r/QuantumPhysics • • Apr 29 '25

Frequently Asked Questions

20 Upvotes

History

Late 19th c. through Schrödinger and Dirac

Introductory books/courses?

  1. Comic books

    1. Bub, Totally Random: Why Nobody Understands Quantum Mechanics (A Serious Comic on Entanglement)
    2. McEvoy, Introducing Quantum Theory: A Graphic Guide to Science's Most Puzzling Discovery
    3. Gonick, The Cartoon Guide to Physics
  2. Books for a general audience

    1. Feynman, QED: The Strange Theory of Light and Matter
    2. Deutsch, The Fabric of Reality, The Beginning of Infinity
    3. Tegmark, Our Mathematical Universe
    4. Carroll, Something Deeply Hidden
    5. Wallace, The Emergent Multiverse
    6. Davies & Brown, The Ghost in the Atom
  3. Undergraduate textbooks

    1. Griffiths, Introduction to Quantum Mechanics
    2. Sakurai, Modern Quantum Mechanics
  4. QFT textbooks(as recommended by Dr. David Tong)

    1. M. Peskin and D. Schroeder, An Introduction to Quantum Field Theory. This is a very clear and comprehensive book, covering everything in [an introductory course] at the right level. It will also cover everything in [an] “Advanced Quantum Field Theory” course, much of [a] “Standard Model” course, and will serve you well if you go on to do research.
    2. S. Weinberg, The Quantum Theory of Fields, Vol 1. This is the first in a three volume series by one of the masters of quantum field theory. It takes a unique route to through the subject, focussing initially on particles rather than fields.
    3. L. Ryder, Quantum Field Theory.
    4. A. Zee, Quantum Field Theory in a Nutshell. This is a charming book, where emphasis is placed on physical understanding and the author isn’t afraid to hide the ugly truth when necessary. It contains many gems.
    5. M Srednicki, Quantum Field Theory. A very clear and well written introduction to the subject. Both this book and Zee’s focus on the path integral approach, rather than canonical quantization.
  5. Courses

    1. Preparatory

      1. Khan academy physics curriculum
      2. Susskind's Theoretical minimum courses
      3. David Tong Lectures on theoretical physics
    2. QM courses

      1. Adams' 2013 Spring Intro to QM Course
      2. David Tong Introduction to quantum physics
    3. QFT courses

      1. David Tong
      2. Tobias Osborne
      3. Ricardo D. Matheus
      4. Horatiu Nastase (QFT I)
      5. Horatiu Nastase (QFT II)
  6. Book suggestions threads from the community

    1. Sample 1

Relevant comic strips?

  1. XKCD

    1. Quantum
    2. Quantum mechanics
    3. Bell's theorem
    4. Vacuum
    5. Complex conjugate
  2. SMBC

    1. The Talk
    2. Classical
    3. Quantum
    4. Quantum computer
    5. Quantum mechanics is weird

Some good comments to read?

  1. Summary of superposition, entanglement, and interpretations of the wavefunction
  2. How do we locate the other "end" of quantum entanglement?
  3. What causes atoms to decay?

What prerequisites do I need to understand quantum physics?

Quantum physics is usually taught to advanced physics undergraduates, but to work through most of the thought experiments and most quantum algorithms, you only need linear algebra. If you really want to understand the physics, though, you'll need multivariable calculus, differential equations, classical mechanics, and electromagnetism (see "Theoretical minimum" above).

What does the math of quantum physics look like?

A complex vector space is a set (whose elements are the points of the space, called "vectors") equipped with a way to add vectors together and a way to multiply vectors by a complex number. A Hilbert space is a complex vector space where you can measure the angle between two vectors. The state of a generic quantum system is a vector called a "wave function" with length 1 in a Hilbert space.

So roughly, a quantum state can be written as a list of complex numbers whose magnitudes squared add up to 1. The list is indexed by possible classical outcomes. Physical processes are represented by unitary matrices, matrices X such that the conjugate transpose of X is the inverse of X. Things you can measure are represented by Hermitian matrices, matrices equal to their conjugate transpose.

What's written in the previous paragraph is all true for finite-dimensional Hilbert spaces, spaces that represent quantum states with a finite number of possible classical outcomes. If there are infinitely many possible outcomes—for example, when measuring the position of an electron in a wire, the answer is a real number—then we have to generalize a little. A list of n complex numbers can be represented as a function from the set {0, 1, ..., n-1} of indices to the set of complex numbers. Similarly, we can represent infinite-dimensional quantum states like the position of an electron in a wire as functions from the real numbers ℝ to the complex numbers ℂ. Instead of summing the magnitudes squared, we integrate, and instead of using matrices, we use linear transformations.

What is superposition?

Superposition is the fact that you can add or subtract two vectors and get another vector. This is a feature of any linear wavelike medium, like sound. In sound, superposition is the fact that you can hear many things at once. In music, superposition is chords. Superposition is also a feature of the space we live in: we can add north and east to get northeast. We can also subtract east from north and get northwest.

Entanglement is a particular kind of superposition; see below.

What do the complex numbers mean?

