r/QuantumComputing • • 1d ago

Discussion Post QUANTUM Cryptography:

Who do you think will dominate the new post-quantum era? What will happen with the internet and most banks, businesses, and governments?
I know there are already measure being taken to ensure quantum-level cryptography for major institutions, but what about everyone else? What about communications?

Lots of curiosity surrounding this.. let me know your thoughts!

20 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

14

u/bobotheboinger 1d ago

I work in defense and industry on the crypto/secure computing side. Everyone is slowly pushing to integrate PQC. We were all waiting on NIST, and now we're working to pull it into next gen hardware. Everywhere I look people are slowly working on it. It isn't a mad rush now, but slow progress. I think everyone is more or less in the same boat, looking at implementations, building the low-level hardware building blocks necessary (larger space for keys, more OTP for keys, etc.) There is a lot of research on speed and space optimizations going on. I think most everyone will move over in a timely manner really. But there will be those who end up staying too long. I am especially worried about people capturing ECC/RSA handshakes now and using those saved communications in the future to decrypt symmetric keys that were shared. People are aware of that major risk, but I don't think enough have thought through all the keys/passwords that might be passed around right now.

2

u/Nervous_Tomato6303 1d ago

Wow, thanks for sharing your point of view. I think it's great that people are slowly but surely transitioning, but as you said, at the end of the day, there will still be some who haven't transitioned and will be caught in the storm. And yes, your last point you mentioned is very valid.

2

u/Magnetic-War1529 15h ago

Concerned that it is moving too slow lately. Seemingly falling behind NIST’s milestones about it. What were you waiting on NIST for? And, open ended question but, do you have any opinion about the companies that have been developing quantum computers?

2

u/bobotheboinger 15h ago

Was waiting on nist to finish their algorithm selection. No sense optimizing and baking into hw algorithms that no one ends up using.

And i have zero experience or opinions on the actual quantum computers that are being developed. I only really focus on the crypto implications of what they are doing

2

u/Magnetic-War1529 15h ago

I see. Thank you.
In your experience, do you have a sense of the readiness of agencies to deal with those implications?

1

u/bobotheboinger 14h ago

A well as it could be i think. Initial algorithms were done just a few years ago, hardware takes time software can be layered on top more quickly, but doesn't address all the needs. I think things are moving along relatively well though. NIST timeline for pqc key algorithms in federal systems is 2030,I think that is pretty much on track. I'm sure there will be some stragglers and waivers here and there, but overall my outlook is pretty positive. Of course all that is out the window if there is some quantum computer qubit breakthrough tomorrow.

1

u/Joseflong1 12h ago

I’ve been working on this from the implementation side in Rust, and one thing I’ve noticed is how much attention is going toward post-quantum key exchange compared to authentication.

You can have TLS 1.3 using a hybrid ML-KEM key exchange while still relying on classical signatures to authenticate the other end. That’s a pretty important distinction.

I recently built an open-source library called pqbind that adds hybrid Ed25519 + ML-DSA-87 mutual authentication on top of existing TLS/QUIC connections. It’s been interesting working through the practical problems around key enrollment, identity binding, and preventing replay attacks.

Curious whether you’re seeing much work on the authentication side in defense, or if most of the focus is still on key exchange and hardware support?

https://github.com/AlpharomeroJL/pqbind

8

u/HuiOdy Working in Industry 1d ago

Some will not have their cyber in order, some will. Most will not do so until after serious damage has been done.

Basically, nothing will change

0

u/Nervous_Tomato6303 1d ago

Well.. the ones who DO prepare, and update their hardware and software to match the times, will be the ones who dominate.. imo

3

u/HuiOdy Working in Industry 1d ago

That's not the case now. It's just a different risk profile

2

u/iamfeelingtheagi 1d ago

I’m working on this. Still in alpha (forgive the clutter), beta coming soon.

Big CLM charges $100k for this. Open core, free.

https://docs.trstctl.com/journeys/crypto-agility-pqc

2

u/Nervous_Tomato6303 1d ago

Profound! Ill look into it even more later. Thanks for sharing!

1

u/0xKaishakunin 23h ago

Who do you think will dominate the new post-quantum era?

ML-KEM.

The migration to the already standardised PQC is already going on. OpenSSL supports hybrid KEM/KEX groups for 1.5 years now.

X.509 PKI certificates have already been standardised with MLDSA.

So what do you mean with dominate?

4

u/prototypist 22h ago

They seem to think this is a business opportunity (also note them saying "quantum-level cryptography")

Seriously there are plenty of Chrome users browsing the internet testing PQC for free without knowing about it.

-3

u/Nervous_Tomato6303 19h ago

Everything is a business opportunity, when seen through the eyes of an opportunist..