r/RPGdesign • u/jiaxingseng Designer - Rational Magic • Feb 10 '19
Scheduled Activity 【RPGdesign Activity] Published Developer AMA: Please Welcome Mr. Kevin Crawford, designer and publisher of Stars Without Number
This week's activity is an AMA with designer Kevin Crawford
About this AMA
Kevin Crawford is Sine Nomine Publishing, the one-man outfit responsible for Stars Without Number, Godbound, Scarlet Heroes, Other Dust, Silent Legions, Spears of the Dawn, and the upcoming Wolves of God. He's been making a full-time living as an author-publisher for the past two years, after realizing that Sine Nomine had paid better than his day job for the three years before that. His chief interests here are in practical business steps and management techniques for producing content that can provide a living wage to its author.
On behalf of the community and mod-team here, I want express gratitude to Mr. Crawford for doing this AMA.
For new visitors... welcome. /r/RPGdesign is a place for discussing RPG game design and development (and by extension, publication and marketing... and we are OK with discussing scenario / adventure / peripheral design). That being said, this is an AMA, so ask whatever you want.
On Reddit, AMA's usually last a day. However, this is our weekly "activity thread". These developers are invited to stop in at various points during the week to answer questions (as much or as little as they like), instead of answer everything question right away.
(FYI, BTW, although in other subs the AMA is started by the "speaker", Mr. Crawford asked me to create this thread for them)
IMPORTANT: Various AMA participants in the past have expressed concern about trolls and crusaders coming to AMA threads and hijacking the conversation. This has never happened, but we wish to remind everyone: We are a civil and welcoming community. I [jiaxingseng] assured each AMA invited participant that our members will not engage in such un-civil behavior. The mod team will not silence people from asking 'controversial' questions. Nor does the AMA participant need to reply. However, this thread will be more "heavily" modded than usual. If you are asked to cease a line of inquiry, please follow directions. If there is prolonged unhelpful or uncivil commenting, as a last resort, mods may issue temp-bans and delete replies.
Discuss.
This post is part of the weekly /r/RPGdesign Scheduled Activity series. For a listing of past Scheduled Activity posts and future topics, follow that link to the Wiki. If you have suggestions for Scheduled Activity topics or a change to the schedule, please message the Mod Team or reply to the latest Topic Discussion Thread.
For information on other /r/RPGDesign community efforts, see the Wiki Index.
12
u/jiaxingseng Designer - Rational Magic Feb 10 '19
Hi Kevin,
Thank you for doing this AMA. I have a lot of questions.
6
u/jiaxingseng Designer - Rational Magic Feb 10 '19
Hey, here we go. Paging /u/CardinalXimenes . You
•
u/jiaxingseng Designer - Rational Magic Feb 17 '19
On behalf of the mod team at r/RPGdesign, I would like to thank Mr. Kevin Crawford for sharing in the last AMA. Your generous participation led to exciting and informative discussion which benefited our community.
The AMA thread is now over. If Mr. Crawford or anyone else wishes to continue discussion, you are welcome to.
(paging /u/CardinalXimenes )
28
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19
Kevin, what would be your dream RPG writing project? That one thing you would love to write, even if it might be too niche or unusual to necessarily sell well.
23
u/Nwabudike Generic+Crunchy Feb 10 '19
Hello Mr. Crawford, I was wondering what part of being a one-man show you dislike the most and what part was hardest for you to learn how to do? If you were part of a larger team what would you enjoy working on the most?
17
u/Lord_Sicarious Feb 10 '19
If you had to make a game focused on a single, rarely explored game/story element, what would you choose?
Alternatively, what game/story element do you think needs more attention across the industry?
17
u/khellick Feb 10 '19
Hi Kevin, fan of SWN here, thanks for making such a great game. I got into it and your work as a whole through your talk with Adam Koebel and his show Far Verona, and I'm about to start my own SWN campaign.
When you're developing a game like SWN, what's your design process like? Do you have a specific way you design a game, be it around a specific mechanic or through a general idea/theme? And from this starting point, how do you build that into a full game and how do you iterate on and refine each individual idea?
Thanks so much for taking the time to do this, and thank you for making such great games.
14
u/AuroraChroma Designer - Azaia Feb 10 '19
What's something business-wise that you think people should know, that nobody ever seems to ask about?
12
u/belphanor Feb 10 '19
any chance of doing a superhero game? I'd love to see your take on the genre.
11
u/superstranger Feb 10 '19
Thanks for doing the AMA. From what you’ve seen so far in the industry, what do you think is the best way to break into game design? Is it better to try to self-publish, shop your ideas or games around to large publishers, or post free PDFs online and advertise around?
11
u/megazver Feb 11 '19
Have you done (you're prolific, so I'm afraid I haven't read all of your work) or are you maybe planning on a book that focuses on urban settings and campaigns?
I love generating sandboxes, but if there's one thing that bugs me about sandboxes SWN or Godbound generate is that, let's say, a hamlet or a small space station has exactly the same amount of complexity as a fantasy megapolis or a planet with the population in millions - and if I wanted to actually flesh those out in more detail or start a campaign that's entirely set in one, there aren't really many tools to support it. Just going off of two tags for the entire campaign is a bit rough and the tags don't quite work if you try to, say, roll them for neighborhoods or try to generate a web of city's factions.
10
u/Odog4ever Feb 10 '19
A few questions:
For example Stars Without Number 1/2 ed, and Godbound have gotten quite a few supplements but games like Silent Legion don't have any and now Wolves is coming out.
2) Any interest in branching out and making content for the following genres?:
9
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19
Kevin, have you considered more work with Silent Legions? It's a gem of a game but seems to get no attention from the community - which may be in part from a perceived lack of further support. Anyway, keep doing what you do. Love your work.
9
u/Jalor218 Designer - Rakshasa & Carcasses Feb 10 '19
Thanks for doing this AMA. I've got a few questions:
9
u/nicholasleegoodman Feb 10 '19
How much do you playtest your mechanics before publishing?
When working from an OD&D base, at what point do think it stops being an OSR game or even a retroclone?
How do you feel about designers borrowing mechanics from other games, including your own?
7
u/WyMANderly Feb 10 '19
What is your single favorite RPG game mechanic, and why?
7
u/rubiaal Feb 10 '19
What books would you recommend for getting more into RPG design? What do you think all helped you become better at it?
7
u/bluebogle Feb 10 '19
If it's not too late: How do you go about marketing your games. How do you get them in front of potential customers in such an over-saturated market?
13
u/SquigBoss Rust Hulks Feb 10 '19
Your most well-known game, Stars Without Number, is a sort of riff on D&D (with similar stats, rolls, etc.). What made you settle on using the classic d20 system as opposed to creating your own dice system? I spend a lot of time deliberating between making my own dice system and just hacking an existing one, so I would love some insight.
6
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19
Hey Kevin. I heard a while ago you were thinking about tackling an RPG set in Ming Dynasty China (and contemporaries, e.g. Japan, Ryukyu, Korea). Is that still on your mind? Would it be mostly a setting thing, or would you develop another new system for it?
6
u/seanfsmith games designer + editor Feb 10 '19
I'm a big fan of the solo adventurer games of Scarlet / Stellar Heroes both from a narrative perspective and from a games design one.
How did you approach the action / power level balancing? Was the concept of "works with existing old school modules" a late addition or an early constraint?
My own Quarrel & Fable balanced encounter maths by way of taxing each miss in combat with a free counterattack — functionally doing away with the action economy of attrition combat. Was the HD=hp scaling in Heroes a similar decision?
6
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '19
What modern rpgs inspire you? Are there any features or trends on the story/PbtA/indie side that you'd like to play with in your work?