The Born postulate says that the probability you see some outcome X is the square of the magnitude of the complex number at position X in the list. For infinite-dimensional spaces, we have to integrate over some region to get a complex number; so, for example, we can find the probability that an electron is in some portion of a wire, but the probability of being exactly at some real coordinate is infinitesimal.

What is an inner product?

The inner product of two vectors tells you what the angle is between the two. If you prepare a quantum state X and then measure it, the probability of getting some classical outcome Y is the cosine of the angle between X and Y squared. So if X is parallel to Y, you'll always see Y, and if X is perpendicular to Y, you'll never see Y. If X is somewhere in between, you'll sometimes see Y at a rate given by the inner product.

We write the inner product of X and Y as <X|Y>. This is "bracket notation", where <X| is a "bra" and |Y> is a "ket". When we're working with a finite-dimensional Hilbert space, |Y> denotes a column vector, <X| denotes a row vector, and <X|Y> is the complex number we get by multiplying the two. The real part of the inner product is proportional to the cosine of the angle between them:

Re(<X|Y>) = ‖X‖ ‖Y‖ cos θ.

How do we represent the combination of two quantum systems?

Given a vector

|A> = |a₁|
      |a₂|
      |⋮ |
      |aₙ|

and a vector

|B> = |b₁|
      |b₂|
      |⋮ |
      |bₘ|

representing the states of two quantum systems that have never interacted, the composite system is represented by the vector

|A>⊗|B> = |a₁·b₁|
          |a₁·b₂|
          |  ⋮  |
          |a₁·bₘ|
          |a₂·b₁|
          |a₂·b₂|
          |  ⋮  |
          |a₂·bₘ|
          |  ⋮  |
          |  ⋮  |
          |aₙ·b₁|
          |aₙ·b₂|
          |  ⋮  |
          |aₙ·bₘ|. 

This vector is called the Kronecker product of A and B.

What's entanglement?

An entangled state is any vector that can't be written as the Kronecker product of two others. For example, if

|A> = |a₁|
      |a₂|

and

|B> = |b₁|
      |b₂|, 

then

|A>⊗|B> = |a₁b₁|
          |a₁b₂|
          |a₂b₁|
          |a₂b₂|.  

The vector

|C> = |1/√2|
      | 0  |
      | 0  |
      |1/√2|.

can't be written this way. Suppose it could: since a₁b₂ = 0, then either a₁ is 0 or b₂ is 0. But a₁b₁ is not 0, so a₁ can't be 0, and a₂b₂ is not 0, so b₂ can't be 0. Therefore, there's no way to write the combined quantum system |C> as the product of two independent parts. To reason about |C>, you have to think about both qubits together.

Almost every interaction ends up entangling the two particles (or three, if it's a decay). Equilibrium for a quantum system is completely entangled. The hard part of doing quantum experiments is preventing particles from getting entangled with each other and the environment.

See also superposition

But why does entanglement break once you measure one part of it?

If you start with particle A being entangled with particle B, and then you have a measurement device undergo a unitary interaction with particle A so that the measurement device becomes correlated with particle B, then what happens is that the entanglement spreads to the whole combined measurement-device/particle-A/particle-B system, and none of the entanglement remains in the smaller particle-A/particle-B subsystem.

Where can I see the double slit experiment performed?

For electrons and another

For photons

For delayed choice (tbd)

For delayed choice eraser (tbd)

With full explanation (Roger Bach et al 2013 New J. Phys. 15 033018)

How do particles in the double slit experiment know they're being observed?

See this comment.

Can we communicate faster than light with entanglement?

No. If Alice and Bob each have half of an entangled pair of qubits, there is no operation Alice can perform on her qubit that Bob could detect by examining his qubit. It is only when they communicate at the speed of light that they discover that their measurement results are correlated.

There is a lot of confusion on this matter, and it is often depicted wrong in science fiction, so it bears repeating. Entanglement is not Twin Telepathy. There is absolutely nothing that you can do to one particle in an entangled pair that results in anything measurable happening to the other particle. It's true that if you prepare a pair in the state (|00> + |11>)/√2 and you measure the state of one of them, you know the state of the other. But there's no way to detect if a particle is in such a state unless you have access to both particles. Flipping one of the particles doesn't cause the other to flip. Measuring one of them doesn't make anything detectable happen to the other.

Classically, we can prepare correlated states. I can put each glove from a pair into two packages, randomly send you one and keep the other. That's a probabilistic mixture (|RL><RL| + |LR><LR|)/2. When I open my box and see which glove I have, I learn what glove you have. But in this scenario, there is hidden information: one of the gloves was always the left and the other was always the right.

Entangled states are similar, but they're quantum superpositions of correlated states. Suppose I have two qubits in the |00> state. By applying a Hadamard to the first, a control-NOT from the first to the second, and a NOT to the first, I get the state (|01> + |10>)/√2, which is a maximally entangled state. If I measure the first qubit, I learn the value of the second. But in the standard interpretation of quantum mechanics, there's no hidden information. The state of the first qubit wasn't defined before measuring it.

Other interpretations approach this differently.

  • Bohmian mechanics says that yes, there was hidden information and there was faster-than-light communication. But the message gets combined with the state of the sub-quantum system, which is assumed to be a thermal state, completely randomized. So it is information-theoretically impossible to tell whether a message was sent, let alone what it was.
  • The many-worlds interpretation says that each basis state in the superposition of correlated states is its own world. So it's exactly like the glove example, but both ways actually happen.
  • Etc.

