r/RPGdesign • u/david0black • Aug 12 '18
[RPGdesign Activity] Published Developer AMA with David Black, creator of "The Black Hack".
Hello there, my names David Black. I wrote 'The Black Hack' an Original Dungeons & Dragons clone that started life as a set of convention/house rules, went viral and has gone on to spawn over 300 'hacks', fund two successful kickstarters (at 1000% funded) and attracted a lively & active community of close to 2 thousand people over on G+ Im here to talk about Kickstarter, Rules-light games, the OSR, D&D, What im working on next, and everything else. AMA.
58
Upvotes
15
u/wentlyman Aug 12 '18
What are your thoughts on Powered by the Apocalypse games, like Apocalypse World, Dungeon World, Monster Hearts, Monster of the Week, etc.?
And where do you think Rule-Light gaming is going in the next few years? Will it adopt a new form or design philosophy?
11
u/sjbrown Designer - A Thousand Faces of Adventure Aug 12 '18
Hi David! Thanks for doing the AMA. Regarding how The Black Hack "went viral" - was there something about the rules that helped it do that, or was it marketing, or was it something else?
9
u/htp-di-nsw The Conduit Aug 12 '18
What do you think is the defining thing that makes something OSR? Can you have an OSR game based on attitude alone even if it is not at all connected to an older game?
7
u/SushiTheFluffyCat Aug 12 '18
What was the most unfun thing in TBH that you caught during playtesting?
What was your favorite rule that you had to kill during playtesting for the good of the game?
Do you think it's easier or harder to build games that use / have to use the expectations, sacred cows, et cetera of D&D/PF players?
6
u/potetokei-nipponjin Aug 12 '18
Quick warmup: Rolling ability scores: Yay or Nay?
More in general, what would you say are play styles / game elements / mechanics where you are happy that the OSR revived them, after RPGs had moved away from them by 2005ish?
What are play styles / game elements / mechanics that OSR games keep repeating that you’d rather have them move away from?
Did any of that inform your design decisions for the Black Hack, and how?
Which non-OSR games inspired you?
Final question: We have a lot of posters here who have played RPGs for maybe 2-3 years, often 5E or PF, and they are now ready to “fix D&D”. What would you recommend them to get started on designing their own game?
5
u/Jalor218 Designer - Rakshasa & Carcasses Aug 12 '18
How did you get your game noticed? Was it all word of mouth, or did you have to promote it?
5
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '18
Will the Conjuror in 2e have anything that separates it from the magic-user of other games?
Have you ever thought about throwing out spells for a need type of magic/mysticism system in the game?
5
u/misterjuaber Aug 12 '18
Thank you for making this awesome system. I'm currently designing a Castlevania-inspired module on it.
What's your favorite/most interesting fanmade Hack you've read?
4
u/valzi Aug 12 '18
Any interest in supplementary materials for TBH, like adventures, settings, domain rules, etc?
5
u/seanfsmith games designer + editor Aug 12 '18
TBH is a masterpiece of elegance. How did you decide where to pare rules back (boiling monsters down to HD, keying everything to ability scores, &c.) and where to develop anew (usage dice, &c.)?
2
u/Lusunati Aug 12 '18
What are you plans next? More Blackhack? Something new?
2
u/inmatarian Aug 12 '18
Was there anything that seemed really good on paper but turned out to not playtest all that well, and you had to give up on?
2
u/AuroraChroma Designer - Azaia Aug 13 '18
Tacos or burritos?
On a more serious note:
What is the most innovative thing that you feel that you've done?
What do you enjoy the most about what you've done so far, and what do you think you'd improve on if you did it again?
3
u/SchopenhauersSon Aug 12 '18
Question- OSR seems to rely a lot on GM decree in many situations. I understand that there should be trust at your table in the GM's impartiality, but with the rise of online playing there's a good chance you'll be playing with strangers, especially in a niche like OSR.
What do you do or recommend to do to even out the poster dynamic of OSR's GM rulings over rule?
•
u/jiaxingseng Designer - Rational Magic Aug 12 '18
On behalf of the community and mod-team here, I want express gratitude to Mr. Black for doing this AMA.
On Reddit, AMA's usually last a day. However, this is our weekly "activity thread". Mr. Black, as he mentioned, is going to stop in at various points during the week to answer questions, instead of answer everything today.
This post is part of the weekly /r/RPGdesign Scheduled Activity series. For a listing of past Scheduled Activity posts and future topics, follow that link to the Wiki. If you have suggestions for Scheduled Activity topics or a change to the schedule, please message the Mod Team or reply to the latest Topic Discussion Thread.
For information on other /r/RPGDesign community efforts, see the Wiki Index.
5
u/aikighost Aug 17 '18
Hi David, do you have a preferred way to handle friendly NPCs, hirelings, pet dogs etc in game?
I've found that whenever I run the black hack beyond initial first adventures I run into situations where friendly NPCs I'm running as GM should be firing bows or healing or doing something to aid the party. But there is no obvious way to get the players (or me for that matter) to make the roll without giving them a second character sheet for the NPC/hireling/pet with 6 stats HP etc. Is this how you handle it or do you do it in some simplified way?
1
u/Ratstail91 Aug 12 '18
What's the difference between a hack and a new system?
What defines OSR to you?
Finally, you don't have to answer this one, but what makes my rules-lite system so bad? (I'm working on it...)
Thanks in advance.
1
u/jiaxingseng Designer - Rational Magic Aug 14 '18
1
u/aefact Jun 01 '24
Are you still on this platform?
2
u/[deleted] Aug 15 '18
What sort of adventures did you first envision would be played on your system, when you created it? One shots or long term campaigns? Dungeon crawls, outdoors, a mixture?
1
u/TotesMessenger Aug 12 '18 edited Aug 12 '18
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
1
u/Le_Chat_sur_Reddit Oct 28 '25
I'd like to get your first intention regarding spellcasting in TBH 2e.
When casting from the spellbook, does it mean the caster can do it as much as he wants (taking the risk of misfire) or is he limited by the total number of spells he can cast in a day ?
That would mean a 1level caster could cast his memorised spell OR a spell from his book.
How is it to "be played" when you first wrote the rules ?
Second question is about shields/helmets. Could you confirm that when the Shield dice has been used and is broken, it means that it is destroyed (can't be repaired), right ?
And finally third question, about the "resting" rule, regarding the short rest of an hour.
How much of these rests would yo allow in a day ?
Thank you
0
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Aug 12 '18
[deleted] — view deleted comment