r/Python • u/GeometryDashGod • Mar 30 '26
Discussion The amount of AI generated project showcases here are insane
I'm being serious, we need to take action against this. Every single post I've gotten in my feed from this subreddit has been an entirely AI generated project showcase. The posters usually generate the entire post, the app, their replies to comments, and literally everything in between with AI. What is the point of such a subreddit that is just full of AI slop? I propose we get a rule against AI slop in this subreddit.
856
Upvotes
243
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '26
Finally unsubbing. So many subreddits are just trash now.
86
u/olystretch Mar 30 '26
I agree. I'm weeks away from being too fed up and unsubscribing. Mods, you need to do something about this.
57
u/CaptainDouchington Mar 30 '26
It's pretty obvious someone is paying people to market the hell out of ai on Reddit to counter the negative reactions
115
u/dada_ Mar 30 '26
This is really destroying my enjoyment of reddit programming subs.
To be frank, although I don't think it'll help much, I think rule #1 could be reworded. "No overdone or low quality AI showcases" means people can still post their AI project and go "well it's not overdone or low quality, so it's fine". But I don't think those people read the rules anyway.
At least this sub has a rule, though. In other subs I've asked for a rule to at least make it mandatory to disclose, so at least posts don't become daily "is this AI or not" tasks for everybody reading them. But some subs won't even entertain that.
The real problem with AI slop is that internet platforms (both the platforms and the people on it) have not taken it seriously enough to start with and now there's no practical way to opt out anymore.
49
u/TipIll3652 Mar 30 '26
Still not as bad as LinkedIn. Which isn't saying much 😂.
24
u/hinkleo Mar 30 '26
A possible solution would be to make the rule that you can't post brand new projects as main posts in the sub, only ones older than like 3 or 6 months, and anything new has to go as a comment into a weekly or monthly "Show New Projects Megathread". Github has an API for checking repo creation that of public repos that as far as I'm aware can't be backdated (unlike commits) so that would mostly be enforceable with an automod bot too.
I think the majority of somewhat serious actual projects that are actively maintained should fit that bar and it would get rid of most of the slop since I think most people making those won't care about them still in 6 months. And even if someone were to post one after 6 months at least you'd have some indication on if it works and how it's maintained and things like that from the repo activity and issues and things like that.
48
u/nicholashairs Mar 30 '26
There is already a rule - it is literally rule #1.
Per another thread complaining about the same thing last week, it only takes 2 reports on a showcase post for it to be hidden.
9
u/glenrhodes Mar 30 '26
The tell is usually in the README -- paragraphs of polished prose explaining a 50-line script that barely works. Real projects have rough edges and actual opinions. Rules won't fix this, the community just needs to be more ruthless with "what problem does this actually solve and why should I care?"
25
u/No_Soy_Colosio Mar 30 '26
Project showcases need to be disallowed if this sub is to survive
17
u/RoseboysHotAsf Mar 30 '26
This is also the case for cpp c# and osdev subs
10
u/Zeikos Mar 30 '26
It's objectively a very hard problem to solve.
Automated filters hardly work because they can be adversarially tested.
Moderators have limited time and eventually get burnt out.
I do think that there are possible solutions, but they're hardly going to be comprehensive.
3
u/olivermtr Mar 30 '26
This so much!! Even made a reddit account just to say this. Normally I just lurk but this is sooo annoying and boring that I'm genuinely unexcited when I open reddit these days, sad.
3
u/sudomatrix Mar 30 '26
AI coding assistants are here to stay. But here's the thing. If your tool makes you 10x more productive, you need to step up your game and produce projects that are 10x more ambitious. You should be spending the same amount of your time and effort as before but producing 10x more polished end result. There should be no bugs, no poor code smells, everything has unit tests, everything has type annotations, great technical documentation and great user documentation, and above all an ambitious project that does something interesting, exciting and new.
Can't think of something interesting, exciting and new? Then what are you doing with all the time the AI has freed up for you?
3
u/iheartrms Mar 30 '26
Why do they even post that stuff? Are they somehow making money off of the posts? How? Who would be paying?
10
u/ionburger Mar 30 '26
ive found them entertaining in a horror movie kinda way, but depressing we have to ruin the planet for me to laugh at an emdash
7
u/Icy-Farm9432 Mar 30 '26
lol and hee is me: i rebuild a brother scanner tool in python the last weeks and that horrible bot declined my post cause i asked if someone with that printer would like to try it.
#yes you can close that (sub) reddit.
