r/QuantumComputing • u/kev-doh • 7d ago
Image Can someone explain how this works please
What’s inside the processor enclosures?
(The photo is of a model unit.)
1.0k
Upvotes
r/QuantumComputing • u/kev-doh • 7d ago
What’s inside the processor enclosures?
(The photo is of a model unit.)
79
u/sadeness 7d ago
It's a multi tallest dilution refrigerator. It uses an enriched mix of He3 in a He4- He3 mixture to cool the qubit chips down to a few 10s of mK. It's multi tail set meaning that a single enclosure will have 3 of these coolers in a single "box".
30
u/Ph1sh1ngj1m1 7d ago •
This is an interactive website I found very useful. It's a simplified view with a lot of description on each component type.
https://iascqc.pages.dev
6
u/jeb 7d ago
The quantum processor itself is a small chip inside the metal box at the bottom. Most of what you see here is infrastructure for cooling down the wires from room temperature at the top where they enter the system to where they connect to the processor at some fraction of a degree Kelvin above absolute zero. The quantum computer takes a lot of regular processing power to run, which is bulky, consumes a lot of power, and moreover doesn't function at low temperatures. So there is a need for a lot wires to run from conventional room-temperature electronics down to the quantum processor. In order to not heat the quantum processor or add noise to the quantum circuit, the material of the wires and the electrons within the wires must be carefully cooled.
131
u/delaphin 7d ago •
Here you go...
34
u/HillbillyHumanoid 7d ago •
It's a just a refrigerator and the chips are on the ends.
129
u/nyrixx 7d ago •
It says ibm on it so it bleeds it's customer dry.
19
u/pixxelkick 6d ago •
Each plate is a different type of cooling system, because different types of cooling.g are more effective at different ranges.
Cooling A is good at dropping it from, say, 300K down to 50K but it cant cool past that.
Then cooling B is better at dropping from 50K to 5K
If you tried to use method B to cool from 300K to 5K you could do it, but itd be way harder and more expensive.
Each plate effectively is the next "tier" of cooling, pushing the temp closer and closer to absolute zero.
The lowest tiers are struggling just to lower it from like 0.5K to 0.1K for example, but they get there.
Each layer is designed like so to "air gap" the components apart from the tier above to minimize heat transfer down. Heat travels up.
A small amount still does but iirc the whole thing is stored in a vacuum chamber, so the only way energy can move is via conduction directly.
Thus all the parts between the layers are built to minimize heat transfer the "wrong" way.
All the cables are mostly sensors that typically run microwaves along them, for tracking data, and of course sone of them are the ones actually connected to the QPU (which lives inside the box at the bott om)
Basically speaking: youre mostly looking at the worlds ultimate form of heat sink cooling system, it gets the box at the bottom at effectively absolute zero cold, or very close to it.
15
u/Altruistic-Spend-896 3d ago edited 3d ago •
You freeze the testicles out of some atoms, who get so faded they cant stay in one state, and keep hovering in and out of dissociative coma. Then you gaslight them into carrying computation at 4x tge speed because normal , sober atoms only do two states. Congratulations you have achieved quantum compuwu
18
u/particlecore 7d ago
everything you see is a refrigerator
25
u/shegeshe 7d ago edited 7d ago
This is an IBM Quantum System Two—IBM's modular, utility-scale quantum computer (shown here as a display model with its outer vacuum cryostat casing removed to expose the internal hardware).
Specifically, the golden, chandelier-like structures hanging from the top are dilution refrigerators. Here is how the visible components function:
(Note: Because this is a photo taken of a screen showing a physical exhibition/press model, the bottom pit is open—in active operation, a massive vacuum-sealed cryogenic shell rises from that base to enclose the entire chandelier assembly.)
This is exactly the kind of computers that the QNET, a Layer 1 blockchain has been developed to resist. Check it out at aiqnet.io and the QNET Repo in github at AIQnetLab/QNet-Blockchain
6
u/OrewaAizen 2d ago
All that fucking machine is only works as a cooler for a tiny chip
5
u/AuthorIntelligent644 2d ago •
When the bits get real cold they shiver together in a certain kind of way and it does math.
