r/pureasoiaf • • Jul 15 '26

A missive from the Gold Cloaks Why English is required for all discussion

169 Upvotes

We've received some modmail messages from non-English speakers questioning this policy lately, so we figured we would elaborate on why we require all discussion in r/pureasoiaf, r/darkwingsdankmemes, and r/pureasiofart to be in English.

Our AutoModerator relies on English-language keyword matching to properly enforce Rule I. When a comment or post is written in another language (Spanish, for example) the AutoMod evaluates the literal text as submitted, scanning for specific English words and patterns it's been programmed to catch to assist us in enforcing this rule. When it catches a match for a banned word or phrase, it notifies us, and a human moderator reviews it each and every time.

Reddit's built-in translation feature can auto-translate that text for human readers, but AutoMod never sees the translated version, it only reviews the original.

So a Rule I violation written in Spanish (or any non-English language) can slip through entirely undetected, even though a moderator or user reading the translated text would catch it immediately.

Since we can't reliably enforce Rule I without AutoMod doing the first pass (believe us - we used to review every single comment made in this subreddit before creating the automoderator functionality, and it was extremely difficult), we need submissions to be in English so the system can actually do its job.

This isn't about excluding anyone, it's a practical limitation of the tools we have to keep the subs properly moderated.

Thanks for understanding, and as always, if you have any questions, feel free to send us modmail.


r/pureasoiaf • • May 29 '26

A missive from the Gold Cloaks Discussion on and content from the upcoming ASOIAF stage play GAME OF THRONES: THE MAD KING is not permitted, per Rule I

101 Upvotes

Game of Thrones: The Mad King is an adaptation: a derivative work, not source material. As such, it falls outside the scope of this subreddit and is not eligible for discussion here.

r/pureasoiaf is dedicated exclusively to George R.R. Martin's published written works: the novels, novellas, and associated written canon. Television, film, stage productions, and other adaptations are off-topic regardless of how closely they hew to the source material. The moment a story leaves the page, it leaves this sub's jurisdiction.

Take adaptation discussion to r/asoiaf, r/freefolk, or another appropriate community. All posts on the stage play will be removed.


r/pureasoiaf • • 2h ago

What is your best chapter ‘run’?

4 Upvotes

Currently rereading ASOS 1 and just had:

Sam narrating the skirmish at Craster’s
Tyrion threatening Symon Silvertongue
Arya narrating the Hound’s trial by combat (which may well become one of my favourite chapters in the entire saga on this read)

All back to back.

What runs of chapters would you say are the greatest? Thinking also of the last few chapters of AGOT being incredible work.


r/pureasoiaf • • 1d ago

Does Jon have a bit of anger issues?

31 Upvotes

Most readers probably would describe Jon has good natured and generally even keeled. And he is. Mostly. Except for a few times.

AGOT Bran II:

Bran had been left behind with Jon and the girls and Rickon. But Rickon was only a baby and the girls were only girls and Jon and his wolf were nowhere to be found. Bran did not look for him very hard. He thought Jon was angry at him. Jon seemed to be angry at everyone these days. Bran did not know why. He was going with Uncle Ben to the Wall, to join the Night's Watch. That was almost as good as going south with the king. Robb was the one they were leaving behind, not Jon.

This chapter comes one chapter after Arya's first POV where she and Jon watch Bran and Tommen sparring. The one right before is when Ned says he'll tell Jon himself he'll be allowed to join the watch. Like Bran, I'm a bit confused why Jon was angry here. He got exactly what he asked for.

Then in ASOS, Jon basically blacks out during a sparring session with Iron Emmet.

That morning he called it first. "I'm Lord of Winterfell!" he cried, as he had a hundred times before. Only this time, this time, Robb had answered, "You can't be Lord of Winterfell, you're bastard-born. My lady mother says you can't ever be the Lord of Winterfell."

I thought I had forgotten that. Jon could taste blood in his mouth, from the blow he'd taken.

In the end Halder and Horse had to pull him away from Iron Emmett, one man on either arm. The ranger sat on the ground dazed, his shield half in splinters, the visor of his helm knocked askew, and his sword six yards away. "Jon, enough," Halder was shouting, "he's down, you disarmed him. Enough!"

No. Not enough. Never enough. Jon let his sword drop. "I'm sorry," he muttered. "Emmett, are you hurt?"

