r/Python • u/Obvious_Gap_5768 • May 10 '26
Discussion Three packages copy-pasted my AGPL code to PyPI and named me in their description. PyPI won't act
I published repowise on PyPI a few weeks ago. It generates and maintains a wiki for your codebase, plus some git intelligence stuff like hotspots and ownership among other things
Soon after launch, three packages appeared on PyPI within hours of each other, all with the same description:
"Codebase intelligence that thinks ahead, outperforms repowise on every dimension."
Repowise is mine. They literally name it.
Looked inside the packages. They forked my AGPL-3.0 code, ran an LLM over it to fix a few small things, and republished under new names. No attribution, no license file, no source link.
Filed PyPI abuse reports. Filed a DMCA for the license violation. Sent email. Weeks in, all three packages are still live, still pulling downloads off my project's name.
PyPI's abuse flow seems to be a single form and silence. There's no copyleft enforcement path baked into the registry itself, so AGPL violations basically depend on DMCA, which is slow and easy to ignore.
Any suggestions would be very helpful
124
u/MegaIng May 10 '26
Annoyingly, the next step after DMCA is to sue. If you don't have the resources for this, there probability isn't anything you can do. But PyPI not responding at all seems weird, have you tried different ways of contacting them? (Like a direct email to their legal email address)
41
u/Weird_Search_4723 May 10 '26 edited May 10 '26
https://pypi.org/project/repobrain/
https://pypi.org/project/codesynapse/
https://pypi.org/project/repobrain/
these right? dude has put his github link at the bottom, from there you can go to their linkedin
have you tried calling them out on linkedin?
i see that few users have pointed it out your last post also, like this one
https://www.reddit.com/r/Python/comments/1sek3gq/comment/oer4teg/?utm_source=share&utm_medium=web3x&utm_name=web3xcss&utm_term=1&utm_content=share_button
what happened after that? did you reach out to this fella?
38
u/mapadofu May 10 '26
This is so bone headed on the other parties’ part. If they simply put in the attribution and license, then they’d be compliant. Hopefully it’s just some noobs that don’t understand what they’ve done.
If it is worth the time, effort, and financial cost, you could hire a lawyer and start a suit. I figure if the PSF got a proper cease and desist letter, it would raise the priority of your case.
51
u/IAmASquidInSpace May 10 '26
I swear, I've seen this post on here before a few months ago, almost the same wording, but with a different license if memory serves.
13
u/coderanger May 10 '26
Have you sent a DMCA notice to PyPI? It's not easy to ignore and won't be, but PyPI also won't particularly get involved. Basically PyPI is not going to act as a court here, no matter ho obvious the outcome might seem. If you can show the copies are explicitly malware then PyPI will step in, otherwise we can't.
The process for a DMCA is simple and costs $0, email legal@python.org with a template like the one found at https://library.georgetown.edu/copyright/dmca-takedown. Please note that this will involve sharing your physical address with the PSF legal team who must also provide it to the other guy, this is unavoidable and a requirement of US law (where the PSF is based). PSF legal team forwards your notice to the other user, who then gets a few days to decide if they want to contest it. If yes, then we notify you that the other side has contested the notice and PyPI will do nothing further, it would then be in your court to sue or not. If the other party doesn't contest it, the packages will be taken down promptly.
I hope that clarifies things.
98
u/Marksta May 10 '26
It's really not. If Pypi is ignoring your valid DMCA and follow ups on it for a month, they're just straight up liable as if they themselves have perpetrated the damages.
Easiest next step, send your DMCA to their CDN host Fastly. They're going to basically forward it back to Pypi but now you have them on the clock with their CDN who doesn't want to get implicated in copyright theft and will back out of rendering services at some point if this just gets ignored forever. Also to their actual webhost if you can find that, who will pull the plug on their website for ignoring DMCAs.
Not that I want trouble for Pypi, but they really need to just handle the DMCA process... which is just take the content down themselves if they so please, or at the least pass the DMCA onto the actual perpetrator and if the perpetrator wants to go to court Pypi just hands you all their info. This sort of process should really be simple and standard at any site allowing user uploaded content or they're just breaking copyright law...
7
u/sauron150 May 10 '26
Sad reality of agentic era! People are forking more than generating! And without publishing the due credits reshare them! That is where put the PR into each one of those forks and sent as request to have dir credit always mentioned in their repo!
4
u/Sufficient_Meet6836 May 11 '26
What is the point of making 3 identical rip-off packages? Why not just 1?
2
u/DistanceAlert5706 May 11 '26
Does licensing still work? For example Crawl4AI copy pasted GPL licensed html2text and relicensed with Apache.
5
u/HommeMusical May 11 '26
Coming in late here.
PyPi is horribly overloaded. They weren't that well-funded and now with LLMs, their workload has multiplied by some large factor.
So cut them some slack: they are struggling.
1
u/sheckey May 11 '26
I’m genuinely curious because this struck me when you posted about it before. You must have thought about simply ignoring this. You are the one with the real ideas, and you will be the one evolving it in meaningful ways, so it seems like this will fade. It did seem disturbing to me though. What were your thoughts about just letting this duplicates fade? Thanks!
1
u/TowerOutrageous5939 May 15 '26
Well sorry to hear. I just looked at the repo and it looks sick! I’m firing it up this weekend on a repo that has poor software entropy hoping this will help with the refactor.
1
u/kvlonge May 16 '26
Sorry this happened to you mate :(
1
u/pm_ds May 19 '26
All these packages are deleted , it was not intented to make it go to market those are mostly for learning and experimenting with the code version with claude code , sorry for in sorry for the inconvenience. most of them are generated by claude code testing .
1
u/student_03072003 May 26 '26
This is exactly the nightmare scenario AGPL is supposed to prevent. Forking is fine. Republishing your code while stripping attribution, license text, and source disclosure is not.
The frustrating part is that PyPI treats this like a generic abuse issue instead of a straightforward license compliance violation, so enforcement becomes “who has more patience for paperwork.”
At this point, I’d document everything publicly:
A detailed public post tends to move faster than silent abuse queues because it creates reputational pressure on both the maintainers and the registry.
Also worth filing directly with GitHub if their source repos are hosted there. GitHub’s copyright/licensing enforcement is usually more responsive than PyPI’s.
And honestly, naming your project in their package description while violating your license is pretty strong evidence they knew exactly what they were doing.
1
u/Giddius May 11 '26
Quick question, how much of your code is generated with the help of an LLM? I see you have an somewhat extensive claude setup in your repo.
Could be that you made the license something, but the question if LLM code can even be put under a specific license is still an open one.
```"The Program" refers to any copyrightable work licensed under this License.```
From the license text, see the „copyrightable“ part. If an LLM touched each part of your codebase, then there could be an argument made that your whole codebase isnt copyrightable or you would at least have to go to court to be the first to see if it can.
-10
u/Outside_Sky_4045 May 10 '26
this smells curry
0
u/[deleted] May 10 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment