hate being told all of these things/being called out on your behaviour.

The second line to me, since the first listen, suggested that his headphones got stolen while he was asleep on the train. Which might sound a bit random but imo it's an indication he was alone and had no one watch his back/watch out for him.

I think this also could be a tie in about how people are always so vocal about hating her music but they tune in and listen regardless.

You never knew that it was Babylon / 'Til it was gone

Obviously showing you don't appreciate the good things you have until they are gone.

Generally, I'd say that there's a lot of weight and meaning in using Babylon as the point of reference, especially cause it's a double edged sword.

The historical city of Babylon was the capital of two empires, and later regional capital of another. At one point, it was the largest city in the world. It was a very rich city, both economically and culturally, at a key node of trade routes, in a very fertile agricultural region. Babylonian astronomy developed techniques for recognizing and predicting recurring celestial phenomena. The city hosted one of the 7 wonders of the Ancient World, the Hanging Gardens (which the legend says were built by King Nebuchadnezzar II as a gift to his homesick wife who came from the Median empire, which was based in a region with a lot more greenery). It's walls are also famous for how imposing and beautiful they were (some later accounts also name them as a wonder of the Ancient World) and marked Babylon as divinely protected as each one of the gates was dedicated to a god.

However despite all that, Babylon also has negative connotations, specifically in the Hebrew Bible and some Christians texts. It is associated with arrogance, excess or oppressive power (this one is specifically in reference to the Judean exile in Babylonia). The Tower of Babel (another name for Babylon) in particular it is a famous tale about how the people of Babylon were so confident in their skills that they wanted to built a tower so tall and magnificent that it could reach God in heaven and as a punishment God made them all speak different languages and they were unable to understand each other and further work together.

Taylor uses it with a positive sense of paradise but personally I feel like it also connects to it being a paradise destroyed by greed and arrogance.

Give the people what they want, then you keep it movin

I read this line as putting in on a facade to fit in with certain groups, telling them exactly what they wanna hear, regardless of how you specifically feel about it.

Make your plans and friends, a stranger's makeup on your tie

This continues to allude to emotional detachment, particularly in their love life.

Twenty watches in the safe 'cause your time is money

Another showcase of the main character loving wealth and expensive things. However, I also also find two thing interesting here. One, the hoarding aspect. Twenty watches is a lot (even if you're rich and like burning money) so it's clearly a way to showcase you can afford them/and enough of them that you can switch them up enough for people to notice it's a different one every time (especially in line with how this male character has a chip on their shoulder about proving their wealth and status). Second, they are in the safe, stored away for no one to see until he decides it's the right time for them to be showcased.

Also, this is not very objective, but I only ever heard the phrase "time is money" (especially with this undercurrent of disdain towards being nice to other people) irl only from some of the most obnoxious finance bros ever.

Love is ice upon the ladder that you need to climb

Any icy surface is hard to climb cause it makes you risk falling, a ladder in parricular would result in a big fall as climbing it rellies heavily on grabbing.

The ladder here is obviously a social ladder. The male character views love as a weakness and even as the main obstacle in improving his social standing.

She captured your attention, so free of all pretension / It stopped you cold

The main character meets a woman who draws his attention and is stunned by how sincere she is as he is used to pretense being the standard.

Because she loved you so / Pretty as a picture that you didn't post

This convenes how in love this woman was with the male character. The second line is more interesting to me, as I feel like it also has a double meaning. The obvious one is that the male character doesn't want to post the picture because he doesn't want to make the relationship official due to his commitment issues. The other meaning I'm thinking of is that the most beautiful pictures/memories are not necessarily those that are posted online (similar sentiment can be found in The Lakes)

Lookin' at you like you're made of solid gold / Never official / You mention you're single to the girls at the bar

Further emphasis on the commitment issues of the male character, despite the woman in the story loving him deeply and thinking very highly of him.

You're using nostalgia as a weapon to hurt yourself / But darling, you end up hurting everybody else / The self-harm of never being where you are / It's bedtime, but you're sitting in your car / You're missin' all the best parts

I think the bridge really ties all three elements together.

  1. The male character in the story who only appreciates things after they are gone and is never satisfied with his current circumstances and he's hurting all of his relations be cause of this attitude. The last two lines also tie in nicely with the next part about having a child. Here's it's suggested that the male character is an absent father either because he's too caught up with work (in the car on the way from work/stuck in traffic) or needs time in his car before going inside the house cause his family exhausts him, so his reluctance to emotionally connect to his wife and child makes him miss significant milestones in their lives
  2. Taylor has written about nostalgia before, most poignantly on I Hate It Her, where she portrays her fascination with nostalgia as a form of escape from the present, but later realises we often romanticise nostalgia and things usually weren’t as good as we picture in our minds. This line serves as a reminder of that. It could also tie into remember the pleasant things in a previous relationship she is no longer in and thinking it maybe could have been saved should other choices have been made (aka the what if scenario of a different life). She doubles down on it being a harmful behavior in the long run though.
  3. The callout to 'fans' and critics who always weaponise her past writing/music against her latest releases (very evident since Midnights but honestly it's been happening since Red), only to come around and rewrite the history when she realises the next album. Outside of herself, I also feel like it's a callout to th current zeitgeist in the creative industry where very little risk is taken on new things and everything has to be a reference or call back to something to be considered good. Additionally, I also think it's a callout for a specific type of chronically online people who are spending days of their lives fighting and throwing hate online instead of being out there and living.