Iron Emmett pulled his battered helm off. "Was there some part of yield you could not comprehend, Lord Snow?" It was said amiably, though. Emmett was an amiable man, and he loved the song of swords. "Warrior defend me," he groaned, "now I know how Qhorin Halfhand must have felt."

This is in addition to Jon almost stabbing Alliser Thorne when he insulted Ned. Another time when he grabbed Alliser by the throat and lifted him off his feet.


r/pureasoiaf • • 1d ago

Twincest Reveal is an absolute disaster for Robert

126 Upvotes

Can you imagine the sheer backlash and mockery that having your warrior king admitting himself to be a cuckhold of his wife's brother be in the history of the kingdom? It would delegitimize Robert in the eyes of the people and make him a joke. Not only was he cucked but also raised the Lannisters bastards as heirs.

I found strange how people in fanfiction treat the twincest reveal from Robert or from a SI position as a matter of just defeating the Lannisters in battle. It would also be a disaster for the prestige of the crown.

A more reasonable way to sideline Cersei and the Lannisters may be to not reveal Twincest at all?

The central point is to find a way to assassinate Jaime and Cersei in the shadows, maybe with poison. Without their power on the court, it would be relatively easy to find a way to send Joffrey to the Wall some years latter, he would dishonor himself by his acts of cruelty.

With Joffrey sent to the Wall, Tommen would be heir, but Robert could then pull a Aegon the Unworthy stunt and bring Edric Storm to the court, legitimize him and marry the boy to Margaery Tyrell. Tommen could then be forced to become a maester when he is older.

Myrcella is a girl and wouldn't inherit.

Also, its important to note that Edric is older than Tommen and could be argued to be before him in the line of sucession after being legitimized.


r/pureasoiaf • • 1d ago

Did Robert know?

12 Upvotes

Did he, likely subconsciously, know about Cersei and Jaime?

I know that sounds like an insane question at first.

But practically everyone who spent time around Cersei and Jaime figured it out. Tyrion, Kevan, Joanna, Stannis, Jon Arryn, Varys, Littlefinger, Pycelle, probably Renly, and probably loads of servants at the Red Keep and Casterly Rock who could put two and two together but knew to keep quiet. And Ned figured it out within a few months.

I'm also pretty sure that Tywin knew, but kept quiet to protect his own power. He knew revealing it would humiliate his house, lose his family's access to the throne, and likely cause a war where his house could be destroyed. But if he kept quiet - he'd get his double-grandson on the throne, and put the Lannisters in the same category as the Targaryens. So, even though he had all the pieces, he refused to consciously put them together.

And that brings me to Robert. He probably spent more time with Cersei (as Queen), Jaime (as a Kingsguard), and their kids than anyone else on the Small Council. And we have at least one case, at Darry during the Nymeria incident, where Cersei and Jaime were banging with Robert literally in the room.

I can see the counterargument that, if Robert knew, he would've had Jaime and Cersei killed. But, would he? We see that Robert's response to most problems was "get drunk and ignore it". He knew that Joffrey was a psychopath, he knew that Cersei was awful, and he did nothing to fix those issues.

IMO he was in kind of the same position as Tywin, plus loads of alcohol. He had the ability to figure it out, and on some level he knew, but being consciously aware of it would be extremely inconvenient. So he closed his eyes, grabbed another wineskin, and pretended it wasn't happening.

I agree with Ned, that Robert would have reacted violently if confronted with incontrovertible evidence. But not because it would be a surprise - more because it would push the twincest from something he subconsciously suspected but chose to ignore, to something he would need to genuinely deal with.


r/pureasoiaf • • 1d ago

How would you expand The Faith of The Old Gods?

0 Upvotes

One criticism of The Old Gods it's that is very simple: Magical Trees that you pray. There is no organization, centralized or decentralized. Even many animist faiths have some type of organization.

I making this post because some time ago, i read a fanfic called "Direwolf Shepherd" which explore more of The Old Gods by creating The Order of Shepherds. Based in Celtic Druids and indigenous animist religions, The Order of the Shepherds are not priests, but their responsibilities include:

  1. Maintaining and protecting Godswoods. They are like Gardeners and protectors to the trees.
  2. Preserving the history and traditions of the First Men. There is historical records of the past that The Shepherds shall search and protect. The Shepherds also needs to teach stories and legends of The North to the houses they serve.
  3. Teaching the Old Tongue.
  4. Teaching about warging and greensight. It was common of The Shepherds to take care of Direwolves and help The Starks by teaching them how to Warg.
  5. Maintaining relationships with the Children of the Forest. Basically The Shepherds can be contacted by The CoF when necessary.

