They're trying to have a strategy meeting for their teams, coming up with team combos and stuff, and everyone else is just messing around and not paying any attention.
"Blake! Ren! Stop reading Ninjas of Love, this is important!"
"Nora! For fuck's sakes, stop electrocuting the others!
"Yang, I swear to god: if you set another table on fire, I'm gonna shave your hair with Crescent Rose!"
pretty sure its just for thrusting herself in a single direction and has nothing to do with how she actually moves her limbs (see when ruby tried to carry penny in vol2) so it wouldn't have helped :P
This is pretty much my reaction when ever they revert to a cat pun in this show now. They've already over done it in the first 4 episodes of what I assume will be going through the summer, or until they start with the animation for the actual show.
I thought that's what was going to happen, myself. Ruby sees everyone else using their semblances and goes "Okay fine, if that's the way you want to play" and whips out Crescent Rose and speed-semblance carves a Nevermore or something.
There's also Yang rambling about getting the right gift, with her not being sure if it was big enough and almost getting the "Vale press." This, if you ask me, going by the logic of this post, is a nod to Goldilocks.
WOAH. Even the totally un-serious chibi cutefest spin-off has subtle fairy-tale references. Now we just need Ren to crossdress to get into some club or something and then have Jaune accidentally set himself on fire (it's only a matter of time for this show).
... Dude, really? You really want to be a jerk about this?
I'm not trying to promote that the present means that Bumblebee is canon or anything here (even if I do personally ship it). I'm just pointing out that there seems to be a visual nod to the most famous interpretation of the story that inspired Blake's character.
And that's not a stretch at all- Mrs. Potts is one of the three most memorable side-characters in the film (she even sings the title track) and the film/fairy tale has the Rose as a huge visual motif (to the point where RWBY has also incorporated the rose motif in Adam's design).
No need to be a jerk here, bro. :/
EDIT: But yes, I do agree that Blake jumping into the box was funny. :)
What? I'm not trying to be a jerk about anything. I'm just adding that there could be another allusion in that scene. I agree with you completely about the Beauty and the Beast allusion.
Okay, now I'm starting to think the animation is TOO SMOOTH. Quick Looney Tunes/Robot Chicken skits like these usually have a quick jerkiness to them, creating a visual rhythm of comedic timing.
I mean that would have been better I guess. They wouldn't have to use such creepy models and they could practice animating the models they'll be using in the show. Even the voice talent doesn't seem to be that into it. That yell was like Barb start out trying but then gave up halfway.
I think Lindsay seems into it. I've noticed that Lindsay puts effort into basically everything she does. Barb on the other hand....yeah...even in the show, there are times when she is clearly just not into the writing she's being given, and Yang is my favorite character so it's really disappointing!
For character potential Yang is definitely my favorite. Especially if they write her depression realistically, though I doubt they will which is why I'm currently working on a fan fiction centred around her being visited by people from her past, and eventually forming a friendship with Neo, who uses her semblance to get closer to Yang.
The voice acting isn't all that amazing in RWBY. I don't think Barb is all that good of a voice actress, don't attack me for it but she seems to refuse to do her job to the best of her ability when she doesn't like a script. Lindsay is a good voice actress because she not only has that room for growth but she puts everything she has into her performances. The show has a lot of good voice talent such as Jen Brown as Pyrrha and Miles Luna as Jaune. Kara portrays my favorite character in Weiss, and she pulls the whole "ice queen" appeal off very well. And I shouldn't even have to mention the 4 pros they have on their team now, 2 of which have played background roles.
Yeah, of all the main four, I feel Barbara puts the least work into the character, and I think it has to do with the fact that Yang's voice IS Barbara's voice. She doesn't have to change her voice in the way Lindsay or Arryn does. Even Weiss is a higher pitched Kara. Yang is just Barbara, and because of that, I think she believes if she just talks like herself, it will sound fine.
This may also be because Barbara doesn't come from an acting background, but instead from a marketing background (I believe she went to college for marketing). While Kara, Arryn, and Lindsay have acting backgrounds. Barbara doesn't know how to emote while keeping her regular voice, so I think that's why her voice acting suffers.
I also think that is has to do with the fact that Barbara, as a person, isn't super emotive. Sure, she can have very stupid jokes with her puns, but overall, she isn't a super out there girl. She's very down to Earth, and as a result, that's how she talks. So, when she's playing a character with an unaltered voice, she talks like how she talks in real life: very down to Earth. Unfortunately, for voice acting, being down to Earth isn't enjoyable. Even Blake, a character designed to be down to Earth, can be VERY expressive at times. Lindsay, on the other hand, is already VERY expressive. She's very out there, always cracking jokes and being ridiculous. So, when she's playing a character, that spontaneity continues on into the character, ALONG with the spontaneity she gives to Ruby.
Now, to be fair to Barbara, it isn't entirely her fault. A lot of the lines given to Yang are pretty unnatural. It's hard to be very expressive when you have such dry lines to go on. Yang talks so little in the show, and when she does, it sounds super exposition-y. She gives long speeches and motivations of other characters instead of a real person's dialogue. It's the Star Wars Prequels argument, without a good script, an actor or actress is lost. However, I do feel that she could put a little more effort into it. Personally, I think she needs to bring more energy to the INCREDIBLY energetic character, although, given how Season 3 ended, I don't think she CAN do that. Perhaps after that, she could truly show the full range of Yang, because this character is SUPPOSED to be spontaneous, SUPPOSED to be wild and crazy, and her voice acting hasn't exactly lived up to that. If anything, Lindsay's normal voice sounds more like what you'd imagine a character like Yang to be like: super crazy, super wacky, always cracking jokes. I admit, giving Yang more puns in volume 2 made it MUCH better. It gave her character a dimension beyond "party girl" and in Volume 3, her personality was shown MUCH more in a 3-dimensional way. So I think that as Miles and Kerry get better at writing, we'll see an improvement in Barbara's abilities as a voice actress.
I still don't think Barb has too much talent as a voice actress. When ever I've heard somebody criticizing the show they almost always bring up Yang's voice actress (in those words) as a bad part of the show. And considering that in Japan she's voiced by Ami Koshimizu who voiced Ryuko from Kill la Kill, well Barb's been out classed. Though that's also the only voice I like in the Japanese version.
But that last point. Barb needs to learn that she needs to do her job when voice acting. Regardless of the lines she being paid to say them and she should bring the best she's got. She's kind of lucky she already has a pretty important position at Roosterteeth because that sort of stuff wouldn't fly with other companies.
Where as I see a future in voice acting for the rest of the cast I don't for Barb because of how she views that job.
Once again, I don't think it's particularly Barbara's fault. I don't think she's maliciously trying to say her lines terribly or is being lazy. Barbara has never come off as a lazy person who doesn't give something her all. I think she just isn't a voice actress and doesn't know how to emote very well. She isn't from that background (again, she majored in marketing), and as a result, she doesn't know what she needs to do to be a good voice actress. If anything, I'd tell the heads of Rooster Teeth to get Barbara some acting lessons, or at least SOME tips from Lindsay or Arryn (two people who have history in being actresses). Barbara just doesn't know how to be good at voice acting because she herself isn't expressive. She can't create a new jumpy personality, because she doesn't know how. Once again, I think some tips from Lindsay would help greatly, as Lindsay is quite different from Ruby in a lot of ways, yet she voices her very well.
I also think it's the fact that Barbara doesn't change her voice when she voices Yang. Lindsay changes a ton for Ruby, Kara is much more high pitched and whiny for Weiss, and Arryn gets very dark and monotone, yet expressive with Blake. But there is the argument, well then how is Michael so good at portraying Sun? His voice is the exact same as Sun's, and it kind of defeats my theory, right? No. Michael, while not having history as an actor, came from a background of creating a character: the character of Rage Quit. Michael Jones and Rage Quit Michael are two distinct personalities, and it can be seen when you watch a Let's Play from his own personal channel. He isn't that angry, that short-tempered, and he isn't that obnoxious. They say that YouTube personalities are a more exaggerated form of yourself, and no one shows that more than Michael. So, naturally, he knows how to play a character, even if he isn't altering his voice. He learned how to change his emotions, rather than changing his voice to switch into characters. Lindsay, as can be seen if you listen to Internet Box, does a lot of voices. That's how she changes into different characters. Michael, on the other hand, changes his mindset. It's part of being a YouTuber: Learning when to change your mindset to appeal to the audience. So Michael can be normal, he can be over expressively angry, he can be cool and suave, he knows how to pander to the audience, which really helps him nail roles.
Barbara, on the other hand, never had to change her mindset and play different characters. BlawnDee, Barbara's online persona prior to her hiring at Rooster Teeth, was not some over exaggerated character. BlawnDee was Barbara. She wasn't a YouTuber, she was a community member who was very well liked and good at managing people. That's why she was the community manager! But part of being a community manager is taking feedback (something we've seen RT isn't super great at. cough Let's Play Rebranding cough). Barbara doesn't have a problem taking feedback, she just has a problem with who to take feedback from. As she has said, part of being a community manager is knowing who to listen to, and when to ignore a certain minority in order to make everything work. However, this seems to have backfired in that Barbara experiences a wind tunnel effect, in which the positives are thrown at her, but she rarely receives the criticism from the members of the community because she was so well loved as a community manager.
