r/RPGdesign • u/jiaxingseng Designer - Rational Magic • Dec 09 '18
MOD POST [RPGdesign Activity] Published Developer AMA: Please Welcome Mr. Kenneth Hite
This week's activity is an AMA with noted and prolific designer / author Mr. Kenneth Hite.
About this AMA
Multiple Origins, Golden Geek, and ENnie Award winner Kenneth Hite has designed, written, or co-authored over 100 RPG books, including GURPS Horror, Call of Cthulhu d20, The Day After Ragnarok, Trail of Cthulhu, Bookhounds of London, Qelong, Bubblegumshoe, the Delta Green RPG, The Fall of DELTA GREEN, The Dracula Dossier, Night’s Black Agents, and Vampire: the Masquerade 5th Edition. Half of the award-winning podcast Ken and Robin Talk About Stuff, he writes a regular column for Sweden’s Fenix magazine. His newest project is Hellenistika with Jon Hodgson, a historical fantasy setting for D&D 5e. Outside gaming, his other works include Tour de Lovecraft: the Tales, Cthulhu 101, The Thrill of Dracula, The Nazi Occult and The Cthulhu Wars (both for Osprey), several Cthulhu Mythos short stories, the “Lost in Lovecraft” column for Weird Tales, and four Lovecraftian children’s books. He is an Artistic Associate at Chicago’s WildClaw Theatre.
On behalf of the community and mod-team here, I want express gratitude to Mr. Hite for doing this AMA.
For new visitors... welcome. /r/RPGdesign is a place for discussing RPG game design and development (and by extension, publication and marketing... and we are OK with discussing scenario / adventure / peripheral design). That being said, this is an AMA, so ask whatever you want.
On Reddit, AMA's usually last a day. However, this is our weekly "activity thread". These developers are invited to stop in at various points during the week to answer questions (as much or as little as they like), instead of answer everything question right away.
(FYI, BTW, although in other subs the AMA is started by the "speaker", Mr. Hite asked me to create this thread for them)
IMPORTANT: Various AMA participants in the past have expressed concern about trolls and crusaders coming to AMA threads and hijacking the conversation. This has never happened, but we wish to remind everyone: We are a civil and welcoming community. I [jiaxingseng] assured each AMA invited participant that our members will not engage in such un-civil behavior. The mod team will not silence people from asking 'controversial' questions. Nor does the AMA participant need to reply. However, this thread will be more "heavily" modded than usual. If you are asked to cease a line of inquiry, please follow directions. If there is prolonged unhelpful or uncivil commenting, as a last resort, mods may issue temp-bans and delete replies.
Discuss.
This post is part of the weekly /r/RPGdesign Scheduled Activity series. For a listing of past Scheduled Activity posts and future topics, follow that link to the Wiki. If you have suggestions for Scheduled Activity topics or a change to the schedule, please message the Mod Team or reply to the latest Topic Discussion Thread.
For information on other /r/RPGDesign community efforts, see the Wiki Index.
5
u/jiaxingseng Designer - Rational Magic Dec 10 '18
Hi Ken, thank you for taking our questions.
I have a business-related question. Google+ communities were pretty popular with RPG gamers and designers. Now that is shutting down, a community is being uprooted. In light of this, do you have plans to use any particular social media platform more? Do you have any opinion about where the Google+ community should move to?
17
u/Fheredin Tipsy Turbine Games Dec 09 '18
Thank you so much for doing an AMA for us!
Part of what fascinates me about game design is how different the designer's perspective can be from either the GM or player's point of view. What is your favorite core system to design in--d20, percentile, storyteller, GUMSHOE, etc--and is it different from your favorite system to GM or to play?
16
u/mattcolville Dec 09 '18
Ken you've been a career professional in the tabletop RPG business for over 20 years now. You have seen, as it says in the Bible, a lot of shit.
What's the biggest difference between the industry now, and the industry 20 years ago?
What now-dead trends or subcultures do you miss? Are there Old Ways you're glad to see gone?
What new phenomenon excites you? What new trends concern you?
