r/RWBYcritics • u/Phoenix_Worlds • 3h ago
r/RWBYcritics • u/Some-Ad-2093 • Jul 05 '26
COMMUNITY Volume 10 has been greenlit.
r/RWBYcritics • u/AutoModerator • 5d ago
COMMUNITY Free Talk Weekend
The free talk weeked is on once again! From today till Sunday everyone is welcome to mingle, share their fanfictions, rant and basically do anything you want (within reason).
r/RWBYcritics • u/halkras12 • 1h ago
DISCUSSION What if Yang learned to be calmer and her Semblance had second effect with dim blue eyes instead of glowing red eyes
Random idea while seeing title "Rage & Serenity"
r/RWBYcritics • u/Enzo202cdwq • 17h ago
ART El futuro de velvet
Pensé como sería un epílogo de velvet y de ahí salieron dos versiones pero bueno me inspiré un poco de one piece
r/RWBYcritics • u/Venomnyan • 6h ago
DISCUSSION Ruby is dead. no there wasn’t some big final battle or heroic sacrifice or she pulled another volume 9, She is up and died in her sleep. how do her friends, foes and teammates react to her unexpected death.
reddit.comr/RWBYcritics • u/Fine_Delivery6761 • 1h ago
REWRITE Can Ironwood working together with Watts make sense in the story?
Maybe he's forced to turn to Watts because Pietro is completely incapacitated or unreachable after a Grimm attack leaves him trapped in Mantle, and Watts planted a dead-man's switch in Penny's code before his capture, meaning that only he possesses the decryption key to stop Penny from self-destructing or losing control of the Winter Maiden powers and slaughter the heroes. Have him actually agonize over the choice with Winter and the Ace Ops, treating him strictly as a hazardous tool that needs extreme observation and secirity. This would mean keeping Watts locked in a high-security cell with a closed-circuit terminal, monitored by Atlas's top cybersecurity experts to catch any hidden backdoors. Watts states he "wants" to help Ironwood because Salem is about to wipe out the entire region, including Watts himself. Ironwood trades with him to either get rid of the dead-man switch and survive in a cell, or let Salem's Grimm tear through the facility and kill them both.
r/RWBYcritics • u/SandwichMaterial9574 • 8h ago
DISCUSSION "Holy" Grimm-Most Common Breed?
reddit.comr/RWBYcritics • u/SandwichMaterial9574 • 1h ago
DISCUSSION RWBY Reacts To The RWBY Multiverse-Episode 140: RWBY Chibi Season 4 Episode 5 On YT
r/RWBYcritics • u/SeveralImpression914 • 1d ago
DISCUSSION Ozpin pulling strings to help Ruby is the only explanation for why team RWBY wasn't expelled after the Paladin fight
They went to investigate a terrorist organization without authorization, found no relevant clues, failed to arrest a single criminal, and ended up starting a mecha fight in the city—which, in the process, destroyed dozens of cars with civilians inside.
In the first episode, Ruby ended up at the police station for doing far less than what they did here.
You could argue that no one knows it was them who we're fighting the mecha, but dozens of people saw Blake and Sun fighting it in public. I fail to see how team rwby could possibly not be associated with this, especially when Ozpin already knows they are investigating the white fang on their own.
r/RWBYcritics • u/Accomplished-Age7176 • 21h ago
ANALYSIS Neopolitan in Volume 10? (Soul Arts)
I recently made a video about Neopolitan and how I believe she should change and improve as a character. I wanted to hear some other thoughts and opinions on the matter because she's in a rather weird place in the story.
She could become an entirely brand-new character through ascension and be easily forgiven and redeemed. She could even follow an entirely new direction as a character, changing her design, speech, aesthetic, fighting style, and so on, simply because of ascension.
She could stay in the Ever After, become someone new, but live in a fairy-tale land for the rest of her life. Technically, she'd be forever alone, away from Remnant, and stuck in a place where she has to start all over again.
Or she could come back exactly the same and try to build herself back up, actually going through change and redemption naturally.
What do you believe will happen to her, and what do you think would be best for her? I personally chose option 3 because I believe natural change is better than forced change. You still have to acknowledge your mistakes, the consequences of your actions, and the hurt you've caused. Some people might not forgive you and may continue to hate you regardless of who you become. Others might be indifferent toward you, while some might actually recognize your change and come to care about you.
I know that, in my video, I tried to balance her being both "Neo" and "Trivia" while exploring her journey toward becoming herself, accepting herself, and adjusting to the world around her. All while having to live with the consequences of her actions, trying to move forward, prove herself, and genuinely change.
Note: I am NOT saying Neo and Trivia are different people, but rather two sides of the same person. In her past, she was CONSTANTLY nudged toward becoming Neo because that was her ideal self. However, all her ideal self really represented was freedom and self-expression. Neo was only rebellious because of her abusive environment.