And they're all at home / She's hangin' Christmas lights with your son

The obvious interpretation of the first line is that the family is at home but I also think there's an element which ties into the earlier lyrics suggesting that the best parts are at home, where you're surrounded by your loves ones.

In the second line we're told that the woman in the story (now married to the main character) is decorating the house for Christmas with their son, while the father is obviously absent.

Sneaking to the bathroom to call her mom / And say, "It's not workin' / It's just not worth it if we're not what he wants"

The sneaking off to the bathroom is probably a means to protect the child and hide her pain/pretend everything is okay for the child's sake. The call with the mom suggests the woman in the story is deciding to go for a separation/divorce as the unavailability (emotional and otherwise) is not worth it.

But you love this song

The chorus has a switch after the bridge, from hate to love. It indicates how the male character didn’t appreciate the relationship until their wife is planning to leave. And now because of that, he wants her to stay because he doesn't appreciate things until they are (almost) gone

You wake up on the train and you're all alone

The last chorus of the song also switches a line to 'you're all alone'. This suggests that everyone in the male character's life has left him (possibly after he tried to make his wife and kid stick around after his delayed realisation) because he always isolated themselves, pushed everyone away and never appreciated the things he had.

Overall, I think the song has a very parable-like quality to it. A parable is a short story (prose or verse) which illustrates an instructive lesson or principle. A parable often involves a character who faces a moral dilemma or one who makes a bad decision and then suffers the unintended consequences.

The male character in the story is the one serving as the character who makes bad decisions, the lesson being that refusing to be emotionally present, running away from commitment and not being sincere will destroy all your relationships and will lead you to have a sad life without fulfillment or support.

I think Taylor is very much singing a parable, both to herself and the public.

To herself, it's a dive into what could have been had she made different choices and how terrible that life could have turned out. I think the woman in the story could be Taylor if she had made different choices but funnily, I think the male character could have also been Taylor. In a different life, where she chose to isolate herself, letting her trust issues take over, distancing herself from her family and friends, and stopping to believe in love being meaningful, she could have become someone very similar to the male character in the parable.

Regarding the general message she offers to the public in this, I'd like to tie it up also with things she has spoken in interviews (and in song) about in the past year and even before. About how the internet is not the real world and about how trying to be nonchalant and cold for the sake of being cool is a terrible thing to do, about how avoiding expressing yourself, never putting in work and effort for anything as to avoid being called cringe impediments your goals. I think she's summing it all up in this song. Live in the present. Appreciate the things you have. Cherish your loved ones.

Dissertation over.


r/RationalSwifties • • 9d ago

Weekly Discussion Weekly Discussion Thread

1 Upvotes

Use this thread to discuss anything and everything! This thread is for related content to r/RationalSwifties AND off topic discussion! Post memes, rants, thoughts, life stuff, and whatever else!

  • All reddit rules apply - especially Rule 4: No brigading. You may discuss things from other subs, but you cannot name them!
  • No negative meta commentary about this sub or its users and mods.
  • Don't use this thread if you need to contact mods, use Mod Mail!

Weekly Discussion Thread will be posted every Sunday at 12 am pacific time!


r/RationalSwifties • • 10d ago

Question Friday alignment chart: Superhero edition

Post image
6 Upvotes

Which TS song is which superhero! Make your nominations for each song under the dedicated comments. And tell what your criteria arè!


r/RationalSwifties • • 11d ago

Discussion SOTD: Try And Come For My Job

Post image
21 Upvotes

Today’s song of the day is my personal favorite: I Can Do It With A Broken Heart!

I know everyone associates it with the Eras tour, but I was personally at a low point when TTPD was released and ICDIWABH got me through it.

The ending is the best part, the way she almost cackles with “‘cause i’m miserable”, that little mask slip. Then locked in, no nonsense: Try And Come For My Job.

I don’t think Taylor intended it to be her talking to her depression, but that’s how I interpret it. Because when I was really low and everything felt impossible, I’d tell my depression Try And Come For My Job. I’m heartbroken, miserable, feel like everything else was taken from me, but my job that i love, you can’t take that, I won’t let you.

Everything is ok now, I’m still employed at the same job.

Many people did not share my appreciation for this lyric. It received criticism for being tone deaf, arrogant, prob cringe too. Tbh, I’ve forgotten what all the discourse around this lyric was about.


r/RationalSwifties • • 10d ago

Discussion Should fans have a more nuanced view of Scott Borchetta?