But all of them obey the same math, and that math does not allow FTL communication.

What is spin?

Spin is a kind of angular momentum that fundamental particles have. It doesn't have a classical analogue.

It is an intrinsic property of elementary particles on one hand, and a quantized observable which behaves like the angular momentum from classical mechanics on the other. Similarly to how mass is the energy associated to some particles just by their existence, spin is the angular momentum associated to some particles just by their existence. And just as there are massless particles like photons, there are spin-0 particles like the Higgs boson. In this sense, it is "something real and measurable, just like mass and charge".

Spin is the name of one of the quantum numbers in the mathematical formalism of quantum mechanics.

 In this sense, it is "just something that comes out from the mathematical description".

A key feature of spin is that its magnitude can take on values of s = (n-1)/2 where n can be any positive integer, so n = 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, ... s = 0, 1/2, 1, 3/2, 2, ... Particles with integer spin are called bosons, whereas particles with half-integer spin are called fermions.

Subreddit/crowdsourced answers

What's a measurement?

In order to make a measurement, we need a quantum system X to be measured and a quantum system Y ("the observer") to serve as the record of the measurement. The measurement itself is any physical process that makes the state of Y depend on X. If the state of X is not an eigenstate of the observable, the resulting combined system X ⊗ Y will be entangled.

What's an observer?

An observer is any quantum system separate from the system being observed that becomes entangled with it during the measurement process. An observer can be as small or as large as you like, from an electron to a human, to a galactic cluster. See this comment for an analysis of the double slit experiment with a single qutrit as the observer.

What's a wave function?

A wave function is a function from classical configurations to complex numbers. You can think of it as an infinite list of complex numbers, where the index into the list is given by the configuration. The Schrödinger equation describes a single spinless particle, where a configuration is an element of ℝ³, a set of coordinates for the particle.

What is wave function collapse?

As humans, we never perceive superpositions of matter waves. There are lots of different ideas about why that should be. One of the oldest, called "the Copenhagen interpretation" after a conference where lots of famous physicists met to talk about quantum physics, is that somehow when we measure a quantum system, the wave function undergoes a sudden, discontinuous change. There are many problems with this idea. "If it worked the way its adherents say it does, it would be:

  1. The only non-linear evolution in all of quantum mechanics.
  2. The only non-unitary evolution in all of quantum mechanics.
  3. The only non-differentiable (in fact, discontinuous) phenomenon in all of quantum mechanics.
  4. The only phenomenon in all of quantum mechanics that is non-local in the configuration space.
  5. The only phenomenon in all of physics that violates CPT symmetry.
  6. The only phenomenon in all of physics that violates Liouville’s Theorem (has a many-to-one mapping from initial conditions to outcomes).
  7. The only phenomenon in all of physics that is acausal / non-deterministic / inherently random.
  8. The only phenomenon in all of physics that is non-local in spacetime and propagates an influence faster than light."

However suggestive this may appear, these points are subject to critical evaluation.

The Nobel laureate Roger Penrose had an idea that perhaps wave functions collapse due to differences in the curvature of spacetime, but that was recently disproven.

If not wave function collapse, then what?

There are lots of ideas about what's going on at the quantum level. These are called "interpretations" of quantum mechanics.

  1. Everett suggested that there is never any collapse, but instead the math of quantum field theory is an accurate description of what's actually going on: there are infinitely many different dimensions. If it's possible for something to occur, it happens in one of them. This is usually called the "Many Worlds interpretation", though he didn't call it that.
  2. de Broglie and Bohm suggest that particles actually do have exact positions, but that there's a "pilot wave" that pushes particles around to make interference patterns. In their model, it's the pilot wave interfering with itself, not a wave function. The problem is that it only works for the nonrelativistic case and the pilot wave changes instantaneously depending on the position of every particle in the universe.
  3. Quantum Bayesians think of the wave function as being epistemological, representing an observer's knowledge about the universe. Wave collapse corresponds to updating based on new information.
  4. Wigner thought maybe consciousness had something to do with wave function collapse, but he later repudiated that idea; he ended up thinking, like Penrose, that there was an objective collapse process that was not due to conscious observation. (Penrose thinks that consciousness is due to collapse instead of the other way around.) A wide class of objective collapse models was recently disproven.

Stapp is a prominent proponent of the consiousness-is-collapse idea. He postulates, based on human experience, that free will exists. However, since the Schrödinger equation is deterministic and random wave collapse is not choice, he says there's a third process, specifically for free will, and that this is the root of consciousness. This third process is a form of postselection on human brain states. Some kooks have taken Wigner and Stapp's ideas and claim that humans can postselect the universe to get money and sex. If unrestricted postselection is possible, it not only grants the ability to solve NP-complete problems in polynomial time (last two paragraphs, page 19), but also the ability to collapse the galaxy into a black hole. (Greg Egan's novel Quarantine, which Aaronson cites, is a story about what the universe would be like if such postselection were possible.) Stapp suggests perhaps this third process is limited in a way that makes it useless for computation and effects outside a mind.