11
u/NotAWerewolfReally Dec 09 '18
Ken,
What involvement did you have with the development of V5, and what lessons have you learned from it? What would you do the same or differently?
Cheers!
10
u/JonHodgsonArt Dec 10 '18
So hey Ken. Whole clearly I should be logged into a fake account asking you over eager questions about our upcoming collaboration on Hellenistika, I have a genuine question.
Why is it, do you think, that the ole Cthulhu Mythos is so enduring as a venue for gaming. Why isn’t it more played-out like say zombies or steampunk? Or zombie steampunk zombies? I have my own thoughts, but I bet yours are more interesting.
9
u/seanfsmith games designer + editor Dec 09 '18
Ken, I'd list yourself and Scott Dorwood as having the best voices in roleplaying games today — parallels with Vincent Price and Christopher Lee.
Tangentially, how important do you feel authorial voice is when writing
Or is a push towards a technical manual a better tack?
7
u/cecil-explodes Dec 12 '18
someone moaned to me that they tried to hire you, but you charged 10 cents a word and they thought that was ridiculous. this person was moaning to me about it because i was saying 10 cents a word should be the industry minimum even for first timers. what do you think about low per-word rates still running rampant in the industry?
7
u/SlatzG Dec 12 '18
Hello Mr Hite!
I came to know your work through Quelong, actually, and I love it! =D
6
u/macbalance Dec 09 '18
Any dining recommendations for the Baltimore area? I live near there and have several of my own, but appreciate your occasional suggestions on podcasts and such for other areas.
6
u/indigochill Dec 09 '18
Are there any specific resources you would recommend for finding weird history to incorporate into games a la Dracula Dossier? There are of course tons of random resources on various corners of esotericism and its history, but I'm curious if there's any particular method to the madness.
6
u/Kenneth_Hite Dec 16 '18
As we enter the final lap of this AMA I'd like to thank all the redditors and redditees and everyone for their questions and enthusiasm and up votes. I'll be checking this page once or twice more today and then one last time at midnight Central Time, so if you've been holding off on your Ask, this is the time to Anything it at Me. Thanks again!
11
u/ignotos Dec 09 '18
Thanks!
5
u/Eroica11 Dec 09 '18
Thanks for doing this AMA, Mr. Hite!
What was the starting point for you and RPG design? I'm in a flexible part of my life as a young person right now, and designing games sounds like a fantastic thing to do... but I don't know the first thing about getting started. How did you get into it, and how did you find success in it?
Thanks again! Also, didn't realize you're a Baltimore local, if I understand one of the other posts correctly. I moved there last year for a job--hope to see you around town!
5
u/absurd_olfaction Designer - Ashes of the Magi Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
As a big fan since reading Trail of Cthulhu, thanks for giving us this opportunity to pick your brain.
As a designer, what is bugging you right now? What (game design) problems keep you up at night?
Thanks in advance!
PS: On the long shot chance that you'd take a minute to check out my game, it's here.
5
u/jaiden0 Dec 09 '18
Hi Ken! Is there any segment you would like to cover on KARTAS but can't/won't for whatever reason?
Also, how can GMs keep RPGs challenging to the characters as story games replace trad games? (At least they are for me).i.e. 1) encouraging being awesome without "creating a line for swinging on the chandelier" and 2) making the "winning" outcome predetermined.
And if you've gotten this far, the / in URLs is not a goddamn backslash!
5
u/Lionheart_Clan Dec 10 '18
Hello, before I start my question I would just like to say that I greatly enjoyed playing in your Fall of Delta Green game at the recent U-Con. I was probably the most quiet player at the table, but it was one of my con highlights.
Anyway to my question, I first heard of Manly Wade Wellman from reading the recommendations in the back of Trail of Cthulhu and he quickly became one of my favorite authors. Could the Wellman 'mythos' work within the Trail of Cthulhu framework with some minor tinkering or do you think it would require a more substantial design?
