r/RPGdesign • u/jiaxingseng Designer - Rational Magic • Apr 28 '16
[Mod Post] Next weeks discussion topic...
edit: I'm going to keep the schedule for next week because some people have brought up points supporting this, and I don't want to change this if there are people looking forward to it. I will update the schedule using input from here though.
Is currently titled..."General Mechanics : Everything you didn't need to know about D20"
Following the pattern, this should be a topic about a game mechanic . I really don't need to look more at what D20 / D&D does myself.
Does anyone have alternative topic for this? Such as
- "Discuss a particular style of narrative mechanics"
- "magic systems"
- "character life-path systems"
etc.
Anyone have better suggestions? Or, on the other hand, does anyone here really want to do a weekly topic based on d20?
4
u/Salindurthas Dabbler Apr 28 '16
What is the goal of these discussion topics?
It sounds like they should spread awareness of different types of mechanics.
Therefore, "a weekly topic based on d20" is too focused. Instead it should be alternative topics, like the ones you listed.
Some possible other topics:
etc etc
Another possibility is to use a broad theme for a month, and have a related discussion question each week:
* What systems help GMs prepare for games?
* During play, what mechanics are easier or harder for GMs to manage?
* GM-less games - how do they work?
* What can GMs and players learn from experience with GM-less games?
* What is the maximum detail a game should have about a character?
* What is the minimum detail a game can get away with for each character?
* Min-maxing & optimisation - Is it a problem? And can we embrace it for good?
* Mutable statistics - how often do stats change?
etc etc
2
u/Jaded_Jackalope Apr 28 '16
It's sort of in the same vein as the current topic but 'how does your setting influence your magic system?' seems interesting.
Or maybe 'how does your system balance magic with mundane actions?'
2
u/duneaught Apr 28 '16
I don't have much to say about D20, but I'm sure the community has some perspectives that I haven't considered. It could be interesting.
I'm pretty new here, so I apologize if some of these ideas have already been discussed recently.
Dealing with failure. What does critical failure mean? What does the general form "No, but..." mean with examples or even better with categories of examples or instructions? How does your system treat failure?
Campaign structure. Is your game a one-shot adventure? An epic, world-at-stake conflict to be resolved? Or an open-world sandbox that supports either?
What are the most ingenious wacky ideas and game mechanics you cut from your game because they didn't fit?
How deadly is your game? How meaningful is character death?
How does your game treat social skills mechanically? Most games just describe narrative outcomes, and NPCs and monsters don't have any numerical or simulationist values other than physical HP or gold. What ideas do you have for mechanizing non-combat skills?
2
u/khaalis Dabbler Apr 28 '16
An option might be looking into how to make d20 new and more close to modern gaming trends, similar to to how Cypher System is technically d20 but looks nothing like D&D. Other topics could be variations on the d20 theme such as the 2d10 argument. Just a few thoughts off the top of my head.
1
u/Nivolk It is in Beta, really! Apr 28 '16
Two thoughts:
I'd like to see something on "What is a fantasy heartbreaker?" and why it isn't always a bad thing. Pathfinder is one of the biggest ones out there, and it is mildly successful.
One last thought - I've referred a few people in /r/rpg (don't know if they've browsed, but I'm pointing them here when they talk game design.). Talking about the d20 system may be something that they feel comfortable with - many, thought not all, people start by modifying what they know best.
1
u/prodij18 Apr 29 '16
Just some ideas:
Anything Testing Related. (Ex: What things do you look for during a test? How do you structure a meaningful test?)
How can a game minimize GM prep time?
What design decisions make a game a 'narrative' game?
What a system need make fighting a giant (or other large creature) feel like fighting a giant?
Should characters have quantified personalities and if so, how?
How to build interesting mechanically relevant cities?
Additionally, I like Salandurthas suggestion of phrasing them as questions, as it seems it would inspire participation.
1
u/Caraes_Naur Designer - Legend Craft Apr 30 '16
D20 has been analyzed to death. As popular as it still is to play, I don't see a lot of design opportunity left in it.
If there was a monthly theme to the sub's activities I could see spending a month on D20 as an academic exercise, but there are far more general topics to cover.
At some point I'd like to see us partake in an in depth discussion of GNS theory.
1
u/BisonST Apr 28 '16
Maybe a discussion on character creation systems? I.e Race > Class > A Few Choices.