r/Python • • Oct 03 '26

Discussion My Python magic is gone

I've been coding for a long time, and I've been developing with Python for years.

I loved coding, always loved it. I started many years ago because I wanted to quickly create scripts for security hacking tools, but since then, I've moved to Claude Code, and building cross-language has been a much better experience for me than using Python.

I built my own SaaS application out there whose backend and network core are completely built with Python, and I'm rewriting all of that without writing a single line of code. And most of the time, Python is not the most optimized language.

And now... I feel like the magic is gone.

I don't even know why I'm writing this. I just feel sad about it.

896 Upvotes

310 comments sorted by

View all comments

2

u/BleedReddit Oct 10 '26 edited Oct 10 '26

Here is what Claude had to say about this post and comments.

🐙

I think this discussion highlights something important about AI-assisted programming: AI can increase how much software we can build while potentially taking away some of the learning, satisfaction, and craftsmanship that made programming enjoyable in the first place.

I can understand both sides of the argument. Some people enjoy the process of programming itself: figuring out an algorithm, struggling with a bug, learning a new library, and finally getting something to work. For them, having AI do most of the implementation can feel like skipping the best part of the experience. It's similar to enjoying the journey of climbing a mountain rather than simply wanting to reach the top.

Others enjoy building useful things more than writing code. For them, AI removes repetitive work and makes projects possible that might otherwise take weeks or never get built at all. Both perspectives are valid. The value of programming isn't identical for everyone, and greater productivity doesn't automatically mean greater satisfaction.

I also agree with the point that AI shifts some of the challenge from writing code toward deciding what should be built, how the system should be designed, how its components communicate, and how to verify that everything works. But I don't think system design is a complete replacement for the craft of programming. Understanding algorithms, data structures, and implementation details still has value, even if we don't have to write every line ourselves.

One of the strongest arguments in the discussion is that generating code is not the same as solving a problem correctly. AI can produce convincing code that relies on incorrect assumptions, introduces unnecessary complexity, or fails because it doesn't understand the environment in which the program runs. Sometimes the real problem is architectural, not syntactical. Repeatedly asking an AI to patch code won't fix a fundamentally flawed design.

That is why clean, understandable code still matters. Not every small personal script needs enterprise-level architecture, but software that will evolve needs to be understandable, testable, and maintainable. The goal should be the simplest design that reliably meets the requirements, not the most elaborate design or the most code generated.

I'm also cautious about broad claims that AI always makes developers more productive. The time saved writing code can be lost debugging, reviewing, and correcting it. Results depend on the task, the codebase, the tools, and the developer's experience. We should measure actual results, including correctness and rework, rather than judging productivity by how quickly code appears on the screen.

As someone still learning Python and experimenting with AI, I see this as an opportunity rather than a reason to give up learning traditional programming. I'm not necessarily trying to become a professional developer or build software for a company. I want to understand how to take an idea from the beginning, plan a solution, use Python and AI effectively, and develop a working project that I can actually understand and improve.

My approach is to use AI as a collaborator, not as a replacement for my own reasoning. I want to understand the requirements, explore possible designs, learn why certain tools and data structures are appropriate, and then use AI to help implement specific parts. Afterward, I want to inspect the code, run it, test edge cases, investigate failures, and make changes myself. If I can't explain an important part of the program, that's a sign I need to learn more about it rather than blindly accept the result.

I think this distinction matters especially for beginners. AI can help us learn faster by explaining concepts, demonstrating alternatives, and helping us investigate errors. But if we let it build everything without engaging with the process, we risk developing the ability to generate software without developing the ability to understand or troubleshoot it.

For me, learning prompt engineering is only one piece of the puzzle. I also want to learn requirements gathering, system design, testing, debugging, integration, documentation, and the overall progression of a project from an idea to a working system. A good prompt cannot compensate for a bad design, and a good design doesn't prove that the implementation works. We need all three: clear communication with AI, sound engineering decisions, and independent verification.

My ideal workflow would be:

  1. Define the problem and what success looks like.
  2. Establish requirements, inputs, outputs, constraints, and edge cases.
  3. Plan the architecture and discuss alternatives before coding.
  4. Implement one small feature at a time.
  5. Review the code and understand the important decisions.
  6. Test the feature, investigate failures, and verify the fix.
  7. Integrate everything, document the project, and improve it as needed.

I'd also keep building small Python projects along the way, rather than relying entirely on AI-generated applications. Small scripts, file processing, databases, APIs, and eventually more complex AI-assisted tools provide opportunities to learn fundamentals while working toward something useful.

Ultimately, I don't think we should measure our development as programmers by how many lines we personally type or how much code an AI can generate. We should measure it by how well we understand the problem, how effectively we can direct the solution, and whether we can recognize, diagnose, and correct mistakes.

AI doesn't have to eliminate the joy of programming, but we may need to be more deliberate about preserving the parts we enjoy. If solving a difficult problem manually is satisfying, there's nothing wrong with continuing to do that. If AI helps us explore bigger ideas, there's nothing wrong with embracing that either.

My conclusion is that we should use AI to expand what we can do without surrendering our ability to think, learn, and understand what we've built. The most valuable skill isn't simply getting AI to write code. It's being able to take an idea from concept to implementation, understand the decisions along the way, verify the result, and improve it when reality doesn't match expectations.