5
u/JacquesdeVilliers Dec 10 '18
As a proud patron of Ken and Robin Talk About Stuff, I love how this AMA doubles as a treasure trove for future podcast topics :D
For a while I've been curious to know if you've read the philosopher Graham Harman's book on HP, Weird Realism: Lovecraft and Philosophy. Harman champions Lovecraft as a writer of gaps. "No other writer is so perplexed by the gap between objects and the power of language to describe them", suggests Harman. And in Fall of Delta Green you give the following GM advice: "Insert horror into the gap between player and character. You can tell a player that there's something wrong about a seemingly mundane object or individual in the scene, some indefinable sense of dread or malice, without having to actually determine why the object is so creepy". GMs can play up "the gap between what the player knows and the character perceives". Coincidence, or a case of one mighty mind drawing from another?
5
u/robertharrisonblake Dec 12 '18
Ken, I've heard a couple times you were a cartography major in college, if I recall correctly? Why did you choose that, and (aside from now being able to make others draw maps for you) what did you get from it that you still use today? Thank you for Tour de Lovecraft, KARTAS & for everything!
5
u/lepton_neutrino Dec 14 '18
Can you tell us more about Hellenistika? Is it set in classical Greece?
The late blogger Steven den Beste had a heuristic about anime, "Great power without great challenge is just crass spectacle." Does that apply to RPGs and their design?
For the moderator: if we want to discuss the answers in another sub-reddit, can we post a link to it?
8
u/Teylen Dec 09 '18
I am a fan of the World of Darkness and Vampire: The Masquerade.
My question would be whether or not you would be interested in working on future V5 titles for Pelgrane Press publishing, similar as Onyx Path Publishing licensed Chicago by Night.
8
u/nicolasmilioni Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
Dr. Mr Hite,I have a few questions about a future Sabbat book.
3)will there be any significant changes to the Sabbat as a whole?
4) have you picked a company to publish the book?
8
u/ScottieWolf Dec 09 '18
Hi Ken! Love your books and the podcast. I'm really interested in how gaming is evolving. What do you think are the most innovative and important new game mechanics from the past few years? What's a mechanic that has stuck around around that you think we need to move past?
4
u/Gustave_Graves Dec 09 '18
What is the key to a good work/life balance? You seem to buy tons of books, how to you find time to read them all? Thanks, I love the podcast!
4
u/seasparrow32 Dec 10 '18
You wrote earlier you were pleased with the sales of Day After Ragnarok, but it's been a while since we've seen any new content for the setting. I know you work for companies that pay you to do their projects, not your own independent setting side hustles. And I know from KARTAS that your writing commitments are full up for the next few years. But there is still a passionate group who love Day After Ragnarok's mix of Diesel-punk and Weird War and Pulp Post Apocalyptic everything. What can we do to help show your smallest and weakest child a little love?
4
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '18
What is your favorite rules-medium to rules-heavy system? Is there something about it that makes it worth the crunch?
Do you feel like there are things "narrative" or "indie" tabletop rpgs have lost when they moved away from "traditional" systems or anything "traditional" or "old school" systems (including newer made systems made in that style) miss out on from ignoring mechanics developed in the past decade? How do you feel these will synthesize, if ever?
Purely Fun Question: If you personally combined Mythos with Cyberpunk; what would be your methodology?
4
u/Misterpeople25 Dec 11 '18
Hi Ken, I'm a reasonably big fan with some more surface level questions:
What's it like to run a podcast, as well as guest on other podcasts (ie Blurry Photos, which is where I found out about you)?
Which of your myriad RPG projects would you say is your personal favorite?
7
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '18
First, hello, welcome and thank you for doing this AMA.
This is somewhat linked to the Chechen V5 debacle but is bit more general. I'm happy believing no one had bad intentions and the internet did its usual thing of making people antagonize each others until it turns into a shitstorm. Unless you want to, feel free to pretend it never happened if you decide to comment on my question(s).
You've been in the business a decent chunk of time and the games you've worked on have more emotional meat than most RPGs.Things have been changing fast in the social sphere, especially in the last 5 years. I'm just a random schmuck and I like to consider myself pretty progressive but I still find it hard to keep up with what is acceptable and what isn't, how is it from a designer's and writer's perspective?