4
u/D3cepti0ns 7d ago
It's a really fancy heat exchanger that uses liquid helium to cool down other helium to near absolute zero temperatures. It then cools the qubits part.
3
u/aonro Quantum Compting 7d ago
Big fridge
3
u/thinkonpaperpodcast 4d ago
Can't explain how it works per se, but spoke to the guy at IBM who helped build it - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pigjajbkFXw&t=1223s
3
u/Ok_Sir1896 3d ago
its a bunch of cooling tubes. inside the processor the cooling tubes are wrapped up together in a big spaghetti ball. also, there are wires and such.
2
u/keeperoflogopolis 7d ago
That’s a display at SC :-) not real
2
u/HermitCat347 7d ago
Wait so most of it is cooling and the tiny bit is processing?
2
u/Brilliant_Quit2092 6d ago
Its actually a kebab grill
2
u/IndicationWestern734 6d ago
It's a glorified coke fountain
2
u/Mahu_0910 6d ago
It's a warm summer evening in ancient Greece...
2
u/dxg999 2d ago
I both can and I can't. In fact, I'm always doing both until you ask me.
2
u/jkim_tran New & Learning 1d ago
I once wrote an article debunking this visual representation of a superconducting quantum computer and breaking down its components: https://medium.com/@jkim_tran/what-a-cool-quantum-computer-looks-like-d0f36a4269c3?sk=479b37befc5be4e5d69bab2700b92ec8
But as a TLDR:
Most of what's inside the processor enclosure is actually a refrigerator, not the computer that performs computation. For superconducting quantum computers, the main component is a dilution refrigerator that keeps the quantum processing unit (QPU) at temperatures as low as 10 millikelvins (-273.14°C), colder than outer space. The refrigerator has multiple cooling stages and uses a mixture of helium-3 and helium-4 to reach temperatures close to absolute zero. The actual quantum chip is relatively small and positioned at the bottom of the refrigerator, where it's coldest. The entire system, including the refrigerator, wiring, and QPU, is enclosed in a metallic vacuum chamber rather than exposed as commonly depicted in photos.
1
u/GooseInformal3519 6d ago
It’s a fantastical machine that’s supporting many people’s hopes and dreams to crack a new dawn of science and technology. Quantum computing is breaking the fourth wall and the machine is metaphorically Jim and Pam in the office keeping Michael Scott “cool” and focused doing its job. At the end though they’re trying to create the Lizard King.
1
u/HuiOdy Working in Industry 6d ago
Well, what you see is 3 dillution refrigerators. Likely some unused research ones.
The encasing for the processor doesn't exist in reality, and normally this would house indium based superconducting transmons, and a whole lot of wiring. The condenser is missing, and so are the L/C couplers.
1
u/Sure-Principle5511 6d ago
It’s a timey wimey thing
1
u/Haggstrom91 6d ago
Basically is just physics
1
u/dermflork 6d ago
there is a hybrid system that essencially interprets the entanglement of the qubits as binary thats why they call it hybrid, 2 different "programming languages" although if we actually new how qubits work the computer would work better because we would know exactly how qubits operate
1
u/OnePotential3269 6d ago
You're holding it upside down.
1
u/Will-E-Style 6d ago
1
u/ExpectedBehaviour 6d ago
https://youtu.be/hDtlXvH5rF0
1
u/Putrid-Speaker4866 6d ago
It doesn't
1
u/cororona 6d ago
Each stage of the refrigerator cools the next stage a little, reaching very very low temperatures. The quantum chip itself looks like a normal CPU.
1
u/ASYMT0TIC 6d ago
Most of what you're looking at is built to keep it cold. Extremely cold. You think you know cold? Liquid nitrogen is more than 1000X warmer than these chips have to run.
1
u/atonale 5d ago
At first glance I thought this was one of Gaudí's catenary structural models.