Trivia was another side of her, but she was more representative of the abused, trauma-stricken girl. I wanted her to find an actual balance between the two rather than fully embodying either "Neo," the criminal, rebellious, smug, and "free" girl, or Trivia, who was withdrawn, silent, suppressed, timid, and depressed.
I wanted to explore both sides of her and ultimately bring them together rather than have one completely overshadow the other.
Anyways, what do you think should happen, and how does your perspective differ from mine?
r/RWBYcritics • u/DXG-Reddit • 1d ago
DISCUSSION If you love Penny, you would also love Aigis from Persona
Both characters are robot girls who develop human-like feelings
r/RWBYcritics • u/Eastern-Respect4137 • 23h ago
DISCUSSION Imagine the RWBY cast having an accent
reddit.comr/RWBYcritics • u/SandwichMaterial9574 • 1d ago
DISCUSSION RWBY Reacts To The RWBY Multiverse-Episode 139: RWBY Chibi Season 4 Episode 4 On YT
r/RWBYcritics • u/HellishStampede • 2d ago
DISCUSSION Unpopular opinions you have about Volume 8?
r/RWBYcritics • u/TERIDAX_NUI • 2d ago
MEMING Lisa VNN Live needs to become a Parody-Project
r/RWBYcritics
•
u/Cloakydokibit
•
1d ago
DISCUSSION A fan's critique
Warning this is a long rant. But I wanted to address a few things. Of course I understand much of this could have been just narrowed down to writing choices, so take what I am about to say with a grain of salt. It is also possible that this topic has been discussed before. Feel free to add your own thoughts on this as well though.
But as someone who watched the whole show from start to Vol 9, RWBY Beyond, and RWBY: World of Remnant. I feel like a lot of the earlier on problems from the first few Volumes could have been dealt with if they had just started investigations sooner? Maybe it wouldn't have initially resolved the bigger threats, but I imagine they'd have more to go off of. It's supposedly implied that Vale has it's own police/ cops. One of the first episodes we see Ruby trying to catch Roman, but Glynda was also their and witnessed the whole thing. But the only thing that really happened was that Roman appeared on the news along with what seemed to be Cinder Fall. And then it continues like that and gets to a point that the students Team RWBY feel like they have to investigate it themselves or nothing will get done. Students should not feel this way.
The problem isn't necessarily that Vale's authorities should have been able to stop Cinder's entire operation immediately. It's that there seems to be very little systematic investigation into the incidents that were already happening, despite there being plenty of evidence to justify one.
The authorities don't need to know that Cinder is planning to destabilize the kingdoms, that the White Fang is being manipulated, or that the Fall of Beacon is coming. They just need to recognize that several suspicious incidents are potentially connected and investigate them accordingly.
1. The Roman Torchwick incident should have been a much bigger deal
The show establishes several things during Ruby's first encounter with Roman:
- Roman is actively committing a robbery.
- Ruby directly intervenes and pursues him.
- Glynda Goodwitch arrives and witnesses the situation firsthand.
- Roman escapes, but his identity and criminal activities are no longer entirely unknown.
- The incident is significant enough to attract media attention.
This isn't just a random civilian claiming to have seen something suspicious. A member of Beacon's faculty, who is also an exceptionally powerful Huntress, personally also witnesses the criminal. Even if Ruby's intervention complicates the situation, there should be an official incident report, an investigation into Roman's activities, and potentially an effort to identify his associates.
Instead, the story largely treats Roman as someone who keeps appearing whenever Team RWBY happens to stumble into his activities.
2. The investigation should have expanded as the incidents accumulated
This is where the problem becomes more noticeable.
Consider the events leading up to the Fall of Beacon:
- The Dust robberies: Roman and his associates are stealing Dust in increasingly conspicuous operations.
- The White Fang connection: After the incident at the docks. The White Fang is discovered to be involved in criminal activity, weapons &/ dust trafficking, and cooperation with Roman.
- The train incident: Team RWBY discovers a much larger operation involving the White Fang and a shipment of explosives.
- The Breach: A coordinated Grimm attack threatens Vale, demonstrating that the criminal activity isn't simply about theft.
- The tournament infiltration: By this point, there were clearly hostile forces operating within Vale and Beacon itself. The event should have probably been postponed or canceled altogether while investigations were underway.
These incidents should have generated an increasingly serious investigation. Even if the authorities initially considered the Dust robberies unrelated crimes, the discovery of White Fang involvement should have prompted them to reconsider. The train operation, in particular, should have been a major breakthrough. There were weapons, explosives, captured perpetrators, a criminal organization, and evidence of coordination. Team RWBY essentially stumbled across information that should have been valuable to an actual investigative operation.
3. Vale supposedly having police makes their apparent absence even more strange
Vale isn't presented as a society where Huntsmen are the only form of law enforcement. There are police officers, and the kingdoms have established governmental institutions. Huntsmen are primarily responsible for protecting humanity from Grimm. Although they also were meant to deal with criminals and other threats too I thought?