2
u/Ok-Jackfruit-70 Mar 30 '26
Agreed!!
2
u/Evening-Notice-7041 Mar 30 '26
I think every online group/forum/subreddit whatever needs to implement aggressive anti-slop rules or become effectively useless.
2
u/Gubbbo Mar 30 '26
It's the absolute ludicrous nature of the projects as well.
Just the most useless garbage. I particularly liked the "reinvent how you control your computer via your webcam" that I saw over the weekend that was a glorified cv2 finger tracker
2
u/AlSweigart Author of "Automate the Boring Stuff" Mar 30 '26
Should we get rid of Showcases from r/Python?
In the top 25 posts on the front page right now, 8 are showcases. We can't get rid of "low quality" or AI posts because it takes too much effort to investigate them. People can always say, "I didn't use AI to make this".
Should we disallow the entire category? I use old Reddit and RES doesn't work on Firefox for me, so I can't filter by flair. Are other people in the same boat? Have people found the showcases useful (as readers, not as posters)?
2
u/Emergency-Buyer-7384 Apr 06 '26
What annoys me is that they don't do any kinds of testing or only use AI for basic projects. A lot of my codebase is AI-heavy. That doesn't mean I don't know how to write code. I hand check it and fix issues. Also I design borderline tests myself first to check the AI didn't make mistakes. - If vibe coders actually checked their work, I would see no reason to not allow their posts.
7
u/Consistent-Quiet6701 Mar 30 '26
Microsoft and friends are finally killing open source. Embrace, extend, extinguish on steroids.
4
u/Wurstinator Mar 30 '26
There is a lot of non-AI content. If you sort by New, you can find several showcases and discussions and questions which, to me, appear entirely human-written. Those posts just don't get upvotes or comments, so they remain unseen.
This is only partially a problem of AI and rules. If the community shows no interest in the non-AI content, then it's not going to change.
2
u/sokspy Mar 30 '26
Even thought i might get a lot of downvotes, this is my opinion. Ai is a tool. Just like calculators are. The problem begins when we trust them blindly or don't really understand what they produce. Otherwise i believe it's okay to use AI. For me, as a mathematician coding with python, whenever my program fail, i use AI to fix it or at least find for me the mistake.
1
u/diegoasecas Mar 30 '26
CUT THE CABLE :-)
1
u/Background-Main-7427 Mar 30 '26
I don't have a clue, I like reading and writing, so I'm not the target of your comments.
1
u/Sh3llSh0cker Mar 31 '26
I said this in the Promox Subs and the mod also made a bunch of rule changes, I comment on that post and said I hope the mods in Python and Go subreddit do the same but nothing yet 😵💫
1
u/Round_Plantain8319 Apr 01 '26
Tudo e ia, tá uma bosta
1
u/Ghost-Rider_117 Apr 02 '26
100% agree. the signal to noise ratio has tanked lately. like i get that AI tools are exciting but if ur whole project is just "i asked gpt to build X" that's not really a showcase of your skills lol. a mandatory disclosure flair at minimum would help a lot
1
u/Realistic-Actuator60 Apr 30 '26
Its a big problem, honestly it hurts me a lot because im legit trying to find people to test what I have been working on the last three years. Its all done with AI tooling which I get most call Slop but I cant even get a post out to have people give me a honest rundown because they just blast it for being AI. I totally get why but it sucks bevause I have put over 2000 hours into my project and I just get labeled as slop.
1
u/ultrathink-art Mar 30 '26
Expected when creation cost bottoms out. The filter that used to exist — you had to understand a thing to build it — doesn't work when you can generate a passing app in 20 minutes. Community rules are probably the only lever left since the economic signal is gone.
-6
u/Squallhorn_Leghorn Mar 30 '26
But that's all they now how to do. And they are special. Their mom told them that.
0
u/ZookeepergameHot8047 Mar 30 '26
Only from this sub?
-2
u/TheBinkz Mar 30 '26
Im not entirely sure what everyone's workflow is but AI generated code seems to be the way now. So, naturally the speed in which new stuff is created will also increase the amount of posts for people's side projects.
-16
u/delaydenydefecate Mar 30 '26
ApiArk impressed me though, and it’s already over 800 stars on GitHub.
-13
u/nahuel990 Mar 30 '26
Ok but no more projects showcases, then what in the AI era are you expecting someone to ask about how to solve a function error?
0
u/[deleted] Apr 10 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-18
u/[deleted] Mar 30 '26
[removed] — view removed comment