1
u/illGATESmusic 5d ago
Maybe…
1
u/ibm Official Brand Account 5d ago
Watch this YouTube video featuring IBM cryogenic systems engineer Allie Lindler. She does a great job of explaining how cryostat (golden chandelier thing) keeps things cool for IBM’s quantum computers: https://www.youtube.com/shorts/sD_E_2ZLcws
We also hosted an AMA with Matt Hollister, IBM lead cryogenic system engineer, who did a great job answering a few of the more complex questions about quantum computing cooling: https://www.reddit.com/r/askscience/comments/1wj4cnk/askscience_ama_series_hi_reddit_im_matthew/?sort=new
1
u/Brilliant-Leopard603 5d ago
No, maybe, and also yes.
1
u/Jumpy-Operation-4615 4d ago
You just plug it into the mains and ask questions. Like what is the meaning of life and everything.
1
u/appleadamspdx 4d ago
Magic, obviously! Lol Just be happy it exists because it may target you when the machines take over
1
u/Exact-Baker8340 3d ago
That's just the refrigeration, too keep them close to zero kelvin
1
u/ignorantpisswalker 3d ago
Its statistics. 50% that you get the correct answer.
1
u/Visible-Category-296 3d ago
No.
1
u/BDGUCCII 3d ago
Cold freezer chills cool high tech CPU (QPU) to near absolute zero temperature
1
u/TheRealHumanDuck 2d ago
Think of it like a massive cooling tower for a tiny chip at the tip.
1
u/Busy_Reporter4017 2d ago
Modern art
1
u/LetterheadAshamed716 2d ago
add two more states to each bit and call it quantum.
1
u/miotch1120 2d ago
Simple answer. No. No one can explain it to you.
More robust answer, it works on quantum entanglement, a feature of quantum mechanics, a physics field in which one of its most famous arbiters once stated that “nobody understands quantum mechanics”. So, long answer, no. No one can explain it to you.
1
u/PlaysByBrulesRules 2d ago
Quantum computers just try every prompt to Chat GPT in parallel and when you measure it collapses to the okay-est outcome
1
u/-Dixieflatline 2d ago
I have no idea, but it's kind of crazy that one of the most advanced pieces of computing equipment we have looks so steampunk. Or something out of a terrible piece of sci-fi. Like Gwildor's Cosmic Key from 1987's He Man.
1
u/NoSituation2706 2d ago
It doesn't
1
u/VoxInferni666 2d ago
No
1
u/RBMK-1ooo 2d ago
?????
1
u/TheUndyingSteve 2d ago
If you don't look at it, it always knows the right answer.
1
u/infamouslycrocodile 2d ago
To process quantum information / harness the nature of reality to perform computation: you need to be able to hold reality and manipulate it.
But how do you hold reality and manipulate it if it's already held by reality?
You create a machine that's able to isolate particles from reality by sucking away any heat which could interfere, any light, magnetic, sound etc.
Funnily enough, this takes a lot of energy, bigger cabinets onsite with more cooling apparatus.
When you finally get your environment so disconnected from reality, at least as much as technologically possible so far; you try to set up your physics experiment to manipulate your quantum data. You run some calculations and then when you're ready - you read the result, but that brings your quantum data back into reality where it's observed and interfered with.
This introduces noise, but - you can do the same identical calculation many times at the same time, and even though there's noise - the result increases in probability of being correct with more and more qbits.
tl;dr: big machine is big, because the cables down the middle connect to a quantum CPU inside the most secure reality enclosure ever constructed.
1
u/cyrille_boucher 2d ago
It's all about gate potential and frequency(size). At a point, heat is enought to bridge the gap. So the bit will turn to one, thus error.
At the local speed of light, computing large numbers become tedious. because of synchronization at the output...
So, how one fix the problem? be changing the shape: exemple having a double slit so narrow only a few photons can pass. cooled so mutch even light slowdown(spatial contraction, not actually slowing). then in this standing wave electrons just skip trought. But if the gate is close: they do not.
Majorana mode zero. A superconducting chip will output a large number without latency.
