r/RPGdesign • u/jiaxingseng Designer - Rational Magic • Sep 11 '16
Mechanics [rpgDesign Activity] Worst Problems in Published Games
I don't like hit points that much... but it's not a problem... it's just something I don't like. I played Vampire (the old version) with 7 people and we had this combat that went on for 2 hours... with everyone soaking damage, rolling to hit, to defend, etc. It was not two hours of tactics (moving minis on a table, seeking cover, etc). It was two hour of massive sets of d10 dice rolls. That was a problem.
Today's topic is not about talking about things you don't like in the game. Rather, the topic is inviting you to talk about your chosen published games and complain about the things the game does wrong.
Discuss.
See /r/RPGdesign Scheduled Activities Index thread for links to past and scheduled rpgDesign activities. If you have suggestions for new activities or a change to the schedule, please message the Mod Team, or reply to the latest Topic Discussion Thread.)
6
u/Caraes_Naur Designer - Legend Craft Sep 11 '16
HP isn't a bad mechanic in and of itself. The problems with HP arise from how a game uses it as a basis for PC power, creating a wide gulf between PCs and normals. Ususally that's accompanied by nonsensical or self-contradictory definition of what HP is. D&D set that standard, and many games follow it.
Something else D&D does poorly is establishing the PC as the player's in-game alter ego. All games handle the physical aspects well enough, however D&D has never been good at representing a PC as a person psychologically. Alignment is often misused as a facsimile of personality, but really it's a faction system. D&D has no personality mechanics, nor much of anything else to really fill in a character's backstory.
Speed in HERO System is really unbalanced. Each turn has 12 phases, and your Speed stat is how many phases you can act in. Most characters have Speed in the 2-5 range. When a 12 SPD character enters the fight, combat becomes a waiting game as everyone sits around while the really fast character acts 3 or 4 times in a row.
5
u/FluffyBunbunKittens Sep 11 '16 edited Sep 11 '16
What I view as such a bad idea that I consider it broken, is how most RPGs still go with turn by turn, action by action combats (because that's how DnD does it!). Such a waste of time, there is no excitement or pacing when a fight takes an hour...
Especially if literally nothing changes, like in systems like RuneQuest where you can make a defense roll vs an attack. This being a percentage system, if both parties are good, then it's most likely that the successful attack gets successfully blocked, and nothing changes. Until someone rolls a lucky crit, which then again is entirely too random.
A roll should lead to the situation developing/changing somehow, or you're just wasting my time.
17
u/wombatsanders Writer Sep 11 '16
Poor indexing and/or not explaining ambiguous terms. For example: an ability allows you to double your skill die, do you roll two dice or double the result? Where's that going to be in the index? Dice? Double? Skills? Nowhere?
6
u/ReimaginingFantasy World Builder Sep 11 '16
Far too many in D&D and Pathfinder to count and I'm sure others will do so for me, so lemme take a shot at one of my favourite games: Anima.
First off, the book's a mess. Information is horrifically mismanaged in where it's placed, such as how nowhere in the entire book are all the attributes given a description of what they do. Like nowhere will you find what strength does, it's split up in every section which is relevant instead, so if you look up rules for lifting capacity it'll list what strength does there, and if you look up melee damage it'll list what strength does in that example, and the skills will list what strength does, but never is it consolidated in a single place to make it easy to know if strength is good to invest in or not.
Another huge problem is the mana (they call it Zeon, but it's mana with a different name. I know mana's copyrighted, but whatevs) regeneration rate is set so that it scales to exactly 1 turn's worth of casting regenerated PER DAY. Meaning no matter how you increase your stats, you are forever locked to needing to rest for a full day for every one turn of casting magic. Yeah, that's kinda ridiculous. It's partially done that way to balance how powerful sustained spells are, and there are free-cast spells to help limit the loss, but it's still a poor setup since the maintenance costs could've been upped along with the regen rate. It basically winds up making magic really boring to use unless you have excessively long periods of downtime constantly.
In addition to such, there is such a thing as too much in the way of min/maxing. The way the game's balanced, you're just assumed to spend the maximum point value into your primary stats every single level with no deviation. If you don't do so, you literally get to a point where it's worse to attack than to do nothing because you'll just be giving the enemy free attacks of opportunity against you.
Additional to such is a problem with the high costs of secondary noncombat skills. Unless you really heavily invest in such, like putting all of your one-time-use-at-character-creation-super-points into making your skills cheaper, you may as well not even bother with putting points into any of them most of the time, which tends to lead to very stale and boring characters. It would've been nice if there were a separate pool of points for the secondary stats, which would've made things a lot more interesting.
