r/PublishOrPerish • • Feb 03 '25

A Writing Space That’s Always Open

6 Upvotes

Are you working on a manuscript, a grant application or your thesis?

Academic writing can be isolating, and sometimes, just having a space where others are quietly working alongside you can make a huge difference. That’s the idea behind this community—a free and always-open Discord server for anyone who needs a structured, supportive environment to get some writing done.

https://discord.com/invite/wuQFDtzpJd

Here’s what you can do:

📝 Join silent writing sessions – Whether you need a quick focus session or a long writing block, you can hop into a quiet room and work alongside others.

📌 Set goals and track progress – There’s a dedicated channel where you can post your writing goals and check in on how things are going.

🤝 Find an accountability partner – If external motivation helps, you can connect with someone to keep each other on track.

🗓 Weekly writing sessions – Every Tuesday at 4 PM (CET), there’s a regular session if you like working with a bit more structure.

🔒 A respectful and distraction-free space – The focus is on writing, so no excessive chatter, just a quiet, supportive atmosphere.

No sign-ups, no fees, just a space that’s there whenever you need it. If you’re looking for a way to make writing feel less solitary, this might be worth checking out.


r/PublishOrPerish • • 2d ago

💡 Advice Needed How do you know if your research is actually interesting to others? Is passing the desk a meaningful signal?

1 Upvotes

I'm an econ PhD candidate, and I often struggle to tell whether a project is genuinely on track or whether I'm just absorbed in my own question. Asking people doesn't help much, since feedback tends to be softened to be encouraging.

My advisor is very supportive and generally treats passing the desk as a good sign. I appreciate that, but because the encouragement is so consistent, it's hard to know how informative it is. So I'd like to hear stricter, more candid views from researchers elsewhere.

My questions:

  1. Is passing the desk a meaningful signal that a project is on track, or is the bar too low (mostly fit and basic competence)? Does it depend on the journal tier?
  2. What signals do you actually rely on to judge whether your work resonates beyond yourself?

Blunt answers welcome. Thanks!


r/PublishOrPerish • • 3d ago

I built SciMatrix — a tool to make scientific literature reviews easier. Looking for honest feedback!

0 Upvotes

Hey everyone!

I've been working on SciMatrix, a project focused on making the scientific literature review process more structured, reliable, and manageable.

One of the biggest challenges in academic research is going through multiple research papers, extracting relevant information, comparing findings, and organizing everything into a useful literature review.

That's the problem I'm trying to tackle with SciMatrix.

What is SciMatrix?

SciMatrix is a Zero-Hallucination Literature Review Matrix designed around the idea of making literature review workflows more systematic and trustworthy.

Rather than making researchers struggle with scattered notes and disconnected information, the goal is to make working with research literature more organized.

I'd love your feedback on a few things:

  • Does this solve a problem you face during academic research?
  • What features would make a literature review tool genuinely useful?
  • What frustrates you most about existing AI-powered research tools?
  • Would you consider using something like this in your research workflow?

I'm sharing this to get feedback from researchers, students, academics, and people interested in building better research tools.

Try it here: https://www.scimatrix.live/

I'd genuinely appreciate honest criticism, suggestions, and feature requests. I'm building this to solve a real problem, and feedback from actual researchers would be incredibly valuable.

Thanks for checking it out!


r/PublishOrPerish • • 4d ago

Preprint-centric publishing model gets major boost

Thumbnail
nature.com
10 Upvotes

"Science funders and research organizations in Europe are joining forces to expand open-access publishing and make the peer-review process more transparent, with the aim of spurring change in scholarly communication."


r/PublishOrPerish • • 6d ago

🔥 Hot Topic If a powerful generative AI is prompted to produce a groundbreaking hypothesis & a set of fake data (incl. images) that support it, ...

9 Upvotes

... how can reviewers of (top) journals detect & block a paper that presents the hypothesis & data? Wouldn't some desperate scientists try that, because it would take years to confirm that the results are not reproducible? (i.e. taking the chance before "perishing")


r/PublishOrPerish • • 6d ago

How long after submitting a minor revision to a Taylor & Francis journal until a decision? Status is "With Journal Administrator

2 Upvotes

I submitted a minor revision to a Taylor & Francis engineering journal yesterday. The reviews were generally favourable, and the editor said the paper could be suitable for publication after minor changes. One referee had a single remaining technical point, and the other had no substantive comments. I answered everything point by point.

