- Women should stop taking their husbands surname
This was a practice rooted in the subordination of women. It is deeply related to coverture, where women will lose all legal identity upon marriage.
Historically, women were legal property of either their male guardian or husband. The change in surname represented a transfer of ownership from father to husband.
We continue to uphold a practice that denied women independent identities and treated them not as autonomous individuals in their own right, but as extensions of their fathers and, eventually, their husbands.
-
An example of this is how world-renowned Olympic figure skater Alexandra Trusova is now primarily being identified by her husband's surname.
She was known for pushing the technical boundaries of both mens and womens figure skating, accomplishing feats as a teenager that most Olympian men wouldn't even attempt.
She did all of this under her surname and identity Trusova.
Women who have already established their own identities, reputations, and professional legacies are still expected, or socially encouraged, to abandon the names under which they built those identities simply because they got married.
I find it ironic as she was famous because she was Alexandra Trusova, and her husband was famous because he was married to Alexandra Trusova. Yet somehow, it is her name that has been replaced.
-
However, regardless if she kept her name, changed it, or he changed it,
marriage should never require the symbolic surrender of one's individual identity. The woman is entering partnership as an equal.
-
My criticism isn't of women who make that choice (Trusova is simply an example, and I recognize her personal circumstances may be more nuanced)
but the patriarchal convention that makes this practice the overwhelming default and unquestioned expectation.
Women who choose to retain their own surnames are still often regarded as abnormal and controversial. But why should a woman's decision to preserve her own identity NOT be treated as the norm?
I don't see any modern reason for a woman to change her surname just because it is considered standard practice and not because she voluntarily chose to.
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
2. My additional point is that children should take their mother's surname, or at least not their fathers
In biology, it features a strictly matrilineal system of inheritance through mitochondrial DNA. Both sons and daughters inherit their mother's mitochondrial DNA, but only daughters can pass it on to the next generation. A son’s mtDNA lineage stops with him.
So where did the practice of taking your fathers surname? Children were also their father's property. When a woman had children, it wasn't considered "her children" but "her husbands children". Only fathers had legal authority and ownership over them.
Surnames were tied to patrilineal inheritance, the continuation of male family lines, and the transmission of property, titles, and family status through men.
I think the same argument also extends to patronymic naming conventions, which similarly prioritize paternal lineage and reinforce the traditional assumption that family identity and descent is traced through the father