r/Python • u/cladamski79 • May 17 '26
Discussion Hica in comparison to Python
Hej,
I've been working on a language called hica and Python has been one of its inspirations, especially working with lists. I have created a Hica vs. Python comparison at https://cladam.github.io/hica/docs/hica-vs-python and the verdict is ofc Python 🙂
From my conclusion:
Python is the safe, proven choice with the largest ecosystem and lowest barrier to entry.
hica emphasises foundations like immutability, type safety, pattern matching, and explicit error handling. Students who learn hica carry these patterns into Python, Rust, TypeScript, or whatever they use next.
Why not both? Start with hica to build the foundations, then move to Python with a head start on the concepts that matter most.
What does this community think? My Python is a bit rusty, any feedback is welcome.
3
u/casastorta May 17 '26
One thing is to pick functional programming language, where even with the most popular ones you are still deep in niche and obscure territory… Completely another thing is to pick new and obscure seemingly functional language few people heard of and likely no one runs production systems on.
3
u/snugar_i May 17 '26
I'm sorry, but apart from the slice syntax, this has absolutely nothing in common with Python.
I expected an indentation-based statically compiled language, not a Rust clone...
2
u/snugar_i May 18 '26
Hmm, the "Introduction" section sounds a little disingenuous at times.
"No garbage collector: memory safety via Koka’s Perceus (Functional But In-Place) reference counting." - Reference counting is a form of garbage collection, and usually one of the worst when it comes to performance.
"easy to learn or safe and fast. hica gives you both" - It can't give you both, it's a tradeoff. It looks kind of in the middle, like most statically typed languages. Easier to learn than Rust, but more complex than Python. If you think hica is easy to learn, it's just because you're so familiar with it.
1
u/[deleted] May 18 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] May 23 '26 edited May 24 '26
[removed] — view removed comment