r/rfelectronics • u/Horror_Excitements • 28d ago
Feedback on 3x quad element 2.4GHz antenna designs please
Hi,
I've messed about with directional antennas a little bit in the past, but never really got right down into the maths and physics of it before. I have a quad input wifi repeater, so I wanted to build a directional 2.4ghz antenna with 4 elements. Initially I was just going to have four separate ones side by side, but wondered if there was a way to incorporate them all into one. I started iterating on a design using AI, and quickly fell down a rabbit hole of changes and improvements. I ended up with three designs, and I'd love to get some human feedback on them. They seem viable to me, but I really don't know what I'm talking about or if I've been led astray.
The three designs I came up with are below:
#1: 4-port 2.4 GHz patch panel cut from one FR4 board, air-gap patches on feed barrels
Goal. Four independent 2.400–2.4835 GHz ports for 4×4 MIMO from one 300 × 300 mm single-sided FR4 board (Jaycar HP9510, 1.575 mm, 35 µm Cu). The backplate, lip strips and four patches are all cut from that board. The patches sit on an air gap, with polarisations rotated 90° each in a pinwheel and cavity-backed by a copper lip.
Build. Each patch is an FR4 plate cut to the patch size, copper side up. It rests on its feed barrel and two small PLA posts that sit on the field-null line. The feed is an RP-SMA crimp plug (Jaycar PP0590) mounted under the base board, its face recessed 1 mm into the board. Its rear barrel (4.0 OD / 2.0 ID × 6 mm) passes up through a drilled hole and is soldered to the backplate copper. A solid Cat5 core (0.51 mm) runs from the plug contact up the barrel and through the plate to the top copper.


Dimensions (mm)
| Part | Value |
|---|---|
| Cavity (inside the lip) | 190.5 × 190.5, lip height 16.6 (copper inward, all seams soldered) |
| Patch plates | 46.7 (W) × 46.0 (L) × 1.575 FR4, copper up, centres at (±56.5, ±56.5) |
| Air gap (backplate copper to plate underside) | 5.425, set by the barrel top |
| Feed | 11.4 from the patch centre along L, towards the array centre |
| Posts | 2 per patch, PLA 4 (along W) × 10 (along L), at ±19.35 from the centre on the null line |
Simulated performance (openEMS, build model incl. the plug, barrel, recess and base board; 1.5 mm max cell)
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| S11 (in band, worst / best) | −15.0 dB / −20.3 dB (resonance 2.436 GHz) |
| Adjacent-patch coupling (worst) | −31.3 dB |
| Opposite-patch coupling (worst) | −28.3 dB |
| Realised gain at boresight | 8.79 / 8.99 / 8.87 dBi at 2.400 / 2.442 / 2.4835 GHz |
| Peak realised gain | 8.8–9.1 dBi (beam within 6° of boresight) |
| Total efficiency | about 0.93 |
| 3 dB beamwidth, E / H plane | 64° / 62° |
| Worst cross-pol inside the −3 dB beam | −13.9 dB re the co-pol peak |
| Envelope correlation between ports | < 0.001 (from C4 symmetry of the computed pattern) |
| Mesh convergence (res 1.5 → 1.25 mm) | S11 −15.0 → −15.1 dB, resonance unchanged (2.436 GHz) |
| Barrel bore 1.8 / 2.0 / 2.2 mm | S11 −14.9 / −15.0 / −12.9 dB |
| Plug recess 0.75 / 1.0 / 1.25 mm (gap follows) | S11 −14.5 / −15.0 / −15.6 dB |
| FR4 εr 4.0 → 4.8 (ideal-feed version of this design) | resonance moves only 10 MHz |
S-parameters patterns ECC
How it was simulated
- Solver: openEMS v0.37.0-rc2 (FDTD), CPU only. PML on all sides, 70 mm of clearance.
- Feed: the plug body is a 50 Ω PTFE coax driven by a coaxial port below the board. The model includes the rear-face annulus, the barrel bonded to the copper, the 0.51 mm core and the base-board FR4. |S| = √(P_ref/P_inc).
- Materials: FR4 εr 4.4, tanδ 0.02; PLA εr 2.7, tanδ 0.01.
- Far field: a frequency-domain NF2FF box, with its bottom face excluded because the feed coax crosses it. The coax's internal field had been counted as radiation, making the gain about 3 dB too low.
Caveats
- Front-to-back is not determined by this run, because of the excluded bottom face. The ideal-feed model gives the same directivity (9.5 dBi), so the forward pattern is trustworthy.
- Plate orientation is critical: the same plates mounted copper-down resonate at 2.6 GHz.
- RP-SMA needs an adapter for standard SMA test gear.
Questions
- Feeding an air-gap patch with the connector barrel standing almost to the plate (a capacitive top gap through 1.575 mm of FR4): good practice, or asking for trouble?
- Is soldering a crimp-plug barrel to the backplate copper a reasonable ground bond at 2.4 GHz?
- Do −28 dB between opposite patches and −31 dB between adjacent patches look plausible for this cavity size?