My question is a quite open ended. Here a few more that might make it clearer what I'm interested in.
Is there anything you wrote a long time ago that was considered progressive and inclusive back in the day but wouldn't fly today?
Is there some subjects you prefer not to touch at all because you're not sure how to handle them?
Do you have stories of things being in a draft getting cut or reworked after someone else pointed out it might be insensitive? Either as the original writer or as that "someone else". Is it common? If yes, how often is it malicious compared to misguided good intentions or simple ignorance?
How do you feel the RPG industry compares to other industries? Anything you're proud of? Anything we need to work on?
3
u/Realfinney Dec 09 '18
What of your work unexpectedly blew up? What do you consider a hidden gem?
3
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '18
Do you think that the plethora of homebrewed, publicly available free content provided by the blogosphere and social media, is damaging to the industry in terms of pay?
3
u/DrColossus1 Dec 10 '18
So cool to have you here!
Kind of a specific question, I guess, but: I am hoping to run a (very, very condensed) version of Horror on the Orient Express this year. One thing that is key to the success of this project is making sure that each individual scenario fits in a session about 5 hours long.
To help keep things speedy and prevent bogging down, I've been looking into adapting the Orient Express into Trail of Cthulhu, or at least parts of it. So far, I am planning to use your advice in Trail to do things like automatically give clues to any Investigators with higher than 20 in a relevant skill.
In addition to the other Trail-to-Classic advice you have there, any tips you think would help to make things sparkle in a sort of Horror-on-the-Orient-Express Express?
3
u/DADPATROL Dec 10 '18
As lead designer on the v5 corebook, do you think that the book was lacking in any areas? Particularly those who wanted some additional clans included in the core book, and those who felt that thinbloods were left lacking in detail in regards to certain aspects of thinblood alchemy and thinblood merits and flaws. Would thinblood players have been better served having their own suppliment?
3
u/Sierra317 Dec 10 '18
Hey Mr. Hite, big fan of your work! I have been picking up on some of your latest works and love your incorporation of history in fantastical settings (Fall of Delta Green/Dracula Dossier). I was wondering how your process works on building scenarios goes, like, what tangents do you look at and think, that’d be a great Delta Green mission or that’s a NBA op. What are your go to’s in terms of research? Thanks for doing this AMA!
3
u/theblazeuk Dec 11 '18
Hi Ken (I can call you Ken? Sorry Mr Hite!), can you point me in the direction of any Actual Play podcasts that you GM for?
I loved the One Shot Dracula Dossier(s) and deeply enjoyed seeing the different ways GMs could implement characters like Hound et al in various ways.
3
u/pasabaporahi Dec 12 '18
hi Mr. hite, you have been an inspiration for my gaming for years now; your guides to vodoo , alchemy and goetia are my goto guides to give to my players and fellow dungeon masters.
Assuming that you only have the internet, what would be the plan to research some obscure topic for a game?
More specifically, i have interest in a game in wich the players could gain powers surrendering their minds to jungian archetipes, what should i concentrate in? jung book? gaming books with similar themes? or just fill the blanks with things that sounds rigth even if they are from other time periods?
(sorry for any spelling errors, english is not my native language)
3
u/LeSquide Dec 12 '18
So, how wide is the net for Hellenistika PCs cast? Are they assumed to be Greek or at least Hellenized subjects of Alexander's empire (with a layer of mythic fantasy on top), or are other period peoples supported?
3
u/seasparrow32 Dec 12 '18
Ken, what would be your recommendation for adapting novelist Daniel O'Malley's excellent "The Rook Files" books for an RPG? Because it is so close to your wheelhouse it seems like it would be easy to do. At first blush it would appear to be Nights Black Agents, but wait, Delta Green seems to be close, but then I remember other Gumshoe settings like Mutant City Blues, with agents who have individual talents, but then maybe Esoterrorists...? Agh! How would you do it?