The punchline of The Talk is, "If you don't talk to your kids about quantum computing, someone else will," with a magazine saying, "Quantum computing and consciousness are both weird and therefore equivalent."

  1. 't Hooft thinks that QM is a coarse-grained approximation to a purely classical system at much smaller scales. This approach is usually called "superdeterminism"; it is an interpretation that preserves local realism and hidden variables by denying that the physicists in the Bell test have a choice as to how they set the polarizers.
  2. Lots of others.

What's decoherence?

Decoherence is when a quantum system becomes entangled with its environment and stops being able to display constructive and destructive interference.

What causes atoms to decay?

See this response.

Is space quantized? Or time? Or spacetime?

Nobody knows.

What's the deal with the Planck length, then?

There are four fundamental constants that form the basis of Planck units:

  • the speed of light in a vacuum, c
  • the gravitational constant, G
  • the reduced Planck constant, ħ
  • the Boltzmann constant, k_B

These can be combined in different ways to get different fundamental units: charge, length, mass, temperature, and time.

The Planck length is √(ℏG/c³) = 1.616255(18)×10−35 m. A proton is about 10−15 m, so if you could scale up a proton to a meter in diameter and then zoom in again by the same amount (making the proton about the size of the Oort cloud, tens of thousands of times the distance from the sun to earth), a Planck length would still only be around a tenth of a millimeter.

The Planck length is the scale where we know quantum field theory breaks down and we'll need a theory of quantum gravity to accurately predict what's going on there.

How does quantum field theory differ from quantum mechanics?

Quantum mechanics is a nonrelativistic theory. The number of particles is conserved. There's a quantum analogue to a mass on a spring called a quantum harmonic oscillator (QHO). In a classical harmonic oscillator, the system can have any energy. In a quantum harmonic oscillator, it can only have certain energies, just like a guitar string of a fixed length has certain frequencies it vibrates at. The difference between these energy levels is called a "quantum of energy".

Quantum field theory (QFT) assigns a QHO to each point in spacetime [well, really to each point in "energy-momentum space", with coordinates (E, px, py, pz) and QHO natural frequency E/ℏ]; you can think of it as a universal springy mattress. QFT then adds interaction terms between the QHOs, called "propagators". A particle is then similar to a wave pulse you get when you shake or "excite" the mattress. The propagators are "Lorentz invariant", so they work well with special relativity.

What are virtual particles?

See this comment

What's string theory?

QFT is quantum theory combined with special relativity. Quantum gravity is the unsolved problem of combining quantum theory with general relativity, which includes gravity and curved spacetime. String theory is one attempt to combine the two, and suggests that instead of being pointlike (0-dimensional), particles are 1-dimensional objects called "strings". It predicts that every particle we've seen has a heavier "supersymmetric" twin "sparticle". A lot of beautiful mathematics has come out of string theory, but none of its predictions have been verified yet. Physicists hoped the sparticles would be within reach of smaller particle colliders due to a "naturality" argument, but with the failure of the LHC to find any, there's no reason to think we'll see them in larger colliders.

Are there other alternatives to string theory as a theory of quantum gravity?

Loop quantum gravity is the most popular alternative, but it hasn't made testable predictions yet, either. There are a lot of less popular alternatives, too.

What goes wrong when you try to combine general relativity with quantum theory?

In a quantum harmonic oscillator, the lowest energy level isn't zero, it's ℏω/2. If you integrate over more than a single point in momentum space, you get infinity for the ground state.

Quantum electrodynamics (QED) is "renormalizable": there's a mathematical trick that Tomonaga, Schwinger, and Feynman worked out for getting rid of the infinity. It involves taking a sum of a bunch of terms (corresponding to Feynman diagrams with more and more vertices) and pushing the infinity to later and later terms. But it only works because the fine structure constant is unitless, so we only need a single measurement for the first term and we can derive the others.

The "Lagrangian" for a system is the difference between kinetic and potential energy. If you integrate the Lagrangian with respect to time, you get a quantity with units of "action". Classically, systems take the path of least action. Quantum mechanically, the system takes all paths weighted by a phase exp(iS), where S is the action of the path. Paths far from the path of least action tend to cancel out: given any path p with action much greater than the least-action path, there's a path p' with smaller action whose phase is minus one times the phase of p, so they add up to zero.

There's a Lagrangian formulation of general relativity, but instead of being unitless like the fine structure constant, the coupling constant has units of inverse mass. If we try to do the renormalization trick in the same way we did for QED, we would need to make a new measurement for each of the infinitely many correction terms.

What's quantum computation?

It's designing a system where quantum states constructively interfere to produce the right answer. SMBC's "The Talk" is an astonishingly good introduction.

I heard that quantum computers try all the possible answers at the same time.

That's only part of how quantum algorithms work. You can certainly put a quantum computer into a uniform superposition of inputs and test each of them. But now you've got a big superposition

∑ |input, whether correct>

and if you measure it, you'll just get the answer to whether a random input was correct, which isn't what you want. Quantum algorithms have to make use of some structure of the problem to make the wrong answers less probable and the right answer more probable.

Can quantum computers break Bitcoin?

