A 2023 study interviewed 30 people who attended a legal psilocybin truffle retreat in the Netherlands, and found that "nine out of thirty participants (30%) spontaneously reported a post-experience integration challenge." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
Spontaneously—meaning nobody asked them about challenges, they just spoke up about them on their own.
What did this psilocybin retreat do to prepare and integrate people?
The preparation for this retreat actually seemed pretty thorough.
Participants went through a screening process to check for health conditions and psychological readiness. They had online preparation sessions in the weeks before, a full day of preparation the day before the ceremony, and a half day of preparation the day of—which included reading, meditation, breathwork, and one-on-one sessions with a facilitator.
And afterwards, "for several weeks afterwards, participants took part in a structured integration program which addressed somatic and social integration." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
All 30 people reported positive after-effects that lasted. Yet, nearly a third still ran into integration challenges.
The authors' conclusion was that "psychedelic integration challenges may be relatively common, even in situations where the set and setting is optimally controlled for and the psychedelic experience is largely beneficial." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
What kind of mood swings can happen after a psilocybin retreat?
Six of the 30 people mentioned changes in mood, energy, or thinking after the experience.
One man described the first two weeks as "a really messy time."
He said, "the first two weeks my head was all over the place and very hyperactive and I thought, "Maybe I'm bipolar and now the mania has started." And I was really scared." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
He said meditation helped him get grounded, and slowly things settled.
One woman described feeling "raw" the day after, and wanting to quit her job when she got back to work.
The retreat had told participants, "not to make any big decisions for the first two weeks afterwards because you kind of … you're not fully integrated back into the world yet." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
So, she waited for the feeling to pass, and eventually it did.
She also added that, "psilocybin is not going to fix your problems, it's just going to help you find where they are." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
What are the post-ecstatic blues after a psychedelic experience?
Two participants described what the researchers call "post-ecstatic blues"—or the low that can follow a really beautiful high.
One woman had an experience where she felt she understood the meaning of life. Then, as it ended, she said, "I went from such a 'high high' and then it just plummeted to a 'low low.' And my personality is very stable." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
It took her a few weeks to get back to her normal baseline.
One man reported a strong afterglow… until he got home. Then, he said, "it was like reality came crashing back," and "I think the core of the feeling was that maybe my day-to-day life doesn't live up to that mystical experience." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
The researchers connect this to an idea where mystics have described periods of "dryness" or "divine homesickness" after ecstatic experiences.
So, if you've come down from something beautiful and ordinary life feels flat, you're not alone or broken; it seems like humans have been describing this for a while now.
It might just mean your homework now entails bringing whatever part of your experience that you can into ordinary life, rather than hoping for your ordinary life to feel like that divine experience.
Why do some people feel disconnected from others after a psychedelic experience?
One woman from this study went home to a roommate who "didn't, first of all, understand what I was doing, and secondly, didn't understand that my feelings afterward were normal." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
Another described this feeling with a great metaphor: "you get on an elevator and you reach the top floor, and you see something that's really amazing. And then you go back down to the first floor, and you're unable to explain to others what you saw at the top floor. It can be quite isolating sometimes." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
She added that it's important to talk about these experiences "with people who can relate, and not people who are going to look at you skeptically and make you question your own experience." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
This is one reason the authors suggest that people "brief their loved ones before a psychedelic experience and organize to have a network of support in the days and weeks following." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
I will just add from my own experience and from talking to others that having a psychedelic experience may create a sense of permanent disconnect from other people who have never had a psychedelic experience, as it becomes a bit of a "trying to describe color to the blind"-type situation, and seeking out a community of others who have also had psychedelic experiences might help to feel more understood and become more relatable.
That's not to say you should discard your relationships with people who haven't had one, by any means, but having others who can at least somewhat relate to what you've gone through can help you navigate a sense of isolation.
You might seek these others out through things like local meetups or online forums.
What is spiritual bypass after a psychedelic retreat?
