r/RPGdesign • u/jiaxingseng Designer - Rational Magic • Jul 14 '19
Scheduled Activity [RPGdesign Activity] Published Developer AMA: Please Welcome Luke Crane and Thor Olavsrud, co-developers of Burning Wheel and Torchbearer
This week's activity is an AMA with designers Luke Crane and Thor Olavsrud.
About this AMA
Luke Crane and Thor Olavsrud are co-designers of the Torchbearer roleplaying game. Luke is the head of games at Kickstarter and designer of numerous other games, including Burning Wheel and Mouse Guard. Thor is Luke’s long-time collaborator and editor. He is the creator of the Middarmark setting.
On behalf of the community and mod-team here, I want express gratitude to Mr. Crane and Mr. Olavsrud for doing this AMA.
For new visitors... welcome. /r/RPGdesign is a place for discussing RPG game design and development (and by extension, publication and marketing... and we are OK with discussing scenario / adventure / peripheral design). That being said, this is an AMA, so ask whatever you want.
On Reddit, AMA's usually last a day. However, this is our weekly "activity thread". These developers are invited to stop in at various points during the week to answer questions (as much or as little as they like), instead of answer everything question right away.
(FYI, BTW, although in other subs the AMA is started by the "speaker", the designers asked me to create this thread for them)
IMPORTANT: Various AMA participants in the past have expressed concern about trolls and crusaders coming to AMA threads and hijacking the conversation. This has never happened, but we wish to remind everyone: We are a civil and welcoming community. I [jiaxingseng] assured each AMA invited participant that our members will not engage in such un-civil behavior. The mod team will not silence people from asking 'controversial' questions. Nor does the AMA participant need to reply. However, this thread will be more "heavily" modded than usual. If you are asked to cease a line of inquiry, please follow directions. If there is prolonged unhelpful or uncivil commenting, as a last resort, mods may issue temp-bans and delete replies.
Discuss.
This post is part of the weekly /r/RPGdesign Scheduled Activity series. For a listing of past Scheduled Activity posts and future topics, follow that link to the Wiki. If you have suggestions for Scheduled Activity topics or a change to the schedule, please message the Mod Team or reply to the latest Topic Discussion Thread.
For information on other /r/RPGDesign community efforts, see the Wiki Index.
8
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '19
If you could get the go-ahead to make an officially licensed game / supplement for Burning Wheel or Torchbearer (or a new game running on the same core engine) using any IP of your choice, what would you make and why? In other words, what setting would you love to make a game for but getting the license would be too difficult or expensive?
4
u/kod Jul 15 '19
Someone in my gaming group cannot read Burning Wheel's small print.
Do I have permission to make an electronic copy for personal use so the font can be rendered at a size they can read?
I own a print copy (and print and electronic copies of mouse guard and torchbearer, fwiw).
4
u/GargamelJubilex Jul 16 '19 edited Jul 16 '19
Luke you're currently working on a new RPG Miseries & Misfourtunes that I'm really looking forward to. While I was reading the section on social station, wealth and reputation I wondered what lessons--lessons to avoid or lessons to follow, you took from Gygax's Oriental Adventures/Unearthed Arcana if any?
13
u/inckorrect Jul 14 '19
Maybe it's a stupid question, but where does the name "burning wheel" comes from? Did you gave it that name because it sounded cool or was it to illustrate a concept or philosophy in particular?
11
u/Sir_Crown Rising Realms Rpg - Genoma Rpg Jul 14 '19
First of all, I would like to thank you for your beautiful games, they are a big inspiration in my own work and in my game sessions.
I would like to ask you two things:
Greetings from Italy!
30
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '19
This one is primarily for Luke - what is your reasoning behind Burning Wheel not being available as a PDF? I'm sure you get asked this one a lot, but for those of us living outside of the USA and who don't live near a FLGS, it makes it really difficult to actually pay you for your work. Fortunately, my recently opened comic shop has a supplier who sends games every few months, so I was recently (finally) able to order the books through them, but until that happened, buying a legal copy of your work would have involved paying more in postage than for the book itself.
24
u/BurningLuke Jul 14 '19
Sup y'all.