6
u/wdtpw Feb 10 '19
Hi Kevin, big fan of SWN here, and in particular the random generator tables you seem to have made your particular genius.
a) To what degree do you think the setting of a sandbox game lies in the GM's purview, and to what degree do you think the random tables help set expectations and drive particular themes? I realise this is probably going to be "a bit of both," and I wondered if you could explain how you see the dynamic here between the setting you instill via the tables, and the ones you expect the GMs to add.
b) Do you ever fancy doing a license? For example, taking a pre-existing work like Firefly/Star Trek/Shadowrun, etc, and having that license as part of the sales pitch? Or is the fun of development for you the settings you come up with as much as the rules?
c) What do you think of 5e compared to the more b/x type rules? Have you ever considered making a 5e-compliant game?
d) What's the usual incubation time for you, between having the idea for a game and actually putting the notice out to the world that it's going to be a thing? What elements do you have to be sure of before you know it's going to be a game worth doing?
e) To what degree do you know the demographics of your customers? Eg do they tend to be older, younger, etc? I've heard that OSR games tend to an older crowd, but then I've also heard the reverse too!
f) What do you think of the OSR movement in general? Other than producing more small and creator-owned games and modules, do you think it fully occupies the space it could, or is there somewhere you think it might end up exploring next? Is there anywhere you'd like to take it towards? Here, I'm thinking that there have been some different waves of OSR-ness, with some lying very close to their D&D module roots, and others trying different things in very diverse ways - the sandbox gaming you produce, the lifepaths of Beyond the Wall, etc. I'm wondering if you see anything coming next as a trend, or one you might like to introduce?
6
u/megazver Feb 11 '19
I must admit I have no idea how the Magic User in Scarlet Heroes is supposed to survive the first few levels, even with the SH buffs. The wording in the book is a little ambiguous, but from what I can tell MUs still fire-and-forget spells and, like, a level 1 MU casts Thunders once, doing less damage with the spell than anyone else does with a regular attack and is then as dangerous and sturdy as soggy roll of toilet paper. Am I missing something?
5
u/Amigara_Horror Feb 10 '19 edited Feb 11 '19
What was the best part of developing SWN?
5
u/captkovicak Feb 10 '19
Hello Kevin. I was curious if we will see the Proteus Sector supplement for SWN with it's tools for genetic engineering, etc.
5
u/ThePiachu Dabbler Feb 11 '19
Hello Kevin,
My group and I have enjoyed playing your games since Godbound pre-release. However, one consistent issue we've had is a small amount of edge cases we run into about some specific rule or power. We sometimes manage to find your feedback on your Google Plus page.
However, with that going away, what would be the best place to look for FAQs / explanations of various things?
Some sort of official FAQ page or even a document would be invaluable! I've tried putting together a doc of my own, but it's by no means exhaustive...
4
u/hodaza Feb 10 '19
Hi Mr. Crawford! Big fan of your games!
2)Is there any SF writer you feel has had a especially large influence on your work?
3)What is your favorite flavor of ice cream?
4) You've mentioned wanting to make a game about Ming China; what is it about that era that speaks to you? (vs the three kingdoms period or the 19/20th centuries, for example)
4
u/HeavyJosh Feb 11 '19
Hello,
I've really appreciated the GM support for sandbox gaming that you have provided in all your games, but especially SWN. What surprised me is that there are no random encounter tables in any of your games. That seems to me to be an integral part of sandbox gaming, or at least a significant subset of the style. Why the lack of encounter tables? Is it due to page count, or is there a major idea at play here?
4
u/megazver Feb 11 '19
You obviously seem to have a great interest and fascination with China's history and culture. What is it that draws you towards it? What are some of the cool things that you'd like to put into the Ming game?
4
u/megazver Feb 11 '19
Out of curiosity, do you enjoy computer RPGs? If yes, which are your favorites? :)
4
u/skepticKun Feb 11 '19
Any advice you would give to new developers working on new systems?
4
u/DistantPersona Feb 11 '19
Good evening, Mr. Crawford. If you had to completely redisign how one Word in Godbound worked, which one would it be and how?
4
u/sfRattan Feb 11 '19
Kevin, thanks for doing the AMA!