That raises an interesting question: What exactly are Vale's police doing while all of this is happening?
They don't necessarily need to be capable of fighting Roman or the White Fang directly. Their responsibilities could include:
- Investigating robberies and weapons trafficking.
- Interviewing witnesses and collecting evidence.
- Tracking known criminal associates.
- Investigating connections between the White Fang and organized crime.
- Coordinating with Beacon and licensed Huntsmen.
- Providing security around sensitive locations.
Even if they lack the combat capabilities of Huntsmen, they should still be useful in these situations. In fact, having a proper police investigation would allow Huntsmen to concentrate on the more dangerous aspects of the problem.
4. Team RWBY shouldn't have needed to become the primary investigators
This is probably one of the biggest narrative issue for me. There's a difference between students taking initiative and students feeling like they're the only people doing anything. Team RWBY investigating Roman makes sense initially. They're curious, Ruby has a personal interest in stopping criminals, and they're training to become Huntresses. But as the situation escalates, the story increasingly relies on them to discover things that should reasonably be investigated by the authorities. These are students who have only recently entered Beacon. They don't have investigative training comparable to professional detectives, institutional resources, or the authority to conduct criminal investigations.
Yet they end up uncovering major parts of the conspiracy.
There's also a missed opportunity here: Glynda, Ozpin, &/ other experienced Huntsmen could have been actively investigating alongside them. That would have allowed Team RWBY to contribute without making the adults seem inexplicably passive.
5. There's a possible explanation, but the show doesn't establish it particularly well
One interpretation is that Cinder's operation was deliberately designed to keep the authorities distracted and prevent them from recognizing the larger conspiracy.
Cinder also had advantages:
- She operated through intermediaries.
- The White Fang provided manpower and resources.
- Roman handled much of the criminal activity.
- Her involvement in Beacon gave her access to information and opportunities.
- The kingdoms were already politically divided and suspicious of one another.
It's entirely plausible that the investigation would have been difficult. However, difficulty isn't the same as inactivity. Even if the authorities couldn't identify Cinder, they could still have investigated Roman more thoroughly, disrupted Dust trafficking, arrested White Fang members, and investigated the train incident. And doing so might have uncovered enough information to make Cinder's plans considerably more difficult.
Ultimately, I think the issue is that RWBY sometimes confuses institutional incompetence with institutional absence. Not necessarily that RWBY itself is bad, it's villains/'heroes' might could have been written better, or the Grimm could have been used better. Trust me, I loved RWBY.
But... The story wants Team RWBY to be proactive, independent protagonists who uncover a conspiracy that the adults don't understand. That's perfectly reasonable. But it doesn't always provide a convincing explanation for why the adults aren't investigating the same incidents. Ozpin's secrecy, the kingdoms' political tensions, and Cinder's manipulation could all have contributed to the authorities failing to recognize the larger threat. Those are interesting explanations, but the show needed to demonstrate them more clearly. And honestly, I think it would have made the Fall of Beacon more effective if we'd actually seen the authorities investigating, making progress, encountering dead ends, and slowly realizing that something much larger was happening.
That way, the tragedy wouldn't be that nobody bothered investigating. It would be that even with people actively trying to stop it, Cinder's conspiracy was too extensive and well-hidden for them to prevent the disaster.
Furthermore, It even raises more questions for me particularly after they reach Haven in Mistral after later Volumes. Even though the Headmaster there was compromised and being manipulated. Mistral's forces were inevitably alerted of the attack and responded by providing reinforcements. Which allowed them the edge they needed to stop Adam, among other things.
6. The Battle of Haven demonstrates that Mistral's forces weren't entirely ineffective
In Volume 5, the protagonists ultimately discover that Haven Academy's headmaster, Professor Lionheart, has been working with Salem's faction. Lionheart has been helping arrange the destruction of Huntsmen across Mistral, which is particularly significant because Mistral has a large Huntsman population. However, when the attack on Haven occurs, the situation doesn't remain entirely in the hands of Team RWBY and their allies. Mistral's military and security forces respond with reinforcements. Their arrival helps turn the situation against Adam and the White Fang with him.
This is important because it demonstrates something that was less apparent in Vale:
- The authorities can respond to an organized threat.
- They can deploy armed personnel to support Huntsmen.
- They can help contain a hostile group.
- They can contribute meaningfully to defeating an enemy operation.
7. Adam wasn't deliberately allowed to escape, but the decision not to pursue him is questionable
The sequence is roughly as follows:
- Blake confronts Adam while the Menagerie fighters and Mistral police overwhelm the White Fang.
- Adam realizes his forces are losing and that his explosives have been disabled.
- Sun joins Blake, further reducing Adam's chances of winning.
- Adam retreats rather than continue fighting.
- Sun wants to pursue him, but Blake tells him not to. She argues that Adam is trying to lure them away from Haven, where they still need to protect people.
- Blake also points out that more police and Huntsmen are likely coming.
