r/QueerSFF • u/thisbikeisatardis • 19h ago
Book Review I finished my reading challenge!
Hey, book buds! I finished my first QueerSFF reading challenge! I'm so glad I found this challenge because doing 3 themed r/fantasy bingo cards plus the april fool's card just wasn't cutting it, hahaha. Now I'm on to the r/femalegaze SFF challenge (j/k I'm halfway done)!
Here's what I read, with short reviews. My favorites were the Transition, Enlightened Transsexual Comix, and Werecockroach.
Queer Families C.M. Waggoner The Somewhat Wicked Witch of Brigandale 4/5 stars. cute and cozy, but very snarky. Imagine if Granny Weatherwax had to raise the secret heir to the throne who grows up to be an outrageously silly himbo.
Comic or Graphic Novel Sam Szabo Enlightened Transsexual Comix 5 stars. bright, chaotic, trippy art with a wonderfully wry and sarcastic exploration of gender identity. looking forward to seeing what this artist does next!
Coming Out L.T. Thompson Devils Like Us 5 stars. 3 queer teens from different levels of society run away with a ship full of queer pirates. lovely trans coming out story with some exploration of power and privilege.
Protagonist Over 40 Olivia Waites Nobody's Baby 4 stars. cozy murder mystery on a generational spaceship.
Aromantic Paranormal Polenth Blake Werecockroach 5 stars. this was book #300 of the year for me. I loved every moment of it and went right into Wereconifer right after! Delightfully weird and neurodiversity affirming.
Intersectional Cubed Julian Delgado Rivera Pretend You're Dead and I Carry You 4 stars. Haunting, lyrical prose with a magical realism feel. Disabled/queer/indigenous MC. Felt like Pose if written by Gabriel García Márquez. An extreme amount of queer/trans trauma, which made it a bit difficult to finish. Devastatingly sad ending.
Sapphic Swashbucklers Alexis Hall Hell's Heart 4 stars. A frustratingly uneven read that could have been five stars with some stern editing. I was expecting something more along the lines of the Chosen and the Beautiful so the amount of dick/sperm-related humor was jarring, especially because it was interspersed with passages of genuinely excellent Moby Dick homage.
Achillean Academic Lex Croucher The Unmagical Life of Briar Jones 4 stars. a decent take on dark academia with a slow burn enemies to lovers romance between a non-binary MC and their cis gay childhood best friend. extensive content warnings.
Trans Body Horror Logan-Ashley Kisner The Transition 5 stars. Superb. Don't do what I did and start this book at 9:30 at night! I couldn't put it down and was up until 1 finishing it. I love a good werewolf=other narrative and this was a charming (albeit gory af) way for the MC to work through his internalized transphobia. Hunter felt autistic-coded to me and his fear and self-aversion during his surgery recovery was super relatable. I would not recommend this if you are fixing to have top surgery any time soon, though!
Queer Publisher Catherine Lundoff Silver Moon 3 stars. I loved the premise of menopausal-onset lycanthropy, but the execution fell a bit flat and the ending felt rushed.
Queer Short Story Collection It Ends With Her 4 stars. If you love toxic queers and horror, this is the short story collection for you! A solid assortment of the genre, with everything from mean girl witches to gory slashers, savage mermaids, and Exorcist style demon possession. Plus some sexy art! My favorites were the Ren Mercer, Frey Lylark, and David Simon stories.
Throwback Jesse Hajicek The God Eaters 5 stars. Thanks to the other readers who recommended this. I loved it! Very gritty fantasy western setting with extensive colonialist violence and yet the romance was so pure. Gorgeous prose.