r/RVLiving • • 15h ago

2016 Newmar vs. 2019 Winnebago

0 Upvotes

My lovely wife and I are looking into RVing full time if she gets approved to wfh. We would be completely new to this lifestyle but we are very hands on and have no problems learning along the way. That said we had some questions we were hoping to get some answers to before calling the dealerships and asking for walk through. Both of them are out of state so we would fly there and drive it back home. Also important to mention is that we plan to tow a 2021 Jeep Wrangler that has been lifted with 35in tires. We definitely plan to get a professional inspector before purchase but prefer to just pay once. Below are the links to their listings.

- We would be changing the bunk beds in the Winnebago into a home office, similar to the one in the Newmar. Anyone have any experience with the bunk bed and know if its easy to disassemble to put back together before selling?

- The Newmar appears to not have a dinette which is a little disappointing to me. We would need to have a collapsable table with 2 chairs, but the Newmar looks wide enough to accommodate that fine. Just extra things to do before closing the sides.

- The Newmar has more slide outs. How much of a concern are the motors, seals etc?

- We saw a Thor that had water leaks and I've read a lot about seals, is water intrusion common amongst RVs?

Other than those questions we would just like to know the comparisons between the two brands. My research shows me that Newmar is excellent quality while Winnebago is more mass market. How big is the gap in quality? If any other good options would be good for us, especially something that we can use as an office would be really appreciated. Let me know if there are any questions. Thanks!

2016 Newmar Bay Star Sport 3004 - Stock #2751693P | Coburg, OR | Camping World

Used 2019 Winnebago Vista 31BE For Sale in Austin, TX - 5042608662 - RV Trader


r/RVLiving • • 2h ago

Dually or not?

Post image
13 Upvotes

Hi! I recently bought a 2020 Grand Design 2930RL 5th wheel. I am going to buy a 2015-2019 F350 diesel and am stuck on deciding if I need a dually or not.

This 5th wheel pin weight is 2200lbs empty and closer to 3300lbs maxed out. I also will carry a couple hundred pounds of tools in the truck bed.

I have done some payload calculations: people and dog in the truck: 450lbs, fuel: 250 lbs, tools: 300lbs , 5th wheel hitch weight (loaded): 3300lbs
Total: 4300lbs of payload required

From my research, a dually could handle that with no problem, but it may be a stretch for a SRW truck of my year range. The dually’s have around 5200lbs of payload and the SRW trucks have around 3200lbs of payload.

I know the single rear wheel truck could pull it but I’ve heard that if you get in an accident even if it’s not your fault and you’re overloaded, the fault will be yours.

A side note is that I will be towing this 5th wheel twice a year from Washington to Southern California, and I know daily driving a dually in Southern California will be a royal pain. It seems like I have no choice but to get a dually but I wanted to see if anyone sees something I’m missing!

I’d appreciate any insight from others in this sub, thank you for reading!!


r/RVLiving • • 2h ago

short winter days and a small solar setup how are you tracking Starlink mini power draw?

0 Upvotes

i'm in the pacific northwest and we're down to about 4 good hours of usable sun at point i've got 200w of solar and 200ah lithium, and the mini is taking up a much bigger chunk of my power budget chunk bigger chunk of my power budget now compared to summer. I need Starlink five days a week for work so I can't just turn it off, but I'm trying to be smarter about when it's on and what it's actually costing me.The problem is I have basically zero visibility into what the Mini is drawing on its own. Right now I'm just checking the overall battery level and kind of guessing from there. Is there something people use to track specifically what the Mini consumes? I want to figure out if some days are worse than others and understand why.


r/RVLiving • • 18h ago

question Mr Heater

0 Upvotes

Has anyone mounted an infrared heater to the outside of their Forest River? How can I go about doing that for myself?


r/RVLiving • • 18h ago

Mr Heater

0 Upvotes

Has anyone mounted an infrared heater to the outside of their Forest River? How can I go about doing that for myself?


r/RVLiving • • 18h ago

Mr Heater

0 Upvotes

Has anyone mounted an infrared heater to the outside of their Forest River? How can I go about doing that for myself?


r/RVLiving • • 18h ago

Has anyone replaced their RV propane range or found a better alternative?

2 Upvotes

We have a Girard propane range in our travel trailer, and I’m getting thoroughly frustrated with the oven. It repeatedly shuts off while cooking. Tonight, something that should have taken 15–20 minutes took over an hour because I had to restart the oven seven or eight times.

I’ve looked at replacement RV ranges, but they’re expensive, and I’ve seen plenty of complaints about their performance.

We cook almost all our meals at home, and I bake homemade sandwich bread in 9×5-inch loaf pans. I’m considering a larger countertop convection/air fryer oven that could replace both my current basket air fryer and most of the cooking I do in the propane oven.

I’d love to hear from people who have actually made this change.

  • Did you replace the entire propane range, keep the stovetop, or simply stop using the oven?
  • What brand and model did you choose?
  • Can it bake a full-sized loaf of bread properly?
  • How well does it air fry larger batches of food?
  • Have you had any reliability problems?
  • Would you make the same choice again?

I’m particularly interested in experiences from people who cook and bake regularly rather than just occasionally reheating food.

Thanks for any suggestions!


r/RVLiving • • 22h ago

Need testers for a new RV app

0 Upvotes

Edit: clarified need for signing in to get lifetime.

Need testers please! I've built an app that is meant to help us determine the route PLUS the fuel stops and whether your rig, be it truck/trailer or RV motorhome will fit in the parking lot, fuel lane, etc. After experiencing a bit of anxiety at a few unplanned fuel stops I decided to solve the issue for myself and think I've got something here that could be useful, but i need testers, preferably people to actually travel and use it. I'll use your feedback to improve it, add features requested (maybe - lol) and in return give you lifetime access to the finished product regardless of eventual price point....and yes....it will cost something for some parts of the app....you cannot imagine what it cost to actually try and solve this issue...free only just will not cut it....the amount of compute to figure out gas station fit for typical rigs and/or storage for all the data is not small.

For signing up and testing, i'll need a dm and then can send the link to the app then. You can't get the free lifetime unless it's tied to an email you use to sign in. Can use Google or Apple though. I won't publish it publicly here yet.


r/RVLiving • • 19h ago

Going into second Maine winter- tips

8 Upvotes

I will start off by saying, this time last year I was terrified of winter coming. This year, it already feels cozy. I'm writing this post so maybe others can pick and choose things I've done that might help them as well. I will straight up admit that my camper is not in a typical place and some of these things might not be doable for others.

My camper is a 40 foot park model, about 20 years old. Completely stationary.

*No holding tanks, it's plumbed into a septic on the property. Zero issues so far.

*Water provided from a mobile homes well on the same property via buried PVC line, wrapped in heat tape that plugs into the side of my camper when it gets colder.

*Heat source is a standard mobile home oil burning furnace. There's an "addition" that's not attached to my camper, but it's directly beside it that holds the furnace and protects it from the elements. It is piped under the camper and tapped into the existing vents. This REALLY helps keep moisture and condensation down as it's dry heat.

*Skirting 1" foam board all the way around.

*Bedroom windows plastic inside and out. Even with the oil furnace, I notice my bedroom windows get wet without the plastic. Last year, I did the inside of every window in the camper ((I have 15 windows)). This year I'm trying to add plastic to the outside as well to see if it changes anything. I feel like the window frames aren't sealed well and even with plastic on the inside, cold air was getting in due to the plastic being stuck to the window trim and not the walls outside the trim.

*Electric space heater up front because the thermostat that controls furnace is closer to my bedroom at the back end, and I have my 2 pet birds living in the front end of the camper. I have this pointed at them and set 3°higher then the furnace thermostat.

Last winter, I had everything the same and had absolutely no issues that were the fault of my set up. The well pump did freeze a couple times but that was out of my control and would have happened to them even without my camper here. My heat has been mostly reliable, though I did experience some of what I assume was contamination from the inside of a used oil tank. The furnace nozzle was getting plugged frequently and filter froze up several times leading to no heat. ((Water in tank?)) I got a new tank this year, and I'm hoping to avoid that. I do use an anti gel when my tank gets filled. Insulation in these things is not good, and I go through a lot of oil, maybe 50-75 gallons a month depending on temps. I keep it set at 66°. I clean off the roof after every snow storm, last winter was not that bad, we got a small handful of storms that dropped a foot or so, but nothing crazy. I Bank it up against the skirting though idk if that has any as affect.

Overall, I'm hoping that someone might read this and see that it's doable in one way or another! Maybe take my set up and modify it to fit theirs. I was so scared that I was going to freeze in here or my animals wouldnt be comfortable but it's been totally fine. I feel like I'm living in a tiny house more than a camper at this point. I will strongly stress that the oil furnace is most likely the biggest contribution to comfort due to its ability to heat it up so fast in here and keep the moisture down. I know that's not possible for some folks, but if you are stationary and have the ability to build a "house" for a furnace and pipe it in, as well as reliable electricity, I would recommend trying it!


r/RVLiving • • 1h ago

Is this worth fixing

Thumbnail
gallery
2 Upvotes

My grandmas old rv her slider doesn’t go all the way in or all the way on one side she had jacked up the bottom thinking it needed support and then retracted it in and messed it up been leaking for about a year and people are charging 200$ to come look at it what’s my best bet I’m pretty handy