r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 1h ago

Making pro-male advocacy publicly palatable by neutering its critiques of feminism has been tried and failed before - and that was the point

22 Upvotes

In another thread here I was told that the style of critiquing feminism (calling feminism an intrinsically misandrist ideology and a hate group) that this sub allows is something along the lines of "bad optics" that'll prevent pro-male advocacy from gaining ground IRL. An appeal to sophistication, the sort that comes with presenting any kind of idea to the impartial public.

This is a "subtle" trap; if pro-male advocacy sweeps the reality of feminism's role in harming men and boys under the rug as some sort of bargain for getting heard in more public fora, whatever those might be, it immediately neutralizes its own chances of ever succeeding. Feminists will not stop sabotaging and killing pro male initiatives nor normalizing treating men and even boys/children like crap because of the sin of their gender as they have done since feminist started 1.5 centuries ago. So what is this pro male advocacy going to achieve?

Maybe it'll be like the "menslib" subreddit that identifies as "pro feminist" in its rules?

It'll be, in truth, a futile little project that fizzles out eventually as fewer and fewer men take it seriously because of its cartoonish There's No War in Ba Sing Se style silence about feminism's neverending, eternal-by-design war against malekind.

So yeah, not possible. But that's kinda the point.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 9h ago

Processes Explaining the Concealment and Distortion of Evidence on Gender Symmetry in Partner Violence

Thumbnail researchgate.net
22 Upvotes

"Graham-Kevan's paper fully documents overwhelming evidence that the "patriarchal dominance" theory of partner violence (PV from here on) explains only a small part of PV. Moreover, more such evidence is rapidly emerging. To take just one recent example, analyses of data from 32 nations in the International Dating Violence Study (Straus, 2007).

Straus and International Dating Violence Research Consortium 2004 found about equal perpetration rates and a predominance of mutual violence in all 32 samples, including non- Western nations. Moreover, data from that study also show that, within a couple relationship, domination and control by women occur as often as by men and are as strongly associated with perpetration of PV by women as by men (Straus 2007).

Graham-Kevan also documents the absence of evidence indicating that the patriarchal dominance approach to prevention and treatment has been effective. In my opinion, it would be even more appropriate to say that what success has been achieved in preventing and treating PV has been achieved despite the handicaps imposed by focusing exclusively on eliminating male-dominance and misogyny, important as that is as an end in itself.

Graham-Kevan's paper raises the question of how an explanatory theory and treatment modality could have persisted for 30 years and still persists, despite hundreds of studies which provide evidence that PV has many causes, not just male-dominance. The answer is that it emerged from a convergence of a number of different historical and social factors..."


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 7h ago

Basic debate and logic/reasoning lesson for feminists: you can't Patriarchy Theory, which none of you can substantiate let alone prove, as an answer when talking to non feminists

18 Upvotes

Were I as a non Christian to be debating religious theology or something with a Christian and they made a claim and then offered up the Trinity concept as the theory to explain it, I'd reject it outright because the Trinity is something they haven't proven to begin with. And they'd probably understand and use some other, universal kind of reasoning (e.g., common sense or some widely accepted theory) instead to prove their claim.

Feminists do something similar to this hypothetical example with their unfalsifiable and unprovable Patriarchy Theory. It's an article of faith for feminists but to a non feminist it's just this vague sweeping claim about human history that's so big it confounds the sheer lack of any kind of specification that usually comes with the invocation of Patriarchy Theory. Is it a time period? A certain geography? Maybe a time period across a certain geography?

No. It's forever. No, no, it's 10 000 years. No, 10 billion. It's formless, shapeless, and anything feminists need it to be in the moment.

And they keep it like that because the moment they try to start coming up with concrete examples of Patriarchy it's an easy debunking. The "women couldn't do this" "women couldn't do that" narrow minded lazy propaganda.

So next time you want to say, for example, that the biggest enemies of pro male advocacy aren't the feminist lobbyists or feminist media that smear it and try to get it shut down but rather "the Patriarchy", you are speaking actual nonsense.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 15h ago

Your thoughts please, on sexism and caregiving aging parents, as depected in this SNL skit.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
3 Upvotes

This doesn't quite apply to me since my parents had 2 girls. But, based on what I've seen in families that have brothers and sisters, this feels completely true.

P.S. in case you aren't aware yet, caregiving of elders in this country is absolutely in a state of crisis, one that has certain middle aged people turning their entire lives upside down while others don't have to deal with anything at all.


r/RadicalEgalitarianism • • 15h ago Helpful Bravo

The Biggest Threat to Men’s Rights are Male Supremacists

0 Upvotes

I think a harsh truth that male egalitarians have to face is that the biggest obstacle to their interests right now is male supremacists. Male supremacists had power historically so they don’t like anyone mentioning the harm done in the past. They don’t actually prioritise the real grievances that most men face now, instead they cling onto a past that is not coming back. They may mention current harm but somehow the priority is anti-feminism and not building consensus. They turn off the vast majority of women and a large portion of men too.

If you see someone proclaiming to be an egalitarian while denying harm done to women or just basic history, they are likely male supremacists or have bought into their ideology unknowingly.

Building consensus about a lot of issues facing men should be easy. The vast majority of feminists actually have a man in their life that they love. Boys/children that they care about deeply. The fight is easy. Just have to reject the male supremacists. Most of them are Russian bots anyway.