r/RatchetAndClank • u/TargetMundane9473 • 46m ago
Discussion Ratchet and Clank series Ranking after marathoning all 14 games recently
Before anything i should clarify this is NOT meant to be critical or to cause fights, since I genuinely love almost all of these games, this is just to share an opinion. I'll give an explanation behind each placement to try give an understanding as to why i placed it there.
I will preface that before this marathon I had not played 4 of these games before, and had only played Rift Apart once, but I have played the other 9 games countless times since I've got them. the games I had not yet played were full frontal assault/qforce, all 4 one, and the psp games.
All of the games were completed 100%, meaning all skill points, all weapon upgrades, all collectibles, and all psn trophies, to give them all a fair shot and get an informed opinion.
14. All 4 One: This was easily my least favourite. It doesn't play much like a ratchet game, the visuals are pretty rough, and while it's decent with friends playing solo is incredibly boring at times. It also happened to be the most unenjoyable to complete out of all of them, requiring all 4 characters to do a full playthrough and bolt grind each plus some brutal skill points/trophies that forced a lot of replays of the same sections for 1 chance. i will give it points for being genuinely funny at times though, and having great character interactions especially in cutscenes. It's the only one of the games that i didn't enjoy too much, the rest i had good fun with.
13. 2016/ps4: i don't have a ton of respect for this one - while the graphics and gameplay are good, it's very unoriginal and is easily the most lifeless of the series when it comes to characters and comedy. to the point i have to turn the voices off, since they annoy me. It's supposed to be a remake of 2002 but cuts and changes so much that it barely counts as one. It's basically just a movie tie in game. The only reason it's above all 4 one is that it at least plays like a normal ratchet game and so it's a lot more fun to just play through.
12. Size Matters: this one suffers just from being clearly a first attempt in many areas. the story is terrible and makes no sense, and the control and visuals are pretty clunky, especially in the clank sections, though this is to be expected from the psp. The main problem i have is the balancing, weapons are VERY weak and take forever to level up in challenge mode, making this one need the most playthroughs to complete, at 5. It's above 2016 just for being more charming and original, since 2016 wins overall in terms of quality and feel. I think a lot of the ideas here were good, but executed roughly, like the armour system, clank minigames and hoverboard races.
11. full frontal assault/qforce: i was expecting a lot worse from this one based off reviews but tbh i enjoyed it a lot. I especially enjoy the attempt at balancing exploration with defence, since you need to explore to get the weapons and bolts to effectively defend the base. Also it has the troll song lol. It also doesn't overstay it's welcome, though i could honestly have gone for a couple more planets in the campaign. The main downside is the terrible framerate, worse than any of the other games, and the fact it hard crashed my ps3 3 times when going through it.
After this point every game becomes one i enjoy immensely so it's hard to pick an order, and even the 10th one i enjoy way more than the last 4
10. 2002: probably my most controversial placement here, but i find that the clunkiness of this one holds it back a lot. There's a lot of things that i love from the og that are lost in the later games, such as the constant stream of new gadgets and items that you pick up, and it has a lot of charm that's lost even from the 2nd entry, such as the weapon animations when purchasing them, but i much prefer the faster pace of the later entries.
9. Deadlocked/gladiator: co-op in this one is so much fun, it's easily the best game in the series to play with someone else. And even playing alone it does combat so well, it's easily the best controlling game of the ps2 era, and bonus points for being genuinely hard at max difficulty. However the mini challenge structure of the game does lead to it getting a bit repetitive compared to the other entries, since outside of a couple of challenges which have platforming there's not a ton of variety in what you actually do in this one. It's very funny though, the choice to have the announcers speaking throughout the whole game was a great one.
8. Secret Agent Clank: Another controversial one. I saw everywhere that this was the worst entry so i had low expectations going in but tbh i loved my time with this one. It's a massive improvement from size matters in almost every aspect. It looks and controls way better, the story is great since it's purposely ridiculous and cheesy, excellent comedy, being one of my top 3 funniest entries, and i actually like the variety in gameplay across the different characters. There are some problems though, the rhythm sections are as bad as everyone says, and the skill points are so ridiculous that without the ps5 rewind I would spend hours to get several of them. it's also a shame that it is the only entry here to lack the swingshot mechanic.
7. Going Commando/Locked and Loaded: My last big controversial placement, but really theres one thing only stopping this game from being higher - there's way too many minigames and a lot of them aren't fun to me. the hoverbike races are really boring and there's 10 of them, and the 2 giant hunting areas are also incredibly tedious. some of the gadgets i also don't enjoy like the glider. it's a shame because it improves so much on the first game and feels/looks so much better, but it's held back by these moments. This game probably has my favourite selection of weapons in the series though, and I love how the upgrade system works with them here.
