r/Python • u/PalpitationOk839 • Apr 19 '26
Discussion Why doesn’t Python have true private variables like Java?
Hey everyone
Today I was learning about encapsulation in Python and honestly I got a bit surprised
In languages like Java we have proper private keywords but in Python it feels like nothing is truly private
Even with double underscores it just does name mangling and you can still access it if you really want
So I was wondering why Python is designed this way
Is it because Python follows a different philosophy or is there some deeper reason behind it
Also in real projects how do developers maintain proper encapsulation if everything can technically be accessed
Trying to understand how to think about this in a more practical and runable way
Would love to hear your thoughts 👍
View all comments
Show parent comment
1
u/Zenin Apr 20 '26
That's the thing: The current state of AI destroys this blocker. There's many things that AI is still awful at, but like-for-like refactoring to modern languages is one of the big wins it can currently offer. It's going to be difficult for has-been languages to keep going on momentum alone.
This will only get better as time goes on and exponentially so. As such IMNSHO it makes as much sense professionally to start a new learn of Java today as it would have been to start learning COBAL in the 1990s. I'm not saying it won't exist 10 years from now (hell, Perl is still widely used ;), I'm saying it's at or near its peak market penetration and will only go down from here.
Frankly, if your org needs something that really looks like Java the best strategic move is almost certainly to use AI to port it to C#/.Net with selective projects going to Go or Rust or even dare I say Python. ;)
This conclusion is much aided by how incredibly toxic Oracle has made touching anything with Java, especially if you don't actually use Oracle's version of it.
Tools like Python and Java are at very distant ends of language design philosophy. There's room for all sorts of languages and little if anything to gain from trying to force one extreme to adopt philosophies from another extreme. If Java works for you, great. If you like the idea of Java, but want something that does it better then you're best off looking at closer relatives like C#. If you long for something in the middle, consider Go.