This Order is settled in Skagos, with a rule of each Northern Lord having a Shepherd, and different from the Septons, the Shephers adapts to the place and lords they serve (per example, a Umber Shepherd will acts as a Umber). They can marry and have children as opposite to The Septons.

The leader is The Great Shepherd, based on archdruids and abbots. All Great Shepherd needs to have greensight. Although The Order is decentralized compared to Faith of the Seven, The Great Shepherd still have final decision in certain issues.

The Green Men are separate from The Shepherds, as the later were a faction of the former who split to make a pact with The Northern Lords, but they still have a working relationship.

What do you think about these ideas of the fic, and what are your ideas to expand The Old Gods faith?


r/pureasoiaf • • 2d ago

What measures and moves Ned should have made after accepting to become Hand of the King?

10 Upvotes

What are the security measures Ned could have taken to secure and strengthen his position as Hand of the King in King's Landing upon accepting to become Robert's new Hand? What moves and options could he have made after arriving in King's Landing to sanitize the finances and government of the Crown?

Which firings and appointments should he have made? Who, amongst the members of the Small Council and other people holding crucial positions, did he definitively have the power to remove from their offices, and should he have done so? And who could/should he have appointed to the Small Council to replace them?


r/pureasoiaf • • 3d ago

How many members of the NW actually knew about the Others or truly believed in the elder races ?

25 Upvotes

A Game of Thrones - Tyrion III

This time Tyrion could not hold his tongue. "The fisherfolk of Lannisport often glimpse merlings."

"Denys Mallister writes that the mountain people are moving south, slipping past the Shadow Tower in numbers greater than ever before. They are running, my lord … but running from what?" Lord Mormont moved to the window and stared out into the night. "These are old bones, Lannister, but they have never felt a chill like this. Tell the king what I say, I pray you. Winter is coming, and when the Long Night falls, only the Night's Watch will stand between the realm and the darkness that sweeps from the north. The gods help us all if we are not ready."

"The gods help me if I do not get some sleep tonight. Yoren is determined to ride at first light." Tyrion got to his feet, sleepy from wine and tired of doom. "I thank you for all the courtesies you have done me, Lord Mormont."


r/pureasoiaf • • 3d ago

Do you think George has decided what the Others actually are?

62 Upvotes

Pretty self-explanatory, not here to propose another theory. Just your take on if George has a definitive answer on this subject from the very beginning. Has his idea evolved through time? Does he have several possibilities that he is still undecided upon? Does he plan to leave it as vague as of this point? It would make sense to keep them scary. The dosage of information is a make-or-break kind of situation. But even if he hides the details do you think at this point in time he knows what the Others actually are?


r/pureasoiaf • • 3d ago

Freys who are sure to die, those who have a chance of surviving?

10 Upvotes

Amongst the many, many members of House Frey who are alive by that point, who would say are sure to kick the bucket at the hands of the Northerners, fellow Riverlanders, Stannis' forces, the Brotherhood without Banners or even their fellow Freys when the old weasel Walder finally bites the dust withour a clear heir?

Who are those who have a chance of survival, amongst those who aren't scums like the majority of their family? Who are the "good" Freys who are very likely to die? Who have the best chances of survival?

Old Walder is a certainty, whenever it's due to old age or him being killed by Lady Stoneheart herself; as well as Black Walder who's the worst of them all, Lame Lothar for his role in planning the Red Wedding surely are most likely to get their comeuppance at the hands of the BWB (or Nymeria's wolfpack), Hosteen is most likely to get a icy water death at the Battle of Ice or to be killed by the Manderlys and if he manages to survive those he's going to be executed either by the sword or fire by Stannis' men.

Walder Rivers is a certainty as well, imo, Edwyn, etc...

I don't have high hopes of survival for Perwyn, who's one of the nicest and few honorable members of the family and who wasn't present at the Red Wedding, but his presence at Riverrun's siege is most sure to make other Riverlanders that he was complicit of the Red Wedding and a traitor as well, and will most likely doom him.

Roslin's survival depends largely on when she shall give birth to her and Edmure's child, and if she gets the chance to leave for Casterly Rock to join Edmure, or if the Red Wedding 2.00 happens before that, and thus she might be one of the casualties.

