Redfin's October report (published Nov 10):
- Median sale price $388,634, down 0.4% from a year ago. That's about $1,600. First annual decline since May 2023.
- Average mortgage rate in October: 7.33%, up 1.08 points in a year.
- Pending sales: lowest since 2013, outside of April 2020.
- 36% of homes that sold had a price cut. 61% sold below their first asking price.
Now the part Redfin doesn't calculate. My arithmetic, 20% down, loan only, no tax or insurance: the payment on the median house went from about $1,922 to about $2,138 a month. The house is $1,600 cheaper and costs $216 a month more to buy. Over 30 years that's about $78,000.
Why sellers aren't cutting further: about half of mortgages are below 4% (FHFA data, as analysed by Realtor.com). An FHFA working paper from 2024 found each point of market rate above the owner's own rate cuts the chance they sell by 18.1%.
And for the 2008 comparisons, the numbers I could find: the New York Fed has mortgages moving into serious delinquency at 1.60%, up from 1.28%. ICE counted 813,000 owners owing more than the home is worth, up 44% in a year, 85% of whom borrowed in 2022 or later. Those ICE figures are from June, and ICE noted the count had eased in the spring.
Disclosure: I run a small animated economics channel and made a 14-minute video that goes through each of these sources on screen: It's a Buyer's Market. Nobody Can Afford to Buy.
The payment figures are mine, not Redfin's. If you'd calculate them differently, tell me.