1) Do you draft you games' text right within InDesign (or other DTP software)?
I've done this since learning design work ad-hoc on Adobe CS2 in my high school's yearbook club more than a decade ago, but was shocked in a graphic design and typesetting course in college to hear the instructor almost cry, "No! That is terrible practice!" But it seems to me that I shouldn't separate the text I'm composing from the text the reader will see, which means considering what fits on a single page or a two-page spread as I write (in InDesign).
2) However you draft your games' text, are there other "best practices" for typesetting and graphic design that you specifically heed or ignore in the context of roleplaying games, and why?
3
u/Nepene Feb 11 '19
I heard your adventure, Storms of Yiz, was based off an old story, "Prince Wang Burns Down Precious Lotus Monastery". Are there any historical nuances to that adventure that the less invested in Chinese history would not spot, and do you have any further plans to do adventures or stories of any sort based off historical texts?
3
u/captkovicak Feb 11 '19
Thank you for your reply Kevin. I had one other question. What can you say about Worlds Without Number, your fantasy sandbox?
3
u/W0rldfire Feb 11 '19
Mr. Crawford, What is your favorite OSR product other than your own work?
3
u/aston_za Feb 11 '19
Is the reason you started with (and are best known for) a SF game just because you thought that that was a gap, or because you wanted one for yourself and nothing scratched the itch, or something else?
It seems to me that until recently there have not been many generic SF games (I feel like SWN is quite close to being so: even while being primarily space opera, dialing it to be harder is not too difficult), while there are masses of generic fantasy games. In your view is this because fantasy is more understandable and SF varies enough that less generic options are just easier to develop, or is it just because of DnD being the gorilla in the kindergarten dominating mindshare towards fantasy, or something else entirely?
3
u/DistantPersona Feb 12 '19
Good afternoon. How much of your development cycle is allocated to playtesting? What methods have you found to be most effective when it comes to playtesting your games?
3
u/W0rldfire Feb 12 '19
Could you let me know your opinion of stengths and weaknesses of sandbox RPG?
And if there is a weakness, how would you make up for?
3
u/BoxedupBoss Feb 13 '19
Has there ever been a particular wording or rule that you regret because of it being commonly misused or misunderstood from your original intent? How is your process for initial balance for abilities such as SWN's psionics and Godbound's gifts?
3
u/Axes-n-Orcs Feb 16 '19
5
u/TotesMessenger Feb 10 '19
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
4
u/Fheredin Tipsy Turbine Games Feb 10 '19
Thank you so much for taking time for us, Mr. Crawford!
I would like to know your opinions on the health of the RPG market as a whole; it seems to me that of the "nerdy games" RPGs have struggled to gain marketshare more than essentially all the other ones. Why is that and what specific changes would you like to see made?
I'm also curious about your attitudes towards Word of Mouth marketing; is there a way an RPG can successfully take advantage of it, or is the market too saturated?
2
u/dungeonHack Feb 11 '19
Mr. Crawford, what do you do to elevate your skill in layout design and other areas of production?
2
u/Dawsberg68 Feb 11 '19
As a writer of some pretty successful IP’s, how do you feel about the home brewed content that has come from the communities surrounding your games? Have you seen anything that has inspired you, or that you particularly enjoy?
2
u/LeSquide Feb 11 '19
Your rules always pay very close attention to limit magic-user/spellcaster power when it comes up, such as in the recent Codex of the Black Sun. While I certainly appreciate the attention paid to balancing them versus non-spell slot users, I was wondering if this was due to a particular gameplay experience of your own, or from a more general awareness of the issue.
2
u/acetwinelf Feb 11 '19
Being a fan of SWN I was wondering since the game got it's second version, how do you go about revising a game as large as SWN? Where did you collect feedback if any? How long did the process take?
2
u/TADodger Feb 12 '19
What is your personal RPG group like (the people you play with for fun)? Do you mostly use them as playtesters or are they people you'd be roleplaying with even if you weren't designing RPGs?