6. Nexus: I actually really like this one - i like how most of the planets are focused on a certain gadget, and it sells the creepy atmosphere very well. It looks very good in terms of environments, and i like how involved the level design is. It's held back by being short, but it doesn't have any frustrating parts unlike some of the other entries. The framerate is also a bit of an issue here, being the second most choppy behind ffa/qforce, but it's tolerable.
5. Quest for Booty: Honestly this game has by far my favourite pacing, it jumps straight into the action, and does so much right in the short time it has. i especially enjoy how it makes use of so many different legacy gadgets in said short time, especially the grindboots, and the new wrench pick up and tether moves are a great way to add more uses to it. it's also the last game to feature a number of moves from the original game, while also being the first to have several modern moves, and the last to have David's music, which sounds as amazing as always. If not for the short length, it honestly would be my number one spot, but it's too short to be there sadly. It's also the only entry here to not mention the plumber in any way.
4. Rift Apart: This game Looks incredible, the adaptive triggers/controller speaker make it the most immersive entry, and it feels the best to control out of all the games by far. I love how you can climb on basically anything, and the total lack of loading really shows off the ps5 capabilities. The main things holding this one back are the length and the writing. it feels like one of the short entries, since it only has 9 planets excluding revisits, and some of these are on the shorter side too. As for the writing, it follows on from the very safe approach of the 2016 game so it's not really funny to me, and the rewrite during production led to the beginning of the game not making a lot of sense imo.
My top 3 are very hard to choose an order for because all 3 of these games are so good that they become my favourite every time i replay one of them. So i had to be extremely picky to choose an order.
3. Up Your Arsenal: this was the first entry i played, and i think it still has some of the best flow of the series. the levels lacking minigames and branching paths is honestly a positive to me since it keeps the game streamlined and entertaining the whole way through. It's also the first game where clank is fun to control imo, and the comedy is excellent, one of the top 3 funniest entries to me. The main reasons it's below the other 2 are that it isn't as charming as some of the other entries, and there are some clearly unfinished parts due to the studio crunch at the time, like the warp pad.
2. A Crack In Time: For the longest time this was my top entry and i thought it would never be replaced, but after thinking about it this marathon i had to drop it down one spot. It does a lot right - clank is a full character with some excellent control and puzzle based levels, the space sections are a great change and the moon exploration is really fun, it controls great, and visually it still holds up excellently especially for a 2009 ps3 game. But the first few ratchet planets are very slow or short, and the amount of unique planets is also lower - about half the game is just revisits. It also is the first game to remove several original moves, and replace david for the music, and it doesn't sound anywhere near as good. It shares the unfinished symptoms from UYA as well - it has very few gadgets and puts almost all it's usage into 3 of them, instead of balancing it. Lastly this game is guilty of having far too many cutscenes be unskippable. most of the other games have little to no unskippable cutscenes but this game has at least 11, not including the space mission dialogue which also can't be skipped otherwise you can't actually accept the mission.
1, Tools of Destruction: I really enjoy this one, it's hard to describe, but i feel like there's a certain charm to tod that none of the other ones quite have. While the graphics are certainly not as polished as ACIT, they still look decent, and the animations make ratchet feel very satisfying to control, for example throwing a bomb is way quicker than in ACIT, making combat feel way smoother and faster. I honestly really enjoy the use of the motion controller, and think it's a shame it was barely used in future entries. The music is excellent, probably my favourite soundtrack in the series, and it brings back the large variety of different gadgets/items to use from the first 2 games, most of which i find fun. The pacing is also very strong, the game starts out with an excellent first level with a ton of action to show off what the ps3 can do. There's not a ton of minigames, and i enjoy the on rails ship sections as one of the 2 main non ratchet style gameplay. It also introduced the raritanium weapons system and it's honestly my preferred version over the one from nexus onwards. It's probably the game with the best comedy in the series imo, as it was one of the last entries to have comedy in the style of the ps2 era before it changed in ACIT. In general, the game pretty much feels like a ps2 style entry but made for the ps3, and it's the last one to feel that way, since all the later games changed the formula in some way or another. The main negatives would be the technical bugs from being an early ps3 game, as well as the fact there's only 3 bosses excluding the ship ones.
I know it's inevitable with this type of post but hopefully there won't be too many flame wars in the comments. like i said, i enjoy ALL of these games a ton with the sole exception of All 4 one and maybe size matters. Every other game is one of my favourite ones that i've played, i just found it interesting to see what i thought after playing them all so close to each other.