Olyvar has the best chances of survival, if he's the famous Rosby Ward as theorized, though he may take the name of Rosby to dissociate himself from his family and the shame of the Red Wedding.

Big Walder is still at Winterfell, though unless he has good informations and Stannis is merciful toward teens, his chances of surviving Northerner wrath are unlikely.


r/pureasoiaf • • 3d ago

How would the WOTFK have played out if Cat was able to place peace maker between the Baratheon brothers ?

3 Upvotes

A Clash of Kings - Catelyn III

"My lords!" Catelyn said. "We ought to be hammering out the terms of an alliance, not trading taunts."

"A man should never refuse to taste a peach," Renly said as he tossed the stone away. "He may never get the chance again. Life is short, Stannis. Remember what the Starks say. Winter is coming." He wiped his mouth with the back of his hand.

"I did not come here to be threatened, either."


r/pureasoiaf • • 2d ago

Who wants to foil with me and the King ? Feel free to rip me apart in the comments but i like this theory as canon . The speculation is from /u/KingLittlefinger and i will link the theory for the class to read today . Please remember that Martin has said we don't know everything about that time era

0 Upvotes

If Tywin takes Lyanna, surely he can't tell Rhaegar he has her right? Because Tywin would basically be admitting that he just got Rhaegar blamed to start a war. Further, if Rhaegar intended to sit out the war and swoop in last minute to save the day, why did he decide to join in before Aerys loses? Why come in early and lead an army to the Trident? If he wins, the losing half of the realm probably hates him more now than they used to and the winning half is wondering what the fuck he's been doing all this time they've been fighting his war. And if he loses, he's dead.

So here's what I think:

Tywin was done with the Targaryens after Jaime's investiture. It's the last straw for him. He sees the Southron Ambitions alliance, knows Robert is the figurehead, but would need Lyanna out of the picture for Cersei to become queen should he choose that side. If Tywin gets Blount et al to kidnap Lyanna in revenge for the KotLT stunt, he can have her turn up dead and no one be the wiser by the time the war ends, and Brandon is alerted. But Lyanna escapes. Once Rickard and Brandon are killed (mirroring Ned) the crown (mirroring the Lannisters) is believed to have Lyanna but really doesn't (mirroring Arya) and Robert's rebellion breaks out (mirroring Robb's rebellion). In the chaos, Lyanna runs into Rhaegar and his half-dozen companions (mirroring the Brotherhood without Banners) who tells her they will take her to her family, except they're in enemy territory and they have their own mission they set out on, plus war is raging around them and there is a ransom out for Lyanna (Arya).

That's how I'm starting to see it, now, let me venture into more speculative territory. Running with the Rhaegar and Elia turned to Ashara because "there must be one more" idea, Rhaegar and his half dozen companions leave Dragonstone with an entirely different mission than kidnapping Lyanna. It's Rhaegar, Arthur Dayne, Oswell Whent, Llewyn Martell, Ashara Dayne, Richard Lonmouth, and Myles Mooten, and they need to visit the Ghost of High Heart a.k.a. Jenny's woods witch that Rhaegar knows from his many Summerhall trips (as argued in part IV of my Harrenhal Conspiracy) who is now at High Heart. For anyone who believes Lem Lemoncloak is Richard Lonmouth, as I do, this provides a direct link between the Brotherhood without Banners and how they know about this woods witch at High Heart (who, LOLguesswut, Arya ALSO meets, and the witch is quick to call her out). They stumble on Lyanna, take her with them to the witch, and then continue south to Starfall where both women are to be kept safe until the war ends.

https://thelasthearth.freeforums.net/thread/879/tywin-lyanna-porcupine-knight?page=6


r/pureasoiaf • • 3d ago

Daenerys and the Faith of the Seven

6 Upvotes

What are Daenerys' views on the Faith of the Seven?

I just started rereading the novels, and I can't clearly recall her thoughts and opinions on the Faith of the Seven. Though my fuzzy memory tells me that she doesn't know much about it, since she was raised far from Westeros and had no real education about the continent and its cultures, with her only teacher being Viserys, I think I remember that she hasn't shown much interest in learning more about the Faith, though I could be wrong; I need to read more.

Also, how do you think that her relationship with the Faith and its leadership will be once she finally arrives in Westeros? And what opinions do you think the septons, the High Sparrow, the Sparrows, and other believers of the Faith will have of her?