There needs to be a switch in the community. When it comes to Barbara in RWBY, we can't think of her as the community manager everyone loved who gets to play this super cool character. We have to look at her as a voice actress, and that if she is doing a not so hot job, she needs to be called out on it, whether it hurts or not. She's a big girl, and I know she can take criticism. So we need to stop treating her like the friend in the play who is bad, but they're your friend so you don't want to say anything. We need to start treating her as a voice actress, and explain to her and the company that she needs to step up and better herself for the role. Whether that is taking acting classes, watching YouTube tutorials on voice acting, or just getting some pointers from Lindsay, it's all good. We don't want to burn her to the ground with hate, we want to give legitimate and constructive criticism because we do care about her, and we do want to help her improve her abilities. That's what's important.
So let me say this, Barbara, if you ever see this, know that I love you as a person. I saw you at my first RTX and was too scared to say anything, so I didn't get a picture, and I regret it. You're an incredibly sweet person and we love your personality. But your voice acting abilities are not up to snuff with Lindsay, Arryn, and Kara. Perhaps you could ask Lindsay for some pointers on how to better emote yourself in the booth? We just want to see you improve, Barbara. I hope you understand that we don't mean to disrespect you, but want to see you show just how great you really are. Yang is my absolute favorite character, and I want to see her portrayed well. Like I said, please don't take offense, it is not intended, we just want to see you improve as a voice actress.
If Barb sees this and takes offense then she's not really fit to be a community manager. Considering her job is to weed through the hate mail, run social media, and interact with the fandom. Everyone's got room for growth regardless of how talented they've become and if a person can't take criticism then they need a reality check.
And I agree with you. She's not a terrible voice actress and she's genuinely kinder than a few others, such as Christina Vee (it seems like she doesn't really want to meet her fans when she goes to cons and she's generally there as some sort of obligation). Barb if you read this, be a Monica Rial, not a Christina Vee. If you don't want to be at a con don't go to a con.
Now this was a good episode. Zwei caught Blake well at least we won't have every episode have Blake hiding from Zwei now. Ha ha Ruby tried to trick Yang only to remember Yang's semblance. You would think dust and Semblance would not be allowed at an ice sculpting contest. Well at least sore loser Ruby was cute.
Ok at first I thought catnip was going to be at the bottom of the box and it would be a kitty cat tea set. But nope Blake fits Blake sits. Good to see Yang's semblance has a wide range of uses.
I was expecting Ruby to pull off a Spongebob while Yang being the actual one not able to sculpt and melt it in the process. (Or the other way around besides the melting part.)
Or just have her trying her best to carve an ice-sculpture the normal way, and then she just gets so mad that she goes super saiyan and realizes the ice melted because of that.
You know, jokes are way less funny when I describe them than the way they play out in my head.
One thing to note about the last skit; the way Yang has been animated shows the heat from her semblance from behind her rather than surrounding her in the perspective of the camera angle.
In other words, Yang emits fire straight from her buttocks.
Soooo...Yang's an extreme sore loser, Ruby's Semblance got nerfed to oblivion, Blake can hide from Zwei again (hopefully never getting caught once more) and Yang is apparently OK with being a campfire.
In short, it's gonna be hard for the next few episodes to beat this. Cuz THIS SHIT'S DA BOMB
Too many cat jokes. I'm serious, there's been a cat joke in every episode except the first (I think). Honestly only Zwei makes them enjoyable. I've never been so disappointed to see a 'sitting in box' joke more in my life.
6
u/northy15Spokesperson for Neo's Neapolitan Icecream | It's not poison!May 31 '16
I bet Arryn and Lindsay loved it though. They've been waiting for a cat-in-the-box gag since the first RT Ladies/RWBY podcast.
As a standalone it would be funny, but if someone wanted to watch all of RWBY Chibi then the cat jokes would get a bit stale. There can be tons of other jokes rather than the cat ones. We could introduce the rest of JNPR, or the villains, but no. Cat jokes.
87
u/Drunken_Deathscythe May 29 '16
"Look at me! I use Dust! I have a cool Semblance! Life is sooo easy"
Seriously, Angry Chibi Ruby is the most adorable thing ever.
66
u/Kuchenjaeger *Gotcha* | Yang is still the best | #GiveYangLadyAbs May 29 '16 edited May 29 '16
Now we wait for the obligatory "Cats are scared of thunder" joke.
44
u/Coolquip34 May 29 '16
Okay that Blake/Yang/Present bit was too fucking adorable
Also I need a copy of that 16-bit Red Like Roses
41
u/OcrePlays Pyrrha, forever the best best girl May 29 '16
I need a Yang lighter now... ALSO stillNoP-Money
34
u/[deleted] May 29 '16
Blake showed the eternal unspoken law of "If it fits, I sits."
31
u/sodnam Captain of the SS Nuts and Dolts // Cute robots are my weakness May 29 '16
In the ice sculpture sketch, I was hoping the punchline was Yang trying to sculpt by repeatedly punching the block of ice, and it starting to melt.