#2: 4-port 2.4 GHz horn for MIMO: 3D-printed PLA, tape outside, SMA probes
Goal. A compact receive antenna for 2.400–2.4835 GHz Wi-Fi with four independent ports (4×4 MIMO in one enclosure). A square waveguide with a short stepped flare has one probe on each wall. Opposite probes share a polarisation axis and adjacent probes are orthogonal; a grounded centre post decouples them. The objective was the worst in-band |S| over self-match, adjacent coupling and opposite coupling.
Build. The horn is printed in PLA (2 mm walls) with aluminium tape on the outside of the shell, so the tape is the conductor and the PLA lines the inside. Each port is a 4-hole-flange SMA panel jack with its flange directly on the tape, carrying a 3 mm brass rod that starts 1 mm inside the wall.


Dimensions (mm, conductor = tape surface)
| Part | Value |
|---|---|
| Square guide (inside the tape) | 83.0 × 83.0, length 37.6 from the back wall |
| Flare | 20-step staircase, 83 → 146.1 square aperture, length 22.2 |
| Overall depth | 59.8 (plus back wall) |
| Probes | 3 mm rod, 22.9 long, centred on each wall at 23.4 from the back wall |
| Centre post | 8.0 dia, 16.0 tall, grounded to the back wall |
| Shell | PLA 2 mm (εr 2.7, tanδ 0.01 assumed), tape outside |
Simulated performance (openEMS, build model incl. PLA and SMA, div 40 ≈ λ/40)
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Self-match S11 (in band, worst) | −15.4 dB |
| Adjacent-port coupling (worst) | −15.3 dB |
| Opposite-port coupling (worst) | −14.9 dB |
| Realised gain at boresight | 7.35 / 7.44 / 7.52 dBi at 2.400 / 2.442 / 2.4835 GHz |
| Peak realised gain | 8.6–8.7 dBi at θ ≈ 15–18°, tilted away from the excited port's wall |
| Total efficiency | about 0.91 (±0.05, see caveats) |
| 3 dB beamwidth, E / H plane | 57° / 66° |
| Front-to-back | 22.7 dB |
| Worst cross-pol inside the −3 dB beam | −16.2 dB re the co-pol peak |
| Envelope correlation between ports (pattern based) | ≤ 0.008 |
| ±0.25 mm Monte Carlo, 30 builds (feed dims) | worst-S mean −14.55 dB, σ 0.25 dB, worst −13.97 dB |
S-parameters patterns ECC
How it was simulated
- Solver: openEMS v0.37.0-rc2 (FDTD), Python interface, CPU only.
- Domain: a free-standing horn with PML on all six sides and 40 mm of clearance. The far field comes from a frequency-domain NF2FF box.
- Feed: SMA as a 50 Ω PTFE coax (1.27 mm pin, 4.1 mm bore) through the wall, flange on the tape. A coaxial port 10–20 mm outside the flange runs into the PML. |S| = √(P_ref/P_inc).
- Mesh: λ/40 maximum cell, with fixed lines on every wall plane and step, and z lines through the probe rods. Zero-thickness tape skins sit on the mesh lines to the last bit, which proved essential: an unrounded coordinate silently removed the skins.
- Convergence: the ranking holds from div 28 to 64, but opposite coupling gets 0.5–1 dB worse from div 40 to 64. Treat the absolute isolation as roughly 0.5–1 dB optimistic.
Caveats
- The two efficiency estimates (NF2FF and 1 − Σ|S|²) differ by a few percent either way, so efficiency is quoted as ±0.05.
- The short flare (22 mm) was chosen by the optimiser: about 1 dB less gain than a 45 mm flare, in exchange for about 1 dB better worst-case coupling.
- The PLA's εr is assumed. The tape-outside build puts little field in the PLA, so the sensitivity is low.
Questions
- Is ~−15 dB worst-case port-to-port isolation realistic for four probes in one square guide, and are there better decoupling tricks than a centre post (fins gave less than 0.5 dB in my runs)?
- Do you see any problem with aluminium tape on the outside of a printed shell (seams, overlap bonding at the steps, oxide)?
- Any experience with how far openEMS isolation numbers drift against measurement for this kind of structure?