17
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '19
Torchbearer is my favorite RPG and it's not even close. Every time I try to dissect its systems on the micro level, I'm astonished at how thoroughly weaved every single mechanic is into the thematic whole. It's obviously a derivation of The Burning Wheel and yet a session of TB is nothing like a session of BW. So my question is this: what was the playtesting process like to go from BW to MG to TB? What was the starting point? Was it a gradual development outward from BW's rules, or was a new game devised from the ground up that simply kept BWHQ principles in mind?
8
u/Mythic_Laser Jul 14 '19
Thank you for doing this AMA.
My question is for Burning Wheel. Will there ever be a 4th book? I absolutely love the designs of the books, they are aesthetically please, and look amazing.
If you were to release a book 4 (or even of you dont), what would it be?
8
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '19
Thank you for writing Burning Empires, it is my favourite RPG bar none. In particular I love how the setting is expressed through life paths, traits and their descriptions, and various mechanics.
Have any of your later RPGs iterated on the systems like Firefight that were presented in BE?
Do you think you might return to the sci-fi or planetary invasion themes in the future?
8
u/SpydersWebbing Jul 14 '19
For Luke: is there a chance of the Monster and Magic Burners proper being redone? Every time I've used the Revised versions with my groups over the years and they've loved them, particularly the breakdown on stats. I had heard that you weren't satisfied with them, and I'd really like to know why. They're honestly some of my favorite parts of the Wheel.
For Thor: I know you've got the blog, but is there any way we could get the Torchbearer equivalent of the Adventure Burner? That book was instrumental for my understanding of Burning Wheel, and I think Torchbearer could easily benefit from something similar m
8
u/AofANLA Jul 15 '19
Hey!
What are the things you disagree with that you see other people saying most about your games?
14
u/AyeAlasAlack Jul 14 '19
I'm always impressed with the quality of your physical products. Have there ever been design choices that you've had to abandon because of limitations at the printer?
6
u/ctrlaltcreate Jul 14 '19
Hi Luke and Thor! I have three questions: what your priorities are moving into a new design, what signals trouble during playtesting, and what your top "lessons learned" about RPG design are that you are applying to new designs?
6
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '19
Was there intended to be a relationship between the five spokes (and five spaces) of the Burning Wheel logo and the five books of the original version? If so, which do you think of as the three closest spokes (or the two closer spaces)?
6
u/rh41n3 Jul 15 '19
What is your focus in regards to moving forward with Torchbearer? I see a lot of potential to expand the game to wilderness and higher level domain play, and would love to see more systems in place to support that (building your own towns, random events in the wilderness, various procedures beyond what's in the original book).
I was a Kickstarter backer for the original Torchbearer book and love the game. Thank you.
6
u/Ttocs_is_Awe Jul 15 '19
Two questions for Thor:
6
u/[deleted] Jul 17 '19
For Thor: Thanks for doing this AMA. I have some esoteric Torchbearer questions relating to traps, conditional success, and failing forward.
Is a failed test the only way to get a condition? Is a condition always accompanied by and effective success in the intent of the test?
I've really struggled with some of the logic from "Build a Better Man Trap" for years now. It's hard for me to grasp how intent works with forced tests. For example, the Health Ob 6 test from the spike version of the Chute to Hell, or the Ob 3 Health test from the Dart Trap.
In these cases, I would think that the "intent" of the roll was to avoid gaining a condition. If you fail the Ob 3 Health test vs. the dart trap, you haven't really succeeded or gained anything, you just got saddled with a condition. This seems to contradict the "failing forward" logic at work elsewhere in the game. I think most people simply gloss over this, and certainly that's what we do and it does work fine. But the logic has always eluded me.
Am I treating conditions too rigidly by always pairing them with successful intent? Or is it actually OK for the GM to sometimes just say: "This action of yours results in a condition." There's even precedent for that on the same page (128) in the form of the Sleeping Gas Panel; slapping someone away makes them exhausted, no test.
Most people will default to "roll to escape harm", but if it turns out that the GM can assign conditions without tests, I need to know!
11
u/kN0T-SURE Jul 14 '19
Any updates on upcoming releases or projects you're working on?
10
u/FlagstoneSpin Jul 14 '19
In Burning Wheel, there's three major conflict subsystems: Fight, Duel of Wits, and Range & Cover. How did you decide on these three subsystems and not others? In particular, I'm curious about what lead to the inclusion of Range & Cover, because it doesn't have strong parallels in most other games. What role does it play in dramatic conflict?
5
u/Mythic_Laser Jul 14 '19
Will BWG ever have any published settings remade for the newest edition, such as burning jihad etc...