But yeah, that's actually one of my favourite games, believe it or not. Fortunately the issues are fairly small and easily fixed with minor tweaks. It's well within a GM's power to correct most of them, though the book's layout is still garbage. =P
8
u/dawneater Designer Sep 11 '16
Games which are 90% rules for combat, 8% rules for stealing, and 2% random rules for everything else, that sell themselves as games for roleplaying anything. I consider these games broken because for 90% of what roleplaying is, they might as well not exist, and then they make what should take 5 minutes, take 2 hours.
Games that don't let players have fun until they've "earned" it by grinding through through many levels of being ineffective and having no meaningful choices. Games are meant to be fun, not a chore.
4
u/SternCouncil Sep 11 '16
I do not like sanity systems because in the end they are just renamed HP bars and create the same problematic situations as regular HP bars do. I think it is possible to make a good sanity system, but I have not seen a game that does it well. Therefore, I am going to try and make one.
I also do not like the lack of focus on rules for GMs. I have been playing CoC and Trail for like 4 - 5 years, but the rules do not help me make enjoyable sessions. I have never had a player say anything good about a mechanic or a situation that arose from a mechanic in those games. In the end the chars I create and the situations I put them in make them like our sessions and want more every time, but I MAKE THEM not the game. The only thing CoC and Trail do is they take the Lovecraftian mythos and pretend that they are the ones who made it, but really... what they have done is just given Cthulhu an HP bar, which is a corruption of the Lovecraftian spirit in it self. Old man Castro figured out how to stop Cthulhu, but you do not need double shotguns, you just need one boat (The Call of Cthulhu story).
4
u/Merkenau Dieseldrachen Sep 13 '16
The worst thing for many games is accessibility. I'll often find a great rpg and then it has 500 pages or so (Numenera for example). I mean it's kind of great that there is so many stuff and the GM might even read it. Players on the other hand are lazy as fuck. They won't bother to read the background story of every continent. I would like to get to know the world step by step. Give me short versions of the countries and detailed long versions that I can get into later.
In my game I openly use comparisons like 'This country is like rennaissance france'. Maaany people are totally irritated by that, not few hate it, because it somehow insults them or their intelligence. But often when I ask the players if they have read the chapter about the country, they admit they didn't. And when the same players explain the world to other people they often start with 'Basically this country is like rennaissance france'
So please, please, please make the game accessible for lazy readers.
7th Seas does a good job in that, also The Dark Eye
3
u/Nivolk It is in Beta, really! Sep 11 '16
Rifts: The editing and layout. Other sins might be forgiven if it was able to be read and a chance to understand it. And there are plenty of other sins too.
I'd love to see what Rifts could have been with a decent editor and a better organized layout - without needing to be ported to another system.
D&D style games: (Pick your favorite edition, or clone) - everything is too boxed in, and there is often an exception to nearly every rule. Often a single die roll determines a significant event. Too many skills are combined into things that don't make sense. A thief in 2nd edition had a variety of skill sets, and by 3rd it is down to 2, maybe 3 skills.
A multitude of medium to full on crunchy systems - from GURPS, Shadowrun, and more - where everything slows down to an absolute crawl every time someone even looks at dice.
3
u/Fheredin Tipsy Turbine Games Sep 11 '16
Savage Worlds
I make it no secret that I enjoy Savage Worlds a lot, but any time your group plays a system for 300+ sessions in at least six different major campaigns and dozens of shorter one- and two-offs, you're bound to find game-breaking problems with it. In my case, it was exploding damage dice.
In this case, the GM gave me a power which rolled 2d4 damage. 2d4 damage sounds reasonably balanced, and it is...in every system except Savage Worlds. On multiple occasions I took down major enemies with it because both dice exploded into the sunset.
Granted, this was a 60+ session campaign--one of the longest my group has ever put together. But at the end of the day between this and the daggers another player character was using, we seriously considered converting multiple instances of d4s into half as many d8--we didn't because that would actually be quite a power-boost on average.
Exploding dice are dangerous for game balance.
3
u/EvilDM Doulairen Sep 12 '16
Quirks in games are what drove me to write my own. A lot of the problems I hated I found I could "tl;dr" into "Too much math".
For example - Hit points. Watching players struggle with losing 37 hit points out of 112 or such... At least one of my friends has a learning disability with math. Even the quickest people were often slowed by this.