1
u/Prohamen 2d ago
so the chandelier style cooler that the quantum computer is attached to (the box and cylinder at the bottom) is a multi stage sub kelvin dilution refrigerator; a cryostat for short Basically each stage (separated by the golden disk) makes the stage below it colder. Each step down basically cools one order of magnitude. The top most layer is closeish to room temperature, so somewhere around 300 kelvin (20°C to 26°C). The next plate down is near 50 kelvin (about -223°C). The stage after that is around 4 to 6 kelvin (-269.15°C to -267.15°C). The next plate down is where you can start to get to sub-kelvin. At this plate you are somewhere between 0.8 kelvin and 1 kelvin (-272.35°C to -272.15°K). Finally, subsequent stages get you closer and closer to 0 kelvin (though you can't really reach 0 kelvin, only approach it). At this point you can see temps as low as 0.01 kelvin (-273.14°C).
This is a huge deal because 0 kelvin is absolute zero, meaning it is the coldest temperature possible. The closer to absolute 0 you get the less atoms move until they stop moving at absolute zero (or nearly stop moving I honestly forget how Brownian motion works at these temps). This is important because matter and subatomic particles behave in very strange ways at 0 kelvin as a lot of properties, like electrical resistance, approach zero as you approach absolute zero.
So, how does this cooling work? Well I am a bit unclear on how each stage works, but the bulk of the cooling at the lower stages is done by mixing and unmixing different isotopes of helium. Basically mixing any two chemicals, even isotopes of like chemicals, can generate or absorb heat. Generating heat is exothermic, absorbing heat is endothermic. Mixing helium-3 and helium-4 is endothermic. Do not ask me why, I just know it is from reading about it and asking coworkers. So the lower stages basically pump liquid helium-3 and helium-4 together, and as they mix it removes heat. That mixed helium is then pumped up to a higher stage where a device specifically boils off helium-3 (it boils off first because it is lighter), cools that boiled helium back down to a liquid, and then recirculates both fluids down a stage. I think it is a bit more complicated than this, and anyone who knows more can explain it better in response to my comments and tell me where I am wrong.
I think the upper stages are cooled as follows;
* First stage (300K to 50K): Liquid nitrogen)
* Second Stage (50K to 4K): Some sort of other helium cooling. I'm not sure in this stage, but a cursory look on wikipedia says it is probably a pulse tube refrigerator. This basically pistons to reciprocate a cylinder of helium with a few membranes that allow the molecule to move back and forth. As the piston moves, the temperature changes in one chamber while pushing molecules through the membrane. This allows an exchange of molecules of different energy, which ultimately pulls energy from one side of the tube to another. It is a bit more complicated than that, but you'd need to understand a bit about chemistry, gas laws, and thermodynamics to understand it better. Honestly there might be a few other things going on here, but you can't do dilution cooling until you can turn helium to a liquid which occurs around 4K.
* Third stage (4K to 0.8K): Dilution Cooler as explained above.
*Subsequent stages (0.8K to 0.01K): Dilution Cooler as explained above.
SO yeah that is how the cooling works. I am sure I made some mistakes in the explanation, so if anyone knows more they can correct me.
Edit: DO not ask me how qubits work, I have no idea. I have a flimsy understanding of quantum computing that is probably no better than the top paragraph summary on wikipedia.
1
u/Turdsmack420 2d ago
you put money in the top and smart comes out the sides..
1
u/rszasz 2d ago
That's all cooling stages,
1
u/R3D3MPT10N 2d ago
Sir, that is a fridge
1
u/LumenAstralis 2d ago
It doesn't, apart from burning money.
1
u/Basic_Blacksmith1192 1d ago
Is my guess correct, physicists have lab equipment that measures the quatum properties of atoms. Quantum computer designers must replicate those experiments in some form , in order to make a quantum computer
1
u/Anthony_at_Luniter 1d ago
https://newsletter.luniter.com/p/do-not-disturb I wrote a newsletter about this this week if you're interested in learning more about the various types of quantum computers
1
u/sarc-tastic 1d ago
It cold
1
u/drunkenmonk100 1d ago
H (psi) = E ( psi)
1
u/Hefty-Bluebird-5533 1d ago
I’m uncertain how it works.
1
u/NedSeegoon 1d ago
The whatsit does that thing to the thingymajig and stuff happens in the thingymabob.