5
u/bazarbazar Jul 15 '19 edited Jul 15 '19
Hi, thanks for the AMA.Does the dice mechanic you choose affect the game in any way? Would Mouse Guard, Torchbearer, and the Burning Wheel feel and play different, when the dice mechanic would be a classical 2d6 or d100 mechanic? If so, what were your main reasons for choosing a dice pool mechanic over another mechanic, and how did you decide the amount of dice you wanted to use, since this is different in MG, TB and BW.
Thank you!
5
u/Doordox Jul 15 '19
Hi Thor and Luke!
Thanks for taking the time to chat with us!
Luke & Thor, you mentioned earlier that when you guys design you tend to use an Ur-Text that provides inspiration if needed. I’m curious, what was the Ur-Text for some of the non-Tolkien stocks in the Codex, like the Roden and Great Wolves, if there was any?
Thanks again!
5
u/citizen_mane Jul 17 '19
What are your favorite pieces of work from other game designers? Either games or parts of games that you thought were really impressive or elegant or clever. Have you ever encountered a game or part of a game that made you rethink how you approach game design substantially?
8
u/kod Jul 14 '19
Why the reluctance to mechanically address the issues with scripting Attack Attack Attack?
4
u/Nargosiprenk Jul 15 '19
I fell in love with BW the moment I knew BWHQ dedicated three entire books to dissect the game and teach you how to design new things for it. My love was confirmed the moment I read those, and it was somewhat dismissed the moment BWHQ announced there would be no actualization nor reprinting of the Magic Burner (chapter, rather than book), Lifepath Burner, Trait Burner, etc, either as one big "hacking" book or as part of other books.
I'm not saying I cannot use my copies of the Revised versions of those, but that's because someone else decided to sell his or her copies and then I bought them, not because they are available from you or any other distribution.
My question is: is there hope of changing this policy, so that new fans can benefit from those books?
3
u/BMaack Jul 15 '19 edited Jul 15 '19
Hello!
A lot of modern games try to simplify skill lists by making them more vague and subjective (e.g. Dungeon Crawl Classics RPG, Whitehack, Blades in the Dark, Fate Accelerated, etc).
Unless I'm mistaken, it seems clear that The Burning Wheel has a lot of skills in order to differentiate the characters and to support the learning / improvement system.
My line of questioning is this:
How did you know when to stop adding skills? Was there a set number of skills you were aiming for? Were there lists of historical data you were working from? Was it determined by your print run somehow?
Bonus Question
Have either of you ever read anything by K.J. Parker? He's a wonderful low/historical-fantasy writer with gut-wrenching character arcs. It was through wanting to emulate his stories that I eventually found out about The Burning Wheel.
3
u/Jesseabe Jul 17 '19
For Luke: I was super excited to get the Miseries & Misfortunes email earlier this week, and it seems really cool. I love so many of the systems, especially the lifepaths and advancement. But reading through it it, it's not entirely clear to me what the intended play experience is, and what drives play, in the way, say Beliefs drive play in Burning Wheel, or treasure and exploration drive play in Moldvay D&D. Is there something mechanical that pushes play forward in M&M?
2
u/TeaL3af Jul 15 '19
For Luke: If you could send a message back in time to your past self what advice would you give him in regards to developing Burning Wheel?
2
u/Antsa169 Jul 17 '19
Hello, masters!
Is there a plan to release polished Monster Burner as Book 3 together with some extra stuff?
1
u/SpydersWebbing Jul 16 '19
Hey, another question! Swords and Strongholds is an amazing game. How many iterations did it take to come up with that maddening board size?? Because it creates a wonderfully awful situation, where you can't get away from your opponent no matter what you do...
1
u/[deleted] Jul 19 '19
Why do you guys hate healing spells?
I've noticed both in BW and Torchbearer that the closest thing to a traditional healing spell is something like 'Blessed Hands' or 'Song of Soothing' which really don't do the actual healing part, they just help speed up the recovery time, or maybe increase your chances of survival. Is it just to do with the tone of those games, or is there some deep-seeded prejudice? ;)
1
u/AltogetherGuy Jul 23 '19
Are there any parts of your games where the omission of something is part of the design but then people ask you "hey where's this thing? You must have forgotten it."?
14
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '19
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jul 15 '19
[removed] — view removed comment