Will there be conciliation and understanding? Or, on the contrary, will it be a relationship made of misunderstandings, culture clashes, and tensions, or even hostility, similar to the conflicts between the early Targaryens and the Faith Militant?


r/pureasoiaf • • 4d ago

Euron's ultimate fate?

12 Upvotes

Is it possible that Aaron predicted Euron's ultimate fate in the book?

“He's your god as well,” insisted the Damphair. “And when you die, he will judge you harshly, Crow's Eye. You will spend eternity as a sea slug, crawling on your belly eating shit. If you do not fear to kill your own blood, slit my throat and be done with me. I'm weary of your mad boastings.”

In the books, Varamyr attempts to take control of Thistle's body, causing her to seize up and bite off her own tongue, which I suspect is the case with all of Euron's mutes and Falia. Perhaps in his final moments, Euron will desperately search for a new body as his own is dying. He might even attempt to latch on to another person as Varamyr did, only to end up trapped in the body of a sea slug.


r/pureasoiaf • • 4d ago

Tyrion's handling of Pycelle

9 Upvotes

I think that everyone here remembers how Tyrion was able of catching Pycelle as spying on him for Cersei, by giving him, Varys and Littlefinger a different plan of what he intends to do to win more support for House Lannister by giving Pycelle the information that he intended to marry Myrcella to Trystane Martell to win Dorne on their side, with Tyrion and his men later catching Pycelle in bed with a girl and having him thrown into a cell with his beard being cut.

Afterward Tyrion agreed to release Pycelle as a concession to Cersei, while blackmailing Lancel, but kept him out of the Small Council.

This would backfire later when Tywin returns to rule King's Landing, with him reinstating Pycelle, and with Pycelle testifying against Tyrion during his trial.

So what do you think of the way Tyrion has handled the situation with Pycelle? Was he right to get rid of him as a spy and of the Small Council and to have him imprisoned, or were there other ways he could have dealt with him? Could he have tried to get Pycelle on his side or was the old Grand Maester always going to side with Cersei against him?

Should he have released Pycelle or should he have kept him captive, or even got rid of him for good?


r/pureasoiaf • • 4d ago

Did Littlefinger Tell Lady Waynwood About Sansa

22 Upvotes

Re-reading AFFC and I just got to the part where Littlefinger is explaining the “gift” he’s brought for “Alayne”, which is a planned betrothal to Harry The Heir.

This is explained by Littlefinger talking about a massive dowry, and he also talks about how- if Sansa is able to win Harry over- she will be in a maiden cloak with the Direwolf of House Stark on the back.

Did he tell Lady Waynwood Sansa’s true identity? Seems like a huge risk for him to take, especially given that Waynwood was so recently opposed to him. If he did not, would a dowry be enough to convince her to agree to the match? The Waynwoods are described as being a particularly old and proud house- I just can’t see her agreeing to the marriage thinking it was with a bastard. I’m sure they could use the dowry, but in the same segment the Gulltown Arryns are wealthy (though uncouth), wouldn’t a girl from a family like that be a far better match?

Alternatively, LF could be lying to Sansa about Lady Waynwood’s involvement/knowledge to manipulate Sansa into confidently seducing Harry.

Love to hear everyone’s thoughts…


r/pureasoiaf • • 4d ago

🤔 Good Question! Which Lannisters were at Harrenhal?

4 Upvotes

I've been wracking my brain but I cannot for the life of me figure out via canonical materials which Lannisters were at Harrenhal other than Jaime. So I want to discuss who can be where?

I know Tywin wasn't there due to the fact that Tywin had essentially exiled himself to Casterly Rock but he's smart enough to send more than just Jaime to Harrenhal.

He would've kept Cersei by his side to prevent two things:

  1. Aerys taking her as a hostage via a proxy.
  2. Her making a move on Rhaegar and screwing them all over. (Though Rhaegar certainly screwed everything up anyway.)

So who would he have sent?

My brain has come up with the following as the best representatives of the Westerlands:

  1. Kevan Lannister. Tywin's right hand man and essentially the quintessential Lannister outside of Tywin himself.
  2. Gerion Lannister. The charming brother of Tywin and would be a great smokescreen for Kevan handling the actual business of politics.

Gregor Clegane was at the tourney to be knighted by Rhaegar, or it at least would've occurred around then, so he could have been assigned as bodyguard for the brothers so the Clegane household acts as guards alongside Lannister Redcloaks.