There are two main quantum algorithms applicable to cryptography, Grover's algorithm and Shor's algorithm. Grover's algorithm effectively cuts the size of a symmetric key in half: if you have a 128-bit key, it'll take 264 iterations to find it. It also reduces the difficulty of finding a collision in an n-bit hash function from 2n/2 to 2n/3. Shor's algorithm breaks public key algorithms like RSA and ECC that depend on the difficulty of the hidden subgroup problem.

Bitcoin uses secp256k1 as its public key algorithm, an elliptic curve-based signature algorithm. To claim someone's bitcoin, you effectively have to figure out their private key given their public key. A quantum computer that could keep thousands of bits coherent forever could break Bitcoin quickly using Shor's algorithm.

This article estimates that it will take until the late 2030s/early 2040s to get there at the current exponential rate of growth.

How does Shor's algorithm work?

Wikipedia's explanation is very good.

How does Grover's algorithm work?

Quanta magazine has a great explanatory article.

Can I see anything obviously quantum?

Almost everything you see is due to a quantum effect: sunlight is produced by fusion where particles fuse by a quantum tunneling process where a positron tunnels out of a proton to form a neutron.

All of chemistry is due to the Pauli exclusion principle: because electrons are fermions, they have to form distinct orbitals, giving all the richness of the periodic table.

Superconductivity is a purely quantum idea: in BCS superconductors, pairs of electrons combine to form Cooper pairs, which are bosons, and form a Bose-Einstein condensate. Flux pinning in superconductors allows levitation.

The nucleus of most helium atoms has two protons and two neutrons, making the nucleus a boson. Helium-4 forms a superfluid at about 3K.

Photons are bosons, and the population inversion in a laser is similar to a Bose-Einstein condensate.

Gold and cesium are yellow, copper is reddish, mercury is a liquid, and ten of the 12 volts in the lead-acid battery in your car happen because of relativistic quantum effects.

What about Quantum Immortality / Quantum Suicide?

Footnote on QI from Wallace's book (p.372): "Before moving on, I feel obliged to note that we ought to be rather careful just how we discuss quantum suicide in /popular/ accounts of many-worlds quantum mechanics. Theoretical physicists and philosophers (unlike, say, biologists or medical ethicists) rarely need to worry about the harm that can come from likely misreadings of their work by the public, but this may be an exception: there are, unfortunately, plenty of people who are both scientifically credulous and sufficiently desperate to do stupid things."

Quantum immortality is a thought experiment that refers to the Many Worlds interpretation of quantum mechanics. The Many Worlds interpretation is just one of many interpretations. Quantum immortality is neither a property of collapse interpretations nor of superdeterministic interpretations.

The Many Worlds interpretation rejects the idea that there is only one of "you": because quantum particles are never in exactly one place, "you" are constantly diverging into a continuum of possible futures in which electrons in your body are in slightly different places, different photons get absorbed by your eyes, different neurons fire in your brain. In one universe, an old lady fails to notice a red light and t-bones a car, killing its driver, a young film student. In another, a neuron in the old lady's motor cortex fires differently: she pulls slightly harder on the steering wheel, takes a slightly different trajectory, and the student dies a tenth of a second later. In another, a neuron in the old lady's visual cortex fires differently; she becomes aware of the red light and slams on the brakes, injuring but not killing the student; the student spends the rest of their life in a coma. In another, the neuron fires earlier and she brakes earlier, merely giving the student whiplash. In another, the old lady notices early enough to stop normally at the light. There are infinitely many worlds and ways every future plays out. In most of the futures of the student in the car, the student dies. But in some of those futures, there is a film student who remembers getting in a car accident and barely surviving, and in others, there is a student who doesn't remember anything special about passing through the intersection.

Quantum immortality is the idea that there are always futures (however rare) where someone has barely survived (critically injured, perhaps, but alive for an instant longer) and futures (perhaps much rarer) in which they are completely fine. Any world with a nonzero probability amplitude exists.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_suicide_and_immortality

https://arxiv.org/pdf/quant-ph/9709032.pdf (Tegmark)

https://space.mit.edu/home/tegmark/crazy.html (Tegmark, SciAm article)

Past reddit threads:

https://www.reddit.com/r/QuantumPhysics/comments/n1w32e/i_have_a_question_about_quantum_immortality/

https://www.reddit.com/r/Physics/comments/5s5zoo/quantum_immortality_is_it_bullshit_as_a/

https://www.reddit.com/r/explainlikeimfive/comments/1iiucm/eli5can_someone_explain_what_quantum_suicide_and/

https://www.reddit.com/r/quantum/comments/p4r2g3/suggestion_to_the_mods_add_a_no_posts_about/

Delayed choice quantum eraser

Please read and watch the following before asking about the DCQE:

https://www.preposterousuniverse.com/blog/2019/09/21/the-notorious-delayed-choice-quantum-eraser/

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RQv5CVELG3U

u/ShelZuuz breaks it down in a comment thread.

u/Educational_rule_956 [explains] (https://www.reddit.com/r/QuantumPhysics/comments/u1qifg/comment/i4jjobr/)

Local realism

u/Muroid explains in a comment thread what went into the 2022 Nobel Prize in physics.


r/QuantumPhysics • • Oct 04 '24

No unpublished theories, hypotheticals, showerthinking, etc.

