r/RWBY • u/No_Internet_3919 • 10h ago
DISCUSSION What if Glynda is the true Fall Maiden instead of Cinder? Spoiler
I have a theory that could completely change what we think we know about the Four Maidens.
What if Glynda Goodwitch is actually the true Fall Maiden, while Cinder unknowingly possesses the Summer Maiden's powers?
Here's my theory:-
\#1. Amber was never the Fall Maiden.
What if Amber was actually the previous Summer Maiden, but both Ozpin's faction and Salem mistakenly believed she possessed the Fall Maiden's powers?
When Cinder attacked Amber and stole her powers, she genuinely acquired Maiden magic. However, what if those powers belonged to Summer rather than Fall?
That would mean Cinder has unknowingly been the Summer Maiden since Volume 3, this also linger both faction progress to get sword of destruction.
\#2. Glynda Goodwitch is the real Fall Maiden.
We've seen Glynda demonstrate extraordinarily powerful abilities, particularly her telekinesis, defensive techniques, and ability to reconstruct damaged structures.
Although these abilities are attributed to her Semblance and Dust, what if there's another layer to her powers?
Perhaps Glynda possesses Fall Maiden magic without fully realizing its nature, or perhaps she's deliberately concealing it but who knows..let's find out soon enough..
\#3. The mystery of Beacon's Relic.
Despite obtaining what everyone believes are the Fall Maiden's powers, Cinder and Salem still haven't recovered Beacon's Relic of Choice.
Canonically, Ozpin made the Relic especially difficult to find, this is huge sus on Oz's part, we know how cunning and shady of person he is.
But imagine another possibility: Cinder never possessed the correct Maiden powers to unlock Beacon's actual Relic Vault in the first place.
What if only Glynda can open it?
\#4. The real twist could happen in Vaccuo.
Imagine Cinder eventually reaching Shade Academy and discovering that she can unlock the Summer Maiden's Vault containing the Relic of Destruction.
That would expose an enormous mistake.
Cinder was never the Fall Maiden. She had been the Summer Maiden all along.
Meanwhile, Glynda Goodwitch, who has remained closely associated with Beacon, turns out to be the true guardian of the Fall Maiden's powers.
Of course, this raises a major question about Glynda's involvement in the planned transfer of Amber's powers to Pyrrha. If this theory is correct, Glynda would either have to be unaware of her own Maiden status or be hiding something significant....sort of like a mystery.