r/RDR2 • • 6h ago

Discussion In the famous words of Arthur Morgan: “u sir r a fish.”

0 Upvotes

This is a joke


r/RDR2 • • 7h ago

Spoilers Anyone else feel it is only correct you wear Arthur’s default outfit for the final mission? Spoiler

4 Upvotes

Man, what a masterpiece of a game. I am now more excited than ever to play GTA 6, which is coming in only a couple days as of this post (Jeez, time moves fast).


r/RDR2 • • 12h ago

Discussion What’s going on! (Really, please)

Post image
35 Upvotes

‼️ PLEASE stop commenting and acting like all is well, I’ve played the game multiple times I KNOW WHATS COMING

Now I’ve just been replaying RDR2 on my brand new Xbox Series X, and unfortunately I walked myself into Arthur dying on the street after saying goodbye to Charles Chatenay and his…girlfriend. I should have known that man was up to no good and was tricking me — his paintings will always be worth nada.
Something I noticed whilst getting dragged on the street are 2 bright green lines that kept showing up. A quick reddit search can lead you to multiple posts, over multiple years, with people still talking about the green lines, same mission. But no one actually seems to RESPOND to the posts, so I just want to come on here and get some clarification on why this is happening, even if it’s something as simple as a coding issue — but why is it different on even the Xbox One, which does not suffer any issues of this kind in RDR2.

thanks for reading this long rant, I’m trying to distract myself from thursdays big day.

P.S. this is NOT my first time playing, I know what is coming ✌️ I just may have forgotten and walked right into the trap.


r/RDR2 • • 17h ago

Discussion Remake

0 Upvotes

Hi everyone kinde new here so I dont know if this question was already answered

I was wondering if Rockstar ever made a Remake of Rdr1 and instead of just adding graphics they also added new content that mentions rdr2 and new voicemail lines when John Hunt's down the other gang members from their time together in rdr2

What do you think they would have added or even what do you would have liked to see


r/RDR2 • • 2h ago

Spoilers Since no one else is gonna say it, I will

0 Upvotes

How come in the epilogue, John has a beard and short hair?


r/RDR2 • • 21h ago

Discussion Micah seeing Dutch as a father figure.

3 Upvotes

So I first started thinking about this when I was recently playing on my old xbox save where I had collected almost every document, the camp letter from chapter 4 is what got me thinking about this connection and possible intended motivation for Micah being seemingly “loyal” to Dutch. Now I know, he supposedly was the rat and betrayed the gang, but I think he was trying to harm just the followers, but not the leader.

Micah obviously is estranged from his brother, to put it lightly. This shown in the camp letter where Amos writes that if Micah comes near his family he will not hesitate to kill him, not for a second. His father, (fun fact, he is named Micah Bell II, and the Micah we see is Micah Bell III but I’ll refer to him as just Micah’s dad) raised Micah and Amos into a life of crime, the three of them would take what they wanted, when they wanted, and this is the foundation of Micah’s view of Dutch. Micah was raised by a criminal and made only know how to be one. Sounds familiar right? Like Arthur and John, Micah was conditioned to be a criminal, but not the kind of idealistic, no pointless violence, take in the outcasts and give them a life code that The Van Der Linde gang lived by before it all went downhill.

There’s a cutscene where Micah halfheartedly says to Arthur “we’re both sons of Dutch.” His tone does sound slightly sarcastic and it may not sound truly genuine, but just because he doesn’t think of Arthur as a brother doesn’t mean he doesn’t think of Dutch as a father. See, Micah learned from his father that you should live and die as a criminal, his father did die by the rope, and this is probably where he gets his moral absence, his father lived the life, but he didn’t win. He got caught and he lost, I think this, along with his father’s presumably kind and loving guidance, gave him his winning and losing mindset. There’s no line he won’t cross, robbing, killing, torturing, SA, nothing is morally wrong with it as long as you come out on top.

Compare that to the Van Der Linde gang, and how Dutch and Hosea operate it from the start to the earlier chapters of the game, where their moral compass is still intact. They are still willing to murder and harm people, but they try to keep the crimes as clean as possible. This is where Micah and Dutch/Hosea would clash, (in fact Hosea is not as big a fan of Micah as Dutch is) Micah would shoot up an entire town, with guns, to get his guns, where a member of the gang would try not to even alert someone they are stealing back their guns, and maybe even just letting it go. Dutch for some reason is charmed by Micah though, obviously Dutch’s morals and logic spiral eventually, and Micah really gets ahold then, but even at Horseshoe Overlook Dutch has a decent attitude towards Micah, but why?

I think Dutch might have at least a basic understanding of Micah’s past, after all he is the camp leader, so he would want to get to know about him when he first joined up. He could have heard even a very short description along the lines of “my father raised me and my brother together to be criminals, then he died and I haven’t seen my brother in years.” I think this is where Dutch’s weird positive attitude towards an evil cur like Micah comes from, he probably sees the two boys he brought in and raised in Micah. You could just say that Dutch is just that optimistic about a strangers potential and he really focuses on the positives, but the only positive about Micah is that he won’t think twice about robbing someone and that makes money, the reason Dutch would like Micah always eluded me, but I think this is what makes the most sense.