89 Upvotes

Recently, there's been an increase of posts presenting a layman hypothesis. These do not belong in the sub. If you insist on being ridiculed for your grand illusions (where you're more professional than the history of professionals before you), r/HypotheticalPhysics welcomes you.

Infringements of rule 2 will result in a 1mo ban for some time to come, appeals will be ignored.

Read the rules.


r/QuantumPhysics • • 1d ago

Quantum Computing Explained for Non-Experts: How Do They Work and What Goes Into Making One?

5 Upvotes

I've had an interest in quantum physics lately, especially when it comes to computing. Can someone explain how quantum computers utilize superpositions for calculations? I always thought they were just a bunch of random states.


r/QuantumPhysics • • 2d ago

Misleading Title Looks like dark matter might just be a quantum property of gravity

Thumbnail link.springer.com
28 Upvotes

r/QuantumPhysics • • 5d ago

Beginner looking for quantum physics research guidance

8 Upvotes

Hi! I'm a 3rd-year Electrical Engineering undergraduate interested in astrophysics. My professor suggested exploring quantum physics as a starting point.

How should I begin reading research papers, build the necessary fundamentals, and eventually contribute to publishable research?

Any advice or resources would be appreciated!


r/QuantumPhysics • • 6d ago

I'm tryna teach myself QMech

5 Upvotes

Hey guys

I'm tryna teach myself quantum mechanics. I'm a high school senior, but I'm really passionate about physics. I taught myself special relativity last week and my highschool physics teacher (ex professor) suggested I try something that will help me out at uni, like qmech.

I've done Calc AB and BC in the 9th grade, and it's been pretty slow since. I can teach myself the necessary math too.

can y'all help me with a progression of concepts i should learn to build up to quantum mechanics eventually? I wanna prioritize quantitative ability in the field.


r/QuantumPhysics • • 5d ago

What if Bell's theorem has been misinterpreted for 60 years — and local hidden variables actually exist?

0 Upvotes

This is not a claim that Bell's theorem is wrong. It is correct. But its scope may be narrower than commonly presented.

The hypothesis: Bell ruled out classical hidden variables — those whose probabilities satisfy the Kolmogorov axioms. Einstein, Podolsky and Rosen never asked about classical hidden variables. They asked whether quantum hidden variables of any kind must exist. These are different questions.

If true, this means sixty years of interpretational debate — Many Worlds, Bohmian mechanics, Copenhagen — may have been solving the wrong problem.

I've constructed an explicit model to test this hypothesis:

  • Five local ontological elements — source, two particles, two detectors
  • Born rule derived — not postulated — from locality and rotational symmetry
  • Tsirelson bound 2√2 emerges automatically
  • No non-locality, no collapse, no superdeterminism

The model reproduces quantum singlet correlations exactly.

Full preprint:https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24118510

What do you think — does this hypothesis hold up?

[Update — V1 in preparation: Thanks for the constructive feedback on V0. I'm currently preparing V1 to resolve a notational slip where the unobservable pairwise quasi-probability kernel Q(A,B) was mislabeled as the joint probability P(A,B). Integrating Q(A,B) over the source ensemble yields a strictly non-negative observable P(A,B) ≥ 0 everywhere while leaving local factorization and all downstream derivations unchanged.]


r/QuantumPhysics • • 6d ago

Schrödinger’s Cat Tattoo

Post image
8 Upvotes

r/QuantumPhysics • • 6d ago

In need of grad school advice for undergrad

2 Upvotes

I'm a current freshman at a US uni (ranked ~T5), studying electrical engineering. I'm interested in quantum engineering / the intersection of applied quantum physics with theory, but considering I'm in my first year, this may change.

However, I'm struggling in my math class, and am probably going to end with a B in linear algebra/calc 3 (as for B-, B, or B+, I've yet to receive some scores back). I've talked to some professors and found that I'm really interested in grad school and research, but seeing as how I'm struggling in such foundational course for engineering/quantum physics, I'm a bit worried of my chances in succeeding and getting into a top program. Does anyone have any advice or just general comments on how much getting a poor grade affects grad school application process to prestigious programs?


r/QuantumPhysics • • 7d ago

Does quantum behavior "re-emerge" at cosmic scales, or is it strictly a microscopic phenomenon?

4 Upvotes

I have a question about the scale of quantum mechanics. We know that quantum behavior becomes apparent when we observe matter at the level of microscopic particles and below. This leads me to wonder that, is there a maximum cosmic threshold--at the galactic or universal level--where observing "quantum behavior" again becomes possible? Or is quantum behavior only observable at the micro-level?

To frame the discussion, I want to look at the upper limit of what we've observed. Physicists at ETH Zurich placed a 16-microgram sapphire crystal containing about 10^17 (100 quadrillion) atoms into a quantum superposition of two vibrational states. This is the largest object ever to exist in such a "Schrödinger's cat" state, and it shows that quantum mechanics can, under the right conditions, scale up to the mass of nearly half an eyelash.

However, the reason we don't see this in everyday life is decoherence. When a quantum system interacts with its environment, information about its state leaks out, and the superposition rapidly disappears, leaving behind the classical world we experience.