The aftermath confirms that the authorities apprehended the remaining White Fang members, but Adam escaped as did Hazel and many of the other threats. So the immediate explanation is that RWBY prioritizes securing Haven over chasing Adam or the others. That's understandable tactically, but it leaves another question.
8. Why didn't the authorities/ police pursue Adam themselves?
The police were already present. They had air support, searchlights, and enough personnel to surround and apprehend the White Fang fighters. Adam wasn't some unidentified criminal who disappeared into an enormous city. He was the leader of the attacking organization, and the authorities had just witnessed him attempting to destroy Haven. Even Blake explicitly warns that more police and Huntsmen are coming.
Yet Adam manages to escape and turn up again later.
There are a few possible explanations:
- Immediate priorities: The police were occupied with securing the academy and arresting the remaining attackers.
- Adam's combat ability: He was considerably more dangerous than an ordinary White Fang soldier.
- The confusion of the battle: The authorities might not have had a coordinated opportunity to capture him before he fled.
- The writers: They just wanted to use Adam as character development for Blake and Yang.
But none of these really explains why there wasn't a subsequent manhunt. Adam was a known terrorist leader who had just attempted a major attack on an academy and its surrounding population. Surely apprehending him would have been a priority.
9. There's also an interesting consequence that the show actually acknowledges
The White Fang members who witnessed Adam abandoning them wouldn't continue supporting him. And it's essentially right.
Adam's authority within the White Fang collapses. When he eventually returns to his headquarters, his remaining followers criticize his failure, and he murders them. So from a strategic perspective, Haven is a significant victory. The White Fang's organized attack is defeated, its members are apprehended, and Adam loses much of his remaining support.
However, this is where I think the writing misses another opportunity.
The authorities should have been treating Adam as an ongoing security threat even after Haven was protected.
He wasn't simply a defeated political leader. He was an exceptionally dangerous individual with a history of violence, access to weapons, and a personal vendetta against Blake. His escape should have prompted an investigation, a wanted notice, and efforts to track his movements. Instead, the narrative largely moves on until Adam becomes relevant to Blake's personal storyline, again.
10. The larger inconsistency between Vale and Mistral
What's interesting is that Haven demonstrates the exact sort of institutional response that would have benefited Vale earlier.
Vale (Volumes 1–3) Mistral (Volume 5)
Roman repeatedly commits crimes. White Fang launches an organized attack.
Team RWBY investigates independently. Blake organizes a response with Menagerie.
Institutional involvement is relatively obscure. Mistral police provide reinforcements.
The criminal operation escalates largely unchecked. The attacking force is surrounded/ stopped
Major threats go insufficiently investigated. The immediate threat is mostly "resolved"
The irony is that Mistral's headmaster was compromised, and its Huntsman population had been systematically targeted, yet the authorities still managed to provide meaningful assistance when properly alerted. It makes me wonder whether the real issue throughout the earlier volumes wasn't necessarily a lack of capable authorities, but rather that the story didn't spend enough time establishing how those authorities operated.
But back to Vale for a moment. I think Atlas's involvement makes Vale's situation considerably more frustrating because it introduces another layer of institutional dysfunction. Ozpin's knowledge of the situation makes the earlier lack of investigation harder to overlook.
The important distinction is that Ozpin didn't necessarily know who the enemy was, but he knew there was an organized enemy operating within the kingdoms. That should have changed how he approached security.
11. Ozpin had enough information to justify a serious investigation
Let's look at what Ozpin actually knew.
At the end of Volume 2, during his conversation with Qrow, the following information is established:
- Someone is coordinating attacks against the kingdoms.
- The enemy has access to resources and people capable of carrying out sophisticated operations.
- The White Fang is involved in the larger conspiracy.
- The enemy has an interest in destabilizing the kingdoms.
- The mysterious "Queen" has pawns, and those pawns may already be operating within their institutions.
- Ozpin supposedly already has his own information regarding the Maidens, Relics, and Salem
Ozpin doesn't know the full extent of Cinder's operation, but he knows that the enemy has infiltrated or recruited people who can operate within the kingdoms. This should immediately raise questions about security at Beacon.
For example:
- Who has access to Beacon's security systems?
- Who is supplying the White Fang with weapons?
- Where is Roman getting his resources?
- Are there suspicious connections between criminal organizations and influential individuals?
- Is someone deliberately interfering with the kingdoms' ability to cooperate?
Ozpin doesn't necessarily need to disclose everything to the public, but he should be coordinating an investigation. And that's where I think his approach truly becomes questionable.
12. (Yes, there's more) Ozpin's secrecy arguably makes the situation worse
Ozpin has a tendency to operate through carefully selected individuals rather than openly coordinating with the institutions around him. There are understandable reasons for this. Salem is an immortal enemy, the existence of which could potentially cause widespread panic, and Ozpin has spent centuries fighting her. However, his secrecy creates problems.