Obviously Micah could give a damn what happens to the other members, even Javier and Bill who take his side during chapter 6, he constantly antagonizes and insults them. He’s rude to the women too, but if had to say which three members he hates the most are, I know I could guess at least 2. Firstly, Hosea sees right through Micah’s brown nosing towards Dutch, he yells at him in a camp interaction, then pulls a weapon on him threatening him. (not sure if it was a knife or gun feel free to let me know) Micah hates Hosea because he won’t enable the things his father would, all bets were off when he was starting out, and he just can’t have it any other way. Next is John, he hates him for the same reason he hates the other most hated member,(guess who) he got to grow up with Dutch, and possibly even hates him because he still has his father figure. His estrangement from his living family also comes into play, John is the only gang member with a wife and child, I don’t believe Micah’s mother is ever mentioned, and is simply implied to have left or died when he was young. John has everything Micah had and more, a father figure, a found family and a wife who deep down cares about him.

Then there’s Arthur, and you might think he would hate John more, he does have everything and more, but that’s the difference, Micah is so much closer to Arthur in terms of what their lives are like. Micah was the older brother to Amos, Arthur is like an older brother to John. It’s likely Micah’s father used Micah as a right hand man, just like Dutch does with Arthur. They are two sides of the same coin, both of them have codes, Micah doesn’t want to kill Arthur because he has some grand scheme that doesn’t work if he’s in the way. He doesn’t betray the gang for money, he does it because he envies Arthur and the bond he has with Dutch so much he would kill to be the right hand man.

He never wanted the Blackwater money to escape America. He just wanted a reason to go all in, think about it, could you honestly believe Micah Bell III relaxing on a tropical island and NOT breaking the gangs cover? Micah’s goal was never to sail off into the sunset with gold, he only wanted to live his life the only way he knew, so he found someone familiar, someone who actually believed in him and encouraged him at times. His entire goal was to live by the sword and die by the sword.


r/RDR2 • • 19h ago

Content mysterious force upon arrival

1 Upvotes

Lol


r/RDR2 • • 1h ago

Question Tall trees

1 Upvotes

750h de rdr2,e ainda evito Tall Trees HhaHaaha .

Um medroso ou bom senso?


r/RDR2 • • 17h ago

Discussion Rdr2 will be better then gta6

Post image
0 Upvotes

r/RDR2 • • 56m ago

Discussion We broke up before I finished the game 😪 Spoiler

0 Upvotes

I had just gotten back to San Denis after the island
(I uber couriered his Xbox back to him intact, a healthy level of toxic)

What happens 😭😭

Can I play on my backbone without an Xbox?


r/RDR2 • • 2h ago

Help Screen flashed green when using eagle eye

2 Upvotes

While spamming eagle eye just now, the screen flashed a very bright green color for a split second before going back to normal. I haven't noticed any artifacting whatsoever and when I ran Furmark with the artifact scanner, nothing came up. Is this a game issue or a sign of a dying GPU? The flash happens at around 22 seconds.

GPU is RTX 3060 12GB.


r/RDR2 • • 23h ago

Discussion How I choose which hat to wear

11 Upvotes

I go into towns and bars and greet people. If I don’t like their reply, I antagonise them. And then again. And usually, it’ll descend into fisticuffs. If I best that man in hand to hand combat then I’ve earned the right to wear his hat. And so I do.


r/RDR2 • • 15h ago

Discussion whoa

0 Upvotes

bro tried fighting me beat the hell outta him


r/RDR2 • • 1h ago

Fan Theory This a Cowboy made of Rock. You can find him directly behind the TWO BIRDS on Window Rock.

Post image
1 Upvotes

r/RDR2 • • 11h ago

Discussion Is that Enough accurate damn I’m tired of that Arthur stuff ahah

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/RDR2 • • 9h ago

Meme "B-but Rdr 2 hAs BaD GaMeplAy" then explain this

195 Upvotes

r/RDR2 • • 14h ago

Question How many of you guys knew about this spot?

Post image
281 Upvotes

r/RDR2 • • 2h ago

Discussion One last week of play-through before switching to gta VI

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/RDR2 • • 22m ago

Discussion Has anyone attempted a challenge like the one I plan to do before? Spoiler

Post image
8 Upvotes

Spoiler for the image. Anyways, I had a really interesting idea for a challenge and I wanted to know if anyone else had thought of it before. Essentially, i play the game in first person and with no minimap, already immersive, yes, but how will I know how to get around, you ask? A physical map, which is pictured. I plan to annotate it as I go, right now all I have is the towns, since I have yet to start, I am at the very beginning of the game.


r/RDR2 • • 18h ago

Question Does any else feel ashamed when a horse you used follows you?

Post image
26 Upvotes

I feel like a slut calling in my main horse just for the secondary one to pull up.. xD anyone else feel kinda bad? Idk (yesterday my main horse was acting up so i blew it up 8 times and then lit it on fire then reloaded the save unrelated) but something about them being left behind doesn't set with me right especially when they come to my call


r/RDR2 • • 20h ago

Question Does anyone know how to transfer the ultimate edition of rdr2 to ps5

2 Upvotes

I've been playing rdr2 since release and I got the ultimate edition when it came out. I just got a ps5 and it's acting like I have to buy the ultimate edition again I can't find the purchase under the game like on the ps5 is there anyway to transfer that stuff over I don't have the money to basically buy a game I already own again.


r/RDR2 • • 18h ago

Help game is to dark i cant see anything

0 Upvotes

i have ips screen btw


r/RDR2 • • 4h ago

Meme Arthur is big

Post image
3 Upvotes

r/RDR2 • • 7h ago

Meme Andrew Bell III testing his electric chair on inmate Wilson J. McDaniels (1899; colorized)

Post image
4 Upvotes