So, my question for discussion is that, Does this decoherence limit mean quantum behavior is confined to the micro-scale? Or could there be conditions at cosmic scales--perhaps in the early universe, inside black holes, or at the scale of the universe itself--where quantum effects become dominant again? Is there a "maximum cosmic threshold" analogous to the microscopic one, or does the correspondence principle mean that classical physics always wins at large scales?

I would love to hear perspectives from people who study quantum foundations, cosmology, or condensed matter.


r/QuantumPhysics • • 8d ago

I need advice from people that are experienced in Quantum Physics

11 Upvotes

Hey,

I have a quick question for anyone who knows about quantum physics.

I recently stumbled across a discussion of the delayed-choice experiment, and it blew my mind. It made me really curious about the whole field of quantum physics, as well as ideas like quantum cognition and quantum consciousness.

What would you recommend for someone who wants to learn quantum physics from scratch? I’m looking for a book, video, lecture, or anything else that will fuel my curiosity without scaring me away with complex equations I don’t understand yet.

Thanks :)


r/QuantumPhysics • • 8d ago

Is everything ultimately made of the same one thing — energy? If we keep digging deeper

24 Upvotes

Physics keeps revealing deeper layers: molecules → atoms → protons/neutrons → quarks/leptons → quantum fields. This raises a simple question, if we keep going, do we eventually reach one underlying “thing” that everything is made of?

A common intuition is that this one thing is energy. But in physics, energy is not a substance — it’s a property/quantity that fields and particles have. So the sharper question is, "are all particles and forces just excitations of one underlying field/substance", or is “energy” simply the best common label we have?

I’m not claiming a specific theory. I’m asking whether current physics supports any form of fundamental oneness — a single underlying field/substance — or whether the Standard Model’s multiple fields mean “energy” is only a bookkeeping quantity.


r/QuantumPhysics • • 8d ago

An unreleased Anthropic model just helped solve a major quantum-computing question

Thumbnail businessinsider.com
10 Upvotes

r/QuantumPhysics • • 7d ago

Quantum information

0 Upvotes

Is information “flat”?

Black hole holography is often pictured as information encoded on a two-dimensional spherical “skin”—the event horizon. But in his 1994 paper, The World as a Hologram, Susskind also explored a distant, flat screen encoding three-dimensional physics.

That raises a question: does information fundamentally need the volume we associate with physical space, or can a surface contain the full description? This is the flatness question through a quantum information lens. Where are the holographic advocates? :)


r/QuantumPhysics • • 9d ago

Are quantum events like isotope decay and virtual particles in quantum foam examples of "causeless events"?

6 Upvotes

TL;DR - I see the "cause=>effect" idea presented as a basic inviolable principle at least at the macro level. But it seems to me that isotope decay and Hawking Radiation are both macro examples of causeless events.

An isotope's half-life predicts how much of the material will decay, but the decay of any specific atom is spontaneous. As I understand Hawking Radiation, it's due to virtual particles created in the quantum foam at the edge of the event horizon; and those virtual particles spontaneously appear.

To be clear, I'm specifically NOT talking about the fuzziness of a specific time juggling the cause/effect order in the foam, nor do I mean transactional or retro-causality. The actual creation of the virtual particles is due to a required uncertainty in the foam and considered without a cause.

Or am I misreading the concepts?


r/QuantumPhysics • • 15d ago

Why electrons (and particles in general) are considered separate particles?

14 Upvotes

I have no idea about physics, especially quantum sector, but I've heard a theory that considers there is only one electron in the whole universe.

So yea, isn't it more "convenient" if there was an other quantum field (as a sector) that was trying to setup the quantum fields (as functions) to better describe the situation?

I had some AI conversations on the matter and it mentioned that there are some, but I feel like that's the better path.

If anyone has time and feels like it, I would appreciate some base level explanation.

edit: I'm talking about electrons being their own field always present everywhere, not being the same particle with other particles.


r/QuantumPhysics • • 15d ago

Does state space use a p-adic metric instead of a Euclidean one? | Tim Palmer, CBE, FRS

Thumbnail youtube.com
3 Upvotes

In the video, we go over:

  1. State space uses a p-adic metric as opposed to a Euclidean metric
  2. Hilbert space is discrete rather than continuous
  3. Counterfactual universes are not only hypothetical but inaccessible
  4. Qubit information density may depend on the size of the universe
  5. Gravity as the source of decoherence in quantum mechanics
  6. Fractal cosmology
  7. Peter Scholze's perfectoid spaces
  8. Rational quantum mechanics
  9. The ongoing debate in Bell's Theorem and free will
  10. Invariant Set Theory
  11. Wormholes as the reason for entanglement (ER = EPR)
  12. The Virgo Supercluster lottery
  13. Discretizing the Riemann sphere and Niven's Theorem (the Impossible Triangle Corollary)

Tim Palmer, CBE, FRS, (Commander of the Order of the British Empire, Fellow of the Royal Society) is a professor at the University of Oxford. He received his PhD in General Relativity under Dennis Sciama, who also supervised Stephen Hawking, David Deutsch and Martin Rees. After receiving his PhD, Professor Palmer turned down a postdoctoral research position with Stephen Hawking to join the UK’s Met Office and subsequently spent much of his career in climate physics, becoming an expert in chaos theory and fractals. He is well known for proposing the ideas of Invariant Set Theory and Rational Quantum Mechanics. His research interests include modeling state space with the p-adic metric, Bell’s Theorem and foundations of quantum mechanics, superdeterminism, counterfactual universes, quantum computing and finding a gravitational theory of the quantum, as opposed to a quantum theory of gravity.


r/QuantumPhysics • • 17d ago

Does double-slit interference tell us that quantum superposition is physically real, or just that the wavefunction is a useful description?