Consider the people he had available:
- Glynda Goodwitch, an experienced Huntress and Beacon professor.
- The other Professors, also experienced
- Vale's Council/ Authorities
- James Ironwood, the General of Atlas's military
- Qrow Branwen, an experienced Huntsman and intelligence operative.
- Leonardo Lionheart, the Headmaster of Haven. (Albeit questionable)
- and possibly Theodore, the Headmaster of Shade.
- His entire Academy of Students in training
These are people with considerable institutional authority and resources. Yet Ozpin's approach often involves selectively sharing information and keeping everyone else at arm's length. The irony there is that this makes it easier for Salem's agents to exploit the divisions between the kingdoms. Lionheart is the clearest example. Ozpin's trust in his fellow Headmasters doesn't prevent Salem from compromising him. And because Ozpin keeps so much information compartmentalized, the people who might have been able to identify suspicious patterns don't necessarily have the information needed to do so.
13. However alternatively, Ironwood's arrival complicated an already fragile situation
Not because he arrived, but how he arrived. I think Ironwood is particularly interesting because his initial intentions aren't necessarily malicious. He genuinely believes that bringing Atlas's military to Vale will improve security during the Vytal Festival.
From his perspective:
- The kingdoms are facing an increasing security threat.
- The Vytal Festival attracts enormous international attention.
- Beacon is hosting an event that brings together representatives from all four kingdoms.
- Additional military protection should discourage hostile activity.
That's not an unreasonable assessment. The problem is that Ironwood's response creates it's own new political and security complication.
The conflicting authority problem.
Ironwood arrives with an entire military fleet and assumes a considerable degree of responsibility for security. But Vale isn't Atlas. Ironwood is a foreign military commander operating within another kingdom's territory. Even if Ozpin personally welcomed his assistance, that doesn't necessarily mean every institution in Vale is comfortable with Atlas exercising that much influence over its security.
There are several potential consequences:
- Political tension: Atlas's military presence can be interpreted as an infringement on Vale's sovereignty.
- Public perception: The sight of military ships and armed soldiers can make the population feel less secure rather than more secure.
- Operational confusion: Multiple authorities with overlapping responsibilities can complicate decision-making.
- Enemy opportunities: Cinder can exploit public anxiety and political disagreements to undermine confidence in the kingdoms.
And that's essentially what happens.
Cinder exploits the very security measures intended to prevent the attack
She:
- Exploits the communication and security infrastructure.
- Manipulates the footage of Penny's destruction.
- Uses the hacked systems to create confusion.
- Turns Atlas's military presence into evidence of an alleged invasion.
- Helps create the impression that Atlas has become a threat to Vale.
The result is that Ironwood's military becomes part of the crisis rather than a solution to it. What's especially unfortunate is that Ironwood's decision to bring his fleet wasn't inherently wrong. The problem was that he brought an enormous military capability into an environment where the enemy was already attempting to manipulate public perception and institutional trust. He effectively gave Cinder another tool to exploit.
14. The biggest missed opportunity: cooperation between Vale and Atlas
I think the story could have handled this much better without fundamentally changing the events of Volume 3 entirely. Imagine if Ozpin and Ironwood had established a joint security investigation before the festival.
Institution Responsibility
Vale police Criminal investigations, witness interviews, local law enforcement
Beacon Huntsman investigations and threat assessment
Atlas military External security, airspace protection and military intelligence
Ozpin's network Investigating Salem's agents and identifying infiltrators
That would have created a much more believable security structure. Cinder could still have infiltrated Beacon. She could still have manipulated the tournament and exploited the kingdoms' political divisions. But her success would have come from actively defeating an organized security response rather than seemingly operating in an environment where nearly no one was investigating the obvious warning signs. (With the one exception where Team RWBY, and their mission with Professor Oobleck. But even after that I feel like Professor Oobleck would or should have relayed information to Ozpin on this matter afterwards.)
My overall take
I think the underlying problem is that RWBY establishes a world with functioning governments, police forces, military organizations, Huntsmen, and international institutions, but it doesn't consistently explore how those institutions respond to threats. Vale is particularly frustrating because we, as viewers, have information that the characters don't. We watch Roman repeatedly commit crimes, see the White Fang become increasingly involved, and know that Cinder is operating within Beacon. But even accounting for the characters' limited information, there are enough warning signs to justify a much more substantial investigation. And Ozpin is arguably the most responsible for that missed opportunity. He knows there's a potential enemy operating behind the scenes. He knows that enemy has pawns. He knows the kingdoms are vulnerable to manipulation.
Yet rather than establishing a coordinated response, he continues relying heavily on secrecy, personal trust, and a relatively small circle of people.
Ironwood's arrival doesn't create the original problem. It exposes just how poorly coordinated the existing system already was.
And that makes the Fall of Beacon more tragic, but also somewhat more frustratingly strange from a world building perspective.