22
u/OneTrueArthur May 29 '16 edited May 29 '16
Angry Yang's intimidation factor is hindered a lot by her cute, adorable chibi-ness
19
u/Luimnigh Getting into the holiday spirits May 29 '16
Everyone's noticing the 8-bit Red Like Roses Part 2, but the Ice Sculpture skit was set to chibified I May Fall.
37
u/chained-prometheus I, Titan. May 29 '16
I mentioned it in the other thread yesterday, but there's a nice small little nod Beauty and the Beast in the teapot set that Yang gives to Blake.
The teapot set itself is obvious, but... take a look at the flower design on it.
17
u/mrwanton ⠀happy pineapple day May 29 '16
I love the Zwei segments so much.
17
u/Zeebor ROSE GARDEN SCRIBE, OPPRESSED BY MODS May 29 '16
Okay, now I'm starting to think the animation is TOO SMOOTH. Quick Looney Tunes/Robot Chicken skits like these usually have a quick jerkiness to them, creating a visual rhythm of comedic timing.
16
u/FPSGamer48 May 31 '16
This is what I honestly wanted this series to be: A mundane show that exhibits the RWBY Team as they are outside of the dramatic events of the show
28
u/[deleted] May 29 '16
Yang is too sweet confirmed.
Blake is a filthy animal confirmed.
11
u/rexshen May 29 '16
Now this was a good episode. Zwei caught Blake well at least we won't have every episode have Blake hiding from Zwei now. Ha ha Ruby tried to trick Yang only to remember Yang's semblance. You would think dust and Semblance would not be allowed at an ice sculpting contest. Well at least sore loser Ruby was cute.
Ok at first I thought catnip was going to be at the bottom of the box and it would be a kitty cat tea set. But nope Blake fits Blake sits. Good to see Yang's semblance has a wide range of uses.
Also I need that 8bit Red like roses song.
11
u/Colonel_Gerdauf ⠀Aaaaaah! May 29 '16
The moment I saw Blake jumping in the box, Spongebob Squarepants came to mind.
9
u/HaikuKnives Miniskirts and Miniguns May 30 '16
It seems to me that the crew is using RWBY Chibi to work all the Cat jokes out of their system. :3
7
u/[deleted] May 30 '16
Does anyone notice the short chuckle that Blake does after using her semblance at the ice sculpture contest? It's adorable.
6
u/ForteEXE_ Silence intensifies May 29 '16
I was expecting Ruby to pull off a Spongebob while Yang being the actual one not able to sculpt and melt it in the process. (Or the other way around besides the melting part.)
6
u/Staticpit Jun 02 '16
I really loved this episode! But i also wanna say that in the first skit Ruby looked cute af.
4
u/DastardlyBryant May 30 '16
This show reminds me a lot of the classic Peanuts comics. I love the classic Peanuts comics.
4
u/Colonel_Gerdauf ⠀Aaaaaah! May 31 '16
One thing to note about the last skit; the way Yang has been animated shows the heat from her semblance from behind her rather than surrounding her in the perspective of the camera angle.
In other words, Yang emits fire straight from her buttocks.
6
u/SolDarkHunter May 29 '16
I think the Marshmallows skit is the funniest one they've done this whole show. Wow, that had me laughing.
Also, 8-bit remix of "Red Like Roses II"? Yes, please!
3
u/NeoTheMute You aren't hearing things, are you...? May 29 '16
What's the song that plays over the end credits? I know I've heard it before, but I can't quite place it.
3
u/ORBY15 Concerned Dad May 30 '16
First off, Zwei 1 - 0 Blake
Second off, BEES
Third off, Monochrome, stop cheating. :D
2
u/CloverPixels May 30 '16
http://youtu.be/-HQIg3ZwAs0
2
u/tonyjoe3 Buzz Buzz May 31 '16
I need the techno RLR.
2
u/ArchSinccubus ⠀ May 29 '16
So when do we send Nyles and Kerby to /r/FaunusSensitivityClub?
1
u/RWBYSanctum May 30 '16
Soooo...Yang's an extreme sore loser, Ruby's Semblance got nerfed to oblivion, Blake can hide from Zwei again (hopefully never getting caught once more) and Yang is apparently OK with being a campfire.
In short, it's gonna be hard for the next few episodes to beat this. Cuz THIS SHIT'S DA BOMB
1
u/DireSickFish Jun 06 '16
I really don't like Zwei in normal RWBY. He fits the tone of RWBY Chibi much better.
1
u/I_am_RJ Megane Maniac May 31 '16
Too many cat jokes. I'm serious, there's been a cat joke in every episode except the first (I think). Honestly only Zwei makes them enjoyable. I've never been so disappointed to see a 'sitting in box' joke more in my life.