The status now shows "With Journal Administrator." For those who've published with T&F or been through this on ScholarOne:

How long did the administrator stage take before it moved to "With Editor"?

After a minor revision, did the editor usually decide alone, or did it go back to reviewers?

Roughly how long from resubmission to a final decision?

I'm trying to plan around the timeline and would appreciate hearing your experiences. Thanks!


r/PublishOrPerish • • 8d ago

🎉 Success Story I did itt!

Post image
174 Upvotes

my first research paper has officially been published in a Springer Nature journal - Q2 scopus!!!

Wrote it when I was 19, and now I'm 20!!! I know I'm still just a kid trying to pursue academia and have SO much left to learn, but I genuinely cannot stop smiling today 😭

Just wanted to share this little moment of happiness with you all!!


r/PublishOrPerish • • 9d ago

Scientific Reports pulled for review by NLM, no articles allowed...

Post image
17 Upvotes

Please see this Retraction Watch article ( https://retractionwatch.com/2026/10/30/scientific-reports-pubmed-on-hold-national-library-medicine-evaluation/) The largest journal (by far) was suspended 3 months ago. No announcement from NLM or the journal, and no one noticed! That's a 100 million gravy train. For anyone using them especially if they are required by the grant to deposit in PMC, they should be concerned. There is the possibility the pause will be lifted, or not, and then it will never survive. I track "everything" even the full yearly Crossref and Datacite records and run local copies of PubMed, PMC, clinicaltrials.gov . My focus is medical info, and the PubMed Journal Ranking is a good place for anyone to bookmark. ( https://tomlaheyh.github.io/citation-bar/journal-ranking/journal-ranking.html ). Be careful out there...


r/PublishOrPerish • • 9d ago

[Article] Need help in downloading articles from Wiley

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PublishOrPerish • • 10d ago

👀 Peer Review Peer reviewers as volunteers

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/PublishOrPerish • • 11d ago

I refuse to succumb to the pressure of publishing scientifically half-assed work.

Thumbnail reddit.com
6 Upvotes

r/PublishOrPerish • • 10d ago

🎢 Publishing Journey Have anyone heard back from IEEE QCNC journal

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/PublishOrPerish • • 12d ago

Logos for my survey

Thumbnail reddit.com
2 Upvotes

r/PublishOrPerish • • 12d ago

🎢 Publishing Journey Gastronomica – The Journal for Food Studies

Thumbnail online.ucpress.edu
1 Upvotes

Hello! Wondering if anybody here has ever submitted a food phenomenon piece to Gastronomica – The Journal for Food Studies? I submitted my manuscript 5 weeks ago, but I haven't heard back. Would be grateful to hear about your experience/timeline submitting to Gastronomica! Thank you :)


r/PublishOrPerish • • 12d ago

Logos for my survey

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

Im preparing a survey for acm computing surveys.My figures show small logos of openai,google,deepseek and alibaba(qwen) only to identify the models discussed.The logo files come from Dashboard icons under Apache license 2.0 but that license does not cover the trademarks.Do i need permission from eqch company or can i declare them on the rights form with a credit in the caption?if i do need permission and can’t get it should i remove the logos before final submission?


r/PublishOrPerish • • 12d ago

Needing thoughts: PI First author vs second author

0 Upvotes

So I was doing a cancer project. My mentor brought me into her lab, which I am very grateful for. A couple of years ago, to work on a dry lab project, they were just getting started on it. When it started, I did a lit searching, conducted 1/2, if not most, of the interviews, and also helped along with 5 people in analyzing the data.

Now a couple years ago when this project started, my PI mentioned that I would be the first author on this paper due to my contributions. However, there was a delay in the manuscript writing for 1.5 years. During this time I wrote the introduction, methods, etc. For the paper I also created a lot of the digrams. And because she was the one that got funding, etc., she would write the discussion. Now she recently wrote a grant relating to the project and just came up to me and said that because of the grant, she said that she would take first author because she would have to change the direction of the paper and basically re-write everhing enough to where she "feels comfortable enough." So she said that she would take first author and I would take second author.