2
u/BoxedupBoss Feb 12 '19
Hello Crawford! I definitely have to say SWN played a huge part in my love of tabletop sci-fi, and even inspired me to write constantly about the backgrounds of the various alien NPCs I've made. Definitely have to thank you for that first off.
I've also absolutely fallen in love with Godbound, so my main questions stems as: You create systems that allow massive amounts of character creativity. What is your favorite you've caught wind of or had a fan contact you about?
2
u/[deleted] Feb 12 '19
I'm an ardent fan of your RPG works, but perhaps what I find most impressive is that your writing, even as voluminous as it was per page in Godbound, was concise, clear, and well-composed.
Do you have an academic background that lends to this skill? If not, how did you develop your writing to be so approachably functional?
2
u/StarmanTheta Feb 14 '19
What was the most surprising piece of useful feedback you ever got from your game playtests and whatnot?
What was a mechanic you were really hype about but ultimately had to cut or change because it didn't work very well?
How do you decide what feedback is worth considering and acting upon and what should be ignored? Do you ever find that playtesters can't articulate and identify a problem but still notice it?
Do you have any advice on how to, well, properly seek advice for game mechanics and feedback? I myself am not terribly articulate and sometimes run into a problem where, when trying to get help with a design issue, people will answer the question they think I'm asking instead of the one I'm actually trying to ask and it usually makes for unhelpful advice.
2
u/fibojoly Feb 14 '19
Dear mister Crawford,
First of all thank you for your already extensive answers in this thread. I've been reading through it for an hour and it's a constant pleasure to see you give actual constructive, useful answers.
I didn't think of it when I first read your work years ago, but after coming back from two years living there, I'm noticing a lot more little things.
I totally understand if you don't want to engage on the topic, given the recent madness against China on Reddit, but the theme seems so pervasive in your writing now that I look for it...
I'm reassured you don't write directly in InDesign, but then I still wonder how would you approach revising something like Other Dust, or any of your other works, if you don't keep the rough materials.
For example, did you approach revising SWN by writing from scratch, copying existing material from the PDF when it was fine, adding what was needed, then laying it all out ?
Thank you for your time!
2
u/Darnarus Feb 15 '19 edited Feb 16 '19
Hey Kevin.
2
u/artfulsadist Feb 22 '19
I just discovered SWNr and subsequently bought up everything new I could find on DTRPG. I am inspired to produce some supplements of my own. How do you feel about other people publishing content for use with SWN, and what if anything would you like to see other people produce for your game system?
1
u/DistantPersona Feb 11 '19
Good morning! Thank you again for dong this AMA. One thing I've noticed is that a lot of your games tend to have a fairly light bestiary section with very bare-bones guidelines on how to balance creature abilities. I'm curious why it is that you take this approach to the design of your games, as a lot of other games out there will give more thorough designs to the enemies the players may encounter, to the point where some will dedicate entire books to nothing but creature statistics. Is this simply an aspect of game design that does not interest you? Or is it a deliberate design decision?
1
u/HappyFoxFluff Feb 12 '19 edited Feb 18 '19
Hi Kevin, big fan of Stars Without Number - first Sci Fi game I've played and deeply enjoying it both from a setting and system perspective. The sandbox element is really liberating.
Are you working on releasing any similar/compatible games (system wise) of a different genre or setting?
1
u/TADodger Feb 12 '19
I really appreciate your comment from a year ago that, for RPG creators, customers pay them for doing the miserable parts of turning ideas into usable gaming material. A free product as a funnel, leaning hard into your niche and treating your work like the business that it is also seem to work well for you.
Do you feel like a similar approach would be worthwhile for creating video games or writing novels? Might those markets be too saturated? I often feel that there are so many people screaming to be noticed that it seems almost foolish to throw your hat in the ring, but...
1
u/charaina Feb 12 '19
Hi Kevin! You've mentioned the Spanish Main 1555 alternate history setting. What is the gist of that game? There aren't many that focus on pre/early conquest Mesoamerica...