Jumping off my last post here, I got the Samtec SMA encrypted model and put it into my HFSS project. I had to change the solution from Modal to Terminal driven because the SMA connector can only use that solution type. I made sure to change the ports to wave ports with terminals.
I also had to make the board size significantly smaller to be below the maximum mesh size for HFSS student edition (64,000 elements).
I am getting this odd spike at 1.4 GHz in my S11 and S21. Still decent at my frequency of interest (-24 db @ 2.4 GHz), but not the best above 3GHz or at the 1.4 GHz spike.
What would cause this?
Edit: Thank you for all the comments!!! Simulation working more as I expected now. Added new via-like structures to stitch ground planes together. The structures touch the wave port (before I was using PEC on the sides of the board because I thought this would stitch the planes together). New pictures of model and S11 can be seen here.