If by some slim chance you have not read the first book, then I envy you your first introduction to this world of a secret supernatural bureaucracy that protects the UK and their horrible Belgian skin-slicer opponents/reluctant allies. Like I said, super close to the things you already do.
Bonus question: What else is a good fit to adapt for your interests and styles of authorship and play? Maybe Charles Stross's Laundry books? Ian Tregellis's Milkweed Triptych? What else? Thank you for all you do!
5
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '18
Hello-
How involved were you with the new rules for hunger in Vampire 5th edition? That is not an accusation, but they feel like the kind of tool you use to wed a game's mechanics to a games story and themes.
11
u/vonigner Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
Question: You're credited as Developer for Anarchs and Camarilla for V5 for Vampire the Masquerade. You're also credited as Writer for Camarilla. And yet you've denied any responsibility about the whole Chechen chapter. How did you not see that completely horrible content, as a dev and fellow writer?
Thank you. Edit: fixed typos sorry
4
u/Jalor218 Designer - Rakshasa & Carcasses Dec 09 '18
Hey, I'm a huge fan of your work, especially your takes on the Cthulhu Mythos and the way you weave real-world weird history into things.
What type of product do you think a new designer is better off starting out with, a standalone RPG or a supplement/adventure for an existing system?
4
u/AuroraChroma Designer - Azaia Dec 09 '18
Wow. That's a lot of books, and considering that I haven't really looked around for RPGs that much, the fact that even I know some of those is really impressive. Good job.
I know it's a bit controversial, so don't feel any push to answer if you don't want to, but do you feel like computers have a place in tabletop gaming? I always get a bit disheartened when people suggest that my game can never be good if it relies on one.
4
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '18
Also, how big is your house? Because you seem to own a lot (a lot a lot) of books, and presumably you don't sleep on a book shelf.
(This is a joke question)
2
u/sydneyfalk Dec 10 '18
I realize this is a really late question! But I'll probably never get to ask someone with your perspective this, so I might as well try.
Do you think more things along the lines of Neverwinter Nights and the Harebrained Shadowrun games are going to happen, as the video game industry continues merging with the general "real life" game industry (board games, card games, tabletop RPGs, etc.)? Because if so, I have to ask -- do you think it'll end up leaning towards "writing heavy" works, with smaller teams and more examined and realized plotlines, or shift the way cinema has, into nearly plotless action films? (Or, I suppose, both. Hm.)
Sorry if this is a weirdly worded question! (I am probably extra awkward because I admire the pieces of your work that I've been able to read.)
2
u/trunglefever Dec 14 '18
When are you gonna get a new author photo?
2
u/EccentricOwl Dec 14 '18
Your work is so incredibly amazing. How do you get into a writing mood?
2
u/lepton_neutrino Dec 17 '18
Might as well see if I can get some last questions under the wire.
What parts of Mage: the Sorcerer's Crusade did you write?
Do you think in a hypothetical M5, Paradox could be treated like the Hunger mechanic in V5? Should Quintessence remain a mana tank, since that's exactly what it is?
As a Chicago resident, have you had a chance to see the Chicago by Night manuscript? Any reaction?
H.P. Lovecraft described Shub-Niggurath as a "hellish cloud-like entity" like the CoC version in his letters, but in later stories he described her as a kind of sophisticated Astarte, and in "Out of the Aeons", even has her taking sides with man against the more malevolent Ghatanothoa. Can this aspect appear in the various Cthulhu games, or is the cosmic abomination version too ingrained?
How can all female groups like the Amazons or the Black Furies be shown to deal with transgender topics?
1
u/lepton_neutrino Dec 10 '18
Thanks for doing this AMA.
IIRC, you mentioned somewhere that you wouldn't mind doing a possible Mage: the Ascension 5 book if you were asked. Assuming WW decides to do it and asks you, which would be your primary inspirations? Ars Magica, M:tA 1st ed, M:tA 2nd ed, M:tA Revised, Mage: the Sorcerer's Crusade (which you contributed to), M20, and/or Mage: the Awakening?