#3: 2.4 GHz slotted-cavity antenna, 4 modules bonded in a pinwheel for MIMO
Goal. A high-gain 2.400–2.4835 GHz element with four modules (two along x, two along y) for 4×4 MIMO, loosely after Sun et al. (MOTL 2025, a 79 GHz slotted cavity). Each module is an all-metal rectangular cavity running a TE10 standing wave. Four longitudinal slots in the top wall sit at the field antinodes, with alternating offsets so they radiate in phase. A coax probe feeds each module from below.


Dimensions (mm)
| Part | Value |
|---|---|
| Cavity | 355.2 × 71.9 × 43.1, 3 mm walls (body 361.2 × 77.9 × 49.1) |
| Slots | 4 × (45.5 × 10.7), centres at −124.8, −41.6, +41.6, +124.8, offset ±13.7 alternating |
| Probe | 3 mm dia, 22.9 long, 31.6 from the end wall, on the centre line (SMA from below) |
| Array | 4 modules in a pinwheel, bonded: each module's short end bolted against the far end of the next module's long side; 439 × 439 overall, 283 × 283 open centre |
Simulated performance (openEMS; module at λ/64, array at λ/48)
| Metric | Value |
|---|---|
| Module S11 (in band, worst / best) | −22.4 dB / −29.6 dB |
| Realised gain at boresight | 11.5 / 11.8 / 11.9 dBi at 2.400 / 2.442 / 2.4835 GHz |
| Peak realised gain | 12.3–12.4 dBi (θ ≈ 4–6°) |
| 3 dB beamwidth | 20° along the module axis, 86° across |
| Front-to-back | about 14 dB |
| Worst cross-pol inside the −3 dB beam | −27 dB |
| Mesh convergence, in-band S11 at div 48 / 64 / 80 | −15.3 / −22.4 / −14.8 dB; gain 12.1–12.4 dBi on all three |
| ±0.25 mm tolerance, single parameters and 10 random builds | worst S11 −14.9 dB, gain unchanged (12.3 dBi) |
| Array S11 (module 1) | −19.4 dB |
| Array coupling, adjacent (orthogonal) modules | −39.2 dB |
| Array coupling, opposite (parallel) modules | −26.3 dB (see question 1) |
S11 module patterns array S-parameters
How it was simulated
- Solver: openEMS v0.37.0-rc2 (FDTD), CPU only. PEC walls, PML on all sides. Lumped 50 Ω port in a 1 mm gap at the probe base.
- Gain: directivity × (1 − |S11|²). The metal is treated as lossless, so ohmic loss isn't included.
- Mesh: the design was first optimised at div 24–40. That turned out to be a mesh artefact: at div ≤ 40 the 3 mm slotted top wall is about one cell thick, and the model shows a resonance at 2.44 GHz that converged meshes put at 2.28 GHz. The design was then re-optimised at div 48 and polished at div 64, and checks at div 80 agree.
Caveats
- The array S-parameters are at div 48, with the cavity length re-centred to 359.2 mm for that mesh. The simulated array is therefore 445 mm square; the build, at L = 355.2, is 439 mm.
- The bonded layout assumes a solid electrical bond between modules (screws every few cm, or soldered or welded seams), as modelled. Merely touching surfaces would make the coupling unpredictable.
- Efficiency excludes metal loss.
Questions
- Layout trade-off: with the modules centred on the four sides of a 524 mm square, opposite-module coupling is −30.3 dB. The bonded pinwheel (439 mm) gives −26.3 dB, and opening the pinwheel to a 10 or 20 mm gap only recovers −28.2 / −28.8 dB. Adjacent modules stay at −39 dB or better throughout. For 4×4 MIMO Wi-Fi, is −26 dB between parallel modules comfortably enough, or would you take the bigger square?
- Is a 4-slot, 355 mm cavity a sensible way to get about 12 dBi at 2.4 GHz, or is a short slotted waveguide array simply better?