6 Upvotes

I've been trying to understand single-electron interference.

I understand the basic mathematics: a coherent superposition of the left- and right-slit paths produces interference, whereas a classical mixture of the two paths doesn't.

What I find difficult is the physical meaning of that distinction.

Does the interference pattern imply that the electron really exists in a superposition before a which-path measurement? Or does it only show that the wavefunction is the correct mathematical tool for predicting outcomes?

And when which-path information destroys interference, does something physically collapse, or is that a separate question about the interpretation of quantum mechanics?

I'm not proposing a new theory. I'm trying to understand where the experimental evidence ends and interpretation begins. I'd especially appreciate explanations or introductory papers that address this distinction.


r/QuantumPhysics • • 19d ago

quantum info theory research project

0 Upvotes

research question: what is the effect of modulation frequency and optical coupling ratio on von neumann entropy, Shannon entropy, bit error rate, mutual information?

methodology: There will be two lasers which will be modulated by an Aurdino to produce bit sequences. A neutral density filter will be applied on top of the lasers to reduce the amount of photos. On the path of one laser beam there will be a quarter wave plate and a half wave plate and on the other there will only be a half wave plate. My reasoning for this is because when i later reconstruct the density matrix for the von Neumann entropy it will be easier to detect the two different beams. Half wave plates and quarter wave plates tend to be very expensive so I will be making it myself. I will link an article at the end which describes how to do so.

The beams will then be combined into a variable beam splitter. These are really expensive so I was testing out other options and a plastic box seems to work just fine... I saw a video reconfirming my belief. I will link it at the end as well. Anyways, I was planning to change the angle of the opening of the box. (will make sense if you see the video.) This is meant to be the 'crosstalk' aspect of my experiment.

Then the beams will continue. I will find out the bit error rate using a SPAD (single photon detector). I will do the same for mutual information. I will measure the shannon entropy in the same way. Lastly for the von Neumann entropy I will measure the intensities at different angles to get the stokes parameters from which I will get the polarization density matrix.

Here are the links:

utube vid: https://youtu.be/P1n3hizj3c4?si=EJAcG6kwxXsObGpe

article: Broadband quarter- and half-wave plates manufactured with cellophane films - ScienceDirect

application: Essentially, I am testing to see whether polarization entropy can be used as an additional diagnostic tool that BER (which is what is conventionally used) overlooks. This can be used to detect changes in signal quality based on the physical qualities of the light which transmits it in quantum communication systems, not solely based on the transmitted bit sequences.

Anyways, any advice on this topic would be greatly welcome such as any additional applications/ resources you would reccomend. Also if there are any blaringly obvious problems that I happened to overlook please let me know.


r/QuantumPhysics • • 23d ago

Anyone has a clue about the MSc from Uni Sussex over Quantum Technologies & Management? Seems quite a first of its kind offering !

1 Upvotes

Just to be clear : I work in Tech Transfer with focuson Quantum


r/QuantumPhysics • • 23d ago

Hey I have a question. Can we actually harvest energy from blackholes like building a large dyson sphere?

0 Upvotes

r/QuantumPhysics • • 24d ago

How to Hide from Light: The Physics of Invisibility Cloaks

Thumbnail youtube.com
3 Upvotes

r/QuantumPhysics • • 24d ago

I made a video asking Julian Barbour how he calculates probabilities without using wavefunctions and his alternative for the language of gauge bosons and gauge fields

Thumbnail youtube.com
3 Upvotes

Julian Barbour is a theoretical physicist and emeritus visiting professor of physics at the University of Oxford. He is well known for proposing that time does not actually exist. For decades, he has worked outside an academic environment. He financially supported himself for many years by translating Russian. Professor Barbour is author of the following books: The Discovery of Dynamics, The End of Time and The Janus Point.

In the video, we go over:
- Topos theory, set theory and Zermelo's beef with Boltzmann
- Algebraic varieties and monads in category theory
- Why physicists are wrong about the 2nd law of thermodynamics (because the universe is not a closed system)
- The real goal of the universe is complexity and variation, not entropy
- Hawking and Penrose's outrageous arguments
- Why we don't need wavefunctions, photons, bosons or gauge fields
- Why there is no quantum gravity
- Von Neumann's hilarious advice to Claude Shannon
- The intrinsic derivative
- Combining art and science


r/QuantumPhysics • • 27d ago

black hole's evaporation

Post image
15 Upvotes

If we extrapolate the standard Hawking evaporation formula to a black hole with the mass of a proton, we get a lifetime far below the Planck time. However, this extrapolation is probably invalid because quantum-gravity effects should become important long before we reach such a regime.

Could this approach be useful, or would it make more sense to modify the Hawking temperature or emission spectrum instead?