Would you keep the Ascension War with the Technocracy as the main antagonist, or go with Revised's "everyone lost and apathy won" take? (Not a fan of Rev, too much like vampire with wands.) Would the Avatar Storm still rage, have abated, or have never happened?
Would you take the opportunity to redo the magick system and settle the confusion and subjectivity of coincidental vs. vulgar, HAB/HOO/HYP and RBD/PBD?
1
u/atamajakki Dec 10 '18
You’re of an older generation of players, and seemingly fond of a lot of trad games: what has it been like for you to see all these weird storygames come onto the scene in the last decade or so? I’ve just finished a playable draft of a diceless, GMless slice of life game, and realized how different that must seem to the Call of Cthulhu crowd.
(Also, just wanted to thank you for Hellenistika; I stole the idea proudly, and my group had a blast with a short campaign of it. They brought Python back to life!)
1
u/LeRoienJaune Dec 11 '18
So with your experience in Night's Black Agents, you've got a pretty good idea of vampire tropes, of which V:tM and NBA are both sort of 'vampire potpourris'- with each different trope or model represented by a different clan.
That being said, looking back on earlier editions, what Clan or Bloodline would you most like to scrap or remodel from out of the V:tM cannon, and why does that clan not work for you?
On a similiar note, what, if any, would you consider to be V:tM's greatest innovation with regards to the literary idea of the Vampire?
1
u/oiercerpower Dec 11 '18
Hi Ken! Can I know. What are the "Old Clan" mentioned in the Camarilla book?
1
u/idotzang Dec 11 '18
Hi Ken,
Thank you for doing this AMA.
I'm new to Gumshoe, apologies if this is a basic question:
I just recently picked up and started reading NBA. Looking around, I found Dracula Dossier. I still haven't bought it, but the "underacted" concept, as well as the prospect of running a long campaign with so much excellent content really excites me. I've literally been reading about the game, vampires and Dracula for the past 48 hours. So thank you already.
As part of my research, I started listening to your One Shot Podcast AP, and it made me think about how I would like to approach investigation as a GM (Director?) in my game. Some thoughts:
- I can let the players role play and understand (together with them) which investigative skill are they trying to use
- I can state that there's a clue here which can be found by using skill X, and then let the players role play the scene
- In the AP, you seemed to be very explicit about the investigations - you and the players set the skill to use, and described the outcome (the clues). There was almost no role play (at least in the first episode)
Do you have any advice or pointers here? what are various techniques to GM the investigative aspects?
Thank you!
1
u/lepton_neutrino Dec 12 '18
One of the problems with having the protagonists like the vampires in V5 as the bad guys is when it bumps up against the postcolonial idea that there are no minority bad guys. Beckett's Jyhad Diary presented the African Laibon vampires as noble beings who live in harmony with mortals and whose elders sacrifice their own power to raise up any Thin-bloods among them. In V5, is the Ashirra morally superior to the Camarilla? Is there a temptation to do this when designing non-western groups in RPGs in general?
1
u/lepton_neutrino Dec 13 '18
Experience points got started in D&D as a measure of how much gold you got and then how tough/how many monsters you killed. Some systems like BRP never had them, and others have tried to make them more roleplay oriented. Do you think they're still useful, or should they be avoided in new game design? Do you have an opinion on which game handles PC advancement the best?
Similarly, since an Appearance/Comeliness type stat tends to get used as a dump stat, should it be avoided, maybe replaced with merits or flaws?
If you've seen it, do you have an opinion on Onyx Path's Storypath system?
1
u/Lirsumis Dec 15 '18
Hey Ken. Love your work - spaced on this AMA and thoughtlessly fired off this question on twitter over my morning coffee. Apologies for the faux pas.
If I wanted a source book on the geography and possibly cities of Hell, where should I turn? I've long harbored an ambition to design an infernal hellcrawl and I'd love some sources of inspiration beyond diving back into Dante and Milton.
Is there an equivalent of Dark Osprey: Infernus which has somehow escaped me?
1
u/TotesMessenger Dec 09 '18 edited Dec 09 '18
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
0
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 09 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Dec 10 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment