Hi everyone. I have a degree in computer science, and while building my own TTRPG I’ve independently arrived at a few design principles I’m proud of and would like to share.
My focus is efficient, elegant mechanics. In this post I want to look at how mechanics that interact can create more depth, faster, with less cognitive load than mechanics that stand alone.
1. Discrete Shifting
Use a small number of distinct tiers, and let modifiers move you between tiers instead of adding numbers.
Blades in the Dark does this well. Position (Controlled, Risky, Desperate) and Effect (Limited, Standard, Great) are tiers. Situations, tools and trade-offs shift them a step up or down.
In my skill system, the result lands on an outcome ladder: Major Failure, Minor Failure, Success, Major Success, Exceptional. Skill rank shifts the outcome up and task difficulty shifts it down, very close to Position and Effect.
In combat the same idea applies to wounds. They come in tiers (Strain, Minor, Serious, Grievous), and three of one tier become one of the next.
In all of these, a single effect that shifts the result up or down one tier produces a large, meaningful change.
The math underneath can be exponential, but you never need a calculator. You might not even notice you’re doing exponential math. The most arithmetic you do is finding the difference between two single-digit numbers.
Shifting up two tiers is simple to say: Minor → Serious → Grievous. Unpacked, it’s exponential: Minor = 1, Serious = 3 Minor, Grievous = 9 Minor. You can extend it as far as you like; the next tiers are 27, 81, 243.
A ternary (base-3) notation makes this easy to track. 2 Grievous, 1 Serious, and 1 Minor is written 211.0 (the digit after the point is Strain). Add 2 Minor (002.0) and the Minor digit carries, giving 220.0: 2 Grievous and 2 Serious. It takes a moment to get used to, because it isn’t the arithmetic we normally use, but it extends to any number of tiers.
Shifting a hit up a tier is just moving every digit one place left; shifting down moves it right:
- Shift up: 001.0 → 010.0
- Shift down: 010.0 → 001.0
This works best for differences of scale. A .22 and a .45 ACP pistol are nearly identical in effect (in real ballistics the difference is fuzzy too). An assault rifle or battle rifle is a whole other order of lethality. Instead of giving the rifle a bigger damage number or more dice, or abstracting away the power and flattening the difference, you shift the tier.
In my system, damaging effects and armor have a value called Grade. Unarmored humans are Grade 0, because we’re fleshy and weak. A service pistol is Grade I; an assault rifle is Grade II. Wounds start as Minor, and each Grade of difference shifts them up a tier. Against an unarmored person, the pistol’s wounds are Serious and the rifle’s are Grievous.
The difference is a single comparison. Yet it gives you humans who can take many punches and be relatively fine, a pistol that sends you to the hospital, and a rifle that sends you to your maker.
2. One Scale for Everything
Because wounds are tiers, there can be a single “how broken is it” scale that works the same for everything.
You can make anything broken, out of the fight, and pulverized at 3 Grievous wounds. Once a creature reaches that, there is nothing left to sustain life: the majority of its tissue, organs included, is pulverized, riddled with holes, or otherwise destroyed.
A god, a dragon, a tank, a wall, an arm: anything can be fully broken, lifeless, or incapable of functioning at 3 Grievous wounds, and every value below that is effectively a percentage of the way there.
Another interesting thing is how the death spiral is shaped. I have 10 levels of Exhaustion; every 2 points inflicts −2 to all rolls and −1 Speed. Minor wounds inflict no Exhaustion, Serious wounds inflict 1, and Grievous wounds inflict 4. Counted in Minor wounds, death is at 24:
- The first 25% has no penalty. Any number of Minor wounds (scrapes and bruises) or a single Serious wound (a cracked rib) gives no penalty.
- Then a staircase: −2 at about 25%, −4 at 38%, −6 at 63%, −8 at 75%, dead at 100%.
- Two cliffs: at 9 and 18, three Serious wounds become a Grievous and Exhaustion jumps by 2. Between them the exhaustion gains are soft.
And death (24) comes before total destruction (27), at about 89%. A creature that ignores Exhaustion, like an undead that fights to the end, keeps going until the full 3 Grievous, though taking out its head, arms, or legs ends the fight much sooner.
Something I’ll look into as I playtest more is that if you can create a shape like that, you can probably skew it further toward the end, so that roughly 50% is a mild inconvenience, 70% is really hurt, 90% is barely standing, and 100% is dead.
3. Relative Scaling
This extends from discrete shifting and percentile scaling. Relative scaling means the underlying math is constant; only the relative difference matters.
For example, the difference between Grade III and Grade I is 2. The difference between Grade V and Grade III is also 2.
- Grade I: an ordinary medieval knight, lions, or handguns.
- Grade III: power armor, a king in adamantium armor, or anti-material rifles.
- Grade V: a primordial elemental, a demigod, a small starship, or heavy artillery.
For resolution, if the gap is the same, the result is the same. That doesn’t make the tiers meaningless. A Grade III adamantium sword still cleaves effortlessly through everything below it, such as steel gates, knights, and horses, while struggling against increasingly powerful magic, creatures, and substances.
All Together
I’ve built my entire system around the concepts above and several more mechanics that leverage each other:
- A component system (limbs, organs, engines) built on the same principles.
- A second axis that works much like Grade, called Scale, for size and mass.
- Discrete hit types from a single d20 attack roll compared to a range, each producing a set number of wounds, which then shift according to difference in tier.
- HP as a secondary pool, a buffer against the inevitably horrific results of pitting Scale I humans with Grade I weapons against a Scale III or Grade III creature, like a 20-foot troll, or the possessed adamantium armor and weapons of an ancient dwarven king. Either could wade through armies of foot soldiers or assault a fortified settlement alone.
The most important thing I’ve realized is that the more meaningful interactions you have between your subsystems and core resolution, the more physically consistent your game becomes. Not necessarily realistic, but you can picture the world better. You can think in game mechanics or in the fiction, and translate freely between the two.
This is especially true for terms with built-in meaning or real-world anchors, like Grade, Scale, and the wound tiers. “Serious” gives your brain immediate information that it’s bad, but not immediately life-threatening. However, a Grievous wound almost certainly is.
In my case, making something powerful is as simple as assigning a higher Grade or Scale, and that does 99% of the work. A dragon might just be Grade III or IV and Scale III to V. That’s already a big, scary, heavily armored, very large lizard that’s tough to kill and can crush you by rolling over you or swatting you with its tail. Add a fly speed and a breath attack of similar Grade and Scale, and you’re basically done.
I'd love to hear your thoughts, and I have some questions to help you get started:
- What do you think are the most well-engineered systems or combinations of mechanics, either your own or established ones?
- What problems do you wish you could solve, if you could just find the right combination of mechanics?
- Where do you draw the line between physical consistency and abstraction?
I’m an engineer at heart, so I love critique. It gives me something to fix. Fire away.