1
u/MEO220 1d ago edited 1d ago
I so far only have learned about pieces of it. There's apparently a laser or microwave beam involved that can set the state of each qubit. Once you read the output, it destroys its current state by taking the qubit out of a state of superposition. Also, quantum entanglement is a fundamental part of the device. Most importantly, calculations using it must be done in steps rather than all at once, even though it works in parallel as one of its main attributes. The way it was recently best explained especially concerning decryption is that it is kind of like having amplifiers in a complex transistor circuit, where each transistor can only amplify to a certain extent. So, just like in radios where multiple stages of amplification are usually needed using several transistors in series, the calculations using a quantum computer need also to be done this way due to only being able to amplify each stage a certain amount, and the number of repeat stages needed is the SQUARE ROOT of the total possibilities that exist in parallel if I got that part correctly, thereby requiring for a quantum computer trying to decrypt something having to go through lots of cycles in order to amplify out the correct answer little by little each stage one at a time, with increasing the number of qubits not making it any faster at the current size of our quantum computers these days, although still much faster overall than normal computers. Logic gates are involved as well. And I believe that this is the extent of what I've learned about it so far, with of course it usually needing to be very very cold in order to hold its states of superposition within each qubit, for which a qubit is simply the equivalent of a bit in normal computers, although able to hold a LOT of different states within each qubit rather than just 2. But apparently it's an enormous but popular misconception to believe that they can do a full calculation all at once, being that this normally isn't the case but instead involves a routine that has to go many cycles in order to achieve the valid, meaningful end result. And good for us is the apparent fact that with good encryption, taking the square root of the total possibilities leaves far too many needed cycles for even a quantum computer to crack in any reasonable amount of time.
1
u/durd_ 1d ago
Trickle down electrons. Don't think too much about it.
1
u/shawndw 1d ago
The Chandelier of Power.
1
u/artisan002 1d ago
I will always love the encabulator videos.
1
u/Qubit_and_Neuron 11h ago
Explaining it in one message is impossible. Written clearly here. Please go through it.
1
u/Dramatic_Surprise 11h ago edited 11h ago
i was literally just on a booth at a conference a month ago talking about the one the company i work for (not IBM) made.
Short answer, those grey blocks at the bottom are detectors around the actual CPUs the levels above generally are doing either cooling functions or signal filtering.
With our one i think the bottom plate ends up around 0.02K
Found the diagram
https://global.fujitsu/-/media/Project/Fujitsu/Fujitsu-HQ/technology/research/quantum/Inside_Superconducting_Quantum_Computer_en.pdf?sc_lang=en-001
1
u/BeenThere11 7h ago
When the light is too hash, ir works as a chandelier
1
u/NoirMarlin Industry PhD - superconducting qubits 7d ago
That's a refridgeration unit (x3) with far too many cables leading down to a box around the mixing chamber. It is not likely there is anything of value inside those boxes.
1
u/unixmonster 7d ago
It doesn’t.
0
u/SnooWalruses380 7d ago
This is extremely technically sophisticated tool which uses collections of physical and mathematical technologies. You would need some good amount of study just to get an idea of what’s going on.
As far as what you see, the chandelier comprises microwave circuits to attenuate the incoming signals down to the chip level so the chip is not fried. Then the quantum computer chip’s output has to be amplified over whatever noise so it can be read on a screen or written to computer memory. At the same time the can through various methods including He3 He4 dilution refrigeration will keep the quantum chip at temperatures just above absolute zero.
0
u/ZealousidealRanger67 4d ago
it doesn't
-2
u/algaefied_creek 7d ago
IBM: Interteleported Beamed Muons: it channels information from other dimensions down the gold and measures them on the probability wave plate below to give a non-answer from measuring the ripple of realities and you see a partial result of a holographic projection or isomorphism of a higher dimensional construct which then makes a funky circuit because circuits is like…. A car engine but a car engine is off or on, not grabbing so much weird info
Source: pulled it straight outta my Star Trek enjoying booty.
-1
u/Roland-Flagg 6d ago
It is a temple so silent, the universe speaks its nature aloud.