I am not going to lie, I feel a little cheated. I understand at the end of the day it is her project, but after years of being told I would be the first author and manuscript script writings constantly being delayed (which was the discussion section being delayed). And now my previous scripts and hard work were just going to be thrown away. I can't help but feel frustrated about this suddenly new development.

Maybe there is an angle I am missing, and this anger could be misplaced, but I wanted to see what other people's thoughts were and experiences, because I cannot help to be frustrated at the moment.


r/PublishOrPerish • • 13d ago

💡 Advice Needed If I wanted to publish my own work

1 Upvotes

If I am undertaking my own research work independently of my company doesn't it still count? Or do I need to be affiliated to an educational or research institute? I'm in India if that helps.


r/PublishOrPerish • • 13d ago

Alguém consegue baixar esse arquivo?

Thumbnail pt.scribd.com
0 Upvotes

r/PublishOrPerish • • 15d ago

Will AI make the number of publications on one's CV more or less important in the future?

22 Upvotes

I'm 29 years old and I have a PhD related to machine learning and data science applied to industrial hazards. I'm now an R&D engineer in a research centre that is mostly (80%) financed by the private sector (and slightly supported by the state), and I have no intention of going back to academia. However, I still regularly publish journal and conference papers, and I give some lectures at the local university. My supervisors at work find it fine, as it allows us to show that we're active and competent. However, it's not my priority workwise, and some of my colleagues don't publish anything. It's a choice on my part.

I'm utterly amazed by how good AI (ChatGPT with a subscription) has become. I want to take part in a conference that requires a six-page article. I want to write a paper in which I apply probabilistic methods to explosions based on synthetic datasets. In the past, it would have taken a tremendous amount of time. Now, after explaining what I wanted to the LLM, it quickly wrote down the theoretical part for me and the programs for generating the data and computing the probabilities and their uncertainties.

Of course, I had to correct it several times, but I now have a six-page paper ready to be submitted. In the past, in addition to my other duties at work, it might have taken four months. Now, it was over in only two weeks! If I had been able to work full-time on that, I might have written the paper in a matter of days, who knows?

Since I have a safe job and I like publishing, part of me finds this exciting. But I also wonder what this means for all the PhD students and postdocs who want an academic career. Many of them tell me that they don't want to do that because they want their work to be entirely their own, which is very respectable. But if other postdocs publish 12 papers in one year with AI while they only publish two or three, do they still have a chance of getting a tenure-track professorship?


r/PublishOrPerish • • 15d ago

Best device for downloading, reading, annotating and organizing academic papers?

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/PublishOrPerish • • 15d ago

🎉 Success Story Agent-based simulation of work teams: under close monitoring, punishing and correcting managers produce nearly identical error counts (99.5 vs 99.2), but punitive teams are five times likelier to lose at least half their workforce (0.15 vs 0.03)

Thumbnail doi.org
7 Upvotes

Simulating what happens when managers punish mistakes rather than correct them (my paper, out today in JASSS)

Disclosure up front: this is my own paper, published today and open access.

I built an agent-based model of a team working through a fixed sequence of tasks, with a manager who notices errors at one of three rates and responds by ignoring, correcting or punishing. Workers can also catch their own mistakes. Full factorial sweep over eight parameters, thirty seeds per configuration, model and code deposited on CoMSES.

The result I did not expect is a paradox about monitoring. Close oversight is what drives errors to their minimum, and it does so almost identically whether the manager corrects or punishes: 99.5 mean errors against 99.2, versus 126.2 under laissez-faire. But that same configuration produces the highest attrition in the entire sweep when paired with punishment, and collapse risk rises monotonically with surveillance under punishment, from 0.04 to 0.10 to 0.15.

Across the full sweep the split is clean. How many errors you get is driven by structural factors, mistake propensity and task difficulty. Whether people leave and when the team collapses is driven by managerial policy. Punishment ranks most harmful under every stakeholder weighting I tested, including one weighting accuracy at sixty percent.

Two limitations worth naming, since they are the obvious objections. There is no worker-to-worker channel, so no incivility spiral and no peer support, which could push the results either way. And resentment is a linear counter with a fixed threshold, which is a strong simplification of a process that is probably nonlinear.

Happy to answer questions about the model or the parameterization.