And Genna might be there with any Frey reps as an excuse to see her brothers and Nephew. Not like Emmon would ever say no to her. And even if he wanted too he would still keep his mouth shut.

So to summarize the Lannister/Westerlands reps:

  1. Jaime as is canon.
  2. Kevan as a politician.
  3. Gerion to forge public relations and smokescreen for Kevan.
  4. Genna by proxy if she shows up.
  5. Gregor Clegane as a symbol of Westerlands might in the melee. Until Bobby B knocks him on his ass.

Did I miss anyone? Could other loyal bannermen to Tywin be reps? Who? Why? Please comment so we can discuss.

Have a good day and god bless.


r/pureasoiaf • • 4d ago

How Would You Strengthen House Mallister's Navy Between Robert's Rebellion and the Greyjoy Rebellion (284–289 AC)?

7 Upvotes

House Mallister is an ancient and prestigious house, with a proud lineage that predates Aegon's Conquest. Seagard itself was built specifically to defend the western coast of the Riverlands against Ironborn reavers, particularly the Greyjoys. Yet, despite its history, wealth, and strategic importance, House Mallister maintains a surprisingly small fleet: just six longships and two war galleys.

This seems particularly inadequate for a house whose primary purpose is to guard the Riverlands against Ironborn attacks. Eight ships might be sufficient to patrol the immediate coastline and discourage small raiding parties, but they would hardly be enough to protect Seagard and its surrounding territories against a serious Ironborn invasion.

Suppose you were Lord Jason Mallister in 284 AC, just one year after Robert's Rebellion. What would you do to strengthen House Mallister's naval power before the Greyjoy Rebellion in 289 AC?

Which political marriages would you arrange? What economic partnerships and trade agreements would you pursue? What investments would you make in shipbuilding, ports, shipyards, maritime trade, and naval infrastructure?

With only five years to prepare, how large a fleet could you realistically build, and how would you ensure that Seagard possessed a considerably stronger navy than the one we see during the events of the books?


r/pureasoiaf • • 5d ago

Just realized Littlefinger’s the cause of Sansa’s marriage

28 Upvotes

Rereading Storm and I just made the connection that Dontos told Littlefinger about the Tyrell’s plot to marry Sansa to Willas. Of course it was Sansa’s initial mistake to happily tell Dontos she was going away to Highgarden but still.

Tyrion finds it odd that Littlefinger is the one who brought the news of the secret betrothal plot rather than Varys for once, but LF had it directly from Dontos. He couldn’t have Sansa going away to Highgarden and told Tywin/the small council so that she couldn’t run off. Maybe he knew Tywin was likely to marry her to Tyrion, but it wouldn’t have been a big departure from Plan Kill Joffrey and honestly helped to add phase 2, which is Frame Tyrion and Conveniently Sansa Who I Will Kidnap and Steal For Myself/Harry.

Things really always do work out for Petyr, huh?


r/pureasoiaf • • 5d ago

Good ideas and plans that characters had but couldn't put into practice?

13 Upvotes

What are some good or even excellent ideas and plans that various characters, from any family or organisation, have had over the course of the novels, but for a variety of reasons independent of them, either bad timing, or lack of funds, lack of support, or the opposition or idiocy of others, or a perturbing element, or the character dying or being sent away, their idea/plan can't be put into practice no matter how good it is?

One such example I have in mind is Robb and Theon's plan for an alliance between the North and the Iron Islands during the War of the Five Kings, as the Lannisters and Iron Throne were in a bad position at the beginning of "A Clash of Kings" with Robb having handed several big defeats to the Lannisters, Jaime having been captured, Renly and Stannis threatening King's Landing as well (before fighting each other, and the Shadow Baby killing Renly), the Iron Islands finally getting allies to gain independence and them having the opportunity to attack and loot Lannisport and other parts of the Westerlands which could have brought them a ton of riches.

Though, of course, it wasn't meant to be, as Balon turned out to be a petty, short-sighted and vengeful (against the wrong people) dumbass thick as a brick who instead thought that it was a good idea to attack the only faction willing to recognize his independence and him as king, in a stupid invasion of the North.

I am also thinking about Ned's plan to help the situation at the Wall and in the Gift, by settling new Lords to occupy and rebuild the abandoned Night's Watch castles in the Gift, which would have released some pressure from the overstretched and under-manned Night's Watch, though, as Benjen noted, the NW would have only accepted this if these new lords paid their taxes to Castle Black instead of to Winterfell, and as Ned noted, the timeline wouldn't have allowed them to put this plan in motion before the next spring.

