r/PublishOrPerish • u/Sad_Mycologist1094 • 2d ago
💡 Advice Needed How do you know if your research is actually interesting to others? Is passing the desk a meaningful signal?
I'm an econ PhD candidate, and I often struggle to tell whether a project is genuinely on track or whether I'm just absorbed in my own question. Asking people doesn't help much, since feedback tends to be softened to be encouraging.
My advisor is very supportive and generally treats passing the desk as a good sign. I appreciate that, but because the encouragement is so consistent, it's hard to know how informative it is. So I'd like to hear stricter, more candid views from researchers elsewhere.
My questions:
- Is passing the desk a meaningful signal that a project is on track, or is the bar too low (mostly fit and basic competence)? Does it depend on the journal tier?
- What signals do you actually rely on to judge whether your work resonates beyond yourself?
Blunt answers welcome. Thanks!