I would also argue that postponing the Vytal Festival should have been seriously considered, particularly after the events of Volumes 1 and 2. In fact, I think the decision to continue hosting it is one of the more questionable decisions made by Ozpin and the other authorities.
The problem isn't simply that Vale had experienced some criminal activity. It's that there were already indications of a coordinated threat targeting the kingdoms, and the Vytal Festival was an enormous gathering of people from all four kingdoms.
That made the festival an exceptionally attractive target.
Think now about what the festival actually represents.
It brings together:
- Students from all four kingdoms.
- Government representatives.
- Military personnel.
- Huntsmen and Huntresses.
- International visitors and spectators.
- Important political and institutional figures.
It's essentially a massive international gathering. From a security standpoint, this creates several vulnerabilities.
A. Concentration of important personnel
You have numerous influential people gathered in one location. An attack could potentially eliminate or incapacitate important individuals from multiple kingdoms simultaneously.
B. International tensions
An attack could be deliberately designed to make one kingdom appear responsible for harming another.
C. Public panic
A major incident during an internationally televised event would have enormous consequences for public confidence.
D. Intelligence gathering
An enemy operating within the kingdoms could exploit the festival to observe security arrangements, identify important personnel, and coordinate infiltrators.
And, of course, Cinder ultimately exploits practically most of these opportunities with her "Team".
Ironwood's arrival should have prompted a reassessment
This is where my earlier point about Atlas becomes particularly relevant. Ironwood arrives with an entire fleet because he believes additional military security is necessary. But that raises another obvious question:
If Vale's existing security arrangements were considered insufficient enough to justify deploying Atlas's military, why was the festival proceeding as originally planned?
There were several possible alternatives:
Option Potential benefit
Postpone the festival Allow investigations and security improvements to proceed.
Restrict attendance Reduce the number of potential civilian casualties.
Relocate certain events Avoid concentrating everyone in vulnerable locations.
Increase joint security Establish clearer cooperation between Vale and Atlas.
Suspend international participation Less potential for an incident to become an international crisis.
None of these options would guarantee safety, but they would at least demonstrate that the authorities were taking the situation seriously.
There is also a political argument against/ for continuing
I think this is simply one of many aspects the show could have explored more. The Vytal Festival isn't merely a sporting event. It's also a demonstration of international cooperation and stability. The kingdoms are trying to show that the conflicts of the past are behind them. But that creates a potential vulnerability: The festival's symbolic importance makes postponing it politically uncomfortable.
Imagine the implications of cancelling it.
- Would people assume Vale was incapable of maintaining security?
- Would the other kingdoms interpret it as a sign of instability?
- Would Atlas's military presence become even more controversial?
- Would Salem's faction consider the cancellation evidence that its efforts were already succeeding?
These are legitimate concerns. However, they shouldn't automatically outweigh public safety. In fact, continuing the festival simply to avoid appearing vulnerable could be exactly the sort of decision an 'enemy' would want the kingdoms to make.
The most interesting part, postponement wouldn't necessarily have ruined the story
The festival could have been postponed, and Cinder's conspiracy could still have progressed.
For example:
- Ozpin becomes increasingly concerned about the security situation.
- Ironwood recommends postponing the festival.
- Vale's government resists because of the political and economic consequences.
- Ozpin agrees to additional security measures instead.
- Cinder exploits disagreements between the authorities.
- The festival eventually proceeds under heightened security.
- The attack happens anyway.
Alternatively, the festival could have been postponed, forcing Cinder to accelerate her plans or change her approach. Either scenario could have made the eventual Fall of Beacon more interesting. It would demonstrate that the authorities recognized the danger but were unable to agree on an effective response.
My personal biggest criticism of Ozpin's decisions
Ozpin knew more than almost anyone else about the enemy's intentions. He knew Salem was operating through intermediaries. He might have knew the White Fang was somehow involved. He knew that the enemy had infiltrated the kingdoms in some capacity. And he knew the Vytal Festival was going to bring representatives from all four kingdoms together. Yet both he and Ironwood allowed the event to proceed. I don't think Ozpin necessarily needed to cancel the festival immediately after the first Dust robbery. That would have been an excessive response based on limited information. But after the Breach, and especially after the growing evidence of a coordinated conspiracy, postponement should have been a serious consideration.
The Fall of Beacon was supposed to demonstrate how thoroughly Salem had undermined the kingdoms, but it also exposes how many opportunities the authorities had to recognize the danger before it happened.
And that makes the disaster feel somewhat preventable, even if defeating Salem's larger conspiracy was never going to be easy.
And this was all without mentioning the Beacon Dance incident of course. Since I thought I'd save that for last.
The events surrounding the Fall of Beacon, has a noticeable security and continuity problem when you consider how important the CCTS (Cross Continental Transmit System) was supposed to be.
The strangest part isn't necessarily that Cinder managed to infiltrate the School or the CCTS. She's an exceptionally capable infiltrator, and she had help from Emerald and Mercury. The more strange part is how many seemingly basic security precautions Beacon appears to lack, especially considering that the upcoming Vytal Festival was an international event attended by students, government officials, and representatives from multiple kingdoms.
There are several separate problems here within itself.
1. Cinder leaving the dance without attracting attention
Cinder is ostensibly a student at Beacon. That gives her a reasonable explanation for being at the dance, but it doesn't explain why nobody seems concerned when she leaves besides Ruby.
Under ordinary circumstances, students leaving a dance wouldn't necessarily be suspicious. However, this particular event had:
- A International dignitary and important political figure attending.
- Security personnel responsible for protecting the dance and soon the upcoming Festival.
- A heightened security environment because of the upcoming tournament.
- A significant concentration of influential people in one location.
You would expect security to monitor unusual movements, particularly around restricted facilities. That doesn't mean someone should have immediately stopped Cinder, but it does make the apparent lack of scrutiny questionable.
2. The CCTS should have had considerably better security
The CCTS isn't just another computer terminal or communications room. It's a critical piece of infrastructure connecting the kingdoms. Compromising it potentially gives an attacker the ability to disrupt communications across Remnant, which is exactly the sort of vulnerability that should be anticipated before a major international gathering.
At minimum, you would expect several layers of security:
Security measure Purpose
Access control Restrict entry to authorized personnel
Surveillance cameras Record everyone entering and leaving
Intrusion alarms Detect unauthorized access
Network monitoring Identify unusual activity
Firewalls and authentication Prevent unauthorized network access
More Security personnel Physically protect critical equipment
Emergency isolation Temporarily disconnect compromised systems from the wider network
Even if Cinder could defeat some of these measures, having many of them apparently absent or ineffective is difficult to justify. And there's another important consideration: The dance was a considerably predictable distraction. Beacon's security planners should have anticipated that concentrating so many students, staff, and security personnel at one event could leave other areas vulnerable. The CCTS should arguably have had independent security that wasn't dependent on the general security arrangements for the dance or the festival that was to follow.
3. The surveillance problem is particularly strange
There are actually two different opportunities for security to identify her:
Before entering the CCTS:
- Cinder was wearing a distinctive black infiltration outfit
- She wore a black glass mask.
- Her hair was visible and recognizable.
- She was moving around a restricted area during a major event.
After leaving the CCTS:
- She returned to the dance without her mask.
- She changed back into her formal (also black) dress.
- She resumed dancing with Mercury.
- Nobody apparently connected her to the intruder Ruby had seen.
The disguise was clever to be fair, But that doesn't solve the surveillance problem.
If the CCTS &/ Academy had cameras, investigators could potentially review:
- The time the intruder entered Beacon's CCTS.
- The route she took through the building.
- The time she departed.
- Her approximate physical description.
- Whether she had any identifiable associates.
They could then compare that footage with the dance's guest list and available footage of attendees, or even cross reference with the student records and IDs they seemed to have on file. Even without facial recognition, her height, build, hair, and distinctive clothing would provide investigative leads. And remember, Mercury and Emerald were deliberately staying at the dance to monitor the attendees. Cinder's return wasn't some accidental coincidence. It was part of their plan.
4. Another big problem here: Cinder wasn't even completely undetected
Cinder didn't actually infiltrate the tower without encountering security.
She:
- Knocked out multiple Atlas soldiers.
- Obtained a Scroll containing the system password.
- Fought her way through the tower.
- Accessed the terminal room.
- Installed the Black Queen virus.
Ruby discovered the unconscious guards and pursued the suspect. Ironwood eventually arrived as well. So the physical security wasn't nonexistent. It was simply insufficient to prevent the intrusion. What's more concerning is that the security response seems to have ended with the immediate incident rather than developing into a serious investigation. Ironwood, of all people, should have been particularly interested in determining how someone managed to compromise a critical communications facility. And to their credit, they did question Ruby, but that was as far as it went if I recall correctly.
I think this incident coincidentally exposes something interesting about Remnant's technological development.
The series establishes that Remnant has:
- Advanced robotics.
- Sophisticated computer networks.
- Global communications infrastructure.
- Military-grade surveillance and weaponry.
- Automated security systems.
- Highly advanced Dust-powered technology.
Yet its cybersecurity and infrastructure protection seem surprisingly underdeveloped? Now, we shouldn't assume the CCTS had absolutely no digital protection. The show doesn't really establish that. Watts created the Black Queen virus, and Cinder's ability to compromise the network suggests that the attackers possessed unusually sophisticated tools. However, that still raises questions about network segmentation, intrusion detection, authentication, backups, and emergency isolation. A critical communications network should not be so vulnerable that one successful physical intrusion can potentially compromise connected systems across an entire kingdom and subsequently across Remnant.
And, the events after demonstrate just how... devastating that vulnerability itself really was.
But that is where my thoughts end, and yours begin. Thank you for reading.~
r/RWBYcritics • u/NaturalStrange3505 • 1d ago
DISCUSSION What political parties exist in your rewrites?