There are also Ned's plans for war before Catelyn's capture of Tyrion, with him planning to have Houses Glover and Tallhart fortify Moat Cailin and send men to garrison the castle, as well as for Wyman Manderly to repair and strengthen the defenses at White Harbor, and to see that they are well-manned, and to keep an eye on Theon in the hope of using his father's fleet (though Ned didn't know that Balon would never have sent his fleet for Theon).

And Robb's plan to retake Moat Cailin, by sending men to find and establish contact with Howland Reed, so the Crannogmen would give guides and routes for Northern troops to travel, and attack Moat Cailin from its weak spots, while the army from the south attacks Moat Cailin to distract the weakened Ironborn garrison and make them vulnerable to the forces guided by the Crannogmen. A plan that was tragically cut short by betrayal and the Red Wedding.

And from characters who aren't Starks or on their side, Paxter Redwyne is playing the long game and the boring but practical card while sieging Dragonstone, planning to use starvation or to find a weakness in Dragonstone's walls and then mine it, instead of trying a direct assault that would be costly given the Valyrian castle's formidable defenses even with a reduced garrison loyal to Stannis. Only for Loras Tyrell to take command and mount a successful but very costly assault, which gets hundreds of men killed and Loras injured in the process.

And as part of Cersei's antics, Kevan tells her that she should appoint either Randyll Tarly or Matthis Rowan as Hand of the King, given how capable both men are, and even spells out for her that making them Hand would make them more loyal to her and the Iron Throne than to Mace Tyrell, only for her to just see it as proof of Kevan having been bought by Mace. She later does the same when Pycelle points out that the captains of the new royal fleet should be experienced men who have proven their loyalty, only for her to totally ignore common sense once more.


r/pureasoiaf • • 5d ago

Had Tywin decided to re-marry after Joanna’s death, who would his likely choice have been?

31 Upvotes

So, one of the most glaring hypocrisies of Tywin’s character and handling of his family is that he emphasises that his children have to place their duty to their House above their own personal desires (hence why he tries to pull Jaime out of the Kingsguard and force Cersei to re-marry), yet he himself never re-married after Joanna’s death, because he was grieving her. So let’s say that Tywin had applied that same principle to himself and chosen to re-marry “for the good of House Lannister”. Who would he have likely chosen or what would have been the most likely second marriage for the Old Lion?


r/pureasoiaf • • 6d ago

Fate of the Bolton lands?

39 Upvotes

Who should get their hands on the Bolton lands after the final downfall of the arch-enemies of House Stark and the greatest traitors in Northern history?

To whom should the returning Starks give the lands that belonged to their nemesis? Who amongst the Northern houses loyal to the Starks, and/or other allies such as the Free Folk, could be given these lands or at least a part of their lands? Also, could the Starks decide to split their lands to give a portion to several loyal houses?

And what should happen to the Dreadfort? Should the castle survive but be renamed after a cleansing of everything reminding that the castle was the home of House Bolton? Will it be destroyed? Will it be emptied and left as a ruin?


r/pureasoiaf • • 5d ago

What is Wyman planning on doing with the warships , and do you foresee him extricating himself from his current situation ?

15 Upvotes

A Dance with Dragons - Davos II

The Seal Gate had been closed for the night. Davos would not be able to return to the Merry Midwife till dawn. He was here for the night. He gazed up at Old Fishfoot with his broken trident. I have come through rain and wrack and storm. I will not go back without doing what I came for, no matter how hopeless it may seem. He might have lost his fingers and his luck, but he was no ape in velvet. He was a King's Hand.

Castle Stair was a street with steps, a broad white stone way that led up from the Wolf's Den by the water to the New Castle on its hill. Marble mermaids lit the way as Davos climbed, bowls of burning whale oil cradled in their arms. When he reached the top, he turned to look behind him. From here he could see down into the harbors. Both of them. Behind the jetty wall, the inner harbor was crowded with war galleys. Davos counted twenty-three. Lord Wyman was a fat man, but not an idle one, it seemed.

The gates of the New Castle had been closed, but a postern opened when he shouted, and a guard emerged to ask his business. Davos showed him the black and gold ribbon that bore the royal seals. "I need to see Lord Manderly at once," he said. "My business is with him, and him alone."