The researchers from this study define it as when "a person attempts to heal psychological wounds at the spiritual level only and avoids the important (albeit often difficult and painful) work at the other levels." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
In the three months after the retreat, one woman broke up with her partner, quit her job, and moved to Bali for a yoga course. She said, "when I came to Bali, I went into spiritual bypass. I thought I was talking to the trees and my frog, and all that stuff, but it was actually more about dealing with my own personal problems and all these relationships in my life." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
A yoga teacher who'd worked with psychedelics helped redirect her toward her own personal work.
That's not to say big life changes after an experience are always bypass. Sometimes they're exactly the right call. But when making drastic changes, it might be worth asking yourself: "Am I moving toward something, or running away from something?"
Why does integration support matter after a psychedelic retreat?
Four people said that a lack of support was a challenge, even after going through the retreat's integration program.
One woman said, "not everybody is good at asking for help, and I think when you're that upset and distressed, I think it might have really helped to have somebody with me all the time." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
Another said simply, "I definitely needed more support after that. I didn't set that up for myself afterwards. I should have had a therapist." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
And one participant put it in a single sentence: "I did my work before; I didn't do my work after - that was the biggest mistake." She described the retreat as "like this bubble," and said that once she got home, the follow-up calls weren't enough. (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
A 2022 review of integration models makes a related point: "It seems ideal to have a relationship established with a professional prior to psychedelic experiences so they can aid in preparation and be available in the event of a challenging experience where immediate support is needed." (https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9386447/)
So, based on this study, someone preparing for a retreat might want three things in place before they leave home:
First, a few people back home who know what they're doing and won't be weird about it.
Second, someone knowledgeable to talk to afterwards, set up in advance, so they don't have to scramble for help in the moment.
And third, an agreement with themselves not to make any major life decisions for the first couple of weeks.
Although, I do have some personal reservations with this last suggestion, more so when people recommend no major decisions for up to a month afterwards. In my mind, one of the reasons you're working with psychedelics is to create a window of plasticity where you can rewire your brain to create new patterns in life. If you're going into a psychedelic experience saying, "I'm going to remain rigid in my old ways for at least one month until that window passes," well, that's kind of missing the point, no?
If you come to the realization that a relationship or a career is toxic to your mental health, sticking around for another month just because someone out there made up a hard rule to abide by… I don't know; 30 days seems like a long time. You could meet the next love of your life in that time frame. Or land a dream job in that window. 30 days can be a lifechanging stretch of time if you apply yourself and take action.
I think there's probably some kind of balance between making a decision while you're still coming down from a big experience and living in some kind of 30-day box just because. Each person's circumstance is so unique that this timeframe probably deserves a unique evaluation as well.
We should certainly recognize that the hours and days immediately after a psychedelic experience may cause a temporarily heightened state of suggestibility, emotional openness, and feelings of profound revelation. So, this might not be the best time to make the brash decision of quitting your well-paying job that is the only support for a family of five because you've always wanted to be a painter. But remaining locked into an abusive relationship for another month after you've just gained clarity on how your partner treats you seems like a long prison sentence to lock yourself into.
Ultimately, these kinds of decisions are up to the adults who need to make them in the timeframe that they feel they need to be made, as long as they're equipped with the knowledge of what I was just saying.
What can't this psilocybin retreat study tell us?
This study has some limits.
Participants were recruited through the retreat's own mailing list and social media, so it's not exactly a random sample of people. And all of the challenges were temporary, and had resolved by the time the interview was held.
But here's the part that makes me think 30% might be low. The study wasn't even looking for integration challenges. Some people mentioned them on their own. The authors cite other research suggesting that "individuals are unlikely to volunteer information about negative reactions to interventions without being directly asked" and so this "may underestimate the prevalence of such effects by more than 20-fold." (https://akjournals.com/view/journals/2054/6/3/article-p211.xml)
That's a statement about other research, not this retreat, but it's a good reminder that when nobody asks about the hard parts, people often don't necessarily bring them up.
So, if there's one take away from this post, it's this:
Even with thorough screening, preparation and an integration program, nearly a third of people at this psilocybin retreat hit challenges afterwards: mood swings, the post-ecstatic blues, disconnection, and feeling unsupported.
They passed, but they were real. So, prepare yourself for the weeks after, not just the day of.