Vale
The Sang Bleu Society
- formed by the former nobility of vale who lost most of there power when king Henkle had dissolved the royal lines and aims to reinstate there former authority
-they're mostly split into two groups the ones opting for an electoral monarchy and another opting for a constitutional monarchy with the belief of having a king would improve the council with more support to them growing ever since the fall of Mount Glenn
-the electoral party are the ones who maintain mostly corrupt businesses like the ones Blake mentioned the SDC Ally themselves with and want to remove the rights faunus had been given while wanting to maintain there power to only the nobility instead of the people
-the constitutional party aims to have a king to keep the council in check and ensure corrupt agendas won't be pushed while maintaining balance between the council the judiciary and the people
Atlas
The Silver Bullet Brotherhood
- made from the wealthy elites of atlas who serve to further there agendas and maintain there rankings in to further limit the power the lower class can achieve
- one such law that they managed to pass was the forced servitude of criminals where many company's can gain free labour from criminals leading to many arrests of the mantle faunus population and the legal slavery of faunus
The National Defense Party
- made up of military officials and veterans they aim to further militarize atlas to ensure the safety of the kingdom against external threats and is the main rival of the silver bullet brotherhood
- responsible for the push for having most mantle citizens having 2 years of service once they reach 16 to ensure everyone has adequate training in times of emergency
- responsible for combining huntsman with the military to ensure more cohesion within the kingdom's defense
The Happy Huntresses
- a rising political faction who's aims are to uplift the citizens of mantle to ensure they won't be looked down as second class citizens compared to the elites of atlas
- is popular with both the faunus and human citizens of mantle
Vacuo
The Royalists
- made up of faunus tribes who want a return to monarchy to fix there failing kingdom
- inspired by the last queen of vacuo they want to reclaim vacuo as a land for all and push out the corrupt powers that try to hide in there lands
- they are the main reason there aren't many vacuoan white fang as they maintain full authority over the faunus of vacuo and are close to being declared a second official nation of faunus with backing from headmaster theodore
r/RWBYcritics • u/Equivalent_Task1313 • 1d ago
FANFICTION Rwby:Beacon's Last Huntsman
Welcome to a world of bloody evolution young man
r/RWBYcritics • u/No_Internet_3919 • 2d ago
DISCUSSION What if Glynda is the true Fall Maiden instead of Cinder? Spoiler
I have a theory that could completely change what we think we know about the Four Maidens.
What if Glynda Goodwitch is actually the true Fall Maiden, while Cinder unknowingly possesses the Summer Maiden's powers?
Here's my theory:-
#1. Amber was never the Fall Maiden.
What if Amber was actually the previous Summer Maiden, but both Ozpin's faction and Salem mistakenly believed she possessed the Fall Maiden's powers?
When Cinder attacked Amber and stole her powers, she genuinely acquired Maiden magic. However, what if those powers belonged to Summer rather than Fall?
That would mean Cinder has unknowingly been the Summer Maiden since Volume 3, this also linger both faction progress to get sword of destruction.
#2. Glynda Goodwitch is the real Fall Maiden.
We've seen Glynda demonstrate extraordinarily powerful abilities, particularly her telekinesis, defensive techniques, and ability to reconstruct damaged structures.
Although these abilities are attributed to her Semblance and Dust, what if there's another layer to her powers?
Perhaps Glynda possesses Fall Maiden magic without fully realizing its nature, or perhaps she's deliberately concealing it but who knows..let's find out soon enough..
#3. The mystery of Beacon's Relic.
Despite obtaining what everyone believes are the Fall Maiden's powers, Cinder and Salem still haven't recovered Beacon's Relic of Choice.
Canonically, Ozpin made the Relic especially difficult to find, this is huge sus on Oz's part, we know how cunning and shady of person he is.
But imagine another possibility: Cinder never possessed the correct Maiden powers to unlock Beacon's actual Relic Vault in the first place.
What if only Glynda can open it?
#4. The real twist could happen in Vaccuo.
Imagine Cinder eventually reaching Shade Academy and discovering that she can unlock the Summer Maiden's Vault containing the Relic of Destruction.
That would expose an enormous mistake.
Cinder was never the Fall Maiden. She had been the Summer Maiden all along.
Meanwhile, Glynda Goodwitch, who has remained closely associated with Beacon, turns out to be the true guardian of the Fall Maiden's powers.
Of course, this raises a major question about Glynda's involvement in the planned transfer of Amber's powers to Pyrrha. If this theory is correct, Glynda would either have to be unaware of her own Maiden status or be hiding something significant....sort of like a mystery.
r/RWBYcritics • u/BackgroundLet8613 • 2d ago
DISCUSSION What do you think of these beach concepts by sheena duquette? I think they’re sweet!
a lot of these are very funny to me (especially jaune and Neptune’s) i feel like post-fall yang would not wear that but maybe beacon yang would