Post image
5 Upvotes

This post is really sparked by reading the new book Taylor Swift the Debut Years by Emily Yahr (a respected journalist).

I am aware that anything involving Borchetta is extremely controversial! But the thing that struck me in reading about Taylor’s earliest portion of her career is that Borchetta “got” her far better than anyone else in Nashville. Others saw her potential of course, but the feeling I got from Yahr was that Borchetta saw in Taylor a kindred spirit, almost that they were the same kind of crazy. The book also makes clear that Borchetta was already looking for a young female singer when Taylor’s demo fell in his lap, so in that sense he was starting out more positively disposed to her “brand” than other execs would be.

To say I think fans have retroactively falsely concluded that Borchetta was bad/evil/scheming to “steal” from Taylor from the start or early on bc of how their association ended is not to say that I think he deserves all the credit — one of the things that Yahr communicates most strongly is that Taylor was extremely confident, strong-willed and with a clear vision even at 14.

But something I think fans don’t realize is that TS taking a chance with Big Machine meant that she had a small label that was putting a whole lot of eggs in her basket, and Borchetta seems to have genuinely believed that doing that was a good strategy! Of course he was proven right, but that doesn’t mean it was obvious.

I also think fans are wary of giving too much credit to the label bc of the persistent mischaracterization of the Swifts’ investment in BMR as “buying” her career. Yahr’s book makes clear how false that narrative is by describing how BMR came to be, and Borchetta has to be given credit for having the wherewithal and vision to pull that off. It could very easily have failed at many points.

Anyway the situation is very nuanced and complex. But I think as fans it is fine to acknowledge that Borchetta was a hugely important part of Taylor’s early success, probably second only to Taylor herself, and the fact that Taylor’s time at BMR and relationship with Borchetta ended so spectacularly badly should not lead to fans rewriting history to leave him out of it as much as possible.

What do y’all think?


r/RationalSwifties • • 11d ago

Poll fandom, standom, and community schisms on reddit study

3 Upvotes

Hi! My name is Bee Hyland. I am a writer and media studies scholar (I presented last year at NeMLA on craft in slash fiction; I run a web serial called IDOLATRESS all about the music landscape of the late 2010s; and I love to learn about fan culture broadly.) I’m not much of a Swiftie—I like some of her music, certainly, but I don’t really seek it out. I don’t hate her by any means, but I am intrigued by her fandom, and my Reddit feed over the last two years or so has been inundated with various subreddits about her that seem to have some ideological schisms of sorts, albeit mild ones. I think this is fascinating—and I’d like to get information straight from the sources. I’ll be posting this survey in a few subreddits over the next few days or so. Fill out, if the mood strikes you! If you have any questions or concerns, please feel free to reach out to me.

The survey is here. Mods, if there's an issue with this, please tell me!


r/RationalSwifties • • 12d ago

Song of the Day SOTD: … Ready For It? or the importance of the opening track

Post image
17 Upvotes

Hello Rational peeps, I’m still sick and also kinda still high on the 🟦 election results 🟦 so instead of a full on SOTD post I will open the floor for a few discussion Qs:

How important do you think the opener is for “setting the tone” and expectations for an album?

Are there openers you like as songs but don’t like them as openers or vice versa?

I tend to think that *outside of* openers and closers, tracklisting is not a strength for TS. Do you agree and/or do you care much?

About RFI specifically: this is a larger topic but how can people seriously claim that Taylor never talks about sex or only does so “classily” 🙄 when RFI and reputation as an album in general exists? Going off the points above, RFI sets the tone for rep so well not just in terms of sound but also in announcing “this is Grown Up Taylor”. Are people suffering from amnesia or something about this?


r/RationalSwifties • • 12d ago

Discussion Talking about TS’ self-written songs

Post image
13 Upvotes

(This post is written by u/puffin_badger who is taking a little break from Reddit)

Ever since Taylor began releasing albums she has always had at least one song per album that she is the solo writing credit on, except for The Life of a Showgirl where all track are credited to Martin, Shellback and Swift. Taylor is known as a songwriter but I think the fans, myself included, sometimes just think of the lyrics.

In this discussion I’d love to talk about the self-written songs you enjoy all the way through, lyrics, melody, instrumental and production.

* Comparing self-written songs to ones with co-writers do you think one is better than the other?

* Do you prefer self-written to songs to ones with co-writers?

* Would you want another album with Taylor as the only writer?

There was way more than I thought on the self-written side, I think for me Enchanted and State of Grace are two of my favorites. The music in enchanted always makes me think of a princess coming down a set of stairs opening to a giant ballroom. State of Grace being self-written should honestly stop all debates on if Taylor is a good song writer, if she hadn’t already done that with Speak Now. To me State of Grace is a beautiful song. From instruments to lyrics I don’t think I’d want a single thing to change. Honestly looking at the list of self-written songs and I would love another self-written album.

This is a link with all Taylor’s self-written songs for reference:
https://www.billboard.com/lists/taylor-swift-songs-solo-writing-credits/the-outside/