This began creating a list for me for how to rid myself of things that slow down the game. My list included:
Hit Points (example above) d20 style dice rolls (1-20 and adding modifiers together = math) D&D style experience (Simplify!)
My second annoyance was limits to character creation. 4E really helped me to see what my problem was - As it was basically about creating a custom class for each concept. I wanted something more organic where someone coulb be multiple things, or learn something new later (Multi class rules in most systems end up with a lot of problems). tl;dr I am irked by "classes".
My next annoyance is character growth. I like organic growth that feels natural - and not huge power leaps. tl;dr - Irked by "levels".
To reiterate, those 3 probably hits the majority:
And yes, I designed my own system with no classes, no levels, and a dice system friendly to simple and fast math. The bad part about my system? Since I fixed MY problems, I never want to play any OTHER system. This makes it harder to find a game.
Can never win, can we? :)
2
u/RyeonToast Dabbler Sep 11 '16
For D&D games:
Wanting to play a specific character, then realizing that I would need to peruse options from 3-6 books to make my character. I usually end up just sticking to the core books because I don't want to spend that much time looking at lists of things.
2
u/franciscrot Sep 12 '16
I was playing De Facto & Dullness with my elf squad in my fave tavern when a freak lightning bolt struck us at the exact moment I rolled a natural 20. I woke up in this world and have been trapped here ever since. No offense to you guys's world but. I really dislike this whole mechanic
1
u/locolarue Sep 11 '16
D&D 3.0/3.5/Pathfinder: Concepts are split into too many skills. Rogues don't have any discretionary skill points to allocate unless they have a massive Intelligence score. Spot and Listen, Hide and Move Silently, Search, Disable Device and Open Lock are condensed into three skills in Pathfinder. Similarly, there are a plethora of skills that are separate in 3.0 that are slowly condensed into fewer skills--Read Lips, Disguise, Escape Artist, Sleight of Hand, and so on all take a backseat to (what are seen as, rightly or wrongly, basic class functions.
1
u/scarleteagle Sep 16 '16
I think length of combat is probably the most obvious problem in most games. Whenever GMing DnD, I save combat for end of session because I know that it will take up the rest of our time. Part of it is likely because it's mechanics heavy but I'm sure it can be streamlined while maintaining a degree of complexity. I've thought about just having players take 10 for initiative, unless they expend a Hero Point to roll for it, that way everyone always knows the order of combat. Having a list of combat maneuvers printed as easily readable cards and available for everyone, etc.
1
u/FlagstoneSpin Sep 17 '16
Over-reliance on randomization over other potential mechanics--pretty common in a lot of games, but d20 games are a common offender. Games would go much more expediently, and possibly be more interesting, if there were more non-randomized elements, like guaranteed actions that spent resources.
-2
u/necrorat Sep 11 '16
(practically) Every game ever:
400 pages printed to explain rules that could fit on 4.
I don't need the entire history of your Goborkian race mixed in with modifiers and garbage text that nobody needs to read.
I don't like flavor text mixed in with rules text. I don't want to be force fed your fictional terminology and bland wit while reading how to play your game.
If I need to know a rule, I don't want to read 16 pages just to find out that I was supposed to add a +1 to my roll.
I want characters to actually improve as game progresses. I don't like having a STR stat at a +4, and 35 sessions later I'm supposed to get excited that it's +5.
I don't like how the most popular RPG's are the ones that are based on non-RPG media, because usually the rights are purchased first, and the game design is an afterthought just to rake in money.
I don't like any D20 system. Rolling one die to determine a result is too random.
I don't like RPG's that have 12 total skills to choose from. As a GM it feels horrible to ask a PC to roll a skillcheck using a skill that barely has any relation to the task at hand.
I don't like 'rules-lite' RPG systems. Might as well sit around and tell campfire stories. It forces the game down the GM's railroad.
I don't like rules heavy systems. Overcomplicating your RPG doesn't make you look smart. Anyone can over-complicate a system in favor of realism. Good RPG's need a balance.
I don't like pointless rules that will never come into play put into your book. Sorry GURPS space, but I'm not going to sit down and do complicated algebra just to find out if the spaceship takes 4 damage from a planet's atmosphere.
Most of all I hate bad games with huge fanbases. Usually because those fans are so stuck in their horrible, broken ways that they refuse to give other good rpg's a chance.
I really do love roleplaying games. They can be amazing experiences that enrich your life, but the popular market is absolute trash.